I might have had it all wrong, but I walked away from another nearby pancake house (second day in a row) for feeling like I was being treated differently because of the color of my skin. A few blocks away, the staff at Anthony’s pancake house were on the contrary, very welcoming and attentive so my husband and I decided to give it a try. The food was amazing and the place was immaculate... so clean! Would definitely recommend this breakfast spot to family and friends

Food was amazing and tasted fresh! Was an excellent way to end my batchelorette weekend. Some of the best home fries I've ever had. Will come again if I'm ever in Montauk. The peanut butter pancakes were delicious

Fast service, fresh fruitsand vegetables. Friendly staff. Busy, tables are clean quickly but no rush to hurry your meal. Inside and outdoor dining. Plenty of seating to accommodate small (1) and larger groups.

Family owned business with attentive staff and great food. If you get a seat by the window, you've got it made.

We came here for breakfast twice from NYC and we loved it! The service is fast and friendly. The food is delicious and well priced. The atmosphere is great and the space is well decorated and designed. Definitely worth coming to!!!

We came each morning for breakfast during our 3 day stay in Montauk. Food was great every time, place was very clean and our servers were always accommodating. Silver dollar pancakes were tasty and their home fries were delicious!

One of the best pancake houses, I got the Oreo waffle and it was delicious with a side order of bacon

The food was delicious and service was exceptional. What a great breakfast spot in Montauk

This is an outstanding restaurant for breakfast. The food is fresh, the service is excellent. Today I had Classic Eggs Benedict, and a very generous serving of the Holandaise sauce. Staff are courteous, friendly and willing to meet customers needs. We had breakfast at Anthony’s every morning that we were in Montauck. I highly recommend Anthony’s when in Montauck.

The food was good for a quick bite. The line was long and we had to wait 30 mins for a table. But the service was really good with nice friendly staff.

Best gluten free waffle ever. Highly recommend the steak and eggs and the hash is delicious. Ate there 3 days in a row...

My family and I had almost all of our breakfasts here in August 2024. This, believe it or not, is one of the very rare places in Montauk where you can still have a traditional American style breakfast: eggs any style, omelets, berries, yogurt etc. The food is delicious. We tried eggs benedict, salmon omelet, spinach omelet, home fries, yogurt (awesome!), French toast different styles. The atmosphere here is very warm and welcoming, the waiters are fantastic and Anthony himself comes out often to help the guests and talk to them. They all do their best to make guests feel comfortable and at home. Sometimes we took take outs from here. Everything was packed nicely and thoughtfully. Highly recommend!

Excellent waffles and home fries

Anthony’s is a wonderful place to eat at! The food is delicious and the service even better. Danny is an exceptional server! We wish there were more like him! He’s very attentive, thoughtful, knowledgeable and professional. This is why we keep coming back. Thank you for making us feel at home!

Just loved this place. Clean, modern, friendly. Great food! Always a line, but moves pretty quickly to get a seat!

Great place The food is phenomenal and the service top notch!

I love Anthony's Pancake House! The owner/staff are so attentive and they really take care of their customers. The food has all the hits. The pancakes are my favorite but you can't go wrong with anything else on the menu. Highly recommended Montauk spot to hit when you are there!

We came here 3 times in a row and loved it each time. The food was excellent (I recommend the famous fluffy pancakes). The service was amazing, our waitress, Darina made our experience 5x better. It’s a very popular breakfast spot and I can see why. There is a bit of a wait time if you come during peak hours (11-12) which is expected but it is worth it!

My husband and I had a great breakfast on our way out of town. Servers were prompt and food was quick and really tasty for an amazing price. The interior renovations look great as well - refreshed modern beach town vibes. HIGHLY recommend bringing cash to pay with before you come :)

Delicious and worth a visit. Casual approach and perfect for the area. Worth a visit for pancakes and or French Toast.

The breakfast pancakes eggs, and sausage are delicious beautiful atmosphere nice staff pricing is great great place to visit for breakfast when in Montauk restaurant is very neat and clean. Definitely recommend to go. Thank you Anthony's pancake House for a great time

Such tasty food!! Outdoor and indoor dining. Love the new decor inside!

We ate here twice during our trip to Montauk. The queue gets long around 9:30 so we got there at 7-7:30 being early risers and there was no problem getting seated (they open at 7am). Tried the pancakes and waffle which were both good, pancakes probably better! Service was quick and food came out quickly too. Recommended (but go early!).

