Mom & Pop restaurant like back in the day when I was a kid. Comfort food... good people.

While visiting my Mom in the Batavia area, we came to Settlers for lunch on her birthday, and it was great! We both had the Beef on Weck which came with Au Jus and was delicious. I had the Buffalo Chicken Wing soup as an appetizer and it had just the right amount of kick to it. Comfortable atmosphere. Easy to get in and out of the building. Wonderful service to boot!

I hadn't been there in years but the food was still yummy and the service was great.

Went here for the first time and I will definitely be back. We had breakfast and the food was really good. There were many items on the menu that looked interesting. My wife and I loved this place. It's 22 miles from home, so it's a nice ride for a great meal.

The people there are always very nice. A great place for a good, homestyle meal

Got off 90 and drove into town as no restaurants were just off the exit. Looked at Trip Advisor and ended up here as it had good reviews and was easy to get to off 90. Had blueberry pancakes, sausage and fries and no complaints. Waitress was very nice and attentive and food came out timely. It's a friendly place with a nice variety of options, including breakfast all day, that the locals go to as evidenced by there being several tables taken at 2 p.m. It's in an old Red Barn Building and is showing its age but was clean during our visit.

Wow. Obviously popular family restaurant in Batavia that does a fantastic job handling a big crowd. A very friendly, efficient staff keeps things moving along smoothly. Great variety of breakfast, lunch, and dinner items and plenty of desserts, too. Service was quick, food delicious, attentive waitress, even though the place was hopping! Home fries are different from any other place, filled with spices. Sausage, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on an English muffin was awesome.

Good home town family restaurant. Had picked out a different restaurant but on arrival at the hotel found out they were closed. Lady at front desk recommended Settlers. Glad she did, perfect place to enjoy some comfort food after traveling all day

Our waitress Kelly was on point and the good was delicious!

We drive thru Batavia about once a month and this has become our favorite place to stop and grab bite. Soups are always delish, we get a cup everytime. Service is always good and speedy. Tonight we had the smothered chicken and the coppne sandwich both were amazing. The hot garlic parm sauce should be bottled and sold. We will be back!!!

Settlers has been around for a very long time, since Red Barn was around if you remember them. Stockton for breakfast in order of the crab cake benedict. These are very likely the best crab cakes I ever taste in my life, tender, moist, Chris on the outside, so delicious. Perfect amount of Hollandaise sauce to mix with the egg yolk after breaking, one of the better breakfasts I've ever had in my life. Home fries were good, but could have been just a little bit hotter. Hard to find a complaint. Great coffee too 😋

Clean, busy, family-friendly atmosphere. Wonderful service and all the food (we all had breakfasts but arrived and were served at different times, per our preference.) The steak and souvlakis were tender and perfectly cooked, as was everything else. They paid close attention to food allergies, and everything was served hot and with a smile. Coffee cup was never empty. If I I lived near here, I'd be a regular, for sure! Try the homefries and then, biscuits with gravy. Mmmm

Our favorite spot in Batavia!!! EVERYTHING is amazing. Dinner specials are really good and their breakfast is delicious. Incredible homemade soups. Picture is of Chunky Monkey Pancakes (bananas, walnuts, and chocolate chips). My daughter picks Settler's over any other restaurant... sometimes we have to force her to go somewhere else. Not your typical greasy "diner" food. Try it!!

We have been in New York for a week. NYC, Cooperstown, Syracuse and Niagara Falls and this is the BEST food we had. Loved the pizza logs (like an egg roll), Greek Dinner, Mac and Cheese (both the Philly and the Buffalo chicken. And the Lemon Berry Mascarpone Cake was the best cake I’ve ever had and my new favorite.

Best breakfast in a while! Great friendly quick service and the place was packed! Got meatlover omelet and crab cake eggs Benedict coffee and water! All witnesses decked out in Bill wear! Highly recommend!

Great Mac & Cheese and cheesecake (in the pic Is already started) :))) Both meals were very tasty and the staff super friendly and fast! Definitely recommended

Great food! Nice serving size. The staff was friendly!

