Cat Mama

Fantastic food, great service, good value. Why go elsewhere when Amato's offers pizza, pasta dishes, and hot or cold subs.

NMarie Donovan

HIGHLY recommend the small turkey sandwich, pazzo bread and brownie. Lasts me all day, sooo good.

Janice Marfiz

Ordered pizza and whoppie pies for dinner. From out of town and ordered through doordash. They were super busy but my pizza still arrived warm and was delicious. Right amount of crust to toppings ratio. Super filling. Enjoyed trying my first whoppie pie ever and let me tell you it was delicious! Would love to have found them sooner so I could have gotten another one before heading back home. Can't wait to come back to get another.

M G

Food was so good! Place was clean and service was fast. Idk what else you could ask for.

Maryann

Amato’s is the home to the original Maine Italian sandwich, from which all others Italians are based on. This is half of a small sandwich: American cheese, ham, onion, green pepper, pickle, tomato, olives, salt pepper and oil. I always order it with extra ham and olives. Absolutely delicious. Even though it is a cold sandwich, I let it rest for about 10 minutes to ensure the oil seeps everywhere before enjoying it with Humpty Dumpty BBQ chips and a Diet Coke; surprisingly, Amato’s does not sell Pepsi products. Amato’s makes their sandwiches fresh, to order. Rarely do they get it wrong. If you’re traveling through or visiting the Portland area, make sure you try Amato’s.

Melissa Boussom

Delicious calzone, though it was a bit heavy on the onion. Good thing I like them! Very friendly service, and yummy cheese bread! A welcome change of pace from all that seafood we'd been eating!

scospi

Ordered online and was ready when I got there. I got the Wednesday pasta special with two meatballs for $9.25 and it was delicious.

Kelly Burnham

The food is pretty decent but the lady who works here is sooooo miserable. She is probably in her 40’s and sooooo rude to everyone. She makes comments, and says things under her breath every single time. I never have seen her smile, her energy is so draining to even encounter with. She’s also rude to other younger employees.

Matt Cullen

Food was great. Unfortunately, the employee at the register was not paying attention to my order. After repeating back to her a fairly simple modification (steak and cheese with no peppers), the prep time was very long, and when I received my sandwich, it still had all the peppers one might normally receive. Upon returning the sandwich, I again, had to repeat my request not just to the same employee, but made sure her colleague who was actually building the sandwiches heard and understood. By the time the oven finished, the small rush of customers had drained out, and I was left standing to watch as my sandwich came out of the conveyor oven and sat at the end while the employee who took my order originally had come down the line to chat and distract the others who were trying to work. One had to ask me what I was waiting for, and said to the others "Hey! Wrap that! He's been waiting for it." At least everyone was friendly about it, but the whole visit took much longer than it normally would or needed to.

Alex Liptak

Ordered a ham Italian. They gave me so little ham that it’s almost invisible when looking at the cross section of the sandwich. By my eyes it’s a ham sandwich with about 0.05” inches of meat. Not good

Brenda Blais

First off I love Amato's. I did not have a good experience at this one. I ordered a regular ham Italian, asked for extra onions (didn't get). Usually Amato's tomatoes are bright red and delicious. Tomatoes on my sandwich were yellowish. The roll seemed fairly fresh. I no longer live in Portland but, used to frequent Amato's on India St. Never disappointed at that location. Also, staff not real friendly except the girl that rang up my order. Disappointed.