Menu
Pegasus
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Hamburg

Pegasus

★★★★ 4.2 · 137 reseñas

En Pegasus, un rincón acogedor con cálidos paneles de madera en Hamburgo, te invitamos a disfrutar de una experiencia gastronómica única. Abiertos las 24 horas, te ofrecemos un extenso menú que fusiona lo mejor de la cocina griega y americana, con platos reconfortantes que te har...

Pegasus

Greek · Hamburg

4.2 · 1,834 recensioni Google
pegasusrestaurant.net
Yelp 3.5 (124) TripAdvisor 3.9 (190) Yellowpages 5.0 (3)

Informazioni su Pegasus

En Pegasus, un rincón acogedor con cálidos paneles de madera en Hamburgo, te invitamos a disfrutar de una experiencia gastronómica única. Abiertos las 24 horas, te ofrecemos un extenso menú que fusiona lo mejor de la cocina griega y americana, con platos reconfortantes que te harán sentir como en ca...

En Pegasus, un rincón acogedor con cálidos paneles de madera en Hamburgo, te invitamos a disfrutar de una experiencia gastronómica única. Abiertos las 24 horas, te ofrecemos un extenso menú que fusiona lo mejor de la cocina griega y americana, con platos reconfortantes que te harán sentir como en casa. Con una valoración de 4.2 estrellas, estamos deseando darte la bienvenida a nuestra mesa.

Cosa dicono i clienti di Pegasus

Pegasus in Hamburg is a local favorite known for its friendly service and large portions. Many reviewers rave about the breakfast options, especially the omelettes and home fries. While most experiences are positive, some have reported issues with the burger and fish fry.

Piatti popolari

fries (6) breakfast (6) chicken souvlaki omelette roast beef on weck Mahi Mahi fried fish Greek burrito steak florentine

Ideale per

Famiglie Locali Informale Veloce

Tip: The menu is diverse, so everyone can find something they like. Several reviewers recommend the breakfast options.

Services

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🌅 Petit-déjeuner 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 🤫 Quiet 👥 Groups

Domande frequenti su Pegasus

Pegasus si trova in 5748 South Park Ave, Hamburg, NY 14075, Hamburg.
Pegasus offre cucina greek.
Pegasus ha orari di apertura regolari. Consulta il profilo per gli orari aggiornati.
Pegasus offre i seguenti servizi: mangiare sul posto, da asporto, consegna.
I piatti più consigliati di Pegasus secondo le recensioni dei clienti sono: fries, breakfast, chicken souvlaki, omelette, roast beef on weck.
Pegasus è ideale per famiglie, locali, informale, mangiare veloce.
Pegasus in Hamburg is a local favorite known for its friendly service and large portions. Many reviewers rave about the breakfast options, especially the omelettes and home fries. While most experiences are positive, some have reported issues with the burger and fish fry.
The menu is diverse, so everyone can find something they like. Several reviewers recommend the breakfast options.
1,834
Recensioni

Recensioni di Pegasus Hamburg

4.2
1,834
5★
57%
4★
25%
3★
8%
2★
4%
1★
6%
J
Jenna Morrison

Sooo happy this place is on DoorDash. Our go to chicken souvlaki wrap. Real authentic Greek food for a great price? It’s a win-win

m
michael gusek

Love this place for all its diner style menu items.open chicken souvlaki is our favorite. Waitresses are pleasant and efficient...cooks need to be mentioned also for their speed in preparing dishes for your party. Parking is easy but leave the lot on the side road near the back rather than the south park exit. The backside has a traffic light to get back onto south park.

R
R. Ashby

We were in the area and stopped in for a quick bite. We were greeted by the hostess and immediately seated. The interior was cozy, clean and visually pleasant. We had the chicken slovaki quesadilla and a turkey bacon club sandwich, both were excellent. Our waitress was both friendly and good at her job. Plenty of off street parking and the prices were great.

i
ioanna koutsandreas

Enjoyed my dinner at Pegasus. My favorite Greek food around! Service was awesome and we will be back!

D
Darryl Smith

Great restaurant, serving Greek diner style food. Its been here forever and still very popular. Always busy, good table service good portion size.

S
Stacy Cee

Pleasantly surprised. It's very big on the inside. A lot of detail in everything. Wide variety of great food. And they're open 24 hours a day. The waitresses are pleasant. Food was out in no time. Sadly I did not have desert, but it looks amazing as well. If you are near the fairgrounds, you have to stop here for food. No regrets 😊

M
Morgan Dunn

Food was AMAZING and the staff was wonderful. 10/10 recommend!!!!!!!

S
Stephen Dolber

Always clean facility. All employees are pleasant and helpful 😀. Quick quality food 👌.

M
Matt F

Waitress was super! Knew how each order was prepared, ingredients, etc. Food was hot when served and tasted great. It was nice to see hostess cleaning various areas. It was a bit slow, but she kept busy. Looking forward to going back to try something else. Maybe the same thing?

L
Laurel Ebert

We had 4 people. Everyone enjoyed their food. We were catching up and they didn’t hurry us along. It’s one of my favorite restaurants.

D
Donald Williams

Had a fantastic chicken souvlaki salad. The chicken was amazing. Everything tasted fresh. definitely recommend.

