Menu
The Beachcomber
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Conesus

The Beachcomber

★★★★ 4.3 · 93 reseñas

The Beachcomber, located in Conesus, offers a delightful experience with stunning lakeside views. Guests appreciate the inviting ambiance, enhanced by live music and various seating options, including outdoor spaces perfect for enjoying the scenery. The restaurant is known for it...

The Beachcomber

Seafood · Conesus

4.3 · 670 recensioni Google
www.beachcomberny.com
Yelp 3.5 (85) TripAdvisor 4.2 (118) Booking 7.8 (38)

Informazioni su The Beachcomber

The Beachcomber, located in Conesus, offers a delightful experience with stunning lakeside views. Guests appreciate the inviting ambiance, enhanced by live music and various seating options, including outdoor spaces perfect for enjoying the scenery. The restaurant is known for its fast service and d...

The Beachcomber, located in Conesus, offers a delightful experience with stunning lakeside views. Guests appreciate the inviting ambiance, enhanced by live music and various seating options, including outdoor spaces perfect for enjoying the scenery. The restaurant is known for its fast service and diverse menu, featuring both restaurant fare and casual bar & grill options, as well as a selection of local specialties. A great beer and cocktail selection complements the dining experience. The Beachcomber is also equipped with a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Open for lunch and dinner on select days, it's a versatile spot for solo diners and groups alike, whether you're looking for a full meal, appetizers, or a sweet treat like ice cream.

Cosa dicono i clienti di The Beachcomber

The Beachcomber is a lakeside restaurant and inn known for its great views, friendly staff (especially Mary Alice), and live music. Guests enjoy the outdoor bar, grill, and various activities like volleyball. Some reviews mention inconsistent food quality, particularly with certain dishes.

Piatti popolari

shrimp chicken wings pretzel bites shrimp tacos Steak and Mushroom Risotto Shrimp and Grits fish sandwich hamburger

Ideale per

Coppie Famiglie Gruppi Turisti Informale

Tip: Enjoy live music on weekends and volleyball during the week. Be mindful of potential inconsistencies in food quality, especially the fish sandwich.

Services

🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy Trendy 👥 Groups

Domande frequenti su The Beachcomber

The Beachcomber si trova in 5909 W Lake Rd, Conesus, NY 14435, Conesus.
The Beachcomber offre cucina seafood.
The Beachcomber ha orari di apertura regolari. Consulta il profilo per gli orari aggiornati.
The Beachcomber offre i seguenti servizi: mangiare sul posto, da asporto.
I piatti più consigliati di The Beachcomber secondo le recensioni dei clienti sono: shrimp, chicken wings, pretzel bites, shrimp tacos, Steak and Mushroom Risotto.
The Beachcomber è ideale per coppie, famiglie, gruppi, turisti, informale.
The Beachcomber is a lakeside restaurant and inn known for its great views, friendly staff (especially Mary Alice), and live music. Guests enjoy the outdoor bar, grill, and various activities like volleyball. Some reviews mention inconsistent food quality, particularly with certain dishes.
Enjoy live music on weekends and volleyball during the week. Be mindful of potential inconsistencies in food quality, especially the fish sandwich.
670
Recensioni

Recensioni di The Beachcomber Conesus

4.3
670
5★
57%
4★
25%
3★
8%
2★
4%
1★
5%
Recensioni (93)
A
Amy Southcott

We went to listen to North 43 play so we made a night of it. We stayed in the Sunrise Suite , it was heavenly. Mary Alice who is the owner, was so fun and made sure we had a good time and that we had everything for a comfortable night sleep! I can’t wait to go back. I would def recommend 10/10 for atmosphere, cleanliness, comfort, and hospitality!! Go try it for yourself:)

H
Hugo Stachel

Had a really pleasant experience here. The staff is really helpful and friendly, and that's not always the case with a lot places these days. We visited on a Saturday evening, without a reservation, but we were seated quickly. We sat at a table which gave us a nice view of the lake and the boats. Our server couldn't have done a better job; we never waited long for anything and she checked on us throughout the meal. The menu is good, there's a lot of good options, something for everyone. Our meal was served quickly and everything was delicious. Everyone around us seemed to be having a good time, just like us. Recommend this place, we'll come back for sure!

S
Susan McFarlane

The Beachcomber is a lakeside resort! My husband and I have stayed in the rooms however, recently we stayed in the Sunrise Suite and we will definitely return! The suite was spotless, the bed was super comfortable and the balcony deck overlooking the water was fantastic. Add great food in both the cabana and dining room, some fun music…what’s not to like!

M
Michelle Donivan

surprisingly good food! new Chef? I had a lovely and slightly spicy carrot bisque. we shared a killer flatbread with fried green tomatoes, cheese and greens with little blue flowers. beer was served in cold glasses, my caesar sald was fresh, cold and perfectly dressed and hubbies' fish fry was very good-fries perfect and possibly fresh cut? def will visit more often. service was spot on!