We went to brunch at this place during Covid. They have outdoor seating available, great hygiene, great cleaning and overall a good and safe place to have brunch. Food is good too and its inexpensive considering the location. Its on the main street, where you can enjoy view from outside and enjoy great food. We ordered Veggie of the day which was a big Veggie omlette long with house fries. Food was great. Definitely recommend this place for breakfast.

The staff greeted our group of 10 people quickly and warmly. We got there around 7:30AM and they were so accommodating. The food was prepared with care and the serving portions are perfect! The staff are kind and attentive which I love! If you are in the Montauk area I highly recommend the country fried steak with sunny side eggs, home fries and toast! The coffee is freshly brewed and they frequently walk around checking cups for refills! I also recommend the pancakes and the waffles are fluffy! The decoration has a nautical style theme reminiscent to the area but modern without being too distracting.

10/10 breakfast spot. A well oiled machine. The staff is so friendly. The owner himself works hard alongside his employees. The food is such a great quality. Anything you could think of for breakfast, they got it.

My grade is 93. Awesome pancakes 🥞 and home fries. Definitely going back. Nice friendly staff.

THE place in MTK for breakfast. It has been around for decades and its recently renovated and everything is spotless and beautiful. Basic diner/breakfast menu but everything is executed perfectly. They have gluten free options, turkey sausage and bacon, fruit, oatmeal, BLTs, eggs Benedict, pancakes, French toast and everything else. I always get an omelet and an English muffin. Coffee is piping hot and fresh, always refilled. Staff and service is spot on. Food comes out fast. My go to spot after fishing an early tide.

Great places to eat. Friendly staff . Food is great

Food was great,service is fast! Just wished that there’s more smoothie on the Acai bowl, they put very little and too much on the peanut butter. Would recommend coming in around 2ish, which is easier to get seat and more quiet

Anthony’s blows the typical Long Island diner away. The food is wonderful and reasonably priced. Extremely clean, well lit, and open. The waitstaff is excellent and friendly.

It is a very clean place, great energy inside!! Sometimes took the server a few minutes to come check on us but otherwise a great experience and would go back 100%. The food came out fast once we placed our order as well. Over all 9/10 review !!! Thank you

Amazing breakfast! You know they're good because all the locals go here.

Wow, what an awesome breakfast! A fast wait 4 a table. Recommended. Cash or debit card only. Some tables outside.

I had the best avocado and nova salmon toast here 04/28/24

Yoseph A

Came here for breakfast on a Saturday morning and had a great experience. We were able to sit wherever we wanted, which was nice. The omelette and steak and eggs were very good, the waffle was fresh, and the home fries were absolutely delicious. A solid spot for a relaxed breakfast in Montauk.

Joseph Morton

Went twice in a row for breakfast and was just lovely. Food was delicious and big portions. Friendly staff and attentive. Reasonably priced for the area, will definitely be back.

John Ellett

I had a locks onion feta cheese omelette that was very good. My wife had a fried egg over corned beef hash that was excellent at the Hormel style corned beef hash not the Irish corned beef hash. The coffee was good. Went here in September

Jessica Jaber

Love this place! The ratings are far too low and do not represent the experience the restaurant is spacious. We were seated on a weekend morning with no wait time. Indoor and outdoor seating is available. We sat indoors. Coffee was served immediately. Hot and fresh. We got the Oreo Cookie Waffle Special and it was delicious! The waffle itself was not a bland chunk of dough, but a yummy flavor and the consistency was perfect. We also got the Dulce De Leche Stuffed French Toast which was divine. I highly recommend. Especially for families or those wanting a large selection of menu options.

Glue Guy

Great breakfast place for traditional eggs, bacon, and pancakes fare. Family run. Lots of seating inside and outside. Popular place. Had coffee on the table immediately. They do charge for using a credit card... but many, many restaurants and stores are doing the same, so it is not unusual anymore.. and in reality, most of us get some perks from our credit card company. They are very upfront about it, so no surprise, and they do have an ATM if you prefer that.

+1

Amanda Hahn

Ate here 2 days in a row- the house veggie omelet was amazing and HUGE! They also serve gluten free waffles. Hot and ice coffee pretty good too.

Keith Beitter (KGB)

Great little breakfast spot. I was solo dining so I sat at the bar and was greeted right away. My server was quick and friendly. Food was delicious and coffee was tasty. Check it out if you are in the area.

