Great chicken finger sub and pizza. Yummy! Really nice people.

This place is amazing. The food is good and the staff is friendly too.

I personally prefer Giuiseppe's over New York's food. When I think of pizza, it SHOULD be greasy. While I'm not saying the Original New York's pizza is bad, Theirs is dry compared to Giuseppe's. What I really like about Giuseppe's is their pizza reminds me of Two Guys From Italy and The Original Italian Ristorante in Montrose, PA!

every time we have ordered we have never been let down! Great pizza and best wings! Will always return.

Drive by it delivering packages.finally stopped in! Great service excellent pizza! 5☆'s

Love, love, love this place. Friendly staff, huge slices, and my favorite part is the variety. They are so creative with the toppings and they always taste delicious!

Pre-ordered Xlarge pepperoni with wings. Was around $50. Was ready when hubs went to pick it up. Hot and tasted great!!!

Impressive pizza. Slices were huge, and so good. These people know how to make a pie.

We love Giuseppe's! They are always friendly, timely and our food is always delicious. We love the char broiled wings!

Food was Delivered and vary good . Driver was on time. The best place in town.

Great tasting pizza and large thick slices.For a reasonable price.

Lots of slice variety. Extensive menu, lots more than just pizza, and it's all great. Try the four horsemen, you won't regret it!

The med. wings were perfect! The deep fried mushrooms were perfect and we got them 15 minutes faster than we expected! Well done folks!

They make a delicious cheese steak, meatball calzone, and even have homemade chocolate creme pie! Kids are always very helpful & polite.

Great pizza, friendly community oriented staff, awesome pizza of the week Creations. If you like chicken wing pizza give there's a try and might I suggest Burban molasses signs as well

Best pizza and wings I ever had drove from Dryden to drop my wife at work and we stop in and got wings and pizza greatest I ever had will be back

Excellent pizza choices and the menu has so many items besides pizza. They also deliver

Best Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza 🍕. I could eat it everyday!!! Great service!!

Great little spot. Very authentic. All local stuff

They have the best garlic parm wing around. Try them you will not be disappointed. I love them, and im a hot wing guy.

Was disappointed at first due to the length of time. There was Some confusion with my order, I guess. Was delivered to my house, the owner made right by it. Personally delivered it! I forgot to mention, free of charge. The food was great!

If you want pizza, go here!!!! We got the hamburger pizza and the mac and cheese. You can't go wrong!!!! The Mac and cheese is creamy, and the hamburger pizza was loaded like a regular hamburger!!! Even though they don't know you, they are always have a smile and treat everyone equally.

First time eating here was Last week, I got a meat lovers pizza! BEST PIZZA I have ever had!!!! Will be ordering again!!! UPDATE: Just ordered tonight, they went to the wrong house and although the pizza was 2 full hours late it was still the best pizza I’ve had!!! Ps I got the meat lovers again!

I have been all over the United States and I live in pizza and this place is hands down the best pizza I have ever had

Best pizza in the area, hands down.

Some of the best pizza I've had. The place is looking a bit run down but it has a charm to it

Kudos to Guisseppies’s for a delicious, perfectly prepared pizza tonight. We ordered on the Slice app and it was just coming out of the oven when we got back into town from a field hockey game. PERFECT 😋 yum

Stopped in for slices. Had their lunch special. Good size slices. Great tasting sauce and crust. Perfect amount of cheese for most people. Will return.

The last pie that I bought here was fantastic. Meat lovers pizza is loaded with meat. The staff is very friendly. My favorite place for pizza and subs.