C
Cindy Madar

We dined at the beachcomber at the crab shack. The location is ideal and sits on canesus lake. The covered patio is spacious and provides shade. There's also seating inside the crab shack and two other places to dine outside another inside the bar. We went to hear the live band which was excellent. Service was excellent and the server was friendly kind professional and loved her recommendation which was the chicken resling entree which I'd highly reccomed. Crispy tasty pieces of chicken strips ( plentiful) along with a creamy pasta sauce with ham chunks. Delicious warm fresh rolls and a nice arugula salad completed the meal. 2 salmon cakes were our pick for an appetizer Accompained with a creamy dipping sayce.Again highly reccomended. Lemon blueberry cocktail was wonderful! A nice blueberry lemon tangy twist. So good I ordered 2. Not alot of parking at the resturant. On street parking and be prepared for a walk. You get down to the resturants in front climbing down stairs which has a hand rail.

J
Jordan Strobel

This is a real gem of a place on Conesus Lake. Their food is awesome and the place has an woodsy/homey vibe. They are right on the Lake with a beautiful view of the water and tons of outdoor seating in the summer with an outdoor cabana bar area to boot. Overnight rooms are available for those who may be too tipsy to drive home. Overall, I highly recommend.

D
Don D

First time dining inside with my girl.. Usually go with the guys as part of our weekly motorcycle journeys.. Good food inside and out and the waitress was great also.

R
Richard Norris

Excellent King Crab pasta special. Really friendly staff. The chef came by and asked how we liked our meal. Later, the owner checked on us. Beautiful view of Conesus Lake from our table. Reasonably priced menu

T
Tess Vesa

Great food! My husband absolutely loves Chef May's Seafood Chowder and both of us love the Fried Brussels Sprouts with pecans and pickled red onion, tossed in a scallion vinaigrette simply the BEST!!! Adding a Boca burger to the menu would be the "icing on the cake" :)

L
Leila Mustonen

A 3-night visit to The Beachcomber on Conesus Lake was such a treat - and only 1.5 hours from the Canadian border crossing at Niagara Falls. The owners Mary Alice and Tom are excellent hosts and really care about their overnight customers and their regular visitors and boaters and have no problem addressing dietary requests (always appreciated!). There are so many indoor and outdoor areas to enjoy delicious F&B, music and atmosphere. A lovely place to visit - definitely will be back.

L
Linda Williams

Inside is not open Mondays or Tuesdays So unfortunately we did not get to eat inside. We sat outside at the bar Had some. Yummy fried foods and friendly service!

L
Lorraine Thompson

Water side grill open with outdoor seating. Trash plate and fried shrimp dinners. Excellent. Abby our server, 2nd day in did a fabulous job. Would recommend and definitely going back.

S
Shari Wagner

We love the Beachcomber any time of the year! The rooms are very comfortable for an overnight or week-end. We enjoyed our stay last year for our Anniversary and hope to stay again soon. The Owners are so friendly, they always say Hi and take the time to chat. We love the outdoor Cabana Grill and the inside/outside bar. Check it out if you haven't already!! You won't be disappointed.

D
Dianne Fredericy

The food was delicious! Everyone from the greeters to the waiter to the guy who filled our water glasses was friendly. They were very prompt in bringing out our food. I highly recommend this restaurant. We will definitely be returning.

T
Tamara Marsh

Incredible. Not sure why we dont eat here literally every day. So delicious. Dublin Lawyer was loaded with lobster and so good. Seafood chowder also wonderful. Fried cheese curds are everything. We will certainly be back. Waitress knew just how to keep kids happy and with refills. So pleased.

D
Deborah Case

We love our Friday night fish fries and really enjoy eating outside in the summer. Food is great and Mary Alice is always ready to go the extra mile to please. My husband got a warm brownie ice cream sundae for his birthday!

F
Frank Biondo

This place is like going on vacation with out having to take a week off. My kids and I love to go here, there beach food is great (we love the garbage plates) and their Restaurant food is a 10. They offer a steamer bucket with mussels, clams, scallops, shrimp, and crab. You just cannot beat it. If you want to feel like you are on vacation check out the beachcomber. Did i mention they have water to swim in, fires, live music etc…

P
Paul Nichols

This is the BEST bbq I’ve ever had. The Mac and cheese was so creamy and the corn bread was so moist. Not to mention the delicious pulled pork and chicken. Delicious and highly recommend

c
cris zaffuto

Best chef ever. However, it is not handicap accessible. Nor is there handicap parking spaces. You have to walk down a long hill and walk up again. Love the food but have to really think hard about going because of the entrance and exit.

M
Michael J. Lechner

This is a fun laid back piece of heaven on Conesus Lake. It's an old school lakefront gathering spot for people who enjoy life as it is. Boaters, Bikers, & Families gather at this place in harmony to have fun. Food is good, beer is cold, what more do you need. Anyone that gives this place a bad review must be wound a little too tight. Give this place a try and see for yourself.

P
Paige Way

I joined the Thursday night volleyball league a few weeks ago and not only is the place a really great environment but the food is awesome. We’ve had everything from the wings, seafood, burgers and looking forward to trying more every week.

H
Heather Francis

Great experience! We ordered for dockside but ended up eating outside and the servers and staff were amazing. They abided by the social distancing guidelines while maintaining a friendly and inviting atmosphere!