J
Joseph Biacan

If your in the Hamburg area and your hungry you should stop by and give them a try food came quick and hot

S
S Bee

I've never had a bad meal here. The staff are friendly, they even actually write down the order. Coffee is kept hot, drinks are kept full. This last time I went they were swamped. We waited no more than three minutes and the server, Skye, still apologized for the wait. She was so pleasant and attentive that I'm sure she was just giving another family the time they needed to make a good decision and enjoy their meal.

J
Jennifer Lee Lair of HOPEC

Great place a little pricey but delicious

T
Tammy Martin

Best Greek restaurant ever! Beautiful restaurant, polite wait staff and the BEST souvlaki ever!!!! Plus their desserts are a bonus! I absolutely am in love with this place!!!

S
Sara Hillman

Gyro and a mamosa's can’t go wrong and Lisa is an amazing waitress!!!

J
Jacquie Walters

Love this place! We always come here after Christmas in the Country.

S
Sarah Seiler

The food is aways delicious! Servers are great! And the atmosphere is wonderful and we love the art works there!

D
Diane George

Pegasus is always delicious and all the waitresses are so pleasant! The restaurant is squeaky clean and they recently updated it with new pictures making it look beautiful! With their large banquet room, you can have large family breakfasts or your church group with advance notice; rest assured that the menu will have something for everyone, even the little ones! Plenty of parking along with handicap access ♿ which is always a plus. Definitely take advantage of this nice, comfortable, friendly restaurant during the upcoming holidays if you just don't have enough space at home.

J
Jenny Nappo

The food was outstanding. Very enjoyable time out.

A
Anne Smith

Our waitress was pleasant and our food was delicious.

P
Paula

We went for lunch and our meals were hot and tasty. Our waitress was friendly and nice. The prices were average. We would stop there again. My husband had meatloaf, and I had roast beef.

D
Diane Passenant

Best Greek yogurt!! I've never found better Greek yogurt. I feel like they think I'm crazy when I just want it plain and nothing on it, but it's so good! I usually get eggs and hash and have never been disappointed. This place is usually full for a reason! Love coming here after festivals at the hamburg fairgrounds to relax and enjoy some great food!

M
Mark Chopyak

Last time we where there (almost 20 years ago) moved to Florida.) When we moved back we went to the Pegasus restaurant and everything was even better. Perfect in every way..

C
Chris Snyder

We have been going here for years. Amanda (manager) is fantastic and always has a smile on her face. My mom loves the chicken souvlaki, and my dad of their breakfast. Highly recommend!

D
Denise Lorka

Years ago, I started going here with my grandfather after he played the slots next door. They have a great variety of breakfast items and great dinner items too. We are always surprised with the large dinner menu variety. The staff is always friendly as well as the owners.

D
Debbie May

Pegasus has been a favorite restaurant of ours for many years and keeps us coming back for more. The food is consistently delicious, whether we go for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Portions are large enough that I always have leftovers to enjoy the next day. The menu is large and definitely offers something for everyone. You can find steaks, seafood, chicken, pasta, burgers, sandwiches and of course their Greek specialities. The staff is excellent, welcoming, friendly and quick. Amanda, our hostess, greets us like family. In addition you can choose from a selection of desserts and beer and specialty mimosas are available. You can't go wrong at Pegusus.

S
SUZANNE BEHLMAIER

We`ve been here several times over the years. My husband brought me the first time I was here. My favorite dinners are the pork chop meals, broccoli shrimp pasta, and salads. The chicken and other Slovakia are the best, too. The servers and staff always make me feel special, almost like family. We always go after 4pm, because my favorite hostess, Amanda, is there.

d
danielle Riley

My fiance and I decided to eat breakfast at pegasus because I've never been! It was great, I just didn't know to ask for medium eggs (if you don't like the white part runny) and if over easy then it's likely to be a bit runny!! It was DELICIOUS AND VERY VERY AFFORDABLE! We will definitely stop there again.

M
Marann Smothers

Passed by this place soooo many times and figured they had good food so decided to finally give it a try and I was very pleased with just the burger, fries and coleslaw. The customer service was very pleasant and welcoming. I can't wait to go back and try some more items off the menu... DEFINITELY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE....

M
Michele Willner

Very nice. My first time at Pegasus. My mother and her school bus friends all go there two days a week and enjoy it tremendously. The Christmas decorations were absolutely gorgeous. Mr Pegasus kudos you did a wonderful job at the Christmas holidays decorating The food and service were very good.

A
Amy Bumbaco

Love going to Pegasus. Food is reasonable and tastes good. My daughter loves the spanikopita. The waitress are very helpful, especially the manager Amanda!

L
Leah Boulware

My family and I stopped here while visiting a friend, the food was absolutely spectacular! The service was great and the place was clean and Beautifully decorated. We’ve never had Greek food before, DEFINITELY RECOMMEND!

A
Andrew Takacs

Went to Pegasus last night. Amazing! I forgot how good it is. The waitress was an older lady, brownish hair, and great! She was being so kind to the old people around us.

M
Matt D

Our favorite for breakfast or lunch. Ham and cheese omelette and chicken souvlaki wrap are the best!

J
John Wilczak

Great food, our service was prompt.

K
Kim Nicinski

We ordered few minutes layer we had our meal. Hostess was very friendly courteous fast and we loved her. We will be back.

N
Natasha

Good breakfast deals - have a Belgian Waffle. One of the few restaurants open 24/7 that's not a Denny's. Great coffee too!

B
Brenda L

We had a great meal after visiting a college in the area. The diner is clean and comfortable. Great service and all of our meals were very tasty with good size portions.

