Madison St Pizza

Cynthia Ayala

The place is very clean at a lowkey spot but definitely worth grabbing a slice or two or five. The owner is very sweet. I visited the spot when it first opened and he threw in a free garlic bread which is now one of my fav thing on the menu. Don’t miss out on the buffalo chicken slice either. Really good I now visit there for my lunch breaks every now and then.

P R

Best pizza in the area from crust to toppins quality and portion. Owner was so polite and kind made us feel like home. He went beyond in service this a must to stop any time your in the area 🙏🏽🍕🤤

satish chand

Delicious pizza and excellent customer service! My daughter thoroughly enjoyed her cheese pizza, and the price was very reasonable, too. The owner went above and beyond to provide an excellent customer experience!

Monique Gonzalez

Delicious pizza, Garlic knots and much more made New York style. Good food and a humble owner with great attitude.

Victoria Fairchild

Easy way to get a quick slice, friendly service and DELICIOUS pizza. Love it! Great crust!

The place is small but the pizza is amazing for the price! The Mexican guy who works there is amazingly friendly and offers good service! I love this place. I'll be back!

Delicious pizza and excellent customer service. Definitely try if you're in the area. It was one of the best pizza slices in NY and cheap. $5 for 2 cheese slices was a steal.

Listen.. this is probably the best pizza below 14

Pizza is amazing and they got mikes hot honey! Definitely would recommend the vodka square and the pepperoni is amazing all halal definitely my new pizza spot

Great halal option pizzeria. Staff is very friendly and works efficiently. I recommend anyone who is looking for a halal bite to def check this place out. 10/10 for customer service and food. Will definitely be returning.

We found this pizzeria by chance, looking for another service, and we were impressed with the quality of the service and the pizza! We highly recommend it. The pizza is tasty, with a thin, crispy crust. The tomato sauce and cheese are also very tasty. For someone who wasn't giving anything for the pizza, it was a 100/10! We STRONGLY recommend it! ❤️

WOW!!! A friend recommended this place to me so I decided to try and was blown away by the experience. The pizza was absolutely delicious - perfectly crispy crust just the right amount of cheese and they did not skim on the toppings. Each bite was a burst of flavor, and you can tell they use fresh, high-quality ingredients. The staff were friendly and went above and beyond. If you're looking for the best pizza in town, look no further than Madison Street pizza and grill. I can't wait to come back and try more of their menu!

Action Jackson

Listen.. this is probably the best pizza below 14

Alexander Sig

The place is small but the pizza is amazing for the price! The Mexican guy who works there is amazingly friendly and offers good service! I love this place. I'll be back!

Moses Motive Action

Pizza is amazing and they got mikes hot honey! Definitely would recommend the vodka square and the pepperoni is amazing all halal definitely my new pizza spot

Nazish Shahid

WOW!!! A friend recommended this place to me so I decided to try and was blown away by the experience. The pizza was absolutely delicious - perfectly crispy crust just the right amount of cheese and they did not skim on the toppings. Each bite was a burst of flavor, and you can tell they use fresh, high-quality ingredients. The staff were friendly and went above and beyond. If you're looking for the best pizza in town, look no further than Madison Street pizza and grill. I can't wait to come back and try more of their menu!

Narrae Nelson

Delicious pizza and excellent customer service. Definitely try if you're in the area. It was one of the best pizza slices in NY and cheap. $5 for 2 cheese slices was a steal.

K. A.S

Great halal option pizzeria. Staff is very friendly and works efficiently. I recommend anyone who is looking for a halal bite to def check this place out. 10/10 for customer service and food. Will definitely be returning.

Karen Furlan

We found this pizzeria by chance, looking for another service, and we were impressed with the quality of the service and the pizza! We highly recommend it. The pizza is tasty, with a thin, crispy crust. The tomato sauce and cheese are also very tasty. For someone who wasn't giving anything for the pizza, it was a 100/10! We STRONGLY recommend it! ❤️

Delicious fresh pizza, so worth going back to. Restaurant has four small tables and six chairs. Some people don't care and will just hold a chair because they feel like. Either their bag is holding a sit or there is a person not eating and just on their phone. This is not a place were you want to chill because it is so small. But some people just don't get it. Eat and go or just take it to go! Best thing to do is take your order to go, there is a park and benches across the street just go there. In ths store some people just don't know how to move. There is very little space but too many individuals act like you can walk through them. Some people act like the Statue of liberty, so very annoying. The pizza is to tasty not to come back. I shall be returning and I 100% recommend this Mini-pizza joint!