Had a great breakfast here, looks like a lot of locals come here and everybody knows everybody. Food is delicious, friendly staff. Thanks!

Fantastic food, very accommodating to our large party, did not have to wait long even during a busy Sunday brunch time, and also the weight staff was extremely attentive to our whole family.

These guys have the best breakfast especially their French toast stacks and their not really expensive either

We had a pleasant experience overall with tasty dishes.

It’s a family owned restaurant. I would highly recommend this place . Has plenty of options for vegetarians too

Alisha was friendly and a good server. Food was good and hot when it came out.

Visiting the area for a day, we were looking for a place to eat and saw this restaurant had a 4.5 rating on Google maps. Obviously, we ate here and enjoyed all our meals. I had a turkey dinner as prep for Thanksgiving, my wife had a salad, and my son had a kids cheeseburger that was really a full cheeseburger with ketchup only. Also, we ate pumpkin cheesecake and a chocolate cone that was part of the kid's meal. Everything was great and the waitress was sweet, attentive, and not overbearing. Most of the clients were older and yet our energetic 5 year old didn't seem too out of place. That's the reason I gave atmosphere 4 stars instead of 5.

Went for a sat morning breakfast. No wait...food was delicious..and very reasonably priced

Great food, great service. Would recommend 100%

Great atmosphere, our waitress was very nice. Food was fast and delicious.

this review is just about the lemonade i haven’t even had food yet. lemonade is very good, tastes homemade (idk of it is but it at least tastes like it). you can safely get the lemonade at this establishment. 4/5

Going to settlers for breakfast is always a win. Their food is delicious. I typically get some form of omelette. My daughter just raves over the sausage gravy and biscuits. Their Belgian waffles are also out of this world. There's always a great selection of soups and desserts. They have plenty of seating available and there's parking right on site. The service is fast and the staff is very friendly.

Breakfast quesadilla was delicious, amazing pancakes. Good coffee too!

Absolutely the best meal I’ve had out in a very long time. Fresh food, heavy portion, fair pricing…just a real “home cooked meal” feeling.

The best Breakfast in BATAVIA! Hands down. They are good at everything though, and the Specials are always unique. Support a family run business. Come here.

Lovely family restaurant we stumbled onto. If we lived closer, we certainly would patronize this place regularly! Thier staff is friendly, place is clean, including thier menus! Food is good, prices are cheap, portions are large!

+2

Food was great, large portions, service was awesome, cozy atmosphere and reasonable prices.

The french dip sandwich tasted home made, with super thinly sliced roast beef on a fresh hoagie roll, and au jus for dipping. Classic and delicious…especially with the side of tater tots!

This spot is great. I happen to drive through this area for an appointment and on my way back I decided to place an order here and it’s was Delish! I got a Breakfast Quesadilla and boy was it good. And I have to say these were the tastiest home fries I’ve ever had 👏👍🏼. It was quick easy and they took Apple Pay. Which save me from the last diner I tried to go to that was Cash Only. But thankfully this one was just a some minutes away.

GO HERE IMMEDIATELY AND EAT!! ordered the Garbage can plate? after a long hike and the flavors on this thing enveloped my taste buds, good lord I've never had something so delicious. ended with the Reese's peanut butter pie to only be met by a choir of heavenly beings singing praises of flavor and love only a family member can put in the cooking. No amount of stars can grade this place, as a west coaster moving here, I'm in love.

Typical breakfast joint with not so typical ice cream shop and what appears to be a Greek diner for lunch & dinner. Friendly service and nice portions.

Great eatery! Within walking distance of many shops! If you haven't been here you should go!

We came at the right time! Just after "normal" breakfast hours, and just before the lunch rush. The coffee was good!! (There have been too many places that have weak coffee. This is not one of them.) We didn't take pics of the food, but it was also good. We had the Southern Eggs Benedict, Eggs Benedict Omelet, and the LA French Toast. We took 3 pieces of pie to go bc they looked so yummy. We are planning to return on our next trip east. We loved the sign upon entering. We were surprised and pleased to see it.