C
CJ Jojo

A wonderful place to visit. It was busy yet... The server was fantastic. She took our orders with a smile and made us feel like we were the only people in the restaurant (a rarity for busy diners). Drinks were replaced as they emptied. Custom orders were accurate ( not even one garbanzo bean (allergy)). I had the gyro slavaki salad. The meat was super tender a wonderful surprise since most places cook it into leather. My one friend ordered a hamburger medium rare, she said it was perfect. My other friend ordered a club sandwich ( to be honest these are hard to mess up. ) she said it was quite tasty and the lettuce and tomato were fresh and made her look forward to garden fresh foods even more . Food was served with a smile and not throw and go like some "upscale" restaurants have started to do. I will definitely be back and definitely recommend to others

S
Sharon Klein

Met with a family member who I hadn't seen in 25yrs. Was perfect place to eat and have a meal. Service was outstanding as was good. Atmosphere was perfect. Our waitress was observing but not hanging over shoulders. Was a great place. I highly highly recommend. Had a great choice of foods on menu. For those not into Greek food you have plenty of options.

B
Branden Dickson

Really enjoyed my food at Pegasus. It was a great family friendly atmosphere with awesome service! Our table ate chicken souvlaki and French toast meal!

M
Matthew Carlacci

Great fish fry. Friendly service Recently had the yankee traditional pot roast. Was very good

R
Roman Stoisolovich

Best French fries ever! The food was cooked perfectly and the searing was very fast😁

R
Ronald Campbell

First time going there for dinner and already planning on returning for the breakfast buffet on Sunday. Great food and service.

D
Dave Perkins

Tasty food, great service, big portions... What's not to love? Prices are reasonable for what you get. No complaints. Been a LONG time since I've been there, and it's as good as I remember.

C
Casey Taylor

Best diner in town. Relaxed environment, quick service, and friendly staff. Definitely worth stopping in for their breakfast buffet as well.

Rozalyn Haley
Rozalyn Haley

Waitress was friendly and attentive. The coffee was hot and delicious served in a China mug. I ordered a sub and my mom had beef on weck, both were very good. Inside the restaurant is all decked out for the holidays. It wads a very pleasant dining experience.

Neil Bandinelli
Neil Bandinelli

Food was great and came out very quickly! A+ by them. Also very affordable for a nice breakfast date!

Antoinetta Lindell
Antoinetta Lindell

I love to order the chicken souvlaki with Greek potatoes. It's very good and always enough left to take home for a second meal. We come here as a group because the menu is diverse enough that everyone can find something they like.

Cynthia Russell
Cynthia Russell

Has always been one of my mother's and my favorite spots for the chicken soulvaki. Staff is always nice.

Joseph
Joseph

I Have been a loyal patron for more than 20 years, I have witnessed various changes in the staff throughout this time. However, one thing that has remained constant is the exceptional quality of your food. The meals have consistently met, and often exceeded, my expectations, which speaks volumes about Pegasus commitment to maintaining high standards. I would like to highlight the friendly and welcoming nature of the staff. Their professionalism and warmth significantly enhance the overall dining atmosphere, making every visit a pleasure. I wholeheartedly recommend Pegasus to others who seek great food paired with attentive service. I would like to Thank them for continuing to uphold such commendable standards over the years. I look forward to many more enjoyable visits in the future.

Lillie Holman
Lillie Holman

I went here while visiting family not too long ago. The food was absolutely amazing! My husband is a very picky eater but the menu has great options that even he was able to rave about. The service was quick and friendly. They were amazing with our large group and were very accommodating with our little ones too! I will definitely be returning.

Charlie McNeely
Charlie McNeely

Delicious breakfast, hot coffee and extremely friendly service. Great prices, plenty of seating and parking. Glad I found it on Google Maps.

Cindy Resch
Cindy Resch

Delicious meal. I got a sandwich I think was called steak florentine. It was 👌 perfectly prepared and very delicious. The fries were fresh and hot. I like them a bit thicker but these were yummy. Wanted dessert but was too full. Excellent & friendly service. Easy to get to location with lots of parking. Clean, well supplied bathroom. Forgot to take pic of main menu (which had something for everyone). They also have a 65+ menu with budget-friendly options for older folks.

Miranda Hansen
Miranda Hansen

Miss Jennifer was wonderful! She provided excellent customer service and had a great sense of humor. We came in about 45 mins before closing and she still gave us a warm welcome. I hope she doesn’t get upset that we have this photo but I need everyone to know who she is. Did I mention she is wonderful!? The only thing that’s mediocre is the roast beef and breakfast food. Otherwise I think everything else on the menu isn’t too bad:) Great service from Jennifer!

Ron Mexico
Ron Mexico

Food & service was great the waitress was trying to apologize because maybe the food took a little while but we didn't think it was an issue.I just replied good food takes time.Our family been coming here for years usual spot b4 or after the Fair. has always been good food & service

James Santos
James Santos

Pegasus was great! Service was super friendly and quick. The food tasted wonderful. Loved their Greek burrito that offer, gyro, steak and chicken, all in one! Awesome wholesome spot in Hamburg!

J
James C.

Excellent service all around. Our waitress Abby was friendly, attentive, and professional, with great menu knowledge and solid recommendations. Everything ran smoothly--drinks stayed full, food was…

J
James C.

