Delicious pizza. Great people and funny delivery guy 😜 Try the buffalo slice. It's the best on Long Island

Just had a slice of chicken Marsala pizza! It was truly amazing! Best Marsala I ever had! Delicious 😋!!!

Very good pizza. Will make a pizza to your liking. Made a pie with 2 slices no cheese , meatball and sauce. Very accommodating.

Just as good as Jersey. Pizza was honestly amazing. Owner is very sweet and appreciative.

Very unique pizza amazing recipes I totally recommend it!

Great pizza 🍕 and I would definitely recommend the Cesar salad.

We ordered lunch today and the food was excellent and lunch specials were an excellent value for the money. I had veal parmesan and it was excellent! Will be back again!!

My go to local pizza place. Nice family run business and very personable. Great food and great prices!

Great Scilian pizza.

Some of the best pizza around. I really like the quaintness of the place too. Definitely recommend.

My favorite pizza place food is great. Staff is friendly and down to earth. Love this place!

Best pizza ever and the friendliest staff I will definitely be back and recommend

Best pizza in the area , always great service even the delivery drivers are great and nice ! Orders always right and delicious !!

I am visiting from Pennsylvania and had 3 of the best made pizza you could ever imagine. Great place, great food, and met with a great family atmosphere.

The food here is absolutely phenomenal. Whether it’s the salads, pasta, entrees, or pizza, everything here I’ve tried is so delicious and high quality. My family and I love ordering from here and everyone there is so friendly. Absolutely love this place

I always have Mama Mia’s pizza cater my parties the food is amazing all the time never a complaint!! My guest know where we get our food from so they pretty much have had everything and even request their entrees since we put it out on a group message .We’ve been a customer for 8 years now and we aren’t going anywhere ❤️💜Thank you Mama Mia Pizza for all of our party needs and when I don’t feel like cooking! :)

I was craving pizza and I haven't had it in months. My husband frequents this spot so I decided to buy dinner tonight. O M G I am in love. Perfect sauce/cheese ratio, delicious sauce, and reasonably priced. I also had a caprese salad and they were not stingy with the mozzarella like other places. Probably a good pound. Enough for lunch tomorrow. Will definitely be back!

Great pizza, other foods are good as well. Nice staff and fast when you place an order. If they say 20-30 minutes I live close and when I do arrive in the time frame it's always ready. It's my local spot and I couldn't be happier.

Great meatball slice and garlic knots.

First of all me and my family called the pizzeria 30 minutes before closing, and the dude I spoke with was a straight up G for taking my order. My man hooked us up with 2 banging Pies and 1 in yo face Chicken parmigiana sub! Blam! Secondly let’s talk about the taste of the food…YO! We are visiting from Florida and I’m praying that Mama Mia’s would start FedEx’ing their pies. Because man, no one in Florida can play with Mama Mia’s Pizza.... STRAIGHT UP SON!

i was there 2 nights in a row. Bartender is great! Sit at the bar and enjoy meeting some of the locals. Met a daughter from the family on the second night. Food is outstanding as well as friendly service. It is refreshing for Times Square and not being so touristy. Fun place, great food and great drinks !

Had to relocate a birthday party to the nearest pizza place and I'm so glad we did! The food was delicious and the service was wonderful! They even sang Happy Birthday with us! I can't wait to go back for some more of that delicious pizza and wonderful service.

This pizzeria is touch notch Going here for close up 15 years when I worked in the area and just decided to try it one day, never stopped going since Everyone is nice and always pleasant Owners is a sweet heart. Food is always awesome. There is a lot of pizzerias on Long Island but I guarantee You that this will not disappoint Charlie Cvd

I must say I love this restaurant. All of the staff is pleasant and quite personable. Family business with a great tasting pizza. I try to stop there for lunch when I can and when I walk in they already know what I want. Again great place and I tell all my friends and family to stop in. Keep up the great work guys!!!

