Cozie's Pizzeria & Cafe

Khylee Ann

a friend and i were disappointed when the pizza shop we wanted to go to was unexpectedly closed, so we decided to give this place a shot. little did we know, this place would hit the spot!!! huge 5 stars for these guys and the atmosphere :) yum yum yum. you have to check it out.

Steffani Bjorklund

I recently visited a neighborhood staple, and I can tell you I was not disappointed! They have a great menu and have frequent specials that are delicious. I tried the calamari, garlic knots, butternut squash salad and a plain slice all of which were amazing. The staff and owners are so sweet I even had the chance to chat with one of them! This is a place I’ll visit over and over the pizza is one of the best in NY! The word “cozy” in the name describes it all for your lovely local pizza shop! They even had a cool birthday wheel 😎

BK Man

The pizza is delicious. The vodka slice is good. The chicken roll is amazing. Service is good. Staff are professionals. Cozie's pizza & Cafe is highly recommended.

Charles Alberta

Wow! Just WOW! Wish I had gotten here sooner but won't be long before I come back all the way from NJ! Sicilian Crust was perfectly cooked. The MVP may be the best pie idea ever! And to top it off we tried a butternut squash salad and it was excellent as well. Super friendly and welcoming place and staff! Don't miss this one if you are in the areas!

Sarah Varenhorst

Oh, YES! Just YES! Go here. I ordered delivery & first off, this ‘medium’ pizza is huge. I got the vodka bacon pizza and garlic knots. Everything is a flavor bomb and delivery came 15 mins earlier than the app’s estimate.

Neil Pacifico

To keep it simple.. the pizza is EXCELLENT!! Favorite is the White Pie! Thank you Lisa, Max & staff!

We had an unexpected visit from family and decided to just order pizza and sandwiches. We had the vodka pie, eggplant hero's ( which he made exactly to our liking, which wasn't on the menu). A few vegetable slices and a spinach pie. Everything was so fresh and the service was impeccable! The workers and owners are very friendly and we will definitely be going back. I'm glad I found this little gem

One of the best pizzerias in the neighborhood. Really friendly staff kids friendly and pet friendly

Over the past 10 years that I've ordered from here, Max the head chef has brought the quality of food and sophistication of flavors up to a level that puts Windsor Terrace officially on the NYC pizza map. Everything he makes is delicious.

Really good local pizza, great people, and great vegan options! The place is under new ownership (Max and Lisa are very passionate) and I love the direction they are going! All the usual pizzeria classics done right, but they are also working with a very experienced local vegetarian chef who has some really tasty salads, a sandwich, and soups! The butternut squash salad with roasted grapes and pistachio fennel crumble was a standout! Very unique combining the classics along with some updated ideas! I will definitely frequent this spot!

The food is excellent, far superior to previous owners. The staff are always friendly and helpful. Very sweet and attentive to my young grandson's. The salads are always fresh and delicious. So glad to have an old fashioned, delicious pizzeria back in the neighborhood.

I had an amazing experience at this pizza shop! The service was fast, friendly, and the staff made me feel welcomed as soon as I walked in. The pizza was absolutely delicious — perfectly cooked, great flavor, and you can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients. The atmosphere was clean and comfortable, making it a great spot to grab a meal. If you’re looking for great food and even better service, this is definitely the place to go. Highly recommend!

This place is a neighborhood gem. The pizza is great and the folks who work here are absolutely lovely. 10/5 stars.

The atmosphere is like a good pizza shop from the 80s and 90s. The pizza is absolutely delicious! My family and I have been ordering from the same pizza place for years on our annual ice skating day, but I told them to try cozies and no one was disappointed! We ordered 7 pies (all different) and each one was better than the last! It's definitely our new go to for pizza on ice skating day and every other day!