Excellent service all around. Our waitress Abby was friendly, attentive, and professional, with great menu knowledge and solid recommendations. Everything ran smoothly--drinks stayed full, food w…

M
Marilyn W.

Very nice place! We went to Christmas in the country. It's practically Next door to the hamburg Fairgrounds. Places is huge very clean, friendly staff great service and food. Highly recommend.

M
Marilyn W.

Very nice place! We went to Christmas in the country. It's practically Next door to the Hamburg Fairgrounds. Places is huge very clean, friendly staff great service and food. Highly recommend.

M
Marilyn W.

Very nice place! We went to Christmas in the country. It's practically Next door to the Hamburg Fairgrounds. Places is huge very clean, friendly staff great service and food. Highly recommend.

D
Denise L.

We have been here for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The food is always great. Servers are thoughtful and friendly which is why we keep coming back.

L
LibrarianBecky

Stopped here for breakfast recently. Waitress was lovely—attentive and pleasant. Food was great. I had an omelette with home fries with onions. I would recommend. Lots of seating and parking, so…

L
LibrarianBecky

Stopped here for breakfast recently. Waitress was lovely—attentive and pleasant. food was great. I had an omelette with home fries with onions. I would recommend. Lots of seating and parki…

L
LibrarianBecky

Stopped here for breakfast recently. Waitress was lovely—attentive and pleasant. Food was great. I had an omelette with home fries with onions. I would recommend. Lots of seating and parking, …

L
LibrarianBecky

Stopped here for breakfast recently. waitress was lovely—attentive and pleasant. Food was great. I had an omelette with home fries with onions. I would recommend. Lots of seating and parking, …

L
LibrarianBecky

Stopped here for breakfast recently. Waitress was lovely—attentive and pleasant. Food was great. I had an omelette with home fries with onions. I would recommend. Lots of seating and parking, …

P
Pat C

I ordered roast beef on weck it was great ! Meat was very good very tender. It came with a lot of french fries and cole slaw. I had it delivered it arrived quick and was hot.

p
ppijacki

Courtney our server was outstanding. We both had the Mahi Mahi fried fish dinner. It was huge and so tasty. They practice social distancing and everyone stays safe. The prices are very good.

R
Ryan Maggio

This is a pretty good place to go. The food is good, the servers are pleasant and helpful, and the prices are reasonable. One caveat I will add, be careful when ordering salads. While the salad was tasty, not all of the ingredients in the salad were listed on the menu, and this was confirmed as intentional by the server. If you have things you don't like on your salads, I'd ask what specifically will come on it before you order it.

K
Kelly

Friendly staff and a comfortable clean environment. The food was 'ok'. I has a shrimp salad and French onion soup, both were pretty good. The person I was with got the ravioli special, could have had a few more ravioli. It was a LOT of sauce and had to search for the ravioli, they were hard to find!

K
Kevin F. Dinan (KFD68)

I would have given a 5but I just haven't been there in a long time! Jeez prolly 15-20 yrs... Wow does time fly by when you think you are busy! 🤨 We , the Flanagan mob use to go for after hrs breakfast👍 was the good times I'll say!! Buddy use to rent Apt next door! 👌 Convenient! No pics sadly to say🥺

P
Paula Herbert

Great service. Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu and friendly. They had a condensed menu the Sunday we went, so I wasn't able to get what I had looked at on their full website menu. They were able to make my grandma's order even though it wasn't on the condensed menu, though. The fries are pretty tasty- and the portion for the side order was very generous. Worth checking out if you are in the area!

R
Racheal Warters

Portion was plentiful. I was stuffed after 1/4 of the meal. Service was prompt. The homefries are cut small, which made for a perfect full cook ..Only reason I give a 4 out of 5 is because they were out of both desserts that I was looking forward to taking home to share with friends.

M
Makeal Jones

Delicious food 🥗, great customer service👩‍🍳, okay indoor atmosphere, great outdoor atmosphere🌴🌳. I recommend this restaurant 👍🏽

t
tammy w

Thanks for accommodating us for our dad's 80th birthday... would be nice if you took reservations... but because we showed up early (before the breakfast buffet started) our group of 20 was able to be seated. We would've liked a second choice for egg type since there used to be two and now just plain scrambled. Otherwise there are a lot of options. Waitress was great...pleasant and on the ball... thank you!

J
John Hwang

Fine and fun with a good atmosphere. Special shout out to Abby, great service!

W
Wayne Deskiewicz

Got seated fast Waitress was very kind attentive Food was good and it was a good value

R
Richard Eppolito

The food is always consistently good. The Dine and Go program subsidized by the county of Erie ended. The Dine and Go menu still exists however the price of $6.00 is now $12.00, just a heads up.

Jimmy Cycon
Jimmy Cycon

Excellent service all around. Our waiter Abby was friendly, attentive, and professional, with great menu knowledge and solid recommendations. Everything ran smoothly—drinks stayed full, food was correct and timely, and the experience felt relaxed and welcoming. You can tell she genuinely cares about providing great service, and it made the meal that much better. Would definitely eat here again and would recommend to anyone!

Kathryn Kramer
Kathryn Kramer

Pretty good breakfast food and mimosas yummy! Have not tried lunch or dinner. Waitress could have been more friendly.