Given that there is virtually no real competition for Guisepis Pizza (one rival) it is very surprising that this place has some of the best food of any pizza place I’ve ever visited. And I spent the bulk of my life as a musician in Manhattan and in Boston. I’ve had some great pizza. But it’s not just their pizza that’s fantastic. Their calzone, stromboli, pasta dishes, and subs are outstanding. They make their food the way you would if you were back there unwatched with access to all the toppings and ingredients: piles of fresh, quality ingredients. Not too greasy. Attractive. No short cuts. This in comparison to Subway where each meager serving is pre-weighed and they ignore you as you try to encourage them. “Yeah. Go wild with the pickles! Can ya throw another piece of Swiss on?” But at Guisepis you don’t even have to ask. It’s almost like a sixth sense they have. They see my 6’4”, 245lb frame and they lay on the stuff. And they do it with a sincere friendliness; the sort we all imagine we’d get at a 1960s mom & pop shop. And they have a cooler filled with various types and sizes of drinks. A cool enough satellite radio alternates from Pink Floyd to Billy Joel to Bowie, though this ranges depending on who’s at the register. Speaking of register, they accept credit cards, Apple Pay and cash. There’s no “have a penny” cup but let’s face it, we live in a take a penny world. There are three booths in case you’re running tight and it’s raining out. But you don’t have to take my word for it; give ‘em a try. You’ll see.

Great pizza! They had a good selection of slice pies and the price was good. The slices were good sized and for two with a 20 oz. Drink cost 7 for everything.

Ask for Mike's chicken tenders. They are the best. It's the only piece of chicken I enjoy eating on this planet. Also, it's nice to see staff. They work hard and care about their food.

Great food at reasonable prices. It's super easy to find and the staff is awesome. Some of the team members remember my name and greet me and I feel that's a nice touch.

The food from this pizzeria tastes so good right now. I wish I ordered more. I will be back soon.

Hadn't been here in years. I WAS NOT disappointed. Service was fast and friendly. The pizza and wings were delicious,will definitely be coming back soon!

The pizza here is the best. True thin crust baked to a crisp but without any charring and a chewy crust. Daily slices of many inventive combinations are available. Yummy!!!!

Pizza was really good. The dough especially. They put the ten out of ten in gluten. Price was fair. Staff was friendly and quick. Someone who lives near by has 2 cute and friendly cats that let me pet them. I will return. Only complaints: They make you pay the 3% service charge for using card (I try to always have some cash on me so it's not a big deal but it prevented me from using my credit card to get cash back and improve my credit score). Bathroom door knob was greasy, faucet provided poor temperature control and a broken stream.

Love the pizza here. It's a great so on my way through to one of my clients and their pizza never disappoints and they are always trying new things. The last couple of times I saw signs for trying some new things. They have a torpedo, a chicken wrap with chicken, cream cheese, cheddar, and taco seasoning. They have a chicken patty sandwich. And pub fries. They are all delicious, they are all amazing.

Good pizza place to drive a half hour out of the way to visit. And can go visit the Glen while u wait for it to cook if you need to.

Ordered from here for delivery while hanging at friends' house outside Moravia and had no complaints. Took a little while to arrive, but it was a Saturday evening, so it was no biggie. Pizzas were really good and the delivery girl was pleasant. Our friends said the wings are awesome and they order them often.

Frank

Was driving home to Georgia in the snow stopped in ordered mozzarella sticks and a Stromboli, Just wow!! Made the drive home easier and definitely the best mozzarella sticks ever tasted and well stuffed Stromboli Thanks for your service and will definitely stop again on our next time through

Cody Morton

Easily the best pizza around. Food is always 5 ⭐

Jason Hurst

Pizza was the best I ever had, thanks a lot!! 😋

Viktor Phelps

I always visit here when in town, the loaded cheese and bacon fries with a slice or two being my favorite thing. Their food is immaculate. The slices are large and delicious, ranging from regular flavors of cheese and pepperoni to their signature Horsemen slices and macaroni and cheese. They offer a lovely selection of desert, and lots of drinks as well. They always treat my girlfriend and I so well, their business is appreciated for how well they run and how they are a cornerstone for this community.

April Berry

I just moved here from Florida and this is the Best New York pizza I've had so far.!

Jason Coon

I used to be a regular with my friends when Giuseppe's had a store in Tully way back when. Always loved his Italian subs, and the pizza was a close second. Now, every time im back in NY on vacation, I find myself venturing out to Auburn from Otisco Valley to get some awesome food. Best part about it all is my wife, who's native Missourian demands we go there when ever we are visiting. See ya in August lol

Paulo Almeida

Great pie for such a small simple place

+2

Jess Lee

My family has gone here our whole life, the pizza is amazing and so is the calizones. I've always had great things to say about the food and drinks, loved the costumer service and over all the place gives off a really nice family vibe. If your looking for a family feeling from a place then this would be it Jessica L.