R
Ray Schultheis

Called for a reservation on Wednesday for 6PM Friday and were offered outside overlooking the lake. We got there a little early and were seated immediately. I had Broiled Haddock with Lemon Pepper and my wife had the Dublin Lawyer. Both were very good.

M
MaryRae Lodato

The Beachcomber is an unassuming restaurant on Conesus Lake. We stopped there after kayaking over the 4th of July weekend. The food was amazing! The service was great. Sitting by the water was wonderful, while we lunched on our amazing fish sandwiches, steamed clams, and sweet potato fries. Service and drinks were great as well!

T
Tina

This place is so cute! Located right in the water. There's great food, great drinks, and plenty of spots to hang out

J
Joe Van Slycke

We had a great dinner at Beachcomber. The restaurant and grill menu offered a terrific combination for the adults and kids. Prices were very reasonable, and the service was fantastic. Our waiter hustled and did a fantastic job taking care of all his tables. He took the time to chat with our kids, made great recommendations, and was very friendly. Our kids loved their food, my surf and turf was perfect, and my wife’s eggplant parm was delicious. Add all that to a fantastic view of the Lake. Really happy we were able to get a table!

L
Lisa Deller

Awesome place on the lake. We had a tire blowout and had to stay overnight while the car was being fixed. I called late in the afternoon and they were able to rent us a room. Mary Alice was the best host. The room was clean and recently renovated. Very quiet location with views of the lake. Down the hill is a full outdoor bar, outdoor food, and an indoor restaurant. The food was great, and the service from the bartenders Leighann, Chris, and the owner Mary Alice was on point and couldnt ask for anything better. We would definitely visit again.

E
Erik Stoneham

Stopped in for lunch. Typical Greasy spoon fair. It was good. Hit the spot / filled the need at the time. Good location in the lake. The overall experience at the bar did not wow us, but I can see the attraction to this location.

J
Jocelyn Young

This was a great place! Nice atmosphere! Clean! The owner was very personable and kind. The food is great at the restaurant and the staff is efficient and friendly! I'd stay here again!

4
4011 Banana

Today an employee from here saved a huge snapping turtle's life and I just wanted to thank her. I do have a video of it. Thanks so much again 🙏

K
Kelly O

Amazing views and atmosphere! The whole property is great although my favorite has to be the outside dining and beach area. It feels like a laid-back resort. My co-workers and I had great service and the grilled chicken i had was perfect. A nice summer day trip I plan on taking again.

J
Jayla Rohrer

Beautiful location!! The food was good. The menu was small but most everyone on the menu was tasty. We got chicken sandwiches, fried cheese curds, chicken tenders, and fried brussel sprouts. All was tasty and the service was quick!

C
Carol Kostraba

Wow! Excellent service from Dan.. He was right on top of everything, very warm and welcoming...Our Meals were outstanding! There was nine of us and we all had ordered something different..High reviews around the table starting with our Appetizers to our meals.. Perfectly prepared and so Delious! The chef even came out to our table to ask how everything was..So glad he did as he deserved the compliments​ in person! Looking forward to our next visit...

T
Tina Monachino

The restaurant was not open early enough. They had a paid band out near the waterfront, very nice. No appetizer. I would like to have something other than ice cream to snack on while enjoying the music and atmosphere. Maybe consider having some non grill options available from inside the restaurant. During the outdoor entertainment.

L
Lynne

I had the pleasure of spending the weekend at the Beachcomber this past weekend! The room was clean and very charming! The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating! The view of the lake was breathtakingly beautiful! We ordered appetizers on the premises for lunch and the food was excellent. If you are in the area I highly recommend checking it out! It is close to SUNY Geneseo which is a nice treat for family’s visiting their children who attend the college or if you are in need of a peaceful get away!

P
Paul Edwards

Our server Brittany was awesome 😎.. food was great.. the vibe is spot on... Fun, friendly atmosphere.. come & check it... double dog dare you!!!

J
Janet Seabridge

We went there to eat dinner while staying elsewhere in the area. The food was delicious - fantastic seafood. We found out the head chef is from New Orleans so the dishes seemed quite authentic. Would definitely recommend and we plan on going back!

Jessica Stansberry
Jessica Stansberry

We stayed at the Beachcomber Inn and had a wonderful stay! Very friendly staff and cozy accommodations. Would definitely stay again 😊

Angela Rogers
Angela Rogers

This place is amazing and the customer service makes it even better. I tried to make a reservation online and technology was not on my side so I ended up calling and spoke with the owner Mary Alice and she was so warm and kind. We chatted like we were old friends. Check in was very easy and the room was perfect for what we needed. We had dinner at the restaurant and it was delicious. We also went to the outside bar to have a drink and enjoy the view. Check out was also a breeze, we sent Mary Alice a text letting her know we were checking out and she remembered we were in town for a wedding and asked if we had a good time. All of the staff was very welcoming and treated us like we were regulars. We were able to meet Mary Alice in person and she remembered our chat on the phone. I would recommend if your looking to stay somewhere off the beaten path you definitely check this place out.

Agnes Muscoreil
Agnes Muscoreil

Nice rooms on the beautiful lake with a Bar/restaurant within a few steps! Great bar, perfect for watching sports!

Rona nena
Rona nena

Bed was comfortable and room was super clean! Mary Alice and the team went above and beyond! Looking forward to our next visit!

