Place was exactly what we were hoping for! Gio our waiter was so nice and welcoming and food was 10/10!

What a wonderful surprise to find this gem inside our cool boutique hotel! The atmosphere and the food were both excellent! We had both lunch and breakfast because the quality was so great! Our server Juan went above and beyond for my daughter who is in a wheelchair. Highly recommend!

The food is phenomenal! We tried the lunch special with the tortilla espanolas, ceviche tropical, sweet & sour chicken, and meatballs. All the flavors were delicious, and the portion size was shareable with my husband and I; we were both full too. Gio was our server, he was attentive and friendly and made our experience better. I'd recommend this spot to anyone, prices are fair for the quality of the food and ambiance. Note: there is indoor and outdoor seating, outdoor seating is covered and heated! Very pretty for pictures

We needed a breakfast place close before our packed day and this was perfect. It was in a hotel, but practically priced. We didn't catch the name of the server, but we were led to a back area (on a cold day but heated) that was cool and had a great vibe. Really cool area. Counter service for ordering, but the rest of the visit was served surprisingly to us. They might have served booze at the hour we were there (and probably did given their name), but we didn't ask, and just had coffee and Naked juice as we had a full day. Wife had the burrata toast and loved it. I had the salmon truffle toast and liked it, but I forgot to order the addition of the egg. I probably would have LOVED it. Actually, I probably still was on the border of love without the egg. Still a 5. My bad, and you should try THAT. Great, central place before you hit some Midtown sites, and you have a great experience, but are in and out in about 30 minutes or so (unless you booze of course). Definitely recommend and see you there (next time we are in NYC).

We had a corporate dinner here and what a hidden gem! In a city that can sometimes feel a bit too fast-paced, we found this wonderful spot — great atmosphere, perfect music volume that allowed us to talk, and absolutely delicious food. We ordered many many tapas with great options for everyones tastes, and everything was just spectacular. A huge thank you to Laura and Jordan, who made us feel completely at home. We were a group of over 15 people, and not for a single moment did we feel unattended — they truly have a gift for what they do. Their passion and care made the experience unforgettable. Thank you for such an amazing time!

10/10 would recommend! The food was incredible fresh and delicious. Luckily our waitress Laura spoke Spanish which along with her kind and funny attitude, made the service and whole experience unforgettable. Gracias Laura!! Will definitely return next time I’m back in NYC

Great tapas spot with really good food and an even better atmosphere. Everything we tried was delicious, but my favorite dish was definitely the chicken, full of flavor and perfectly cooked. OMG, so delicious!!!!! The service was excellent and truly made the experience stand out. Dario was incredibly patient and kind, especially when he took the time to take our pictures. Daniel was also fantastic providing recommendations on the favorites, which did not disappoint. Overall, GREAT food, GREAT service. I will be back again!!!!!

Antonio Torres

I recently ordered pizzas from My Pie Pizzeria Romana and I was pleasantly surprised. First of all they told me they had sugar free pizzas. I was skeptical about this being true but it was in fact very true. The pizza box has a brief story about how the process the doug and how the ingredients are sugar free. We ordered several slices to try them all. We had buffalo chicken, prosciutto, regular and Margarita. Let me tell you ALL of them were excellent !! Great crust not too filling so you can try more. My favorite was definitely Margarita. I usually don't eat more than two slices but this time I need to try at least three. The buffalo chicken was also gone in minutes. It was an excellent meal. I definitely will be ordering from there again. Yaren who took our order was very specific with the menu and everything came on time. I highly recommend it and we'll be ordering from Pizza Romana again.

Amine Djaba

I had a wonderful experience at My Pie Pizzeria Romana. The atmosphere is amazing, complemented by enchanting music that sets the perfect mood. The service was incredibly fast, delivered with a beautiful smile. I tried the Marguerite and Mushroom pizzas—they were perfectly crispy and delicious, offering a unique, traditional taste. A truly remarkable experience!

Tatiana Mikhaylova

We chose to visit this place because of the excellent reviews—and we definitely did not regret it. From the very first bite, both the taste and the friendliness of the staff were well above our expectations. I tried the mushroom pizza, and it instantly became my favorite. My son ordered the buffalo cheese pizza, and it was amazingly juicy, loaded with toppings, and full of flavor. The dough deserves a special mention—it’s outstanding and completely different from what you get at most regular pizza places in New York. You can really feel the quality and care in every slice. We would absolutely recommend everyone to visit this place. However, there is a very limited dining area, be mindful about that.

McKenzie

I thought the pizza was excellent! It’s not the typical NYC pizza but it was still very good. We each got two slices and they were huge so just know ahead how hungry you are. The Buffalo pizza was my favorite. The shredded check-in was moist with a delicious garlicky spicy sauce. The staff were also nice. It was clean. The crust in the pizza was also very good it was crunch and airy.

Ally Jones

This place has phenomenal vegan slices!! This is my 2nd time here and I will be a returning customer. Both times I’ve come in for one slice but ended up having two. The vegetables are really fresh, the tomato sauce is super flavorful and the crust is crispy and perfect. The staff are really nice too. I highly recommend!!