Mora Mundt

This little hole in the wall is amazing!! HUGE slices that are very affordable. The buffalo chicken slices were honestly the best I've ever had. Wish we weren't just passing through and could stop in for slices all the time!

Colby J.

Lots of slice options, even at 2:00 p.m. Good pizza, will stop by again!

Pam Peters

Traveling through from Kansas and this was exactly the pizza place we were looking for. The pizza was delicious and the service superior! The building is small, but we loved it! Their prices are great too!

+3

leechristineg

Biking by, asked a local leaving with takeout if it sold by the slice. “Yes! And they have specialty slices that are so good. Try the taco and ‘The Four Horsemen’!” So glad I asked because I’d never have ordered those, and they were DELICIOUS! 500 degree oven had the large slices cooked in what seemed to be only a minute. So we decided to sit in. One local after the next streamed in. They know what they are doing. And VERY reasonably priced. A nice surprise in a small town. This is a big yes!

Richard Stevens

Great pizza and very friendly staff at a very reasonable price. I highly recommend trying Giuseppe's if you find yourself in Moravia.

Was in town for Filmore Glen and stopped by here with the kiddo. Good pizza and a friendly staff, no complaints here

Good pizza, a good price and good staff. Not much more you can ask for in a pizza place. Although once the pizza was heavily over floured and inedible but every other time it is pretty good...

Improving for sure. They do a great job. Good service and an excellent variety of speciality pizzas. Wings are good too. Some things can be a little pricey.

Very tasty sandwiches, but seemed to take a long time to make. Maybe we were just hungry and anxious. Lots of great looking pizza varieties, but we were getting sandwiches not pizza.

Good pizza, decent wings. The new hires they have on staff can make it unpredictable if your pizza will be a little over or under when you order. Their chicken wing pizza is great though. :)

Iv had really good luck with pizza here. Blt, chicken bacon ranch, pepperoni and cheese even a meat lovers. I would recommend, be patient when they have new staff though, may take awhile and they don’t have the pizzas down yet. Must be I got a new employee pizza cause I was less than impressed. Actually got sick on it and through it away. Greasy, loaded with bacon and what appeared to be breading from just the chicken and no ranch at all. No since In calling and complaining. I’m sure it was a fluke. But usually stellar pizza!!

ordered the ravioli and tater tots, was ready in 5-6 mins which was great but the customer service was a little lacking and felt like i was bothering the workers.

pizza is nice but crispy was still undercooked and when you add garlic to a cheese pizza the don't put sauce in it. really disappointing I have to stress every time what should be normal

Hit and miss with the staff friendliness. It takes 90 mins to deliver a pizza and wings, 7 mins away any time of day. Doesn't always offer delivery so double check before ordering. A little upgrade in all aspects

James Page

Picked up two pizzas and one wasn’t cut. Manager did not offer a solution. Pizza was good but would recommend some sort of resolution when dealing with customers

Julie B

The pizza has too much crust and air bubbles took up whole piece....and very little sauce/ cheese other than in the middle the edges are basically dry. Also the estimated time of 30 minutes was actually almost 45 minutes to an hour. We have had good pizza before but lately things are not what they used to be. Wings last week slimy not crispy. I'm sure that it depends on who's working but people like consistency and to get what they paid for. Train employees to get it right. We'll keep trying but hope it gets better.

Very hit or miss. Last several orders have been awful. Soggy, undercooked, sloppy made. I had hoped it would get better.

Crust is too thick, undercooked, too much cheese and not enough sauce. Five years it was excellent.

If they get your order right, it will always take longer than they told you. The type of place that starts your order once you walk in to pick it up. I only go here for their wings because the wings at New York Pizzeria are terrible.

Made my order at 5:19pm my order showed up at 7:00 pm. Pizza was over cooked and cold. This will be the 3rd time this has happened think I may have to rethink my local pizzeria.

We got their mild chicken finger sub and I ordered mine with extra sauce on the sub and there wasn't hardly any sauce on my chicken fingers.