Carolyn Fico
Carolyn Fico

This is such a beautiful place. In addition to a fantastic view of the lake, it's accomodations are very comfortable and clean. There is a large living room, ample deck seating overlooking the water and seriously comfortable beds. The Beachcomber restaurant is right on the premises and had wonderful food. Mary Alice and Tammy ensured we had everything we needed.

Tina Pritchard
Tina Pritchard

Great relaxing stay at the Sunrise Suite. We enjoyed a delicious takeout dinner from the Crab Shack and shrimp tacos from the grill. I'm sure we'll be back!

Ron Knapp
Ron Knapp

We came in without reservations and were still seated right away, even though they were very busy! Our servers were very polite and accomodating. The food was cooked perfectly and seasoned well. I highly reccomend the Beachcomber.

Angelo LoBue
Angelo LoBue

My wife and I spent 4 days at the beachcomber and the place delivered as advertised. Great room, great views and great service and food. Highly recommend for a lakeside getaway!!

Lorraine Cleary
Lorraine Cleary

Had a wonderful time at the Beachcomber this past weekend with our family. We booked a 3 and some 4 night stay at the penthouse and the suite below with our family and friends, .8 adults 2 kids and it was a perfect getaway !! Mary Alice and her husband were a text away with anything we needed above and beyond which was minimal. We were on the water with beautiful balconies facing the lake, all the amenities to cook inside or outside , or eat at the restaurant or bar grill. We had a great time on property for the whole time with music, water entertainment and bar/restaurant with 5 star service at our fingertips. We would love to go back ! Thanks to the owners for a memorable vacation 🛶💥⛵️👍

Kayla Phillips
Kayla Phillips

I did not leave a review on the room as we did not stay in the rooms we were here. To start my review when we entered beachcomber it did not look packed in anyway, however we were unaware of the reservations they had. There was some back and forth about the situation as we wanted to eat outside and be able to order off the restaurant menu. All in all I was a great experience I am thankful to the manager ( I didn’t catch her name) for finding a solution and our server James was amazing!!! All in all food was great service was great and I can’t complain.

Mistie Beach
Mistie Beach

A group of us girls stopped by for a appetizer and a drink! Sat outside at the picnic table area under an umbrella! The pretzel bites were really good and service was great! Drinks were cold and the view of the lake was very nice 👌

Rachel
Rachel

We just went for the day . My kids played in the sand and got in the water which was great. We sat under the tent which was a plus because it was hot. Only the grill and bar was open, but it was so good. We had 0 complaints. My son said it was the best shrimp and chicken wings he's ever had. Their fries were my fav. On Mondays they had half off margaritas . They were the best ones I've ever had. Especially the peach! We will be back for sure

James Garcia
James Garcia

What a great place. The Beachcomber has everything. Full restaurant with great food. Cool bar with pool and darts. Bar/ grill menu if want something more casual, and even ice cream. They have live music on the weekends and volleyball leagues during the week. We loved watching the games from our balcony. Not to mention the beautiful views of the lake and they even had doc space for our rental boat. We could not have been happier spending the week there. Mary Alice and her staff were fantastic and more than happy to help us with anything we needed.

Kim Haynes
Kim Haynes

I ran into this restaurant and bar on my way home from bird watching. We had lunch at an outside bar with views of the lake, lots of outdoor tables, with umbrellas, some without, picnic tables and indoor seating at a couple of bars. One looks outside. The bar is hopping. The menu has the usual casual lake picnic type foods. My friend had breaded shrimp and fries. She liked it. I had a cheese burger and sweet potato fries. The menu prices were great. Beer good priced. Nicole and another gal served us, fast and with nice demeanor. Great little discovery.

t
ted leader

Great place on conesus lake. Good food, good people, good views. I had some fried pickles and they were crispy and delisious. I enjoyed having a few drinks listening to the live band checking out the sun set over the lake. Good times for all!

J
Jonathan Carmody

Fun place to get drinks and food. Indoor and outdoor seating. Outdoor seating can have annoying gnats that bother you while eating. Can have a drink and put you feet in the water. Live music...

K
Kevin Tucker

New bar is great design. Outdoor food service can be slow, but have another beer, enjoy the view! Live music is nice draw in summertime.

T
Toni Markowycz

Awesome place to sit outdoors and watch the time go by on the lake. Food was delicious and the wait staff is pretty great as well. Inside restaurant accompanied by an large outdoor beach feel area with a bar and live music most nights.

L
Lin Callahan

7.20.16 - Another fabulous meal! Service and timing of meal pleasant as usual. No complaints here! Winter 2016 - Have never had a bad meal. Love the winter time hours, specials and Saturday night music. Times can be tough when the new summer season roles around and staff training is ramping up. Overall Tom and Mary Alice always want to make it right if you are disappointed - just talk with them.

K
K

Hubby and I ate outside, got food from the Dockside Grill. His Philly Steak Hoagie was awesome, loaded fries were great. My fish sandwich was a bit overcooked but still tasty. I got a drink from the Cabana, which took a while. The bartender was stocking and I guess didn't notice me for a bit. Once she started waiting on me, she was very friendly and sweet. I loved being able to sit on the beach with my toes buried in the sand eating my dinner and drinking my margarita. All in all, we had a good time and plan to return.

