Moses S

This is a a great Italian sandwich in midtown. I got their signature Alodoro sandwich which I would rate a 9.5/10. The price is a bit high and it gets a bit packed at lunch but worth the price and the wait. The customer service was 10/10 they rushed my order when I told them I was late for a meeting. Will come back soon.

Kit W

One of the best sandwiches I’ve had in town, generous portion with reasonable price. Ingredients are super fresh, ordered “Pinocchio” , it was really really good, also loved the “Italian Cheesesteak” , absolutely amazing !!!

KarenY NYC

Vibe: loud, busy, smells heavenly mixed of meats and bread ;-) I’ve now been to 3 Alidoro locations: Moynihan, Rockefeller and Bryant Park. With some luck, the location by ESB (giant poster!) will open soon… oh boy I’m in trouble. The Bryant park location has seatings and honestly, I don’t know if I can’t eat there… can get too crowded and too loud for me to enjoy the sandwich. Sando: tried a few and my fav is definitely Romeo… turkey, arugula & hot peppers! (Alyssa is a safe option if you don’t like spicy, Alidoro, Gothamist are good options as well). Got 3 sandwiches - $54 + $2 tip. Staff are friendly! (Except for the lady from the kitchen, who gave me a death stare… I was obviously lost… first time, looking for mobile order pick up… she rudely pointed to the front. Like it costs you nothing to be nice.)

+1

The Foodie Baddie

Sooo the sandwich I built myself here was phenomenal! However a couple disappointing things: The price ofc, unavoidable for midtown Manhattan. It is what it is But the size of the bread and filling? Should be a lot more for that price! Fresh ingredients, deep flavors, enjoyable meal at Bryant park :) Honestly would try it again here Oh and if you want to try my sandwich combo: Fresh Mozz Sun Dried Tomatoes Sweet Roasted Peppers Red Onion Arugula Lemon Basil Pesto Balsamic Dressing

+3

Yani Ed

A well-lit and homey sandwich joint with unique Italian cuisine influences. It's a pricier sandwich on account of the significant size and the ingredients. I had come twice to Alidoro and I am glad I got a second try at the place. The first time I came, I waited about 15 to 20 minutes for my cold Alidoro sandwich. On the site, they say you can also order it hot (but you better ask for that yourself because the server might not ask you). I have never found a place that gives me enough prosciutto, and Alidoro did not change that. The sandwich was good though, and the peppers are surprisingly spicy, packing a good kick. Their bread is also very nice, almost as if fresh, with a crisp exterior and soft inside. The second time I only waited about 10 minutes for my hot Fratelli d'Italia. After about twenty minutes, the sandwich was still warm when I opened it to eat. The bread was excellent once again, and I was happy with the amount of porchetta and mozzarella. The cheese was also still pleasantly stretchy. There was an interesting bitterness from the slightly burnt parts of the porchetta and the pesto spread, which was wonderfully contrasting with the other flavors. All in all, it wasn't a very heavy sandwich at all, which was great.

Stuart Smith

This place is very charming. It took a really long time for them to make my sandwich. I timed It at around 20 minutes with very few customers in the store. Food was good, but not incredible. I thought the spicy peppers in the sandwich overpowered everything else.

+5

Ammie Lin

Placed an online order for pickup an hour in advance on a Friday at 11am. Order was due for pickup at 11:45am Upon arrival at 11:50am, there were only 5 customers (more staff than customers) in the restaurant, waiting for their order, and no one standing on line. Yet, my 1x sandwich was not ready so I was asked to wait about 10 more minutes. While waiting, I saw they had sesame seed bread in stock, which was not an option when I placed the order online… a bit frustrating because I realized that I could’ve had the bread of preference and probably would’ve waited the same amount of time if I had just ordered in person… I also noticed that the sandwich size (I ordered Il Sole) was noticeably smaller than when I ordered it one year ago. $19 for a sandwich, I had higher expectations.

Marissa Taylor

Pretty tasty sandwich! Unfortunately the extras I added onto my sandwich didn’t make it on so it was $21 for this.

Robert Sawyer

Value 3. Taste 3.5. Service 4. NYC is a tough place to compete. Anything less than 5 stars these days can be misleading as if this is a scathing review. It’s not. However, when compared to other choices, even within this category, my score is relative. There were at least 8 people working the line between runners, slicers, someone working the cash register and all kind of other roles. The ingredients were good. The bread tasted fresh from the same morning delivery. Again when comparing relatively, my score is based upon my taste, value, and service. The place was busy so it definitely appears to have a following. Certainly not recommending against it. Also, with compressed time for lunch, it’s an important factor. They can fulfill (and appeared to efficient at it) very quickly, carry outs, deliveries, and walk-ins.

I love Alidoro, truly, it is my guilty pleasure when I am passingby it. But the pickle is really the most ridiculously small one I've seen. For almost a dollars, I'm actually disappointed. I've also got a cold Fratelli, which is supposed to be warm. What is happening here?

Jon Botelho

The sandwiches looked really good online, but the sandwich I got (La Primavera) tasted so bitter I couldn’t eat it. Also, when ordering online, the pickup time was 80min out. That’s unacceptable for a sandwich shop in midtown, where lunch time is all about getting something quick.

Matthew C

My mortadella, ham, parm cold sandwich was good. The cost was $25. Ok a bit much but fine I expected it. Halfway through my sandwich I realized something was missing. It could use just a little mustard. When I asked for a little bit of mustard (bc of course they were not generous with the spread or toppings) I was told I need to spend an extra 1.50 for mustard. WAKE UP ALIDORO. That’s not how you run a business where people are ordering $25 sandwiches. Have some manners. I will never willfully come back.

Mitchell Wilcox

Hot cheesesteak sandwich. Waited 10 min smells great. My only ask was no mushrooms and swap it for hot peppers since I’m allergic. Walk all the way back to work open up and put right in the trash. $20 wasted. The cashier was super friend and nice and read it back to me confirming no mushrooms but here we are.