We’re gunna go with a two because the food wasn’t bad. With limited local options in Moravia most of the time we just kinda take what we can get. But for 50 dollars to forget my husbands extra blue cheese that he paid for, (this is like the third time it’s happened, once it’s a mistake I get it! Twice, okay like annoying but it’s blue cheese, three times okay like now it’s a little more annoying) then when I open my wings they may at one point have been In some sauce but there certainly wasn’t a single drop of sauce inside the to go container. I get that restaurants are trying to reduce spending but like it’s just hot sauce and butter man. So now that I have physically made my own wing sauce at home and retrieved the kens blue cheese we had in the fridge I’m left with the impression that I probably should have just made wings at home. When the benefit is supposed to be convenience, kinda disappointing when it’s the opposite of convenient. I get that we all are trying the best we can, I’m just under the impression that this is not their best.

Ordered the sheet pizza and 36 wing special. The pizza dough was not fresh, it was a pre made like you would get in high school and they slap some sauce and cheese on it, you know kind of like chewy cardboard. Although they did let me pick 3 different sauces for the wings, all three boxes had those funky looking weirdhalf wings that no one eats cause they just look weird. Alot if the wings the bones where black when you bit into them. All in all, I’ll order elsewhere next time.

Pizza ok, just need to get the crumbs out of the oven as there were many burnt ones on the bottom of our pizza. The young female making pizzas really should not eat pizza at the station used to make pizza? Don’t think that’s part of the health code?

We don't go to Moravia very much. We've been there twice in the past year, once last and once this year to walk the trails with our dog. Last year just as we were walking back down the trails we ordered an octagon pizza, with some type of wings that I cant remember. When we got there we were given a pizza, I got it all the way to the car when I realized it was just a cheese pizza. I was furious. I went back in to have them make the correct pizza since they thought I only ordered a cheese pizza. The only reason I gave two stars is because the correct pizza was delicious. This year we went - same thing on the way down the trails we ordered a chicken speedy pizza and boneless garlic parm wings. I got there and made sure the pizza was the correct pizza and it was, but the wings were not boneless… I took the bone in wings because I didn't have the time to have them remake it. My advice to this business is to make the phone order takers repeat the order back to the customer once the order has been ordered, because they clearly have clogs in their ears or maybe the phone they use is just horrible. The chicken speedy pizza was good, wings were good even though they weren't boneless.

Today 7/23/22 we stopped at this favorite pizza shop. For the first time ever we got the size large pizza and the crust was burnt badly and when we tried to eat it we could hardly chew it. The underside was also burned . The dough was thicker than what we are accoustomed to . What is going on? Will they get back to making the great pizzas they are known for? We travelled over 30 Miles just to taste a great pizza . What a disappointment our trip was tonight . Will our family go back?

Mark Dorsey

Overall I like the food,but the extreme wait times and then finding out some of the order is not done or forgotten all together. Normally wouldn't comment, but it happens everytime I order

C B

Always have to wait even when sthey tell you 20 minutes half the food is ready getting cold waiting for rest. Super gross and dirty, like a pizza box for insulation and filthy in general. The food is good if you don't mind all the rest

Charged my card twice after asking for my card 4 times because their connection was poor.

Ordered 2 sub large. One turkey one Italian. Both with mayo,lettuce,tomatoes, onions banana peppers,Italian dressing, we got turkey ,had no mayo,no lettuce and no cheese. The Italian came with lots of mayo,no cheese,no lettuce,no tomatoes and no Italian dressing. She even wrote down what we wanted on them .won't order them again.

Manager was very rude and didnt wear gloves when making food.. She said "the ovens heat up to 500 degrees and should kill all germs." Will not be giving my business to them anymore!!

Use to be great not anymore my simple orders constantly get lost ordered a BLT and i got bread and lettuce cashier's are snobby one went to the back for my order and stood in the back like I was just gonna leave and then sent a different employee to come ask me once again what my order was and then tried to ring up my order even tho I paid online and then said "oh yea it said paid on the ticket"

The inside is not clean at all, the outside hand rail is falling apart on the steps so be careful entering and leaving. The glass front counter is broken. The floor tiles are all cracked and dirty. As for the pizza... it is great according to my family. The salads are not the best. I ask for no cheese due to an allergy and they just try to take all the cheese off of it instead of making a new salad without cheese.