I don't think twice, too busy to make dinner, I stop by and pick up dinner for my family, they know me by name. Need to cater a party, again this is my go too place, never disappointed. What can I say, they make you feel like family. Food and service excellent

I walked into Mama Mia's and had a very authentic experience. 2 older gentlemen sitting at a table to the left of me speaking in italian enjoying their slices, the king of Queens playing on the TV and a very accommodating lady who I would guess is Mama behind the counter, not to mention excellent pizza (1 pepperoni, 1 regular) I had to make a phone call when I left to share my experience I was so ecstatic. I will definitely be back.

Love this place !!! The owner is a sweetheart and she has great staff. Food is incredible. Garlic knots soup pizza etc. I’ve never been disappointed

I've been a loyal customer for 6 years... the food is excellent, the family and staff of this pizzeria have always made me feel like family.

We used to eat here all the time but I had to stop because it will make you fat. Food is amazing, drivers are quick, dangerous to diets!

Catered a 60th birthday party … food was amazing. The best Chicken Rollatine and Rigatoni alla vodka. Everyone loved it.

Best Pizza in town! Awesome specialty slice options as well as amazing linguini and clams! Family owned and operated I love this place

WE LOVE MAMA MIA'S!!! Great food, great staff! Worth every penny! Never had bad food or service. We have been eating there at least once a week for 8 months!!! They are going to make us broke!!!

Great food.The penne a la vodka delicious.We love the pizza.The staff there are lovely.Thank you guys I appreciate everything

These guys are just the best. Awesome staff and even better food. My car died on me and the guys came to help right away. Seriously recommend this place!!

One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Highly recommend this place.

Mama Mia this is some great food!!!! I ordered a Chicken Parmesan Hero. Yum Yum. I went back the next day for another one. Very good!!!!! Great people there working. Atmosphere? They had a Rocky movie playing on the TV. Pizza, Rocky, Ronkonkoma, You can't get much more Italian than that! Thank guys for the great time. I SHALL RETURN!

We got pizzas salad and garlic knots from Mama Mias for my daughters first birthday party. From the moment I called they were so accommodating and worked with us to get everything we wanted. I spoke to Anna Marie and she was the nicest ! The food was delicious and this will definitely be our go to pizzeria from now on !

Pizza is very good. I had a regular slice and a Margareta slice. Regular slice was good looking, cooked well and is a flaky style crust. Margareta is a pan style pizza with a nice garlic/oil/oregano flavor mixed with fresh mozzarella and tomato. Was a little heavy on the parmigiano cheese, but otherwise a nice balanced slice. Would definitely go back again!

We're visiting from Florida. They did not disappoint. My husband called late to order. The food was delicious. If I could give them 10 stars I would. We appreciate how tasty you made these pizza.

I've tried a few of their slices (pepperoni, plain, Buffalo, etc) over the last 5 years, they've remained consistent and delicious. I've also tried a bunch of their other items like pinwheels and what not, all top notch. Not the best pizza I've had in my life, but way up there, better than anything else I've tried in the area for sure.

Excellent customer service even at a busy hour. The food is extraordinary. It has been a while since I have had good ......Italian original flavors. Small but cozy. They make you feel part of their family, especially Anna Marie. Kudos to this place!!

I cannot recommend Mama Mia’s Pizzeria enough for catering! We recently used them for a family party, and they absolutely knocked it out of the park. The food was fresh, hot, and incredibly delicious—everyone was raving about it. The trays of penne alla vodka, chicken francese, chicken parm, lasagna, garlic knots, and caesar salad which is make with a home made dressing just like all of their dressing they use was unbelievable and something youll never taste anywhere else. Everything was top-notch and exceeded our expectations. The staff was professional, making the entire process smooth and stress-free. They helped us choose the right amount of food for our guests, and their recommendations were spot-on. It’s clear that Mama Mia’s puts care into every order, and their quality shines through. If you’re looking for catering that will impress your guests and leave them full and happy, Mama Mia’s Pizzeria is the way to go. We’ll definitely be using them again for future events!

Ordered through Too Good To Go tonight & so glad we did. We received 4 Pepperoni Pinwheels & a Salad pizza Slice. Everything was delicious & the dressing for the salad pizza was garlicky perfection. Thank you, we will be back soon!

