Pete 6776

Excellent NYC Pizza! This place is really good and I'm very picky with Italian food(I grew up in Queens). The regular slice is good. The Sicilian is awesome. It's perfect. Try a slice and you'll be hooked. I take home a whole Sicilian pie everytime I'm there.

Nanette Wallace

Love, love their eggplant anything! And the shrimp pharm was amazing. I have to mention that it was cooked perfectly and not fishy . Just wonderful.

Celine Chook

We dropped by Cold Spring Pizza for a quick bite. We ordered a teriyaki slice and grandma spicy pepperoni pizza. The teriyaki slice was unique as it was doused with teriyaki sauce, but a little too sweet for our taste. The cubes of chicken breasts on top were also dry. The grandma pizza was nice and cheesy and topped with what I think is hot honey, giving it a nice hunt of sweetness! Overall, the crusts of both slices were warm and crispy ☺️ It should also be noted that you pay after you eat, at least that's what the staff told us!

Marvin Martelly (Mobbinator)

I came here with a buddy of mine to feast after hiking through the Cornish Estate trail (definitely worth checking out). Normally when I visit a restaurant, I try things that are interesting and different. Looking through the variety of slices available, I asked the gentleman behind the counter to recommend me some slices. I ended up with a Margherita slice, a BBQ Pulled Pork slice, and the Eggplant Garlic Knot sandwich. My friend had gotten a pepperoni slice and the spicy pepperoni with hot honey (not pictured). I didn't get to try his slices, but he really liked the pepperoni slice. He enjoyed the spicy one as well, but he said it was a little too spicy and sweet for his taste. He did end up getting an additional pepperoni slice. I went for the BBQ slice first, and it was FANTASTIC! Literally perfect in every way. The margherita slice however was rather plain. It wasn't bad by any regard, but I thought it was going to be just as good as the BBQ slice. Perhaps my taste buds were all over the place from the first slice. The biggest surprise here was the Garlic Knot Sandwich however. To be honest I wasn't expecting to like it; I only got it for the sake of trying something different, but I'm glad I did. Of the three, this was my absolute favorite. The combination of the pesto with the balsamic glaze and eggplant melded so perfectly. The staff inside was extremely friendly and welcoming, and the accompanying ambiance was calm and relaxing. The interior was also very clean. Overall this place was absolutely fantastic. The only thing that kept them from getting 5 stars was the margherita slice I had. It wasn't bad, but I felt that it was lacking, especially in comparison to the other items I had. Definitely making the journey to come here again

Chief Caffeine Explorer

Solid classic no frills pizza shop. Went there late so can’t expect much availability. Lots of seating available which is a plus . Would be nice if they displayed the prices.

+1

NeL R

It tastes fresh, the best thing about the pizza here is the crust and the dough, it's PERFECT! Flavor on the other hand...it matches their service, bland. Which is a shame because the ingredients are all there, just no flavor, but does have a flesh taste.

Lea

Hmm they conveniently don't have prices listed on the big menu board, which I suspect is so that they can try to overcharge you and say oh sorry I meant x price if the price they give you seems excessive and you say something, which is what happened to me. asked for cheese with onions on personal size, said it was $15, so I just got it w/ no toppings for $9. also kinda crazy they said 1 slice was $6, which is why I just went with personal. frankly felt like they weren't happy w/ me after I questioned the price.. Mostly, the pizza was just overcooked; you could barely fold it! (but considering it was only $9, it wasn't bad)

eric j

Stopped by on my way through town ,,,nice old school spot with older seating , etc which I think is cool . Real solid pizza and friendly staff… The place could be cleaner,,,only one table / seat that was clean and I was the only person in the place ~

Anshul Augnivansh

Very greasy pizza and I have no idea why the reviews are so great. I took the spicy chicken and barbecue chicken sandwiches. Barbecue was overly sweet and didn't taste good at all. I personally love barbecue so I took pork barbecue pizza too. Honestly, it was worse. Although the staff was very polite and welcoming.

+10

Yolanda Poh

Ordered take-out fried calamari from Cold Spring Pizza and found green mold on the calamari itself under the breading. Very concerning and unsafe — had to throw it out. Won’t be ordering again.