If I could give this place 0 I would. I am sick and tired of not getting what I ordered, so they just lost a customer. I ordered a chicken speide from there. Nothing comes on the chicken speide but the chicken. The employee even told me this. So tonight I ordered this sandwich again and there is cheese all over it! I only asked for mayo! I called them and told them what happened and also let them know that my fiance can't have cheese. He gets super sick from it. Since I ordered from Slice they said to call them and let them know. So I did. They said Giuseppes wouldn't refund it because cheese comes on it. No it doesnt!! 🤬 And if so than why did the one employee tell me otherwise?? I guess Original Pizza will get my business from now on.

So tonight we ordered 1 whole turkey A half ham. And a salad. Was told 2 min. 40 minutes later we get our order. And come to find out it wasn't even made the way we wanted

The cook blew on the pizza before placing it in the oven and it wasn’t fully cooked when handed to me. Mediocre pizza.

Ordered 2 calizones told "35 maybe 40mins" got down there they looked busy so waited an extra 10mims before going in. Went in was told it was going to be another 20mins, go to go back in another annoyed customer on her way out let's me know there only excepting cash. So we had to go to an ATM to get money witch we could of done while we waited, would of been nice to just been told it was going to be an hour wait we like the food for the most part, there not very consistent with the same pizzas, calizones, subs are diffrent everytime we go depending on who is working

I have never ordered here and not have an issue with my order. And not always minor stuff either. Something missing, something wrong like a meatball sandwich with NO sauce, pepperoni roll with No pepperoni, a antipasto salad that was only lettuce and croutons. And the toppings we are charged for never seem to make their way on to our pizza. And when you call about it customer serve is a joke....always an excuse. Never oh we made a mistake let us take care of it. Yet, once again I tried to support locally. Guess what? I ordered 3 things. A calzone, a mushroom roll and a pepperoni roll. Simply unless you want what you actually ordered. Had one wrong one missing. They did offer to make me a mushroom roll. I asked how long? 8 minutes. I agreed. Then this guy jumps in with excuses about how busy they are. I get that. However, the last 10 of 10 times I ordered here same issues every single time. So I calmly (I note calmly because the atmosphere quickly changed) stated I wasn't surprised because this always happens. At which time I was then told rather nasty and loudly that I could always go up the road. And that sounded like the best thing I ever got from this place...an invitation to go someplace else. However, when I took him up on his offer and told him that was a great idea he continued to yell at me about being sorry and that that was what he said first, I'm sorry ma'am. It wasn't though. It was excusses and rudeness and then mad when I took up his suggestion to go up the road. So this is the best place in town to go if what you are looking for is the worst dining experience ever and to be blamed for their mistakes with a side order of excusses and the absolute worse customer service available. 8/19/24 Well my family finally talked me into buying something from here again. I ordered a Italian sub. And because there is always something missing when I ordered here I specifically asked for Italian dressing to be sure I got it. Guess what-no dressing. I don't understand the sandwich in the description states that it has dressing and I said, now this comes with Italian dressing correct!?. Yes I was told but it didn't no dressing. Seriously I don't even know what to say at this point. All these raving reviews.....so I guess it's just us you mess up smh

My wife came home with 2 Supreme Pizza's about an hour ago, WORST Pizza that we ever got from them. We used to look forward to their Pizza, not anymore. The last few that we've gotten from them, they were just a little over-done. Tonight's Pizza was totally burnt on the bottom, so bad I had to scrape the top & toppings layer off, just to say I had some! Like I said, they used to have the Best Pizza around!

Dawn Chilson

Took over 2 hrs for delivery and 5 children waiting to eat ordered at 5 pm got here at 7 unacceptable

Carol Sims

Do not eat the chicken wings from here. I ordered boneless chicken wings from here and got sick the night I ate them. I ended up in the hospital for days with horrible pain for over a week and tested positive for a secere case of salmonella from eating these chicken wings. I will never eat the chicken from here again and I'd advise no one else does either.

Jeremy Coon

Just like I remember it, an hour late while hearing for an hour it's on it's way and will be a couple minutes. Not to mention, when my wife called she was hung up on. No more for us. Plus the sauce goes on the wings not in the bag.