+3

Vince A

A great breakfast place choice for Montauk Point. Price and service and ambiance was very nice as compared to another breakfast location we tried the day before. This place was also busy but was very accommodating with the churn of the guests without much of a wait if at all. The place was clean and roomy and looked to be updated. I would come here again!

Nan Zhang

I had the gluten free waffle, and holy smokes. Blew. My. Mind. It’s corn, and it’s the best gluten free waffle (breakfast, really) I’ve had in my life. Server was attentive and sweet - made sure we had the exact items we needed given other dietary restrictions too. We came on a rainy day and there was no wait. It was super cozy and we didn’t feel rushed at all.

Eugenia Kim Ferrier

When in Montauk, definitely try a pancake house. Reservations not taken at this restaurant so there will be a wait time. This place takes only cash and also credit card but there is extra fees so we recommend paying in cash. Service was fast and the waiter was friendly. Plenty of food and beverage choices. Good quick place to grab breakfast before heading out for the day. Plenty of space for small gatherings, on your own, or a big family sit down.

Lisa S

I came here yesterday for breakfast. This place looked a lot more modern than their competition across the street. They don't have a real extensive menu and it is cash only. The pancakes I ordered were delicious and my scrambled eggs came out perfect. The service here is fast and the waitstaff is friendly. I will definitely come back again the next time I am in the area.

Pam Eltemawi

A small wait, if you come after 11:00am you will wait a little longer. The food was amazing. The fluffy pancakes weren't so fluffy but they were good. Crepes with berries and bananas were also good. A small place with great food, but the service was OK(maybe it was just our waitress). I still give this place a 5 start.

Amanda Miller

Friendliest staff around! We stumbled upon this place by accident when we found that most of the surrounding restaurants were doing take-out only (although they all said dine-in was available on Google maps). Our party of three had French toast, a BLT w/ avocado, a 2-egg breakfast w/ bacon & toast, 2 orders of fries and a coffee for approx $45. All of our food was hot, fresh and good! Our waiter and waitress were very attentive and kind, and the restaurant was very clean. All of the patrons appeared to be as happy with their experience as we were. Restrooms were closed.

Breakfast was good. They didn't even return to see if you wanted more coffee. Better have cash for tip.

Great place for breakfast. Terrific French toast, pancakes. Pricey with some sides added.

Food was good, service was great, establishment was clean and chill. Had a good brunch, felt a bit pricy for brunch.

This is why we love Montauk! Good breakfast menu. Expensive? Not considering location and the quality of meal and super clean interior. The bathroom was spotless! Both Johns and here had excessive wait times, 45min. A minor criticism is that the staff were all business, no conversation skills, like everyone there! That was weird. Still, recommended.

Food was very good. The eggs Benedict was pretty spectacular. Mozzarella sticks were not up to temperature and cheese in the center was cool. Staff was friendly but not super attentive with refills.

Traditional breakfast, maybe it is not cheap, but it is Montauk. Nice staff and perfect pancakes with hot chocolate. Come early if you do not want to stay in front of the restaurant for a long time

the food is busting however i feel like i’m being rationed. My side of bacon consisted of three flimsy strips which is a pitiful amount. The home fires were also hella mid. The service here is impeccable and the way they re-did it is beautiful. Four stars to Anthony’s.

Really good breakfast food . Fresh coffee. Loved the French Toast and bowl of fruits, Home fries were delicious! Will visit again when visiting MTK

It was a clean and Fancy breakfast place but was relatively crowded by 8 a.m.

This pancake house offers bright sunny cafe, nice servers, good food... However, they're dishes are more simple and straight forward (less exciting) than the other pancake house on the block. Also, portions were smaller, but prices were about the same.

Definitely a must try if you're in the area and are looking for a delicious breakfast. We came here twice for breakfast and both times left happy. Our server was sweet and courteous. This place is immaculate and offers great menu options. I recommend the pancakes, turkey bacon, yogurt bowl, and home fries. I'm not crazy about home fries or potatoes in general but wow, the home fries were the best I've ever had!! I didn't give it 5 stars because although the cheese omelette we ordered was tasty, it was a tiny omelette. Looked like a kid's portion. Other than that, everything else was delicious and was much enjoyed.

Extremely packed in the mornings but worth the wait. Extensive menu (especially compared to other places in MTK) and everything on it is done very well. They only accept cash tip or venmo but don’t tell you that up front so be mindful to have cash on you. Highly recommend the fresh squeezed orange juice.

