Gulshan Zain

Carmenta’s: A cozy spot known for its warm ambiance and hearty comfort food. The menu features a blend of traditional and contemporary dishes, with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Service is friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming experience. Popular for its flavorful entrees and well-crafted cocktails. Ideal for casual dining or small gatherings. A solid choice if you want good food in a relaxed, inviting setting.

Philip John Bedwell

Absolutely exceptional subs and one of best Tiramisu's I've ever had. We can't wait to come back and order another!

Kirby Reyes

Randomly checked this placed out on a spontaneous walk and now it’s my personal favorite. The aroma of garlic and herbs takes you in as soon as you open the door. The pasta is fresh and the sauce savory and rich. This place lit me up enough to write a review, because something this good should be well known. Authentic and amazing quality. You will definitely see me again!

Lexi Chipules

Stopped in for dinner and it was delicious! I wish the seating situation was better, its more of a deli atmosphere than a sit down dinner spot, which is fine but I wasn't expecting it.

+1

Shreya Doshi

THE BEST Italian sandwich I’ve eaten in New York. Get the Dom G sandwich on garlic bread, you’ll thank yourself you did. Oh and don’t forget the golden beet salad, man it is refreshing and so damn delicious. We also got the Radiatore, very healthy and delectable. I am shocked not enough people know about this place. I wish I knew it earlier. Super cute spot and great service.

callahandsome

I love chicken parm. My favorite desert? More chicken parm. Wanted to find the best in northern Brooklyn for my birthday. Holy crap this place was incredible. I’m coming back again and again. The $3 garlic bread upgrade was totally worth it. Bravo. Get a seat if you can, but to-go is just as good.

Takyashilah S

I can still taste the pasta, so good! I definitely want to go back and try more from the menu. It’s a great spot for a nice bite, though not necessarily a quick one. The pricing is straightforward, either you want it or you don’t, but no complaints. The food is well prepared and served in a reasonable time.

+2

Ayron Milgrom

Summary: Warming with Great Food Carmenta’s is a great place for food but specifically their sandwiches. This small but inviting cafe has a warm, welcoming vibe the moment you step in. The intimate setup, with the kitchen right in front of you, makes for a unique and personal experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, adding to the vibe of the place. We tried two sandwiches, the meatball sub and the Dom G. While both were excellent, the Dom G was the standout. As a meat lover, I was shocked at how flavorful and satisfying this vegetarian sandwich was. Every bite was packed with rich, balanced flavors that left me perfectly content. Overall, Carmenta’s is an outstanding experience with great food and a cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend.

Blake Rasmussen

Delicious little sandwich shop with excellent sandwich. The bread in particular was superb and I would not sleep on the specials - the Italian ham and mustard is the best sandwich I’ve had in NyC in the past two years.

Pedro Pacheco

It’s the best pasta I’ve ordered. I had to tell the staff that it was absolutely delicious. I ordered the Rigatoni with some kind of sauce that I forgot the name and an order of Rice balls… it was perfect, the cooking time in the pasta was spot on, the salsa was just perfect… the staff is very attentive and friendly. Will be back for sure. I recommend this place 100%

Kaitlyn Rodriguez

Solid food! I got the spicy eggplant parm on garlic bread. I never get the vegetarian option, but I didn’t realize they had the same version with meatballs. I will definitely be back to try that version as well as Italian combo hero. Fresh and hot!

Siena WD

I think life just makes more sense with a sandwich, and thankfully there are places like this to make that dream come true. A very solid place in a cool area, I got a spicy eggplant parm and can't wait to come back and try it on their garlic bread (which I would recommend because if life presents you with an option like that you shouldn't let your fear of talking to people get in the way of making that happen). The people working there were all very nice, helpful and speedy, my sandwich was ready in no time at all. My amateur photography skills don't quite capture its glory but it was delicious and I highly recommend checking this place out

Antônio Roma

The sandwich is the best Italian I've ever tasted. Everything is very flavorful and fresh, and there's a generous portion. It's more expensive than delis, but it's real quality food.

I have been a loyal customer for years constantly ordering from here , as well As my partner who’s been eating here since they opened . One time my friend got food poisoning here and I didn’t believe it because of how much I love this place. But now I am the victim lol I got food poisoning almost immediately after eating their takeout food was also extremly greasy. I’ve been sick now for 4 days. Definitely will be loosing me and my families Buisness.