Kathy H
Kathy H

A Hamburg ‘institution’ - they have been around 40+ years. Sound - good food - good service - good prices. We were very happy with our meals - I’m vegetarian so opted for the lentil soup and a grilled cheese - were good. I did see a house made veggie burger as another option. Mom had the chicken souvlaki - loved it - and she’s very particular!

C
Colleen O.

Greek food and more . I had a seize the deal offer ($50 certificate for $25 ) . Waitress was new and needed guidance with the certificate . Also forgot about my side of fries with my entree, but to…

C
Colleen O.

greek food and more . I had a seize the deal offer ($50 certificate for $25 ) . Waitress was new and needed guidance with the certificate . Also forgot about my side of fries with my entree, bu…

C
Colleen O.

Greek food and more . I had a seize the deal offer ($50 certificate for $25 ) . waitress was new and needed guidance with the certificate . Also forgot about my side of fries with my entree, but to…

M
Michael T.

Excellent spot for breakfast. Family owned, great food huge portions. Excellent.\n\nWe have made this stop a tradition on the way to see Bills games. Right down the road. Great place to fill up befor…

M
Michael T.

Excellent spot for breakfast. Family owned, great food huge portions. Excellent.\n\nWe have made this stop a tradition on the way to see Bills games. Right down the road. Great place to fill up b…

M
Michael T.

Excellent spot for breakfast. Family owned, great food huge portions. Excellent.\n\nWe have made this stop a tradition on the way to see Bills games. Right down the road. Great place to fill up bef…

A
A P.

Pam is absolutely lovely! She greeted us warmly, helped me with details in ordering my entree which was delicious! Try the chicken souvlaki breakfast with English muffin and the open chicken souvla…

A
A P.

Pam is absolutely lovely! She greeted us warmly, helped me with details in ordering my entree which was delicious! Try the chicken souvlaki breakfast with English muffin and the open chicken souv…

A
Anthony S.

My wife and I went there for lunch. She got the fish fry and I've got the open chicken souvlaki. My chicken was super dry. My wife's fish fry was greasy and tasted like old oil. We expressed this…

C
Carol V.

Open chicken souvlaki ordered for pickup. chicken was over cooked and dry. The pita was actually hard and burnt on one side.

S
Sarah D.

I stopped here today for breakfast with friends. Our original restaurant choice was closed. I hadn't been here in years and I'm glad we stopped by. The coffee was okay. I had the Ride & Shine omele…

B
Brian L

Ordered burger and fries medium well, burger came back burnt both sides tasted like charcoal.. fries were hard, stale probably leftover from previous order, doubt I'll be back

B
Brian L

Ordered burger and fries medium well, burger came back burnt both sides tasted like charcoal.. fries were hard, stale probably leftover from previous order, doubt I'll be back

B
Brian L

Ordered burger and fries medium well, burger came back burnt both sides tasted like charcoal.. fries were hard, stale probably leftover from previous order, doubt I'll be back

T
TBone1965

My wife and I went there for lunch. She got the fish fry and I’ve got the open chicken souvlaki. My chicken was super dry. My wife’s fish fry was greasy and tasted like old oil. We expressed this con…

T
TBone1965

My wife and I went there for lunch. She got the fish fry and I’ve got the open chicken souvlaki. My chicken was super dry. My wife’s fish fry was greasy and tasted like old oil. We expressed this…

A
Arnie G

We had Breakfast and Dinner at Pegosus and both times the service and the food were outstanding. Very friendly place and the portions were more than either of us could finish. Will return to this r…

A
Arnie G

We had breakfast and Dinner at Pegosus and both times the service and the food were outstanding. Very friendly place and the portions were more than either of us could finish. Will return to this r…

B
Brian Klute

Food was great for our party of 3. Just not sure when the restaurant started playing a prayer/ sermon channel over the speakers. I was told they don't pick the channel. We had to sit thru people discussing the scriptures and Bible. I'm not anti religion but it felt like I Sat thru mass while I ate.Other tables grumbled about it as well. Guess I don't have to go to church Sunday now....

Z
Zach Tucker

This was our first time at Pegasus. The service was great! Our waitress was very quick and friendly. I had the blackened prime rib. It did not have a lot of blackened taste on it. Overall the food was was just ok and also a little pricey.

S
Steven Janowski

Ordered this to my hotel. Rarely ever leave reviews but how does a business that prepares and serves food for a living send something out with NO flavor. Steak wasn’t seasoned at all. Eggs weren’t seasoned at all. Hash browns weren’t seasoned at all. Whoever prepared this didn’t even try.

Clifford St James
Clifford St James

Friday fish fry , very small -looks like it was caught in a fish bowl size, mentioned it to the waitress, the typical I'm sorry, and nothing ,,,,,,,, for the price should have received a lot bigger, business as usual, price go's up & size go's down. COVID 19 aftermath is alive and doing well ps . the beer batter crust was good

Mary Krencik
Mary Krencik

First time here and won't be back. Had the fish and chips. The the fish had no taste and the fries were undercooked. I tried my brothers gyro/souvlaki melt and didn't care for the taste of the beef. A glass Moscato and it was $7.29. Oh well, one and done!

M
Marcia Lussier

One of our party had ordered beef souvlaki, medium rare, and it came well done. He was very unhappy about it and Drew it to the attention of the waitress. I ordered prime rib. To my shop, instead of the nice thick big slice that I am used to, it was a thin slice about half the size of a regular prime rib. I ordered it medium rare, and it was definitely cooked medium. I returned it, and they came back and told me that they didn't have any more prime rib and did I want it anyway. They didn't knock anything off the bill I don't think. It was all right. Nothing special. The service was good and our waitress was patient. Everyone else seemed to enjoy their meal. However, the Greek potatoes were not good at all.