Everything you want from a diner: clean, fast and basically delicious. Crepes were a big hit and everything was great. Note: Tips only accepted in cash, so you can put the meal on your card but make sure to have cash for the great waitstaff.

Gary Nasta

I had the S'Mores French Toast and my wife got two eggs with bacon and home fries. Everything was delicious and the place is really clean and nicely decorated.

Denis Mantsurov

My experience at the pancake house was a bit mixed. While the menu had a variety of options, I was disappointed by the slow service that seemed to affect the overall enjoyment of the meal. Additionally, I found the prices to be on the higher side for what was offered. Despite these drawbacks, the pancakes themselves were quite tasty, which somewhat balanced out the experience.

Pumpkin pancakes were good but not great (a little mushy). Husband's regular pancakes were delicious. Expensive though - two orders of pancakes, two sides of bacon and two coffees was $37! Too much for a very simple (okay) breakfast. Would try a different place next time we are in town.

To expensive for the amount of food. Delicious but not worth the money.

Avocado toast made by someone who had an idea of what it should be but has never actually eaten it. It looked so sad. I felt sorry for the toast.

Nice place except that the omelet was brown, flat, and lifeless. The scrambled eggs were also awful. Hopefully rest of menu is better.

I ordered the Salmon Benedict for $18.95. The food tasted good but it came out without any sides whatsoever. At that price point, I should at least get potatoes. Yes, the restaurant was packed but the server never came to check on us. I had to find and retrieve my own napkins. Nevertheless, we'll come back next year.

hopping summer scene for pancakes & french toast - especially summer weekends. freshly redesigned inside, this restaurant has a trendy vibe while still maintaining a family/diner feeling while visiting. peanut butter stuffed french toast was a bit plain, so no raving about the food in particular, bit still a perfectly fine pick if someone in your group is hankering for a stack.

The food was a miss. The eggs were overcooked and the pancakes were not fluffy. The service was good and staff was attentive.

The sign says no dogs allowed inside but I had to start to go in to get a table outside (for myself and my dog). They asked if my dog wanted water and I said sure. They had a nice dog bowl (elevated stand) but the water looked dirty (my dog didn’t drink it). The pancakes fruit and bacon were good. I didn’t like the hash browns potatoes. The service was very good . I liked the breakfast at John’s pancake house better and it cost less.

I visited Anthony’s Pancakes in Montauk and the food was good, but I was very disappointed with one thing: I was charged the same price for a small cup of hot water as for a coffee — over $4 plus tax. This was the first time I’ve ever experienced something like that, and honestly it felt unreasonable. I can understand charging for coffee, tea, or other beverages, but hot water should not be the same price as coffee. It left a negative impression despite the good food.

Solid place for breakfast right in the heart of town. Service can be inattentive and not that friendly but the food is ok.

Loved the food here but absolutely furious that they wouldn’t allow my friend (a vegetarian) to replace the meat in the pancakes combo with homefries or fruit. They then even put the meat on the same plate when she told them that!! Potatoes are cheaper than meat, no? Not sure why this was an issue and we had to pay for a separate plate of home fries. Very unaccommodating

Ehsan

The highlight was the french toast, definitely recommend. Pancakes were average, the syrup was helped. Drinks tasted too watered down. Customer service was extremely poor, it didn't feel welcoming at this establishment despite visiting on a Sunday morning. Decor was done well. For parties with 6 or more people, you will be charged 20% gratuity. May return to give it a second chance, but as of yet, nothing extraordinary or remarkable.

James Morgan

A place I've gone to for years every time I visit Montauk and has slowly settled into just being a tourist trap that doesn't care about quality or service. Waiter was not attentive with a rude tone who couldn't be bothered to even give us a glass of water. (in contrast the bus boy was very nice) The "fluffiest pancakes" have turned into flat discs that resemble eggo frozen pancakes. Eggs and omelets were good so if your going stick with the egg menu. For the price they charge i expected more.

Michael Justin Porco

I ordered the $18 açaí bowl and was disappointed with the experience. It arrived too frozen to eat, and when they warmed it up in the microwave, they didn’t remove the fruit—so I ended up with warm strawberries on my bowl. For the price, I was expecting a much larger portion, though I suppose I should’ve expected that in Montauk. The server was decent, but never came by to refill our water, which is a personal pet peeve since I drink a lot during meals. On the positive side, the atmosphere was lovely—clean, bright, and clearly recently renovated.

