Village Square Bagels

W B

A lot of people seem to have issues with their service, but I've never seen it my whole life. They've always been nice to me. On the other hand, I know that Mamaroneck is full of entitled jerks that are rude to store workers, so I wonder where the fault truly lies. Regarding the food... there are lots of bagel places with subpar bagels, but this place has good ones. I never realized how good they were until I left Mamaroneck and experienced a world of bad bagels. I always come here for a bagel if I can, with cash ready. That's mildly annoying, but not enough to make me take off a star.

Ellison Ofarrell

The freshest of in house made bagels come with a variety of spreads and both hot and cold options to put inside. I ordered a sesame bagel toasted with bacon egg and cheese. While my mom had a toasted onion bagel with egg and cheese.They were both beyond reasonably priced super filling and satisfying.Fresh squeezed orange juice was also well worth it but they house a variety of bottled drinks.Great Place!

Emily Carmen

My absolute FAVORITE local bagel place! Always a great bagel and coffee. I have been going to this fantastic bagel place for THIRTY YEARS! And it is STILL always my FAVORITE! I LOVE their different bagel options and unique bagels as also a fun choice. Always also give a try to their different cream cheese options! Chocolate chip is great for a sweet treat! Or the low fat vegetable cream cheese goes great with everything! :-)

"I was excited to try Village Bagels after seeing they were offering a free coupon for a sandwich. When I went in, I ordered my sandwich but was disappointed to find out that they didn’t honor the coupon after I had already placed my order. The sandwich itself was just okay—nothing special. What really bothered me was the poor service. It felt like they didn’t care about the customers or keeping their word on promotions. Overall, not a great experience, and I don't think I'll be back anytime soon."

Long lines, young, untrained staff. They charge you 10 cents more for a “specialty bagel”. Since when is an everything bagel a “specialty bagel”? Charging 10 cents more for an everything bagel with almost no “everything” on it (see pic) is ridiculous! They also charge a 50 cents slicing fee to simply cut a bagel!! I’ll be taking my business elsewhere.

The only reason I’m giving them three stores is I went in yesterday got a bagel toasted with butter and the girl was picking her nose that was tripping when she realized I was staring at her she went to wash your hands and then change the gloves I don’t need to be seeing any of this

Mikey Lelli

"I was excited to try Village Bagels after seeing they were offering a free coupon for a sandwich. When I went in, I ordered my sandwich but was disappointed to find out that they didn’t honor the coupon after I had already placed my order. The sandwich itself was just okay—nothing special. What really bothered me was the poor service. It felt like they didn’t care about the customers or keeping their word on promotions. Overall, not a great experience, and I don't think I'll be back anytime soon."

Lia De Feo

Long lines, young, untrained staff. They charge you 10 cents more for a “specialty bagel”. Since when is an everything bagel a “specialty bagel”? Charging 10 cents more for an everything bagel with almost no “everything” on it (see pic) is ridiculous! They also charge a 50 cents slicing fee to simply cut a bagel!! I’ll be taking my business elsewhere.

Brotherhood Gear

The only reason I’m giving them three stores is I went in yesterday got a bagel toasted with butter and the girl was picking her nose that was tripping when she realized I was staring at her she went to wash your hands and then change the gloves I don’t need to be seeing any of this

Other day I asked for a garlic bagel w/cream cheese and a medium coffee with 3 sugars. Walk back to my car and I noticed no napkins so I went back. When i get back to my car I took a bite of the bagel and it was onion Not garlic so I go back again. When I back to my car I take a sip of the coffee and it barely had sugar so I had to go back to put sugar. Bagels are good but service not so much

Decent bagel but the women making the sandwiches are violating a lot of health codes (hairnet/gloves) and my bagel n cream cheese was over $6. Cash flow at this business is probably very poor if your put your prices that high. It’s bread and cream cheese lol.

Bagels were very good but also bought herring in cream sauce which wasn’t very good

Matthew Tucker

Bagels were very good but also bought herring in cream sauce which wasn’t very good

Jaime Olmeda

Other day I asked for a garlic bagel w/cream cheese and a medium coffee with 3 sugars. Walk back to my car and I noticed no napkins so I went back. When i get back to my car I took a bite of the bagel and it was onion Not garlic so I go back again. When I back to my car I take a sip of the coffee and it barely had sugar so I had to go back to put sugar. Bagels are good but service not so much

No Debit / Credit accepted. No signs on exterior of store indicating they don't accept plastic. Not the staffs fault. However, the waits are long and if you've lived in New York all your life, the bagels and such rank in the lower spectrum for taste. Of course, the ATM charges $2.75, on top of whatever your bank will charge you. I went in on a whim since I had just shopped at TJoe's, but I will never go in here again.

Went in for the first time ever, only because of its proximity to Trader Joe’s and needing to get something on the go. It took 15 minutes before they could get to me and then charged me $8 for two bagels with cream cheese - $4 a bagel! I’ve never paid that much in my life- anywhere. Yes the bagel and cream cheese was decent but I definitely won’t go back.