J
Joanne Eckert

Drove all the way to Hamburg to pick up what used to be the best fish fry around. Not anymore smh...the American potato salad tastes like German potato salad, the macaroni salad has no taste, the coleslaw was gross. On top of all that the fish was dry and they couldn't even be bothered to put plasticware in the bag 🙄...won't go back again period.

E
Eric Metcalf

Been going there for years..unfortunately the food has gone down alot.. we went there for dinner last night, my wife ordered the meatloaf dinner..it looked like it was a tv dinner..very disappointed. On a bright side the hostess was very sweet

M
Mary Kay Waterman

We have been going here for years. I am giving only 2 stars because we are tired of not getting food that has been ordered and paid for and not in order or not what was ordered. This has gotten to the point that we need to find someplace new! Even though it was take out this time and many other times it was in restaurant, food is missing. This time German potatoes salad and the fish broiled was to be plain Even stated no paprika. Outside container said German but no potatoes at all this time. Also never know which recipes for salads, cole slaw etc you will get this week. SERVICE for take out is terrible. Even if you give a tip. When ordering in, instructions such as no seasoning, medium, etc is ignored quite often. YES there has been a pandemic but really!! The prices have increased considerably and still the constant problems with the order. Could deal with the constant change of preparation but the missing food or wrongful thing is just inexcusable Noticed that some staff is different but there is some that have been there for years. So what is the problem? We should not have to constantly have discrepancy with orders,service etc Get your act together as it is said. Use to enjoy having a meal from Pegasus, now it's stressful even when we think the order is explained completely but then get something else! Beware you might not get what you order!!

C
Cathy Snyder

We ordered the fish fry. VERY greasy and most of coating was soggy. The carrot cake at best was mediocre. Honestly, rice pudding was the worst I've had. Not flavorful and creamy. Tasted watered down somehow. Would not order same meal again. However, waitress was excellent.

R
Ryan Mulqueen

I went here with a few friends for breakfast recently and I can't say much positive about our experience. I ordered the biscuits with sausage gravy and it looked/tasted like it came right out of a can. The biscuits were pretty much stale which also didn't help. The service was alright, but it felt like many of the people working were a little lost, but all of them were friendly and extremely nice nonetheless. I can't comment on dinner, but I can't recommend breakfast at all.

C
Carley Anne

We’ve been here once before and got breakfast. It was great! Food was good, it came out fast, and it was great for the price. So we decided to go there again yesterday. I got a Reuben sandwich. We get our food and I start eating and realize there’s a black hair in the fries. Gross. So I discreetly tell the waitress, who apologizes and says they will replace it immediately. After they bring out the new dish, I had already lost my appetite and ate only a little bit. They didn’t even give me another pickle! :( When we get ready to pay and leave, we were expecting some sort of rectification like the meal being free, discounted, or a free dessert. But nope, nothing. That’s kind of crazy. Anyway, I get home tonight and reheat my replacement Reuben sandwich. Take a bite out of it, no way there’s another black hair in the middle of the sandwich right? Well there absolutely was. I originally wasn’t going to make a review because things happen and I’m more forgiving than most people but this is really insane to me... It sucks because I’d like to support a small local restaurant but after two meals with hair in them and zero effort in terms of customer service? No thanks.

A
Annette W.

Went there for lunch earlier today. We were there for 20 minutes before the waitress came to ask for a drink order. She never came back with refills on coffee. Took 40 minutes to get our food and i…

W
Wendy J.

Our dinner experience was horrible. Appetizer showed up with our meals and it was cold. The French fries on my plate were cold. My husband ordered a chicken sandwich that was supposed to have BBQ s…

T
Travelswithdog1

If If I could have given it negative points I would have. We had a terrible waitress she had an attitude when my senior companion asked her questions about the options that came with her dinner. …

D
Deb Mueller

I remember going to Pegasus over the years for breakfast and at night for coffee and dessert. The food was always solid. I have not been here in years but stopped in on New Years Eve to get take out dessert. The remodeled atmosphere seems nice but the dessert was disappointing. The lemon pie was meh at best and we had to throw the rice pudding away. It tasted fermented. I think it had gone bad. Disappointing. Not the quality I remember.

C
Colleen Barker

Was told to make sure there was no peppers, because of a severe allergy. When we got home it was loaded with peppers. The people on the phone offered no assurance or refund, unless we drive another 20 minutes back there. And for what so they can mess it up more.

D
Dean Williams

We ordered at 8 pm when closing time is 9 pm. The coffee was old and I asked if they could brew a new pot. The answer was no, not so close to closing time. HOW CHEAP! I had met a friend from high school and needed to drive 3 hours home, so I would have enjoyed 3 cups from a fresh pot! You can't get any more customer-unfriendly that decision; it made me decide to never return.

k
kate rose muscarella

I was extremely disappointed. Tried for the first time for my birthday dinner and was honestly grossed out. I asked for no onion on 3 if my orders all were covered in onion to a point the taste was overwhelming. Asked for side of dressing and received nothing. The chicken wrap had little to no veggies and what it did have was wilted and soggy. Don't understand why the menu says all soluvaki contain cucumber (which is expected) and nothing came with cucumber. The Greek fries were a like a pile of mush. Out of my entire order I was able to eat a mozzarella stick. 80 dollars terribly spent. Never again. And when I complained about my order over door dash they only offered 5 dollars back. 5. On an 80 dollar order that only one thing was edible.

