Mar Cot

Lentil and Sausage soup delicious. Liked the ribs. Happy hour, good price on drinks.

J H

Staff was nice, steak was overcooked, asparagus plating just thrown down. Prior I rated higher when I had their Italian food, after this experience 3 stars...

al lee

Ordered the egg Parmesan and the special with pasta shrimp crab meat wasn’t crazy about the broccoli Great, dipping oil Clean bathroom

Sharon Hendricks

UPDATE 10/09/2021 Cory, I really appreciate you reaching out to me and I enjoyed our conversation. You also gave me additional insight to other variables that may have contributed to my experience as I ordered through GrubHub and didn't dine it. I certainly look forward to an opportunity to visit your establishment in the near future to experience in house dining and taste the difference. Thank you again.. UPDATE 10/07/2021 Wrote you two days ago in response to your response of my review and have yet to hear from you. I am not sure if it was my high expectation of what Italian food should taste like or just the food but I was truly disappointed. I ordered dinner for my family and normally I don't like to order pasta or pasta with sauce from any place because I expect my pasta to be al dente and my sauce to have flavor. The penne was overcooked and the sauce was bitter and had a canny taste that my own parmesan cheese could not make edible. I also ordered the chicken parmesan and it was equally disappointing. While it looked good it too had no flavor and had a paper thin slice of what I believe was mozzarella. In addition the cutlet itself was overcooked or possibly reheated giving it a rubbery hard texture. I also ordered the house salad and I guess what can you expect it had lettuce, a few cut up pieces cucumbers and a sprinkle of some type of cheese. My daughter had the same thing I did except she ordered the garlic mash potatoes in place of the penne. The potatoes had so much garlic they were light brown and bitter. I ordered the chicken fingers and fries for my granddaughter because she loves them but after one bite of the chicken fingers said she didn't like them or the fries. So I tasted them and just as everything else the chicken was overcooked, hard and very bland. I know that some people would think I was overly critical or nitpicking but when you pay close to $ 100 on a meal from a restaurant that claims to cook authentic Italian food that is what you expect and nothing less. For all of that I could have and should have ordered pizza.

Clark Neumany

Last night out on long island. Going to miss my family a ton. It was a great time this summer at the beach seeing Foghat and the amazing time with the smoker for my grandkids birthday party. And my wonderful daughter's birthday who is raising a beautiful family. Last night at carrabba's. Not the same portion are smaller and not as good. I had the eggplant parmesan and there was very little red sauce.

+5

Glenn

A solid 3 star meal! Service was delightful! The salad portion was generous and fresh. Our meal was timely and dessert was most welcome.

+2

Missy Vonnes

I ordered curbside to go my pasta was dry and my meat was overcooked. There was supposed to be spinach and mushrooms, my pasta had 2 spinach leaves and very few mushrooms. I had to put hot sauce so it wouldn’t be so dry.

Mike OB

Last time I will order to-go from this location. More than $20 for a cold, soggy, half sized piece of Lasagna. could not even finish it. I get it, it’s Carabba’s. I’m not ordering from a five star Italian restaurant, but they really should do better. I don’t know what employee thinks it’s acceptable to allow food looking like this to be packaged into a to-go order but they should be embarrassed

eduardo lievano

I went to CARRABBA’S Italian Grill in Central Islip on my son’s birthday April 07/2023 to have dinner with my wife and my son. The salads came fine, but my son entry pasta a la vodka with shrimps came with a hair in. They took a lot of time remaking his dish. Our food get cold while we wait for my son’s dish. Then the manager came to apologize and promised to honor it with something special even it’s my son’s birthday (reason we went there). Nothing was done on the manager side, furthermore, the waitress brought the check with nothing honoring us. Accidents happen and customers are the ones who keep the business running . I shouldn’t be doing this review if the manager takes care of the service in the kitchen and tables

Mark Volkwein

I ordered a lasagna dinner and meatballs and ricotta through doordash, the flavor was ok but the portions were a disgrace. Almost $30 dollars for this? I'll certainly never order anything from Carrabba's again unless I am picking it up myself or dining in