L
Linda Duman

Nice outdoor bar with seating Great inexpensive food Had the brisket plate Everything on it was delicious & the brisket was some of the most tender I've had. Outdoor seating with umbrellaed picnic tables. Nice place to spend a beautiful day.

S
Shaheen Tonse

One of the few places around this lake where you have public access. Plenty of parking. Nice place to sit with your beer and food and enjoy the lake. Had a nice fish sandwich french fries and a beer. Interesting selection of beers. Did I mention the beers?

c
charles McClarrie

food was very good. The out door grill team did great the first order, but the second was off. The band was horrible. The view spectacular. Rooms has no rating because I did not rent a room. The fish sandwich was killer awesome.

D
Deborah Brague

We went here for dinner at 6pm on a Saturday night. Was not busy, but we did make a reservation just in case. The bar was well stocked (the beer was nice and cold!) and the bartender was friendly. We had a choice of seating in the main dining room with a lake view (which we chose) or we could sit by the fireplace. Very friendly staff and we were even visited by the owner. There was live music which was nice. The food was cooked as we asked....Husband does not like zucchini which was the side mixed vegetable. We will ask for different options next time. The atmosphere was very relaxing. Bit of an old building aroma when we walked in but it was not unbearable. Great food, great experience and when the weather stays warm it will be nice to sit outside. There is plenty of seating outside. I am not sure if they serve outside in nice weather. It's a 'must stop' place!!!

J
Joseph Maldonado

Food was good, atmosphere was great , out next to the lake, prices a little high but not too much

G
Guy Smith

We were here for live music on a beautiful Sunday evening for Memorial Day weekend. Lively crowd. The 80s hairmetal tribute band was pretty good. They were really not prepared for the crowd, food wise. The grill did their best, but not big enough to handle this crowd. One of the few-perhaps only places to eat on Conesus Lake. Parking is probably adequate on most nights, but abysmal for this occasion. I will go back and try out the main restaurant the next time. Prices looked reasonable. Not a very good beer selection on tap. We enjoyed ourselves regardless.

P
Patrick Vimislik

We lucked out and it was a perfect day, beautiful sunshine, not too cold and not too warm. The food was cooked perfectly, we had at our table; fish, crab cakes, and steak. The crab cakes were really good... maybe not Maryland crab cakes with the huge chunks, but very good, nonetheless. The steak was a good portion and cooked exactly how it was ordered. The seafood stuffed haddock was also very good and the vegetables were cooked right, but could have used a little more flavor. We'd definitely recommend this place to anybody looking for something different with a nice view of the lake!!

J
Jen coffey

It does well for a lake bar and restaurant. I have only ate inside a few times, it was pretty good. The grill outside is also pretty good for bar/lakeside food. Most of the staff is friendly. It is hard to get to the bar at night, especially since it's been redesigned. The service is quick during the day. The have some pretty good bands, and some kind if live music almost daily in the summer. This is a seasonal establishment.

B
Brian Edelstein

Expect a long wait for a table on a Saturday in the summer - this is not a negative, just a fact. Bartender seemed less-than-amused to be doing her job, but was admittedly swamped and moving as fast as she could. Best to make reservations for dinner, or call before you leave the house... and drive slowly. If you're looking for a quiet table at the lake this weekend, go elsewhere. Live music Friday and Saturday nights on the outdoor venue makes conversation a challenge. Indoor seating was an option, but the weather was too good to pass up "patio seating" when we went. It seemed like the big party behind us was sapping resources, and our server took forever to take our order tonight. Had to collar another server to get things moving. After that, she was pretty attentive. Food was delicious - we shared the gnocchi with shrimp and it was outstanding. No offer of a pepper mill with my Caesar salad, but the dressing was tangy and the quantity was quality. The place is pricey, but you'll get what you pay for. Would consider returning during the week for that quiet table at the lake and a tasty beverage in a short glass.

R
R. B.

1st time visiting the Beachcomber. We went to hear the music, which was wonderful. Todd Tucker and his wife Sara both are so good, and it's a great place for the kids to play right on the little beach on the lake which is a beautiful view. My reason for a 2 star service, because there was only 1 bartender working and it took almost a half hour to get our only drinks we got, she was really slow and took 4 different tries to get a mixer cup to fit the other one to shake a drink and then she did a shot with that customer while like 8 people were waiting to order at the bar. The chicken wings were decent, would like to try the restaurant inside another time.

Alan Rifkin
Alan Rifkin

Nice spot! They charge more because of the view though...Didn't stay in a room, but it looked nice. Bartenders were very busy but accurate on what we wanted and the tab.

Tom Godfrey
Tom Godfrey

Stayed here this past weekend (7/11/25)...GREAT location, staff and entertainment !!!! Went to the air show at Geneseo and stay here, 10 min away. BI is right on the lake, great view. Staff was great, food was good and they have live music Fri & Sat night. Crowd was pleasant ! Would definitely come back. Price is great compared to the Hampton & Quality Inn in Geneseo. Showers in the room was really small, need to work on that and great rid of the windows on the door. Outdoor lights are needed but they shin too brightly in the room. See you next year !!! Tom G Babylon, NY

R
Rich Dwyer

Came here for a few small drinks. Had the server Tabitha and she did serve us at first but became very rude to serve other people. We came back and she ignored us again. Then decided to answer her phone(personal) instead of coming over to us. Just disappointed in the server but the place was gorgeous.