Cozie's is a neighborhood staple, and our kids LOVE their pizza! Max, the owner is a great guy who truly understands what it means to be a neighborhood pizza spot. Whether he's giving our kids trinkets from the quarter machines or hooking up our school with a discount for pizza parties, Max is a great pizza guy and Cozie's is a great establishment! Oh, and we've order pizza from here several times for our kids' birthday parties too, and he always delivers on time!

menelik bennett

I had an amazing experience at this pizza shop! The service was fast, friendly, and the staff made me feel welcomed as soon as I walked in. The pizza was absolutely delicious — perfectly cooked, great flavor, and you can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients. The atmosphere was clean and comfortable, making it a great spot to grab a meal. If you’re looking for great food and even better service, this is definitely the place to go. Highly recommend!

Nasir Rashid

One of the best pizzerias in the neighborhood. Really friendly staff kids friendly and pet friendly

Cara Chomski

This place is a neighborhood gem. The pizza is great and the folks who work here are absolutely lovely. 10/5 stars.

Kevin Torres

Cozie's is a neighborhood staple, and our kids LOVE their pizza! Max, the owner is a great guy who truly understands what it means to be a neighborhood pizza spot. Whether he's giving our kids trinkets from the quarter machines or hooking up our school with a discount for pizza parties, Max is a great pizza guy and Cozie's is a great establishment! Oh, and we've order pizza from here several times for our kids' birthday parties too, and he always delivers on time!

Claire Maronna

The atmosphere is like a good pizza shop from the 80s and 90s. The pizza is absolutely delicious! My family and I have been ordering from the same pizza place for years on our annual ice skating day, but I told them to try cozies and no one was disappointed! We ordered 7 pies (all different) and each one was better than the last! It's definitely our new go to for pizza on ice skating day and every other day!

Isen Ritchie

Great vibe and service, and fantastic pizza. Comfortable indoor and covered outdoor seating, with well regulated temperature thru all seasons. My favorite spot for pizza, anytime.

eddie ocampo

Over the past 10 years that I've ordered from here, Max the head chef has brought the quality of food and sophistication of flavors up to a level that puts Windsor Terrace officially on the NYC pizza map. Everything he makes is delicious.

Michele McDermott

We had an unexpected visit from family and decided to just order pizza and sandwiches. We had the vodka pie, eggplant hero's ( which he made exactly to our liking, which wasn't on the menu). A few vegetable slices and a spinach pie. Everything was so fresh and the service was impeccable! The workers and owners are very friendly and we will definitely be going back. I'm glad I found this little gem

Brian Olin

Really good local pizza, great people, and great vegan options! The place is under new ownership (Max and Lisa are very passionate) and I love the direction they are going! All the usual pizzeria classics done right, but they are also working with a very experienced local vegetarian chef who has some really tasty salads, a sandwich, and soups! The butternut squash salad with roasted grapes and pistachio fennel crumble was a standout! Very unique combining the classics along with some updated ideas! I will definitely frequent this spot!

This is your everyday's neigborhood style New York Style pizzeria. Pizza are very nice, but it's a little bit pricey, but overall this pizzeria offer great quality of foods. Has to take a star off because of price factor. (Sorry guys, but really the price of even a regular slice is almost the same as some of the great and the most famous Pizzeria at nyc in Lower Manhattan area?)

Mick Kwan

This is your everyday's neigborhood style New York Style pizzeria. Pizza are very nice, but it's a little bit pricey, but overall this pizzeria offer great quality of foods. Has to take a star off because of price factor. (Sorry guys, but really the price of even a regular slice is almost the same as some of the great and the most famous Pizzeria at nyc in Lower Manhattan area?)

We ordered the Margarita, garlic knots and antipasto salad last night. The Magrarita was SO BAD- I don't understand. The dough tasted really weird, and there was an insane amount of uncooked dried oregano. And there was WAYY too much crust compared to the rest of the pizza which made it worse. The garlic knots had almost no flavor, and the antipasto salad was inanely weak.

Slice of pizza very thin and extremely spicy I would not recommend to visit

Ilya Skver

Slice of pizza very thin and extremely spicy I would not recommend to visit

Zach Lindner

We ordered the Margarita, garlic knots and antipasto salad last night. The Magrarita was SO BAD- I don't understand. The dough tasted really weird, and there was an insane amount of uncooked dried oregano. And there was WAYY too much crust compared to the rest of the pizza which made it worse. The garlic knots had almost no flavor, and the antipasto salad was inanely weak.