P
Paula Michalak

We have eaten at Pegasus several times both in person and ordered online. We go to Pegasus because their food is usually really good at an ok price. Last night however we were very disappointed. Everything looked and tastes like it was leftovers from several days ago. The salad was browning, the meat was difficult to cut and swallow, it just wasn't up to Pegasus standards. I emailed the establishment and called. But I haven't heard back yet. I hope they aren't under new management or this is their new business model because it was extremely disappointing. For $60.00, I could have gone somewhere else and enjoyed my meal. Very disappointed.

T
Tamara Boyd

This place is gross. I felt like I was eating in an overpriced Waffle House. Flies everywhere, having to swat them alway while trying to have a conversation was pretty annoying. Dirty exhaust fans above and dust bunny lint blowing in the breeze waiting to fall from the tiles and all around you. You could see the dirt on the tiles 3 sections away. The food came quickly, but one entree had hair in it and then took twice the time to get a replacement, no discount offered, nothing but a replacement and wait was given. We didn’t blame the waitress, she tried to cure the entree issue, but overall, this place needs to be cited by the health department. If their dining room looks like this, I can just imagine how the kitchen is kept!!

C
Courtney Harmon

Came in at 8pm- an hour before close. The girl at the host stand said “hi we close in an hour.” I said “okay, well it’s just me and my daughter. Can we still eat?” I really wish she would have just said no because she made the next hour really awful. She sat us down and turns out she was our waitress too. Wonderful. Every single time she spoke to us she mentioned how long it was before they closed. At about 8:20 she said I couldn’t order anything else because the cooks were cleaning the oven so me and my daughter got stuck splitting a meal. My daughter (she’s 4) started feeling sick and I wanted to leave but our waitress literally left and didn’t come back after that. I had to ask someone else for boxes and to find her so I could get the check. Theres no reason to treat someone so rudely just for wanting to get dinner. We didn’t see here for over 20 minutes and had been done with our meal for almost as long. By the time we got the check, We were literally cashing out at 5 minutes to 9. Our bill was 14 bucks and I tipped her 3 dollars and she was MAD. She literally rolled her eyes at me and snatched the money off the counter and shoved it in her pocket without looking up and said “next time please come in earlier because now I have all these tables to clean up” (note that there was another table with two men who cashed out right before us and another older man who is always there who cashed out after us but she didn’t say a word about it to either of them) It’s really upsetting because I’ve been coming here once a week with my daughter and friends for the past 3 months for the Greek food and the sandwhiches. I always leave tips that are 20 percent or more and I don’t stay that long. I was rushed out the door, treated like crap, and I’m so upset that this woman had some sort of chip on her shoulder the entire time we were there from the moment we walked in. I would never consider not tipping someone (maybe she had a bad day) but the comment at the end made me wish I didn’t! What kind of servers are you guys hiring here?!? I don’t even want to come back because of this experience

A
Amy S

How does the place have a 4.3 star review - fake accounts I suspect. First time I was here I had the Chicken Artichoke dish they were offering, please, just save yourself and don't. Today 1/30/24 I ordered the Chicken with Biscuits yesterday, as did the other two in my party. We all agreed it was horrible. Nothing about this dish looked homemade or fresh, just stay away from it. The staff is always pleasant when we go, so I would never blame them.

p
prince

Ordered a chicken souvlaki dinner for takeout over the phone Tuesday evening about an hour before close. The waitress was rude and hung up on me when I still had a rice pudding to order. Didn’t ask if I wanted anything else just said 10 Mins and hung up. I show up 15 minutes later to pick up and it wasn’t even put in the system. The restaurant was not busy. They said it would be another 15 minutes so I left and gave another restaurant my business

M
Michelle Schmidt

Just like a reviewer posted a couple weeks ago I unfortunately ordered the "homemade biscuits and gravy" and it was terrible. First off it was practically cold. Then the biscuit was the size of a half dollar. It was essentially a mini biscuit just one. It did come with eggs and potatoes but I was predominantly interested in the biscuits and gravy, at least a full size biscuit would be in order not a mini one. Now for the taste, it tasted like unseasoned wallpaper paste with some tiny bits of sausage. It was terrible. Had to send it back and then I lost my appetite entirely it was that bad. Definitely not homemade. Very disappointing.

E
Emma Pfohl

First time. We didn’t even get a chance to try the food. We were seated in the back room (white table clothes) just my husband and I. We wait for 23minutes and nobody came over to even take our drink order or say “be right with you”… so we left out the front door. It was a Saturday night at 6:45.

M
Mark Egloff

Haven’t been there in a few years and decided to go back because it used to be a decent place to eat. Not anymore. The food was the worst I’ve ever tried to eat. There were 4 of us and 3 of the 4 said their meals were terrible and didn’t finish. The restaurant was filthy and the bathrooms were nasty. The only good thing was they took some of our food off the bill. I’m 56 and have never before today retuned a dish. I don’t know what happened, but this place definitely went down hill. I would never eat there again.

A
Austin & Jules

I've had a burger from every small business in a 20 mile radias of this place. This was the worst. All you could taste was the dirty grill it was cooked on. Absolutely disgusting. I could taste grease from 10 other menu items. Clean your nasty grill.

