Alexandra Ferreira

We went to Gramercy Bagels at around 9:30 on a Wednesday and it wasn’t too busy. We ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on an egg everything bagel and it was delicious, though it was overpriced. I wish the cheese was melted but otherwise it was very good.

Alexa Kafka

Really friendly service and really tasty bagels with a ton of options! Definitely on the pricier side, with a bagel with cream cheese priced at over 6 dollars! Crazy, but still tasty and fun vibes!

Brieana Fortner

Love that they have so many vegan cream cheese options including tofu varieties as well as the new Stockeld Cream Cheeses. We went specifically to try the stockeld spread and loved how tangy it was! Highly recommend but do keep in mind the surcharge or cruelty free options like Stockeld and the tofu cream cheeses.

Jea Kim

Simple and basic, but great bagel sandwiches for breakfast. I usually get the sausage, egg, and avocado combo which always works beautifully. I really like their sausage patties which are not too salty but perfect for the sandwich. Although the bagels aren’t the best in the city, they are always consistent and get the job done well.

CS Mo

Lovely little bagel shop - the bagels are very good, the coffee was acceptable one day, excellent another day - would have liked a bit more consistency! The eggs were just okay. The service could be better. I asked for a plain bagel, not toasted, they tried to toast it anyway. I asked for rye bread, they gave me white... Some items seem to be overly expensive, but overall pricing seems to be reasonable for the area. My daughter and I went by there several times while we were visiting Manhattan. After the first time, every morning she would say, "Can we get bagels now?" Ultimately we had an egg bagel, a pumpernickel bagel, a plain bagel, a cinnamon raisin bagel and a blueberry bagel. All of them were excellent, not the best ever, but more than good enough!

+2

M G

I had an everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. There was less “everything” than I’m used to from other places and the bagel was ok. Staff was friendly and kept my bagel on the side for me while I went to the restroom. Restroom walls and floor were dirty but the rest of it was ok. I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back.

Alba

had a bec with a hash brown; the bagel was flavorless and kind of dry and dense, the toppings were passable. go somewhere better if you can help it

Katherine Swenson

This place sucks. I got an “everything” bagel and it had literally no seasoning? Like 4 sesame seeds. Bagel was also a little too dense. Cream cheese was decent at least, but spread was not generous (see photo). Also it was $5.75 for a cream cheese bagel? Absurd. Will not be returning despite living in the neighborhood

Pamela Xs

Wow such a bad experience with a staff member. I ordered, paid with a credit card and signed, received my coffee. The employee turned his back to do something so I assumed a bagel wrapped up was mine. I took it and left, then came back when I realized the mix up. He was very rude in front of a lot of other people saying loudly why did I pick it up it wasn't mine. Um it was a mix up that could have happened to anyone given he rang me up, handed me my coffee. Why would I not assume it was mine, I was the only person who ordered and a group came in while I was waiting. Then he disgustingly made a scene and slammed it in the trash, I guess because he has no idea how to deal with customer issues. I then loudly told him he should have just called it a mistake with no attitude. He wanted to make a scene and embarrass me in front of other people. Otherwise the food is pretty good, just prepare for rude behavior if there is an issue.

Matthew Weitzman

I visited Gramercy Bagel this morning with my trained service animal and had an incredibly disappointing experience. As soon as I walked in, I was immediately asked to leave due to their no-pet policy. I explained that my dog is a trained service animal, complete with tags, but the staff member didn’t believe me. He even came around the counter to inspect my dog, making us both feel very uncomfortable. When I was about to leave, the same employee asked me, rather rudely, what I wanted, while another staff member stood just a few feet away, staring at us. I asked if I could help him with something further, and he just turned and walked away. The final straw? Three bagels with cream cheese and two Tropicana orange juices cost $36—definitely not worth it. Between the unprofessional and rude service and the overpriced food, I’ll never return to this place. I highly recommend that Gramercy Bagel invests in better training for their staff to handle situations involving service animals with respect and understanding. Shameful experience.