Jaye Aster Broder

Very easy to buy tickets online. The drinks are surprisingly well priced, especially for NYC. The comedians are okay so the variety is very helpful. While not a tourist trap, I thought there were a lot of tourists at the show—most if these tourists were not problematic. I am cutting slack for so-so crowd work because of the tourists. Don’t get the frozen margaritas. They melt quite a bit before they get to your seat and taste like straight up sour mix. I suggest arriving earlier so you don’t get seated half on the stage.

+1

Brad Cottle

Is this the place to find new and upcoming comedians? No. But they are definitely trying their hardest. The performances were hit and miss. The biggest problem was the bartending staff. It was like 3 people for a room of 60. No introduction, no follow up. We were barely able to hit the 2-drink minimum because you have to wave down the bartenders like you're drowning. But... for $30 a person, it's not the worst thing to do in NYC.

Julie Escalante

The show itself was fun; however, the food and drink service significantly took away from the experience. We ordered our food and drinks before the show started, but the food arrived very late despite reminding the staff three separate times that we had not yet received it. Although our server told us we would not be charged for the food, we ultimately were still charged.

Rae M

I purchased a ticket from a vendor in Time Square for $30. The street vendor really oversold the caliber of this show. If you have a local Looney Bin this show is the same feel. We were told the show was going to start at 10:30, and it didn't begin until 11. There is a minimum 2 drink minimum requirement that customers have to buy and they automatically add a 25% gratuity to each purchase. This was not mentioned when the ticket was sold. The lowest price drink is $6 and those are non-alcoholic. There were a few good comedians. If I had known it was going to be $30+$17+ for drinks, would I have went to this show? No! This most definitely seems like a tourists trap. If you have nothing else to do and have money to burn, attend this show.

Adam Farmer

It’s fine, but nothing special. The place has that classic underground New York comedy vibe, which is cool, but the lineup the night I went just didn’t land. A few laughs here and there, but not the kind of show you leave talking about. Drinks were decent and the staff was friendly, but overall it felt more like a tourist stop than a true comedy hotspot. Not a bad way to spend an hour in the city, just don’t expect to be rolling in the aisles.

Royal Alchemist (BlackMoon Star)

Comedic were cool enjoyed the show but don't pay anything in cash. I handed the employee 80 dollars for a 78 dollar check (4 drinks and salsa and chips) the employee took my cash, walked away and turn around and said I only gave him 40. Which btw I walked out the house with 100 and spend 20, so when the bill came I was happy and my person was going to tip. Watch out for the slide of hand employees.

r1flyguy

Purchased tickets from street seller,,I think he was funnier than the comedians we were ‘entertained’ by. Tickets were overpriced for the quality and ‘time’ the show provided. Personally it’s a money making tourist trap. Any comedy club worth its pinch of salt would not kick you out for the ‘next’ performance. Really felt more about making money than proving value for it. The drinks are terribly overpriced $6 for a small bottle of water or other sift drinks, menus clearly states 20% gratuity but bill added 25% yet another way of screwing the customer! Overpriced & Underwhelmed, save your money and try find better comedy club elsewhere.

Alvaro Hernandez Martinez

This place is a SCAM! They take you in Times Square with a sign of Comedy Central. When you get to the place, there is no Comedy Central anywhere. It’s broadway comedy club. The drinks are overpriced and they make you pay a 25% gratuiti. So you end up paying like 30$ (the entrance) + 2 drinks (12 each) plus 25% + tax. That’s like 75$ for the WORST COMEDY SHOW I HAVE EVER SEEN. Please go to a broadway show instead. Look at the video if you don’t believe me… 😂

Hugo

Got scammed on the street with tickets. Showing Comedy Central logos and a map with big comedians. Saying original tickets are 60 but selling for 30. In the end got 2 for 30 but that’s still way too much for what you are getting. Instead of proven comedians like promised you get a bunch of nobody’s bombing. Out of all the comedians during the evening, only 1 bald roided guy got the crowd going and the “headliner” who no one heard of and only played for 5 min. All the rest where almost painful to watch. Also a 2 drink minimum as mentioned. Adding ontop of the bill. This should be advertised as an openmic of amateur comedians. Not sold as big names. Very dishonest place and sales practices.

Janaia Farrell

A dishonest & sketchy joint. They send guys out to Times Square with Comedy Central shirts on to get you to buy a $30 ticket (per person), tell you it’s a 7 minute walk to the club. When you finally get there it’s a hole in the wall place where you have to buy two mandatory expensive drinks (cheap soda and spirits) to watch the show. The comedians don’t deserve that. Total spent was $100 dollars for two of us that we couldn’t get back, and poor comedy at best. The comics were interrupted so many times, by the guy selling drinks, that they couldn’t get their flow out. Don’t go here.