So I just ordered on the phone and the guy on the phone was perfectly professional as well as amazing customer service telling me each flavor of whatever drink and not being frustrated among other things. I'm waiting for my food to be delivered and that phone call put high expectations on what I ordered! I'll update once I Actually get and try the food!

Had a birthday celebration for my wife last Saturday. Ordered Zuppa de pesce, seafood marcchiare, buffalo pizza and regular pizza. Annamarie was so great and accommodating taking the order and even offered to call me 5 minutes before pick up time which worked out great as we are only 5 minutes away. All the food was amazing and delicious, just like we always expect it to be and can’t beat the excellent service. This is our go to place for grandma pies as they make the best.. Always good, always fresh and always great customer service. Highly recommend this wonderful place

Honestly if I could give more than five stars I would! My husband wanted fettuccine Alfredo for his birthday and we came here because it was reasonably priced. But not only that. IT WAS AMAZING. There was plenty of sauce for everything. I got the eggplant parm. We will be coming back again :).

Owner and staff are very friendly & polite. Family run & has loyal customers greeted by first name. Something I look for in small businesses

The specialty slices are excellent, same goes for the regular, Sicilian and grandma but definitely try a specialty slice, you wont regret it. The hot wings are mouthwatering good. Out of this world quality and freshness. I had a party for my brothers graduation and had a catering order done by them. Baked ziti, chicken parmigiana, sausage and peppers, baked clams… you cannot go wrong ordering here. Happy to do business with them now and plenty more years to come.

In town from Detroit, stumbled upon this place and sure glad I did..awesome atmosphere great staff..awesome pizza!!

Dawn Casey

We have been customers since the Grand Opening! A family and neighborhood favorite.

Mike N

This place is a staple of our hometown. The food is always great. Pizza, chicken parm, the sauce…you name it. It’s always great. And Mama Mia herself is as good as it can get. She remembers my kids, gives them lollipops whenever they come in, and genuinely cares. They all work extremely hard behind the counter, and I’m grateful to have a pizza place close to home with that warm hometown feel. The best in town, always. Thanks for being great people!

Andy Sharma

Great options at great prices. Food was amazing and service was also great. They had the food ready in no time and it was all fresh. Certainly eating here again I am in the area.

Wendy Hildebrand

Always excited to get our Fresh Hot pies! Caesar Salad is always freshly made with delicious grilled Chicken! We live out of state and this is always our go to restaurant! Thank you for always being dinner we can count on! Thank you for always being intentional to treat us as a friend!

Ryan

I came here for dinner with my girlfriend and her family. I decided to order their chicken parmigiana. As soon as my meal came to me I knew I wouldn’t be able to finish it. I was expect a couple of chicken cutlets & was presented with what was apparently two chicken breasts. It was fantastic. I was only able to eat one of them and a small part of the second one. I was so full, I didn’t get to touch the linguine. So I just took the rest home and had for lunch the next day.

zuperzleeper

This was 2nd out of 4 places I tried during my week in this area. Great service, taste, and people seem to have great relationships flowing.

Marlene is Key

Mama Mia’s is delicious! I had a pepperoni slice and it was super tasty and the atmosphere is great! Location is very accessible and will definitely go again. 🍕

bob smith

One of the few family run businesses left great food meatballs.Excellent veal Cutlet, parmesan, excellent Chicken Roll.Excellent Pizza, excellent, nice family.Thank you

Amanda Bianco

Great atmosphere great food. Depending on all of that as my absolute favorite, it’s to die for. Great crust on the pizza as well, thumbs up!

Daphney

The food here is really good. I got a pie - half pepperoni and half veggie. I’ve had veggie pizza at several pizzerias as this was the best thus far. The veggies tasted like they were sautéed in garlic ahead of time. I also tried their house salad and lasagna. The common thread is the sauce which is really good. I ate at the restaurant and the service great. The staff was polite, attentive and made good recommendations. The price was also fair.

