Holly Mosher

This place was a recommendation & it was one of the best we ever received. This unassuming longterm restaurant was packed even between lunch & dinner times, slight wait for a table. The staff we encountered was very friendly & attentive. The food was absolutely delicious, fresh & plentiful. Salad was fresh fresh! Their red & alfredo sauces were some of the best we tasted, better than mine! Meatballs are excellent. Brought home leftovers for the following day. Listed as a pizza place but more like grandma's italian dishes place. This place is well worth the detour when traveling. We will be back.

+3

Jison Zabala

Got the chicken parm with side of pasta. Sauce is a bit sweet for me but still pretty darned good. Garlic knots were great. Pizza looked pretty solid too.

+1

jackie scott-butts

Dining room small, went around 2 and got seated right away. Food portion was good for the money, salad was fresh. Garlic knots were good size and taste.

Ashley Kirby

Found this place on google and I always check a place out if they have good reviews. The pizza was huge and fresh. Cooked perfect. Wings were pretty good and the garlic knots. Delicious. Really enjoyed the food here and delivery was about an hour on a Saturday night. Not bad. Definitely would eat here again.

Tom Chan

Great food, excellent service and good value. The place is packed in the weekends and they took reservation for large party. We ordered mussels with marinara and they were very good. We split an order of chicken parmigiana and the portion size was definitely good enough for two. The garlic knots served instead of regular rolls were tasty and freshly baked. Overall, it's a wonderful casual family restaurant to enjoy a wonderful meal.

+2

The food is always delicious. The waitress is very cordial and provides the service to please. Been coming here since they opened.

The food is always delicious. The waitress is very cordial and provides the service to please. Been coming here since they opened.

The food is always delicious. The waitress is very cordial and provides the service to please. Been coming here since they opened.

Best Italian food in the area! It's a bit small but it's worth the wait. Have yet to try the pizza but it sure flys out the door and smell delish!

Their famous dish is the chicken parm. Thing is huge, and perfect. Tender in the center, crispy around the edges. Everyone in Binghamton knows it and loves it. Ought to win some sort of award. Real…

Their famous dish is the chicken parm. Thing is huge, and perfect. Tender in the center, crispy around the edges. Everyone in Binghamton knows it and loves it. Ought to win some sort of award. …

Went here as a party of 8 (had a reservation, but needed to wait about 15-20 min till the table was ready). Service, food selection, food preparation was excellent. Can split entrees with nominal cos…

Went here as a party of 8 (had a reservation, but needed to wait about 15-20 min till the table was ready). Service, food selection, food preparation was excellent. Can split entrees with nominal…

Went here as a party of 8 (had a reservation, but needed to wait about 15-20 min till the table was ready). service, food selection, food preparation was excellent. Can split entrees with nominal c…

Went here as a party of 8 (had a reservation, but needed to wait about 15-20 min till the table was ready). Service, food selection, food preparation was excellent. Can split entrees with nominal c…

Went here as a party of 8 (had a reservation, but needed to wait about 15-20 min till the table was ready). Service, food selection, food preparation was excellent. Can split entrees with nominal c…

The wait was a little longer than liked but it's always good to see a smaller restaurant busy, but it was well worth the wait. The fried calamari was so good I almost wanted to order nothing but it. …

The wait was a little longer than liked but it's always good to see a smaller restaurant busy, but it was well worth the wait. The fried calamari was so good I almost wanted to order nothing but …

The wait was a little longer than liked but it's always good to see a smaller restaurant busy, but it was well worth the wait. The fried calamari was so good I almost wanted to order nothing but …

One of our favorite Italian restaurants in Binghamton. Generous portions, great service, and very popular with locals. Eggplant parmesan is yum. Steak ordered by others was huge in a delish sauce, …

One of our favorite Italian restaurants in Binghamton. Generous portions, great service, and very popular with locals. eggplant parmesan is yum. Steak ordered by others was huge in a delish sauce…

Nice surprise after a late evening of searching for a comfortable place for a family dinner. Great food. Outstanding service.