M
Marie D

Lunch was decent. Small but good selection of draft beers. It was raining when we're there and it flooded the only available bathroom. Toilet not working. Gross. Tacky decor.....primary colors

A
A_ ski-Dew

We had 2 of the most expensive Items on the brunch menu. Our brunch was good, though the home fries were luke warm at best. The waitress was told so when she asked how our meal was and did not apologize or offer any comp/discount. Poor beer selection. The chef and waitress complained when another group of 7 came in 10 minutes before brunch ended, like they didn't want their money because they shut down the restaurant between brunch and dinner. I would think a group of 7 would be welcomed no matter This is a restaurant on a lake with a dock. One would think the place would be open all day on a weekend day with beautiful, sunny weather. They did have a small food stand that does stay open for burgers and fries, but was overwhelmed when half of the 7 decided to order from them instead of the restaurant. Guessing they are more interested in serving dinner than brunch or the food stand. There were no customers in the dining areas when we arrived at 12:45 and only 1 table on the food stand and 3 customers in the bar area.

A
Alison O'Connell

This is the second time we have been there. 2 years ago it was AMAZING. No issues and food was great. I like the location but there are many things I didn't like. -the knats/flies were everywhere. A server did try to help us by putting a small fan on us but I went to the car to get out bug spray. -they need a sign on either side of the beach side of the property saying private home owners property. Stay off. My son went to feed the ducks and we got yelled at. We had no idea it would be a huge issue. -the server was nice enough but told us way too much information about why our food was taking so long, why I only had one scallop in my seafood dish and why the steak salad was over cooked and light little lettuce. - did she get us 10% off the bill which was nice but honestly I will not go back after this experience.

Mike , Tampa Fl.
Mike , Tampa Fl.

Don’t order a fish sandwich here unless you’re satisfied with over deep fried breading, no fish in between. Old grease . French fries were good. Hamburger was also great . The Mac and cheese had no flavor at all . Service was good.

M
Matt Morgan

While the food was decent, the hour wait between ordering it and actually being served was pretty ridiculous. The food for the group was missing main ingredients (brisket) on a plate and nobody thought to tell anyone who ordered it. Will just ride right by next time, can let the teens at burgerking mess up my orders at a third of the cost and a tenth of the wait time.

W
William “Billy” Doolittle

Smallest clams I've ever seen. We never got everything we ordered. They tried to make it right and in all fairness it was quite busy. The "Crab shack" doesn't open until 4pm. The menu is limited until then. Descent bar inside & outside dinning available.

J
Julie Taylor

Decided to give this place a chance once again and it wasn't great. Our food was all very disappointing and when we asked our waitress for a drink menu, she promptly responded "there's a full bar so they can make whatever" How about provide a drink menu to your outside dinning guests like you do for the guests dinning inside. It could be so much better with attention to detail.

A
Ann Publow, SPHR

They put a large party of us there celebrating at 85th birthday right next to the band/stage. No one could converse. Short-staffed and the food, although good, took a really long time. Overall, not very impressed.

J
Jeremy Jackson

Restaurant was not great. Poor service and mediocre food. We waited 15 minutes before anyone came to take drink orders. Waited another 15 for the drinks to arrive. Food was severely mediocre--rice on one dish was minute rice/boil-n-bag, brussel sprouts soggy. Would not recommend.

S
Sheri Carroll

We tried to have a nice summer dinner but the staff was too busy having a cigarette and texting. We final got frustrated and left. The Beachercomber has alway been up and down but we wanted to give it a chance. Did not even get to a point to order anything. Hope the staff enjoyed there off time on Beachcomber payroll.

K
Kim Duda

This rating is for the restuarant the cove I think. It was the dirtiest lil restaurant I've ever been in. The bar was sticky and so disgusting.i asked for a rag to clean it off and bar tender came over swiped once and wouldn't let me show her it was still disgusting. Flies were landing on my food as I was eating it. Horrible!!

K
Kathryn Herniman

Drove an hour to go because of the description of the seafood stuffed haddock and it was awful. There was no seafood. It was all breading. The waitress said she has had many complaints ta but it is that the chef or should I say cook he is not Chef, cuts everything fine. Nice excuse. The place had dead flies on the windowsill near our table. I don’t recommend this place and especially not the seafood stuffed haddock. It was suppose to have crab, shrimp etc it had nothing.

P
Paula Banks

Well besides the fact that this place is not used to black people at all or simply because they don't see enough black people. Walked into the place with my boyfriend. The guy sees me doesnt speak to me but tells my boyfriend he's glad he stop by. None of the staff spoke to me only to my boyfriend(who is white). We ordered and left immediately. People kept staring at us. Just a tip to this restaurant. Learn to speak. A hello, how you doing. Just try and be more friendly. I wont ever eat there again!!!