Angelo Julian

If you really want good tasting pizza and food this is the place enjoyed everything I've had here so far.

Amanda Fernandez

We held a backyard birthday party for my mom and had Mama Mia’s cater it. Anna Maria and Antonio went above and beyond and did not disappoint! And that’s not even talking about the food yet! Amazing people, but AMAZING food! The best shrimp scampi and chicken rollatini that not only WE have ever had, but all our party guests as well! They have gained about 30 new patrons all willing to travel for their incredible food. Delivery was on time, hot, and delicious! Very generous portions for catering. WE WILL BE BACK! Again and again and again!

Doobie

Great place, amazing food, what is there not to like. Try the pasta fagioli soup one day, you won’t be disappointed.

Lori Schmidt

Fast delivery, the nicest people, best service, affordable lunch menu that are filling and delicious! Cannot say enough great things about this family owned pizzeria. Amazing Sicilian pie, our Friday night fave! Stop in! Order regularly home and work

Andrey Koval

Loved this place, first time trying NY pizza, I was standing in line off to the side and asked one of the customers if they tried this chicken pie with mozzarella cheese, she looks at me and says, Everything is good here! And it was, ordered a few pies, tipped the guy and he brings me garlic bread as a free side! Very nice ppl here.

Ramona Williams Robertson

Greek salad was fresh with tasty house dressing. I found a new pizza spot! My kids also love the garlic knots with fresh garlic, and the cheese slices were delicious too.

AJosh Transport

Great spot. I was incredibly hungry when I walked in and got everything. Chicken wings, vodka pasta , a couple of cheese slices, Stromboli , and every bite was amazing

Customer since beginning since covid quality has gone down moved away yrs ago but still came to them but no more the family is wonderful. But cutting corners shows . Anna

I live around the corner and this is my go to pizza place, they have great garlic knots, amazing Greek salad, and super yummy scicilian pizza.

Majority of the food was perfect! Sadly, I ate some "bad" seafood and regretted it the next day (I believe it was the muscles, but we had a whole platter so its impossible to know for sure). I would still order from here, but might avoid certain seafood items! Would recommend to a friend! Pizza was great, rolls were great!

My favorite pizzeria. By far one of the best on the island, and with great, friendly staff. The selection of food is varied, and all of it has been delicious. I've been coming here for years, and haven't found anywhere else that I've enjoyed more. For those turned off by the prices, understand that most pizzerias are a bit more expensive, but here you get good portions for the price.

Janice Paulsen

I went there about 6 or 7 years ago for dine in lunch. We sat by the WINDOW and while we were eating, a roach was crawling on the wall right next to me. We immediately threw our lunch out and haven't been back. That made me very sad because they have good food, great marinara sauce. I understand many restaurants have roaches but it was very unsettling to see one in the sunlite window. Hopefully that shopping center was able to exterminate the roaches.

Carol Weber

We walked in because a lady walking out with heroes highly recommended this place. Strong smell of clams & frying oil. Pizza looks good, good crust, lots of stringy cheese. Sauce is a touch too sweet. Otherwise, really decent. Slices are reasonable.

The food and service is hit or miss. When they hit, it’s awesome. When they miss, it’s pretty awful. Some days the staff are amazing, other days they are miserable and rude. Reasonable price and convenient location.

Went in for slice, highly recommended, the man behind counter with close beard didn't look happy thought maybe he was having bad day. I smiled and said, "high, smile" in a friendly manner. He said he cant because I had a small TRUMP pin on my sweater. Then he slide my pizza to me across counter. The pizza was delicious but politics have no place in business. Not professional. I would patron a place that's owned by a democratic (I'm a Republican) that's why will love in the best country in the world. Again their pizza was excellent

Very small inside which is fine but not really made for eat in. We came on 2.5 hours before close on a Saturday evening and they had two pizzas to choose from for counter service. When our slices came out (waited a few minutes before eating) the pizza crust was warm but the cheese was burn the roof of your mouth! It was ok nothing wrong but nothing special either.

