Sarah Rosenberg

10/10 would recommend! We eat lots of pizza and somehow have never tried Amici’s until today. It is a little bit more expensive than some other places (although they often have deals!) but you definitely get what you pay for. Quality New York pie with a crispy crust and amazing flavor. Will definitely be coming back.

Qihua M

Very good Italian style pizza with thin crest, it has 4 sizes to order. We tried a largest 15” pizza for three people. Cheers!

+6

Young Kim

Delicious! Best fettuccine with red clam sauce, love it! New haven white clam pizza with very tasty also! Yummy crunchy garlic bread. Very friendly staff and service.

+1

liam pramono

I went to this place because I heard they still baked the pizza in the open flame brick. Turn out, it is a good experience for me. The services are good and the food is extremely delicious as well We order the amici pizza which js one of their specialty (for meat lovers) and we customize it to add some cheese and jalapeno on it. The pizza is super crispy abd have many size to choose. We also go for the white spaghetti clam, which I think they have one of the best. For appetizers, I would suggest their chicken wings, both spicy and non spicy and also the garlic bread Overall it is definitely a must place to visit

+10

Kevin Paterson

We have ordered dinner the for pickup before, but yesterday was the first time we sat down and ate there. It was about 5:15 pm when we got there and it wasn't crowded at all. We were greeted and directed to sit wherever we liked. Our server came immediately, greeted us and took our drink order. We appreciated the quick and attentive service we received. For this visit I ordered the Oriecchette with sausage, make and pine nuts. I was expecting a lot of flavor from it, but it tasted bland to me to where I needed to add salt. My family members ordered a large lasagna, a personal pizza and a small pizza. They enjoyed their meal. We also had garlic bread sticks which are pan fried. We all enjoyed that. Next time I go I will probably try their pizza instead of their entrees.

M.A. EatsArt

Excellent pizza crust, delicious, and not overly fatty. Succulent bits of tomatoes in the margarita pizza. Super clean restaurant, quick service. Not cheap, but every bite will be worth it. Make sure enroll in their app to accrue purchase points towards free food because this is a rather pricy pizzeria. Chicken wings with lemon and parsley is so addictive. The spice level can skyrocket, so beware! Pizzas are out of the oven quicker than they predict so be sure to arrive earlier for pick up.

Tammy Liu

Haven't been here for quite a few years. Pizzas were pretty delicious, just a bit dry and too crispy. Ingredients tasted fresh and flavorful. The pasta with clams came with lots of clams, reasonably good, maybe just lack a bit of that clam seafood flavor, maybe because these were from a can. Prices were a bit on the high end.

+5

Keith Chan

Nice service, pretty bad food. $20 for one of the worst margarita pizzas I have had is rather ridiculous.

Fiona

Family friendly. Decent service. The dining room felt very dated, with the baseball art and beige walls. Had the kale and sausage pizza, with garlic and pine nuts (great combo). Not bad, kinda dry. Caeser salad was nice, homemade dressing was more of a vinaigrette.

+2

Sam C

First date night of 2026 with the wife met with low-quality food. I ordered Fettuccine with chicken. What I got was Fettuccine soup with overcooked pasta. The amount of sauce I received was enough for four portions of pasta (see picture below, that was the amount of sauce leftover after having to fish for the pasta and chicken). My wife was not impressed with her pizza either (she gave it a 2 out of 5 rating). We wont be returning anytime soon. Quality assurance needs improvement. Front staff were friendly.

A. Scott Dougherty

The customer service is fine and I usually love Amici's other locations but whomever they have working in the kitchen here needs a refresher course. There is so much extra sauce on this I almost think it's a joke that they would send a pizza out looking like this. This is terrible. Previous order the pie was bone dry so I asked for a "little bit extra sauce" and they sent me this:

Chrissie Glidden

Pizza was so soggy and greesy. Had to cut the middle off just to try and eat a slice. It was barley cut as well. Hardly any sauce. I'm not sure what happened tonight. They used to be really good. Today was incredibly disappointing. We tried to eat it but it was just too soggy. Sad take pride in your job!