This place is excellent a great place to eat. Pretty interior, great atmosphere. The parm dishes are delicious. Great desserts too

We go every other week. The service is always great and the food is delicious. We almost always get a pizzatizer (a pizza appetizer) then an entrée so we have pizza and usually 1/2 a meal lef…

It was ok the sauce is sweet which isn't how I like it and the chicken parm dosnt come on pasta which I thought was weird but im from upstate they may do things differently down here

Donnie Rogers

Food took a while to get to us but was pretty good once it finally did. Took about 45 minutes to get a table and then waited close to an hour for the food to come out after ordering. This was a Saturday night about 6:30pm when we arrived.

Blue Davis L

My wife took me here an let me say... That fish sub with fries an the tartar sauce was very Delicious! The garlic knots was served with a nice sauce that was tasty! I even dipped my pizza in the sauce for an extra flavor 😁

Steven Lewis

I had veal parmigiana with pasta and that was v-good. I ordered lasagna to go, and that was not to my liking. The best part of everything was the waitress, Kasey! She gets 5 stars

Mary Naughton

This is a great, casual spot for family-style Italian food. The portions here are pretty large, the good thing about that is the leftovers! I’ve had their pizza a few different times throughout the years and it hasn’t been consistent, so I get their other items instead. This time, we ordered fried calamari as an appetizer, the Chicken Francese and Pasta Pomodori. I love that the bread for the table is their garlic knots. The fried calamari was excellent, it was hot and crisp, not rubbery at all, and their sauce had a slight kick but not too hot; very good. I’d get this again. The portion was so large it could feed a group of people. The Pasta Pomodori was very flavorful, I’ve had it another time and it was good then too. The Chicken Francese sauce tasted a bit too sweet for me, like there was an actual sugar taste to it. I’m not sure if they added sugar to try the balance the acidity of the lemon juice, or if the white wine they use is a sweeter variety. There was definitely something too sweet there. Aside from the sauce, the chicken itself was a very generous portion and it was cooked beautifully! It was a thick cutlet of chicken breast cooked all the way through and still so tender and juicy, I could use a fork to cut it. I may try a different chicken option here as the chicken was perfect but the sauce was the only issue for me. This is a nice spot to try, but go with someone that will let you try what they get too so you have some different ideas of their food.

+5

David Hershy

Yesterday I went to have a very early dinner after playing a round of golf. Michelangelo’s was highly recommended and what I ordered was said to be their best dish. It’s my favorite even though it’s not Italian. I ordered Chicken Parmigiano with a side of spaghetti. They served a side salad and garlic knots too. I liked the way the Chicken Parmigiano was prepared except that it was slightly dry (not bad just slightly) and the sauce should have been mixed in with the pasta prior to serving. These are minor things and did not take away from my enjoyment of the meal. Mike (I apologize if I did not recall your name) was the server and his attentiveness & friendliness was terrific. I definitely will be eating there again. I give them 4.5 stars in Food & Atmosphere along with 5 Stars on Service. Try them when you are in the area. 💜😎💜

+6

Tifani Kirchem

Decent pizza for a decent price. Family of 4 dined on a Saturday evening (5:30-6pm). The restaurant was full and we were told it would be a 20 minute wait. It didn't seem to be a full 20 minute wait to be seated, so that was nice. We ordered a large pizza with meat and onions. We were served garlic butter rolls while we waited. I do not suggest eating these on a first date. They are super garlic covered, almost too much, and it burns the mouth a little. But they were good. The pizza was pretty good. A little thin in the crust for us, but I guess that's the style of pizza. It still tasted really good. And the large is HUGE, we only ate half of it. The waitress was kind but could of come around for drink refills. 3 of 4 drinks were empty and we waited a long time to ask for a to go box and our check. Over all, if we are in the area in the future, we would eat here again.