The woman answering the phone has absolutely NO customer service skills, what so ever. She is probably one of the rudest ones I've dealt with in a while! It took over 2 hours for my pizza to be delivered and it was cold when I finally got it. When the kid delivering got to my door, he attempted to inflate the price by $2.50 only to recant his story once I phoned the pizzeria. Never again will I call Mama Mia's! Horrible experience!!!!

Usually good over all! But tonight was off!! The ETA was 45 min, but that turned into 1 hour and 25 min. real quick, then the pizza was cold, and the order was wrong. Maybe an off night, but it has been going down hill for some time now. Be weary!

Called to ask if baked clams were whole or chopped. Was told chopped. Yea, they were whole and the bread topping was all mushy and soaked with melted butter. For shame. Never again!!

I ordered the pizza with eggplant on it and a two liter of Coke. An hour and twenty minutes later it shows up almost cold; like it was made when I called then delivered later. I realized that I didn't get the coke until a few minutes after they left. Called them back. 25 minutes later it shows up. Never again.

This place has gone downhill. The pizza used to be good but not anymore. The biggest complaint is with the female owner. She’s very unprofessional and nasty to her employees.

The blond that takes order is sometimes nasty and nice when boss is around. When Dino the own er was alive the place was clean.. soda machine always filled. My recent visit the place was dirty and the pizza is not same. I think they changed the sauce and dough.

I used to like this place. Today I order pizza at 1pm to be picked up at 4:15pm. Order wasn't ready, pizza went into their oven for 5 minutes. I asked twice if that pizza was cooked, manager is like "yeah". I come home to serve the pizza to my friends and its RAW. I call up, we'll make you a new one, wants me to drive 25 minutes to pick up another pizza? You don't COOK A PIZZA IN 5 MINUTES!!!!. I didn't buy pizza to be driving back to get another one. Had to order pizza locally. Waste of time and money. Never again!

A friend of mine who lives in ronkonama tried to get an order delivered. They screwed up the order. ( not the first time) delivery guy was rude and cursed out his wife!!!

Worst experience at a pizza place. The place is filthy and overpriced. Nobody wearing any gloves or hats. Just disgusting all around. On top of that I asked if the baked ziti slice was vegetarian. Was told it was. Got home bit into it and it was filled with chicken. I called to complain and the girl hung up on me. Unbelievably horrible service. Will never be back.

My family of 7 and I ALL recieved FOOD POISONING this establishment not ONCE, but TWICE within a two week period. We tried it again just to make sure it wasn't something else we had eaten that day. Within hours after consumption we were ALL sick with severe vomiting and diarhea. We ordered a plain pie and a vegetable pie both times. Both with unfortunate results. I have reported them to the Suffolk County Board of Health.

Horrible experiences! The people are so unfriendly and unhelpful. Seems like your business is bothering them. Every time we've ordered lunch for the office they huff and puff. We also used to cater events from there. NO LONGER!!

We ordered takeout and I was actually excited to try this place it was my first time for me and my family. The food was over cooked expect one thing. So disappointed don’t think I would come back.

Need to fix your phone systems. Been trying to call for 10 minutes and nothing. You guys keep answering and hanging up on me. Currently at my house with perfect service connected to wifi. My wife, who's ordered from you many many times has encountered this same issue. Just called another pizza place 30 seconds after calling you and, what do ya know, they were able to hear me perfectly fine. It's 2024, update your phone provider for crying out loud

We've been going here for a few years. Pizza is a hit or miss. But the last time my husband walked in, he asked the owner for a few minutes as he just walked in & she flipped out !! Cursing & yelling in the back saying can you believe he effing told me that he just walked in & he needs a few minutes. Seriously lady.. your attitude & food isn't worth another dime spent there !!!! Plus your prices are ridiculous. Robbamias !!

Villa Swisher

First time trying this place yesterday and safe to say I will never go back this place is so bad I just had to write a review I never write reviews but how do you leave a slice in for five minutes and still comes out cold. Let alone the taste of the pizza itself just taste like a frozen slice the tomato sauce needs a lot of work. Taste like ellios frozen pizza straight trash.