With a new Name changing from New Madison to Mranellos. This place offers a very friendly service and has a grrat pizza

Marlene Anderson

Delicious fresh pizza, so worth going back to. Restaurant has four small tables and six chairs. Some people don't care and will just hold a chair because they feel like. Either their bag is holding a sit or there is a person not eating and just on their phone. This is not a place were you want to chill because it is so small. But some people just don't get it. Eat and go or just take it to go! Best thing to do is take your order to go, there is a park and benches across the street just go there. In ths store some people just don't know how to move. There is very little space but too many individuals act like you can walk through them. Some people act like the Statue of liberty, so very annoying. The pizza is to tasty not to come back. I shall be returning and I 100% recommend this Mini-pizza joint!

Rodolphe Ghossoub

With a new Name changing from New Madison to Mranellos. This place offers a very friendly service and has a grrat pizza

Ordered a pepperoni pizza on grubhub and had high expectations due to the high ratings on google. So unfortunate, that it lacked flavor and was not crispy like others have rated. I've added garlic powder, onion powder, parmesan cheese before trying and it somehow still lacked flavor. They are really generous on the toppings which was nice though. I really wished it was as good as everyone rated it.

Eng Rita

Ordered a pepperoni pizza on grubhub and had high expectations due to the high ratings on google. So unfortunate, that it lacked flavor and was not crispy like others have rated. I've added garlic powder, onion powder, parmesan cheese before trying and it somehow still lacked flavor. They are really generous on the toppings which was nice though. I really wished it was as good as everyone rated it.

I ordered two slices of pepperoni for lunch yesterday for $3 a slice. Just observing the worker, there might be some health code violations in play. He would grab a slice of pizza from the counter using the spatula and his bare hands. Then I would see him take cash from the customers with the same bare hands, without washing or sanitizing. This cycle then repeats. On top of that, my pizza was completely burnt on the bottom--both slices. I usually don't give out 1 stars, but this place is a hard pass.

Amanda

I ordered two slices of pepperoni for lunch yesterday for $3 a slice. Just observing the worker, there might be some health code violations in play. He would grab a slice of pizza from the counter using the spatula and his bare hands. Then I would see him take cash from the customers with the same bare hands, without washing or sanitizing. This cycle then repeats. On top of that, my pizza was completely burnt on the bottom--both slices. I usually don't give out 1 stars, but this place is a hard pass.

I'm a pizza guy, I know good pizza when I taste it. This pizza just isn't it. Whoever is making it, doesn't put enough sauce or cheese. It's like eating a pizza box with a little bit of sauce and a little bit of cheese on it. They really need to find that perfect balance of enough sauce and cheese. The two pies, that we spent $38 for, WAS HORRIBLE! It probably cost between $4 and $5, to make a large pie at a good pizza shop. I feel this place makes it for like $2. To increase their profits. You are hurting your business because your pizza tastes like baked cardboard and cheese. I will never ever order from here again.

Katie H

Rude staff and owners who blare music in the mornings and evenings despite being located below residential apts. Huge disturbance to the surrounding buildings /families within and they could not care less. Doesn't help that the Pizza is gross too. Lots of great family owned joints in the area who care about the community- give your money to a business that deserves it.

Jeff Colburn

I'm a pizza guy, I know good pizza when I taste it. This pizza just isn't it. Whoever is making it, doesn't put enough sauce or cheese. It's like eating a pizza box with a little bit of sauce and a little bit of cheese on it. They really need to find that perfect balance of enough sauce and cheese. The two pies, that we spent $38 for, WAS HORRIBLE! It probably cost between $4 and $5, to make a large pie at a good pizza shop. I feel this place makes it for like $2. To increase their profits. You are hurting your business because your pizza tastes like baked cardboard and cheese. I will never ever order from here again.