Meg B

Went in for the first time ever, only because of its proximity to Trader Joe’s and needing to get something on the go. It took 15 minutes before they could get to me and then charged me $8 for two bagels with cream cheese - $4 a bagel! I’ve never paid that much in my life- anywhere. Yes the bagel and cream cheese was decent but I definitely won’t go back.

Laurence OfNYC

No Debit / Credit accepted. No signs on exterior of store indicating they don't accept plastic. Not the staffs fault. However, the waits are long and if you've lived in New York all your life, the bagels and such rank in the lower spectrum for taste. Of course, the ATM charges $2.75, on top of whatever your bank will charge you. I went in on a whim since I had just shopped at TJoe's, but I will never go in here again.

The bagels are ok, but the sandwich I got is awful - this pathetic looking thing is supposed to have bacon and avocado, and the skimpy portion of chicken is just meh. The staff seems unhappy. Learn from my mistake and don't waste your money :(

We did a door dash order and only received three of our five items. We also had specific instructions that we paid extra for and were not included. I tried to call the restaurant multiple times after speaking to the Door Dasher, but there were no answers at that time. He was told by the employee who gave him the order that all of our items were in there. Will not be trying this place again.

I paid almost $8 for a bagel with cream cheese and look how cheap they were with the cream cheese. Bagels itself are good but this place is very overpriced for what they give. Also felt very rushed to order

Jessica Douek

The bagels are ok, but the sandwich I got is awful - this pathetic looking thing is supposed to have bacon and avocado, and the skimpy portion of chicken is just meh. The staff seems unhappy. Learn from my mistake and don't waste your money :(

Ryan MacRae

We did a door dash order and only received three of our five items. We also had specific instructions that we paid extra for and were not included. I tried to call the restaurant multiple times after speaking to the Door Dasher, but there were no answers at that time. He was told by the employee who gave him the order that all of our items were in there. Will not be trying this place again.

Stella Mariana

I paid almost $8 for a bagel with cream cheese and look how cheap they were with the cream cheese. Bagels itself are good but this place is very overpriced for what they give. Also felt very rushed to order

HORRIBLE service. I just left there. I stopped tipping the workers about a week ago as they have become ruder and ruder and ruder. Today was the final straw. I must have repeated the order 10 times, and they could not get it and they have such nasty tones in their voices. The food is good-to-ok but not worth the attitude from the order takers. The food is over-priced. I will drive a little further to feel appreciated as a customer. ...I don't recommend this place. Needs new ownership.

Worst bacon/egg/cheese I have ever had. The bread was stale, the bacon was precooked packaged, and the slice of cheese was so thin it was almost transparent. Ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel, yet not one raisin in it. Over priced for the quality of food. Not returning, not recommending.

I went in one Saturday morning before work for a bagel because I didn’t want breakfast from McDonalds or Starbucks. The line was chaotic I didn’t know who ordered already from who didn’t order yet, it’s very overwhelming. I waited in line for 10 minutes before it was my turn. There was an older caucasian lady who had just finished a customers order and it was my turn, she looked at me and walked away! There was no “give me a second I’ll be right with you.” So I waited again for the hispanic ladies to complete the other orders they were working on. This older hispanic comes to the counter after finishing an order then proceeds to take another customers order that was 2 people behind me because she knew who he was!!! Then had the audacity to ask him if he needed anything else! I was sooo pissed I walked out. As I’m leaving then I hear “next customer please” Moral of my review if your black DO NOT GO HERE!!!! YOU WILL NOT BE SERVED!! After wasting my time in this establishment I ended up being late to work 🙄

Stephany Webson

I went in one Saturday morning before work for a bagel because I didn’t want breakfast from McDonalds or Starbucks. The line was chaotic I didn’t know who ordered already from who didn’t order yet, it’s very overwhelming. I waited in line for 10 minutes before it was my turn. There was an older caucasian lady who had just finished a customers order and it was my turn, she looked at me and walked away! There was no “give me a second I’ll be right with you.” So I waited again for the hispanic ladies to complete the other orders they were working on. This older hispanic comes to the counter after finishing an order then proceeds to take another customers order that was 2 people behind me because she knew who he was!!! Then had the audacity to ask him if he needed anything else! I was sooo pissed I walked out. As I’m leaving then I hear “next customer please” Moral of my review if your black DO NOT GO HERE!!!! YOU WILL NOT BE SERVED!! After wasting my time in this establishment I ended up being late to work 🙄

Edite Maria Morais

Worst bacon/egg/cheese I have ever had. The bread was stale, the bacon was precooked packaged, and the slice of cheese was so thin it was almost transparent. Ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel, yet not one raisin in it. Over priced for the quality of food. Not returning, not recommending.

J L

HORRIBLE service. I just left there. I stopped tipping the workers about a week ago as they have become ruder and ruder and ruder. Today was the final straw. I must have repeated the order 10 times, and they could not get it and they have such nasty tones in their voices. The food is good-to-ok but not worth the attitude from the order takers. The food is over-priced. I will drive a little further to feel appreciated as a customer. ...I don't recommend this place. Needs new ownership.