+1

Perfect Veal parm every time and the red sauce is second to none. Service is always very good and prices reasonable. Yes, I've read that there can be a wait time. Good! That means is worth waiti…

Perfect Veal parm every time and the red sauce is second to none. Service is always very good and prices reasonable. Yes, I've read that there can be a wait time. Good! That means is worth waiting …

Perfect Veal parm every time and the red sauce is second to none. service is always very good and prices reasonable. Yes, I've read that there can be a wait time. Good! That means is worth waiting …

Perfect Veal parm every time and the red sauce is second to none. Service is always very good and prices reasonable. Yes, I've read that there can be a wait time. Good! That means is worth waiting …

I had the same food as last time here. Veal Parmigiana with pasta and a soda. I never had pizza at Michelangelo's so I had pizza for an appetizer. Mike was my waiter, did an ok job. The waitress'…

I had the same food as last time here. Veal Parmigiana with pasta and a soda. I never had pizza at Michelangelo's so I had pizza for an appetizer. Mike was my waiter, did an ok job. The wai…

I had the same food as last time here. Veal Parmigiana with pasta and a soda. I never had pizza at Michelangelo's so I had pizza for an appetizer. Mike was my waiter, did an ok job. The waitress's …

I've eaten here before, this time we did takeout. Think it was overpriced...food was just alright. Don't see myself doing this again

It had been quite a while since we had been there. But when we went previously, our all-time favorite was the salmon with their wonderful sauce however, last night, the salmon tasted bread, but the…

Lasagna is one of the best choices in town. Rich cheese and full of fresh tomato sauce were impressive. I even enjoyed a leftover on next day.

The food at Michelangelo's is absolutely delicious. One of my favorite Italian restaurants (if not my favorite) in Binghamton. I'm actually disappointed in myself for not going here sooner. Huge portions of quality food for a very fair price. Eggplant parm & chicken parm specifically are phenomenal, as is their bruschetta and garlic knots. My only gripe is that they are greatly limited in regard to space; I wish they were twice the size & had more room as far as indoor dining and even parking. They also seem to quite frequently have a wait time for seating due to this fact (unless you arrive super early, and even then there may be a wait!). But I assure you, it is well worth the wait and you will be very impressed w/ the food and the service. Edit: Tried to order take-out tonight from them and they hung up on my 3 times. Can't get through. I'm aware that it's Valentine's Day, but please, PLEASE practice better service than this. Take the call and simply say, "sorry, we are not accepting take-out orders at this time." Had to readjust my rating due to this.

Bob Norris

Our server Sophia started out great then went down hill after we got our food. As we were eating she came over never asked how anything was and placed to go containers and a bag on our 2top table. We were no where's near done eating. Then when we were done she was no where to be found. Had to ask a bus boy to find her for us. My Veal Marsala was very small but tasty for 28.00. Finding your prices keep going up and portions are looking smaller. My wife had chicken Marsala she said it was great.

Burak Erdinc

I was honestly surprised by the high Google rating, as my experience was disappointing. Appetizers and salad are mediocre. The penne alla vodka was overcooked, and the seafood-stuffed shells were also overcooked, with a sauce that felt overwhelming. I don’t plan to return.

Marilyn Mares

This is the second time that Ihave had a terrible experience here! We were seated just inside by the door. My legs were frozen. We waited exactly 1 hour for our food. My veal parmigiana was smothered under sauce and cheese. When I finally found the veal, it was semi warm and full of membrane fibers that I couldn’t even chew. Most of my dinner ended up in a napkin. I complained to our waitress (which we saw once through the whole dinner) and she assured me that she would take care of it. When the bill came, she had deducted $3.00 off my meal of $24.99. That means that I paid $21.99 for a small salad and 1 garlic knot!!! Never again You’ve lost 4 frequent customers

ada konkiel

First time going alone. sat myself awkwardly- asked for a food and alcohol menu to get no information on the house made items or deals for the day, couldn’t bother to ask how my day has been was just abrupt and kind of rude through the process- Had to go get my own silverware server forgot and order my own mixed drink at the bar because my server never came back to ask if I would like anything. Cool food but this place is not a good environment to hang out and enjoy a meal was really eager to get me out the door it seems - I get fast pace but it’s 3:00 on a Saturday. Did not enjoy the experience whatsoever.