R
RoOL22 the Wrecking Crew

1st time to visit was last year and the restaurant manager was just mean and at that point there was no other customers..thought ok a bad day. The 2nd time was during covid in mid June this year , service was slow and beer expensive. We figured with all that's going on ok....maybe that was reason. Then we visited this last weekend. Our group was fairly large, and there was that manager again. The food was ok but the prices outrageous, orders were unfulfilled. A lot of food on the menu was unavailable. Quite possibly our last attempt here.

R
Ron Cohen

In response to (owner) the waitress said she talked to you. End result was noone other than the waitress talked to us or apologized. The only management decision made was to remove the items from the bill that where inedible and/or covered in the drink spilled all over my wife and her phone. As someone who has worked in and trained hundreds in customer service I would have expected someone to help the waitress by representing management and talking to us. As a former business owner I would never ask for payment for only the un-ruined portion of my product or service. I would have asked what can we do make this right or offered for you to come back, on us, and give us another chance. Anything other than we won't charge you for what we ruined, which honestly was the entire experience. 1 hour drive for this? No thank you. We will not be back. I understand some of what we went through is due to the staff learning how to deal with new restrictions, but based on our experience maybe you should wait to reopen. At a minimum I would have expected more than not charging us for what you ruined... First round of drinks where not what we ordered. Soda used instead of sprite. Took 20 minutes to get the correct drink. Fish sandwhich was delivered well undercooked. Fish fry was slightly better but had some undercooked parts. Second round of drinks took another 20+ minutes and then was dumped on my wife and my dinner. Also may have ruined her phone. At this point we just wanted to leave. Server said she wanted to talk to the owner about how bad our experience was. Came back and said they where gracious enough not to charge us for the under cooked meals or drinks they spilled on us. $50 for a couple drinks and a small appetizer and a ruined dinner experience. Staff wearing masks incorrectly. People coming from the dock not wearing masks at all. No enforcement of social distancing... A shame. We came here on our wedding day pre wedding, and every year since. Today was probably the last time...

T
Toni Bivone

Took family to dinner and waited 2 hours for food. 3 parties that came in after us got their food before us. The owner gave every excuse in the book instead of owning up to the mistake and was rude about it. We got 25% off the bill which was hardly anything. She gave us no reason to go back. This owner will not last if she does not improve customer service. Terrible customer service. Terrible experience. Very disappointed.

M
Mike Lupi

Incredibly slow service. Drinks took 1 hour, apps 1.5 hours. Then finally got entree 2 hours after sitting down. Never coming back to this trash establishment don't waste your time

J
Joshua Consler

My Father in-law and I stopped in for Lunch on Sunday and decided to get the Brunch. I ordered the breakfast burger and home fries and my father got the eggs and toast. When the order came the waitress forgot the silverware and took about 5 minutes to come back. My burger was raw in the middle. Home fries were decent. We asked for coffee with cream. She brought the coffee with no cream. Again waited like 5 minutes to get that too. After 20 minutes waiting to get the check I walked inside to get my waitress and she said she will find her for me? I’m like you are my waitress? Not the greatest or the most organized on the lake for sure. Good place for a quick beer and a view of the lake.

M
Maggie Steel

My family and I have gone to this restaurant/bar several times. Never once did we have a positive experience with the staff, however we always brushed it off as it is a busy time of year. Food always takes a long time, waitresses are always inattentive, staff is blatantly rude to your face, all obviously without consequences. Several times we have gone and eaten dinner and tried to order drinks while eating. Each time we tried our waitress would say she would be right back and never take our drink order. This has happened even during nights we were the only people around. Our last visit however the staff showed and uglier side than I thought possible. I couldn’t believe it but a bouncer blatantly displayed his homophobic opinions towards a gay couple who asked for help after being harassed by another person. They requested a manager, who, to my surprise, sided with the homophobic bouncer. Sad to see in 2019. Don’t give these people your money. Definitely not worth it. My husband and I will definitely not be returning now.

B
Bonnie K

Verrrryyyyy slow service. Didn’t get drinks until an hour after sitting down and ordering, then apps about 15 mins later. Entrees came 2 hours after sitting down. Don’t recommend wasting your time here. Not the waiters fault I think they are severely understaffed.

Lexi Dasson
Lexi Dasson

Where to begin... We moved back to the area 5 years ago and have been frequent flyers to both the bar and restaurant. We have tried to support this place, as its only 30 seconds from our house. We have spent probably thousands of dollars here at this point and sadly our time visiting might come to an end. For starters, the food is always hit or miss, the service slow and poor, and some of the staff very unfriendly. When you are a regular that spends a lot of time and tips well, you want to be remembered but we never are. We are ID'd every time we are there, which isn't that big of an issue, but recently was about the worst day we have had there yet. We ordered food from the fry stand - a sausage, burger and fries. After an hour and 40 min we asked the stand about our food and they didn't even have our order. They asked if we still wanted the food and we said yes considering we hadn't eaten in about 8 hours. So we waited an additional 20+ minutes for that. While that was going on, we were ID'd every time we asked for another drink (while sitting next to the bar). I have never been to a place that asks for my ID every time I reorder a drink. The 3rd time I was asked for my ID when I ordered a diet coke, I made my frustration obvious, considering I had already been sitting there drinking 2 margaritas previously, but then for a diet coke?? The person realized that was a mistake, but again- we have been frequent visitors going on 5 years. All of the other local bars have remembered us after 2 visits. After waiting over 2 hours for a sausage and burger that wasn't even that great, and they still forgot the sweet potato fries we had also ordered. Unfortunately I'm not sure if we will be back any time soon or recommend to anyone. It is a shame, as the location is beautiful and it could be a thriving business.