Leslie Sun

Service was slow, egg platters don’t come with home fries, but price was decent. Orange juice is fresh. Bring cash for tip (not allowed to be charged to card).

Food was very good the crepes with fruit had rotten fruit and they charge $4 for a cup of hot water other than that the eggs and sausage and pancakes were good but they all greedy

Good food, but their prices are too high. I'm very disappointed that I couldn't pay with credit card and that they added a tip to my bill. I would like to decide about the amount of gratuity. Also I could not finish my coffee, because a waiter said that other people are waiting and I need to go...

Kayla

The presentation of the food was okay -looked fresh at least, however, for the price of the food it is extremely underwhelming. I ordered a salad that was $20 and all it had was some spring mix, sliced onion, and 3 slices of tomato, with some plain unseasoned chicken… the fries were probably the only tasty thing we got. Service was okay, not super friendly but not rude. They charge extra if you pay with card and you have to venmo or use cash only to tip

Wouldn't waste my money. Tried spending local until we were robbed. 10$ for an egg sandwich. And 4.50 for a frozen bagel and cream cheese. Staff lounging around. One waitresses son stretching across counter seats. Seemed nice enough until the bill arrived. Cashier reviewed the bill then straight out told us " well, we're only open for a short period of time and need to make our money". Great way to promote your business. I understand it's a tourist trap but that's insane. Lex ave doesn't even charge that amount

Chef was very unprofessional and rude. I stoped by with 3 of my friends. After checking the menu and asking yhe server if there were any VEGAN options. (no vegan options) I wanted to allow my non vegan friends to enjoy their breakfast and so I walk across the street to a coffee house that offered great vegan options (wrap and matcha). I returned to join my friend and instead of him coming over to the table or send the server. He yield from the kitchen "ma'am no outside food". Which I get it but he could have been more courteous because there were quite a few people in the restaurant. Customer apologized (because they thought that was rude) and the server was very professional he came over to my friends and apologize after I left. Howevet, My outdoor cafe was a better atmosphere so I'm not mad at returning there to eat.

My breakfast didn’t come with potatoes, prices were not good especially with the portion size. Place is fairly clean but very disappointed and would never return. I would not recommend this place. Very small portions, mediocre food at best and I want my potatoes! Super sad and left hungry

Informed the receptionist that id like to dine on the recently vacated table outside that seats 1-2 and he confirmed. I sat next to it on the bench immediately adjacent to the table only to have the table given away to two diners who were already seated and served as soon as the waiter finished cleaning that table for me. Place is lame. I saw their breakfast platters of sausage and eggs and their pancakes and it’s all very basic. Nothing particularly unique or valuable here, especially customer dignity. Lost a customer and got a 1 star review for your disregard. Now you’re rated no different than the pancake house literally across the street. Enjoy that.

Worst place ever!! Waitresses have the worst attitudes and the food is awful. McDonald’s is 5 star meal compared to the overpriced slop there. We had items taken off the check due to horrible quality of food. When I asked for lettuce and tomato for my burger, I was told I had to get the $13 deluxe meal that came with cheese. When I asked to have the cheese removed, the waitress was horribly nasty. Restaurant it’s self is filthy. Dine at you’re own risk.

My partner and I visited this restaurant earlier today, excited for a nice meal. He ordered a burger while I chose a Greek salad and French fries. Unfortunately, I found the salad to be unfresh and not up to standard, so I returned it and decided to stick with just the fries. Regrettably, my partner was also dissatisfied with his burger but chose not to voice his concerns since we had already returned my salad. Fast forward just a few hours, and we are now feeling unwell in our hotel, experiencing nausea and vomiting. Our mini vacation has been completely ruined.

Overrated and overpriced. The quesadilla was basic and we were charged $5 extra for a spoonful of diced onions & tomatoes and this extra wasn’t mentioned by the server. The so called ‘famous’ pancakes were served in pieces not a whole rounded piece, I make better pancakes at home…

Terrible breakfast. French toast was wonder bread dipped in egg mix and cinnamon. Not sure how this is called a pancake house considering they were dry, lacking flavor, and tasted like a store mix. Our service was good and so was the coffee, but everything else was disgraceful.

Beware! No credit tip on the credit cards and then they wack you on there own ATM for a cash tip. $16 for eggs Benedict with no sides or potatoes. Side of bacon, you get 3 strips. Full rip off, I'll stick with John's pancake house or the bakery! Food was good and service but the rest no thanks.