The food was a knock out of the park! I had eggs benedict for breakfast. The waitress was charming and attentive 😁

Came to the restaurant today with my best friend and her son to celebrate his 18th birthday!!! The waitresses brought him a piece of cake with a candle in it and sang him happy birthday 🎉🎂🎈🎁 The employees are very friendly and willing to help without question! Definitely will recommend this restaurant to everyone I know AND I will be coming back again!!

Staff is always kind, food is always good & correct when I get take out. Prices are fair & you can't beat that.

Was here for the first time, loved it, I had the liver an onions, cooked perfectly.

The staff are grat at there jod.. the food was grat. Big porshens .. A great family place...... Thumbs up to the OWNER..

The breakfast was excellent, the service was perfect. Our waitress was attentive without being over bearing. It had a family atmosphere. We live 45 minutes away but we will gladly drive there for breakfast again and again. This place is a real jewel

Carrie Lawrence

We came in on Saturday morning, to an absolutely packed restaurant! We expected a wait, due to it being so busy, but they were on the ball and we got our food fast and it was all freshly made! Everyone was extremely friendly and it was an overall pleasant experience.

Dennis Symons

This is a very quaint little restaurant with that hometown feeling!! Great menu, generous portions, great prices, and very friendly staff. I had their bacon cheese burger special and a banana split it was delicious!!

Robyn Steffen

Food was great. Friendly and attentive staff. Super sad they have "The Stoner" marked off their menu now as that's why I picked this restaurant from Google on our roadtrip.

Dan L.

Pancake Breakfast Deal: $5.99 for two large pancakes, 2 eggs, 2 bacon and 1 sausage patty. Also added a bottomless coffee. Can’t beat this breakfast in the area. .

Kevin Rodkey

Food was very good, portion sizes were generous, and the service was great. It was obviously a placed favored by locals. If you are in the area and looking for a good meal at a fair price, I recommend this diner. A note on the atmosphere - the place hasn't been updated in a while but it's not run down. The atmosphere is friendly, not fancy. I was fine with that.

Erny Bonistall

I would consider this as an amazing long standing local family diner. Great service. Breakfast/brunch/lunch menu. We met family while visiting family in Buffalo and meeting more family from Rochester. Great meetup on between. Our table had stuff from French toast, to Buffalo chicken wrap, omelette, and I loved their beef on kimmelweck having just been to Buffalo and not having one. It was authentic and awesome and their au jus was amazing. Great visit. Everyone shared a piece of awesome blueberry cake to finish. Highly recommend. Off I-90 easy.

+4

Douglas Liebig

Friendly staff with a bunch regulars make it a nice place to stop in to eat. The Turkey Club on 12 Grain Bread is very good. Stopped in again and had the Settler's Greek Souvlaki Breakfast. It's very good! The staff was still friendly and helpful. I know I order my eggs cooked mush more than most everyone else likes them. The cook prepared them perfectly, thank you!

Theresa St. John

Family restaurant was very busy when I went but the waitstaff had everything under control. Food was great - I had eggs in a nest for the first time. Coffee was piping hot (always a plus) I will be back there for sure when I'm next in the area.

Don Savage

If you are traveling on I-90, East of Buffalo, it is Definitely worth a short jaunt off the highway at Batavia, NY! We, as well as those who followed, were pleasantly greeted. The service, food, and dessert selection were all so Awesome that I asked if we could buy stock in this happy family enterprise❣️ The portions were so ample that we ordered our irresistible deserts (carrot cake and baklava cheesecake) to go. One should find them open 7AM-8PM every day except Sunday when they are open until 2PM. 👌

Craig Romain

Food was excellent. It came out incredibly fast! Small town meal in a nice little shop. Everyone seemed to know everyone else here. The waitress was nice, but disappeared mid-meal. Waited quite a while for the bill. Once we spoke up, another waitress stepped right in and got us our bill. We figure the first one hit the end of her shift and had a hot date. Would recommend for the homespun taste and wildly fast food to table time.