Rachael Thomas
Rachael Thomas

What to say... The servers were lovely! The food, however, should be reviewed by Gordon Ramsey so they fix themselves before they are shut down. The vegan options ARE NOT VEGAN! Dairy was in the vegan options, vegan means absolutely no animal involvement. This got several members in our group sick once we got home. One of our members ordered the Hawaiian chicken, which was the equivalent of vomit on a plate. To the point where one of our members spat the food back onto the bowl and it made 3 other members gag. Another member needed to send his calamari salad back. When we first brought up our concerns we were met with doubts. Even the meals that were "good" were terribly over cooked. Once the owner took our food back the meal was removed from the bill and a $20 gift card was given. While thoughtful, we will not be back ... Again! - The Group

Dave Marino
Dave Marino

Went there last night for dinner and I have to say the food was completely disappointing. First off my wife ordered the Shrimp and Grits and I ordered the Steak and Mushroom Risotto. She received a bowl that had overcooked shrimp, rice and some pickled shredded white vegetable and other veggies and raisins. Was nowhere near Shrimp with Chipolte Grits and Gouda. My steak was flavorless and dry, even though it was rare and in fact tasted like it had been in the freezer too long, not a good quality strip steak. The Risotto however was really good. So after I got the bill, I noticed that they didn't get the order right, it was in fact something like Crispy Shrimp and Rice Bowl. I don't normally complain and didn't want to make a scene, so we didn't say anything, we paid and left. We were both hungry, but this meal was a means to an end. Don't know if they had an off night but I would be reluctant to return again. I hate leaving bad reviews but this meal was nowhere near the quality it should've been for the $66 we paid before tip. That only included 2 diet sodas, no expensive drinks or any apps. The server was very nice, I'd give her a 4-5 stars, service was pretty fast, again 4-5 stars, but food would be a 1 star due to the quality, the wrong order and the price.

Accedi per lasciare una recensione

Accedi
👑 È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Esplora la tua zona

Più ristoranti a Conesus →
📸

27 Foto

Esplora le foto di The Beachcomber

The Beachcomber
The Beachcomber
The Beachcomber
The Beachcomber
The Beachcomber
+22 Altro
📍

Informazioni su The Beachcomber

Come arrivare

5909 W Lake Rd, Conesus, NY 14435

Caricamento mappa...
The Beachcomber
Tocca per le indicazioni

Punti salienti

Buon voto
4.3/5 stelle
💬
Molte recensioni
670 recensioni
💰
Prezzo moderato
Livello di prezzo
👨‍🍳
seafood
Tipo di cucina

Servizi

🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Pranzo
🍾 Cena
Caffè
🍰 Dolci
🥡 Da Asporto
🍴 Mangiare sul Posto

Opzioni di ristorazione

🍽️ Mangiare sul Posto
🥡 Da Asporto

Info Ristorante

Stato
Verificato dal proprietario
🕐 Horario Hoy
4PM-12AM
Valutazione
4.3/5
💬 Recensioni
670
💰 Livello di prezzo
$$
⏱️ Visita tipica
People typically spend 45 min to 3.5 hr here
📞 Telefono
+1 585-243-3640
🌐 Sito web
www.beachcomberny.com
📋 Menu
Vedi Menu

Servizi

🅿️ Parcheggio
🌿 Posti all'aperto
Accessibile in sedia a rotelle
💳 Carte di credito
📱 Pagamenti mobili
🏘️

Il Quartiere

Posizione

5909 W Lake Rd, Conesus, NY 14435

📍 Esplora il Quartiere

Weather
Meteo aggiornato ogni ora · Lavoro ed eventi aggiornati quotidianamente
🎮

Giochi

🎮 Guadagna Punti Mentre Esplori!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta punti per sconti da The Beachcomber e altri ristoranti

🎮

Guadagna Punti da The Beachcomber!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta ricompense qui

Guadagna punti extra e riscattali per ricompense da The Beachcomber

🏆 Ricompense di The Beachcomber

💰

Sconto 10%

Da The Beachcomber

1000 pts
Disponibile
🍽️

Antipasto Gratis

Alla tua prossima visita

2500 pts
Limitato
👑

Tavolo VIP

Esperienza premium

5000 pts
Esclusivo

per riscattare ricompense e guadagnare punti

📋 Come funzionano le ricompense?

1

Gioca a Find Me

Ogni 100 punti score = 1 punto ricompensa

2

Accumula Punti

I worker ottengono 2x punti per partita

3

Riscatta Ricompense

Sconti, cibo gratis ed esperienze VIP

Chiama
Lascia una recensione su Google
👑

È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Accedi e gioca

Controlla la tua email!

Nessuna password — ti invieremo un link via email

Ti abbiamo inviato un link di accesso

Controlla la cartella spam se non lo vedi