Rachel

I had the two eggs with turkey bacon meal and it was good. I ordered a strawberry milkshake and it just tasted like strawberry milk. The prices were way too high in my opinion compared to the quality of food. That milkshake was $10… $10 for strawberry milk basically. The waiter was nice however the woman at the front is not friendly at all. She seemed annoyed since the minute we walked in. Other than that the food was fine, mean how can you mess up on two eggs and bacon.

Patricia Edwards

I don’t recommend the mixed drink, for the price expected a much better raspberry margarita…and ordered an Old Fashioned and got a margarita 🤦‍♀️…. Waiting on food, hoping it’s good. Edit to add food review, large portions and patty melt was perfect! Chopped steak dinner was delicious.

Limb Hacks

Love the 24 hours. Menu is colossal, even for a diner. I’d rather see a smaller menu so each dish, especially the staples, can get more care. Tuna salad was gamey. Baklava oversized mush. Fries were on point. The dinner specials looked generous and enticing. Good service. Overall I’m happy this place is there and wish them all the best. Edit: the panini I had when I went back has me wanting to add another star. Let’s see how it goes next time

Amelia PHW

The food was ok and there was no wait on a Friday morning around 11:30. The banana crepes were just slices of bananas in crepes that were smothered in whipped cream. The scrambled eggs and breakfast potatoes were both overcooked. The potatoes were actually quite crusty and crunchy. Corn beef hash was good.

Fred Eichler

$27 for a BEC omelet and cup of coffee $30 with tip. I get stuff is expensive but holy hell did they overcharge for mediocre diner food. Not worth it find somewhere else. The tab for my coworker and I was $60 dollars for a chicken club wrap, seltzer & my omelette and coffee. Don't go, go somewhere else.

Millie Serrano

Came here on a random drive. OVERLY EXPENSIVE! $20 just 8 mozzarella sticks. $10 for fries.... $2 for honey mustard! Bland small portion of fries. Pie was old... Register woman wouldn't get off her cell to check us out. Total bill was $30 for just fries a pie and 2 drinks. Ridiculous. The only upside was server was friendly and place was clean.

Alex

The portions are typically large for a diner. But that's about all that is good about the food. It's totally bland. We had a bowl of chilly, a deluxe burger, and Vacation panini sandwich. Nothing impressive. The best part was their cole slaw, pickles and fresh fries. Just to be clear - I'm not a fan of french fries, but it was better than the sandwich. Their menu is really extensive as often happens in diners. But the prices are higher than your average diner, you'd totally get better food at a restaurant for the same cost. And keep in mind that they charge 3% surcharge if you are paying not in cash. I believe it's exorbitant :( I guess it is totally justified that they are mostly empty all the time.

RIP OFF REPORT: $15 is how much this meal just cost me after tax and a 4% fee for using a credit card. What i got was an ungodly amount of fries and four tiny chicken tenders. Absolute rip off. I would advise getting more value for your money and eating elsewhere. There are a million places to eat in Mahopac that don't price gouge. Ridiculous. I'm never going back.

Amira Darwish

This diner was the closest place to eat after my daughter finished her gymnastics meet at Eclipse, and since we’re not from the area, we decided to give it a try. Unfortunately, the experience was disappointing. The food was overpriced for the quality. I ordered the chicken and shrimp francese, which lacked flavor and was undercooked. The shrimp also had an unpleasant, fishy taste. The mashed potatoes were clearly instant, not freshly made. I won’t be returning and would not recommend this diner.

Anthony Rivera

I travel the east coast often and I like to stop in at local diners, unfortunately this was NOT a good experience whatsoever, I ordered a cheeseburger nothing special the waitress was very friendly to me she took my order I received my cheeseburger I asked it to be cooked well done I proceeded to eat my burger and it didn’t taste fresh and it looked like it was a store bought frozen and thawed patty and it was medium instead of well done so unfortunately I don’t recommend this place plus the prices are super high, a soda a water and a burger cost me $30 so beware if you order a burger here it’s definitely not going to be fresh it’s probably boxed patty’s.

Melissa Correa

Olympus Diner is easily one of the most disappointing dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. The prices are completely unjustified for what they serve. I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap $20 without fries and received three dry pieces of chicken tossed with plain lettuce. No croutons, no cheese, no flavor whatsoever. It came with a random lettuce leaf and a slice of cantaloupe on the side, which honestly felt like an afterthought. For a place that’s been in business this long, you’d expect quality, flavor, or at the very least decent portions. Instead, everything felt lazy and overpriced. The portions are laughable, the food lacks seasoning, and there’s absolutely nothing memorable about the experience except the disappointment. Save your money — there are far better diners in the area that actually deliver on flavor, value, and service.

Jordan Rodriguez

This place simply put is flat out criminal and should be investigated for its poor management and terrible quality of food. The food is incredibly overpriced at $19 for a plain wrap with NO FRIES on the side. But even worse than being overpriced is the terrible quality of the food. This wrap had only a few small chicken pieces inside of it. If you don’t mind paying $19 for lettuce and wrap then this place is for you.

Mr. Andrew

2 GROSS Burgers & a small order of onion rings, No drinks = $59.5O! Burgers my kids wouldn’t eat