+3

Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)

Came in on a busy Sunday morning. It was busy and we were sat immediately at the front counter! We ordered french toast Eggs bacon Hash Browns extra crispy Topped with scrambled eggs , cheese and sausage with a side of guacamole and sour cream! Delicious! Service as quick They also sell great merchandise! Tshirts. hoodies etc

+15

Arthur Jameson

I was so hungry when I ate here that I forgot to take photos of the food!!!! When the food arrived, we all devoured it right away. I had a meat lovers omelette. It had plenty of protein and tasted great. The service was pretty quick! The waitress was on it and the food came out quickly. I would eat here again if I was in the area!

+2

I have the opportunity to meet up with a friend for breakfast at Settler's about 6 times a year. This place is always busy! We typically arrive around 8:00-8:30 and have no trouble getting a table. W…

I have the opportunity to meet up with a friend for breakfast at Settler's about 6 times a year. This place is always busy! We typically arrive around 8:00-8:30 and have no trouble getting a table.…

A very nice family restaurant. They had large portions which were very tasty. The baklava cheesecake for dessert was excellent.

A very nice family restaurant. They had large portions which were very tasty. The baklava cheesecake for dessert was excellent.

This recently updated location is a top tier terrific dining choice for everyone. breakfast, lunch, dinner? Great options await.\n\nLooking for something sweet? Definitely a great choice, ice cream…

Fast, friendly, delicious. Saturday morning rush and waited maybe 2 mins to be seated.

We could tell Settlers was going to be good since there was hardly a table left. Their breakfast eggs, bacon, sausage and pancakes would feed a lumberjack! Great service, great food. Would love to …

Feels like i'm back in my mom's kitchen watching her cook! Such a family environment here! I do recommend for a nice home cooked style meal!

Wife and I stopped in for dinner and well the the food was delicious and great service. Restaurant was very clean and ambiance was nice. Would definitely recommend going there and we would stop by …

This spot was amazing and good also it is clean and the food is not so expensive but tasty it's warm if you were wondering and it has drinks and u can't forget desserts it has cake and ice cream an…

It's a diner that's favored by locals and has no pretence of being anything other than that. Nor does it need to. The food is very good, portion sizes are generous, and the staff is friendly. Th…

It's a diner that's favored by locals and has no pretence of being anything other than that. Nor does it need to. The food is very good, portion sizes are generous, and the staff is friendly. Th…

Yummy! Seriously though, it may look quite ordinary on the outside, but the food is incredible! Homemade and so tasty. I had their sausage gravy over eggs and biscuits, and it tasted just like my gra…

Yummy! Seriously though, it may look quite ordinary on the outside, but the food is incredible! Homemade and so tasty. I had their sausage gravy over eggs and biscuits, and it tasted just like my…

Home town diner that serves excellent food! I had a salad and it was huge with a lot of ham, Turkey and cheese.

Home town diner that serves excellent food! I had a salad and it was huge with a lot of ham, turkey and cheese.

When we visit, this is our go-to place for breakfast every time & also ate dinner there on a Friday evening. Everyone loved their food. My fish fry was exceptional, service was great & prices were …

Stopped blindly for breakfast/lunch on the way home. Friendly people from the host to the waitresses. Busy but were greated and seated immediately. Food was good. Pancakes were very tasty. San…

Food was okay. I got their southern omelet. I'm from the south, never had that before. Service was good. They were busy when we went.

Nice family restaurant. Good food and reasonable prices.

N8ce mom and pop style diner. Good selection of food decent prices. Great friendly service.

Good for a quick home style meal while on the road.

The Philly Mac is delicious. It's a creamy mac n cheese with cavatappi noodles, shaved steak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and topped with a cracker like crumbs and perhaps baked to give it that crunchy topping. It's a very large portion, the picture doesn't do it justice. I'll be eating it for the next few days. The staff are friendly and efficient.

Nice place with very pleasant staff. Could of used more beef on my Weck,but good total portion size and tasty.

Good food, waiter ended shift unexpectedly, nice cozy breakfast place.

+1

This was a nice change from the typical diners. The staff was friendly and the food was tasty. I visited twice during my stay in the area.

Food was good and the service was decent. This is a good option for a small family sit down.