M
Mary Kluczynski-Jean

Don’t go for a fish fry,, it was soggy and the batter just fell off,, I knew it was frozen fish because it separated and was watery,,, however,, I will say the sides were excellent! $23??? I should have gone to Wegmans for that!

M
Mark Bonus

My wife and I went there on Easter for the 29.95 brunch the food was surprisingly cold. The sausage was the microwaveable style. It was maybe worth 5.99 we would never go back.

M
Maria

Very disappointed. Had a funeral breakfast here (have had several in the past) and will NEVER return. The eggs and hash browns were cold, there was not enough food even though the count was called in several days before. The danish were never brought out. The pancakes kept running out so everyone was not able to get them. When the owner was approached he did credit $50 off the bill for the Danish but blamed the waitress for not taking them out of the freezer. He also stated that I would not find the price of the buffet anywhere else. I was not complaining about the price, if the food was hot and if they had everything that was listed for the buffet. Also, charged full price for 3 and 4 year old. The count called in was 50 he insisted someone called the night before and changed it to 58 even though noone did. Was overcharged. Owner was not pleasant . Would NOT recommend and will NEVER return.

Stephanie Aloi
Stephanie Aloi

Came in at 8:10 on a Friday winter night and was told they put away the soup because they close at 9:00!!! Then the waitress asked us to hand her jellies and items from out table so she could clean up and get out while we were eating. The food was below average in taste and had to search for waitress just to get the check because she was busy closing up! It wasn’t even 830 yet and people were still coming into the restaurant!

Charlie Eithyfeet
Charlie Eithyfeet

Just returned home from pegasus. Had dinner with my two sons and daughter in law. Turkey was garbage, carrots not cooked. Parking spaces are tight use2

L K
L K

I typically do not write reviews, but this place was terrible. First, the advertised menu was not available. I ordered a cheeseburger due to the limited options. The cheeseburger came out RAW. I had to send it back. The burger looked like a Walmart burger with a COLD slice of cheese on top. The service was mediocre at best. I will not be back. DO BETTER! CARE!!

Nathan Featherstone
Nathan Featherstone

Haven't been here in a long time. Won't be going back. Coffee is disgusting. Even the water tastes weird. Overpriced and the food is meh at best.

Accedi per lasciare una recensione

Accedi
👑 È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Esplora la tua zona

Più ristoranti a Hamburg →
📸

37 Foto

Esplora le foto di Pegasus

Pegasus
Pegasus
Pegasus
Pegasus
Pegasus
+32 Altro
📍

Informazioni su Pegasus

Come arrivare

5748 South Park Ave, Hamburg, NY 14075

Caricamento mappa...
Pegasus
Tocca per le indicazioni

Punti salienti

Buon voto
4.2/5 stelle
💬
Molte recensioni
1834 recensioni
💰
Prezzo moderato
Livello di prezzo
👨‍🍳
greek
Tipo di cucina

Servizi

🥞 Colazione
🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Pranzo
🍾 Cena
Caffè
🍰 Dolci
🥗 Opzioni Vegetariane
🥡 Da Asporto
🚚 Consegna a Domicilio
🍴 Mangiare sul Posto
🚗 Ritiro al Marciapiede

Opzioni di ristorazione

🍽️ Mangiare sul Posto
🥡 Da Asporto
🚚 Consegna a Domicilio
🚗 Ritiro al Marciapiede

Info Ristorante

Stato
Verificato dal proprietario
🕐 Horario Hoy
7AM-9PM
Valutazione
4.2/5
💬 Recensioni
1,834
💰 Livello di prezzo
$$
⏱️ Visita tipica
People typically spend 30 min to 1 hr here
📞 Telefono
+1 716-649-9639
🌐 Sito web
pegasusrestaurant.net
📋 Menu
Vedi Menu

Servizi

🅿️ Parcheggio
Accessibile in sedia a rotelle
🚻 Bagno
💳 Carte di credito
📱 Pagamenti mobili
🏘️

Il Quartiere

Posizione

5748 South Park Ave, Hamburg, NY 14075

📍 Esplora il Quartiere

Weather
Meteo aggiornato ogni ora · Lavoro ed eventi aggiornati quotidianamente
📰

What people say about Pegasus

🎮

Giochi

🎮 Guadagna Punti Mentre Esplori!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta punti per sconti da Pegasus e altri ristoranti

🎮

Guadagna Punti da Pegasus!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta ricompense qui

Guadagna punti extra e riscattali per ricompense da Pegasus

🏆 Ricompense di Pegasus

💰

Sconto 10%

Da Pegasus

1000 pts
Disponibile
🍽️

Antipasto Gratis

Alla tua prossima visita

2500 pts
Limitato
👑

Tavolo VIP

Esperienza premium

5000 pts
Esclusivo

per riscattare ricompense e guadagnare punti

📋 Come funzionano le ricompense?

1

Gioca a Find Me

Ogni 100 punti score = 1 punto ricompensa

2

Accumula Punti

I worker ottengono 2x punti per partita

3

Riscatta Ricompense

Sconti, cibo gratis ed esperienze VIP

Chiama
Lascia una recensione su Google
👑

È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Accedi e gioca

Controlla la tua email!

Nessuna password — ti invieremo un link via email

Ti abbiamo inviato un link di accesso

Controlla la cartella spam se non lo vedi