I arrived for a brunch and ordered the boneless wings and a Pepsi. The Pepsi was good but the boneless wings were too bready. The sauce was good though. The atmosphere was okay, nothing special. The waitress was nice but disappeared halfway through my meal and didn’t return.

Small to Medium sized, neighborhood family restaurant. Food is great for the price. Waitresses are all nice and friendly. Service is fast and efficient.

Victoria Mullen

Not a regular, but went to breakfast with a large group including kids. Eggs Benedict and Bagels were amazing. Everything was efficient and affordable. We were in and out quickly despite having several in our party. The wait staff was working hard and friendly. Would definitely do it again.

Cheryl Burris

Good food and great service! The pies and cakes are too due for!

Courtney Burley

Friendly. Fast. Great eggs benedict with home fries. They also have good coffee. Their entire menu has many good options. They have ice cream and plenty of other desert options. Quality food for great prices.

+9

Popeye

Food is very tasty, and the staff is friendly. Only giving four stars due to cleanliness. The men's room is neglected. Dirty walls, broken tiles and baseboards separating from the walls. The hallway to the restroom was also dirty. The type of dirty that shows it hasn't received attention in ages. It could be the type of thing for the employees that when they see it every day, it just fades into the background so they don't realize how it looks to somebody new. I don't mean to insult the restaurant owners, but it does make a person wonder what else is being neglected.

+1

Rock solid family restaurant / diner near the center of Batavia, with a good sized dining area with 270 degrees of big windows. Big menu with ample breakfast, lunch, & dinner options. It was break…

Restaurant is quaint but dated. Food was ok but you get what you pay for. Our server was not very nice. Will not be back

Very nice restaurant awesome size portions and our waitress was very good. Nice Greek restaurant with great breakfast and lunches. Very fair prices.

A very long established eatery of the area. Went here to grab a bite while waiting for our hotel room to be available. We ordered a tuna fish noodle casserole and it was delicious! They do offer a …

This is a spacious restaurant with an extensive menu. We were satisfied with the service and food but found the tip to be added automatically?

Very nice service. Cheap and hot! Coffee refilled quickly and had high chairs available for us. Food was good and came out very quick.

Very nice service. Cheap and hot! coffee refilled quickly and had high chairs available for us. Food was good and came out very quick.

Very nice service. cheap and hot! Coffee refilled quickly and had high chairs available for us. Food was good and came out very quick.

Went in for a fish fry only to find the price went up 2 dollars and they took a side away. I don't mind the increase but don't charge more and give us less! The food was good as usual and the service was good, but I don't think we will go back.

Quick service, can tell it’s a town friendly shop. In town for the night stopped in for dinner with my family of 5. 3 kids. 95% breakfast foods Not much to order than breakfast food. Couldn’t substitute chips for fry’s for a sandwich order. It was an up charge… $10 for 3 kid lemonades. Took a while to get food. Only ordered a Burger, 2 orders of pancakes and a sandwich. $60+10$tip

Great friendly staff, ordered the Crab cake Eggs Benedict, sad to say that the eggs were over cooked but the Crab cake itself was great. Daughter ordered the Ishmael and loved it and hubby ordered the country omelette, he liked the omelette better the country potatoes were terrible.

Pretty mid all around. Not bad not great. Small town diner vibes. Give it a shot if that's the kind of place you're into.

Ordered the beef-on-wick and a side of potato salad. The salad was okay, and the beef was a little dry. I had to ask for the horseradish that ALWAYS goes with b-o-w! Our waitress was pleasant, however, slow. Did not order any dessert. Meh...

The service was great. The food is ok. It's a nice place, I'd go again, but it isn't in my top ten.

Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Cleanliness 5/5 Price 4/5 Wait time - 4/5 Neighborhood - 5/5 Came here bc a few friends told us about this place. Had the Philly cheese sub and the wife had the chicken Parm sub. Both were fantastic. Prices are just below other restaurants and quality is better. The kids had chocolate chip pancakes and enjoyed them but they needed syrup(they usually don't) We all got water bc soda is $3.50 per person. Bit pricey, charging more than a 2L per person when I know they pay less than 50¢ for the same amount. Just went here again and it was subpar. The chicken fingers were bland and the taco quesadilla was half empty. The Ruben sandwich was the smallest sandwich I have ever seen for $14. And kids pancakes were Burnt. I know things happen but when everyone’s meal was subpar and not just one, gonna be hard to convince anyone to go back. Especially for the new prices (+50%)

Ordered the roast beef sandwich, fries and a side of Mac and cheese. It wasn't anything special. I'd give it a 3 since you could make this at home for half the price. I ordered for pick up and no silverware or napkins provided... First time here, not impressed.

Michael Demmer

The Service was awesome the food was not so much both chicken sandwiches were dry Fry's are great service couldn't be better

Pretty good family style restaurant. Good selection, good service, convenient location, good parking, friendly wait staff, competitive prices, better than fast food. ambiance was a bit seedy.

Pretty good family style restaurant. Good selection, good service, convenient location, good parking, friendly wait staff, competitive prices, better than fast food. Ambiance was a bit seedy.

Pretty good family style restaurant. Good selection, good service, convenient location, good parking, friendly wait staff, competitive prices, better than fast food. Ambiance was a bit seedy.

Pretty good family style restaurant. Good selection, good service, convenient location, good parking, friendly wait staff, competitive prices, better than fast food. Ambiance was a bit seedy.

Chad Evert

Ordered the roast beef dinner with mashed potatoes and stuffing.. found a long hair in stuffing..waitress offered to get another portion of stuffing..declined... more mashed...declined...after all said and done....she took my drink off the price.. most likely not to return in the future..

Christina Sherman

Everyone I know that lives in the area raves about the food here but I've never had better than an average meal that always seemed overpriced. This last visit to meet a friend for breakfast was a little ridiculous though. I ordered coffee and the Country Benedict breakfast which consisted of the world's thinnest biscuit topped with a sausage patty and eggs and covered with the bland-est canned "sausage" gravy. Total came to just shy of $20 before tip. The half & half on the table clearly says "keep refrigerated" and smelled spoiled when I opened it. When I politely pointed this out to the waitress and asked for some cold creamer she rolled her eyes and gave me attitude. I have yet to find a truly decent place to eat in Batavia for breakfast.

Be faster food was cold service bas terrible portions I waited 45 min for food and drinks do not come here

By far the worst service and attitude from the girls I've ever seen in any restaurant

First, please check my other reviews. I am not a harsh critic by any means. So when I tell you to stop at Panera in a NY state wayside instead of this place, that tells you something. Where all the great ratings come from, I can only assume the lunch/dinner is 1000x better than breakfast. We came in cheerful and smiling. Our waitress was cold and never welcoming. Maybe if we were locals, it would be different. (That said, the hostess was very sweet and kind.) How do you use CANNED mushrooms, corn, etc., FROZEN spinach and LIQUID eggs in your omelets? For the prices, I do expect fresh produce (in bags for restaurants) and real eggs that are cracked into a bowl before preparation. The bread was mass produced and bland. Not butter, but an oily spread. The home fries had a oily aftertaste as well. I am on vacation and expect better from Google Maps reviewers. I hope you read this review and take it to heart if you love food. Please know that alot of small town places like this can be good/great. This isn't one of those places.

High prices for not spectacular diner food. That was our assessment even before a member of our party was violently ill within two hours of lunch. Staff was lovely and it's obviously a loved local tradition, but today at least something was not right in the kitchen 😕

Says they close at 8 but closed sign already out at 7:20. The closed sign was definitely up at 7:20 now I wish I would have took a picture of it with the time on my phone. We ended up at Sport of Kings that was happy to serve us.

Just paid 20 dollars for breakfast asked the waitress if there was silverware in the Togo order she assured me there was get back to work and suprize no silverware guess I'm eating with my fingers will not order again staff is incompetent

Chris Kuder

The service was not the best. Asked for coffee she dropped off black coffee never asked if I’d like creamer had to flag down another waitress only to still receive no creamer due to her being too busy with holding a baby. All you have to do is read the one star reviews and the way the owner responds, it says a lot about the owner not caring.