Lachlan Keller

Adored the vegan truffle oil pizza! Soooo goood. Cool vibe as well - love the wooden tables and chairs

Kevin K

Yummy pizza. Had the pesto and lasagna. Both were good. Will do a repeat when we are back in town.

Egor Grishechko

A great place located just next door to the Hotel 57. Great pizza, friendly personnel.

Honest Reviews

The pizza was amazing, very thin, crispy, and perfect amount of tomato sauce. Will want to come back to try out the other pizza options that they have. Each slice can be pretty pricey for the size

Mark DeVito

Went in around 5:25 PM on a Saturday—no wait, quick service. The slices are big and filling, about $7 each. I had the buffalo chicken, and my wife got the truffle mushroom—both were excellent. Crispy, airy crust with plenty of toppings, exactly what you want from Roman-style pizza. Chill vibe, friendly staff. Definitely worth stopping in if you’re nearby.

Ryanne Mireles

As tourist, this was the only place we came to twice! this was the best pizza place! so comfortable and the choices were amazing. Hayba (i apologize for the misspelling) was such a sweet lady. we would love one in our hometown.

Lauren Helene

My favorite spot to grab a slice of pizza in NY! I love the crispiness of the crust, the variety of flavors, and how generous they are with every topping. Plus, the staff here are super friendly and go out of their way to provide a good experience! I only get to come every 3-6 months because I live out of state but they somehow remember me every time, which is always a nice feeling. The last time I was here, I came a little after the dinner rush and was disappointed that they had run out of my favorite flavor - and they offered to make me a pie fresh! The inside only has 5 small tables so it can get a little crowded during a rush but they have great to go boxes so you can enjoy your slices on the go or in one of the many nearby parks.

Lenara

The greatest place! The most delicious pizza in my life! And the girl is very sweet. We will be back soon for sure! ✔️

Chris P

Small pizza shop with a few tables, friendly service, and excellent square cut pizza. The Margarita and Grandma - Nonnina slices are my favorite (the Nonnina is for garlic lovers). A great spot for a quick lunch after shopping at nearby Bloomingdale's. :)

Hannah W

At 3 pm I was just looking for a quick snack so I ordered one slice of Truffle Oil and Mushroom - OMG it tasted HEAVENLY!!! When my husband joined me (he'd had lunch elsewhere) I would not share a single bite with him :-). Most of their pizzas are vegetarian, which really suit me. It's a very small place, just a few two person tables, but super cozy. The server was very friendly, and explained to me that the slice of my choice was indeed vegetarian, that it only contained mushrooms, truffle oil and cheese. If I happen to be in that part of town again, this would be my first choice for a quick bite and I am eager to try out other varieties.

Noneya

I have heard about the flour used in Italy and had to try this place. Delicioso! We had arugula Parmesan, chicken alfredo, and mozzarella cheese. SO yummy! Eating area is quaint and very small, so groups of more than four may want to order to go.

I ordered the grandma pizza, tri-colored pizza, and the buffalo chicken pizza. The grandma pizza was hands down my favorite! My least favorite had to be the buffalo chicken because the chicken was dr…

I ordered the grandma pizza, tri-colored pizza, and the buffalo chicken pizza. The grandma pizza was hands down my favorite! My least favorite had to be the buffalo chicken because the …

I ordered the grandma pizza, tri-colored pizza, and the buffalo chicken pizza. The grandma pizza was hands down my favorite! My least favorite had to be the buffalo chicken because the chic…

My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman style pizza I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several ti…

My pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman style pizza I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here severa…

My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman style pizza I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several …

My pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman style pizza I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several …

6 I give it a 6 the slice was outstanding and the young lady behind the counter is wonderful Highly recommend

Just a great pizza place. The vibes are cool, it's clean, you eat well and staff is nice.

Just a great pizza place. The vibes are cool, it's clean, you eat well and staff is nice.

Vegan truffle oil & mushroom so good and very affordable! staff is extremely friendly!

pie was excellent. Surprisingly, they also had some great desserts. Location was very convenient to hotel. Placed was packed

Fast service and a good meal for under $7. Location is clean but highly trafficked and ideal for takeout although there are about ten seats for dining in.

Fast service and a good meal for under $7. Location is clean but highly trafficked and ideal for takeout although there are about ten seats for dining in.

Went there for a quick bite. The place is so cute, has this very Italian good music playing makes u feel u in Italy. The pizza was amazing we tried grandma and mushroom very fresh I would highly re…

Incredible food and service, came in for lunch and had an amazing experience. Great ambiance, woul absolutey reccomend!!

Amazing Food made with perfection love the Italian music playing first time coming but it won't be the last

Finally, real Roman pizza al taglio in Manhattan! The crust is properly crispy, and the toppings are excellent. Service is genuinely warm, and prices are completely reasonable, especially given the…

We loved the pizza, the crust was perfect t , Lots of different options. Service was fast and everyone g was very clean. Highly recommend!

Gave this place a shot and very glad I did. Fresh ingredients, crispy, and swift service. price for two slices and a soda was less than $10 which is unheard of in Manhattan. Can't wait to try more.

My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman-style pizza, I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several t…

My pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman-style pizza, I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here sever…

My Pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman-style pizza, I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several…

My pie Pizzeria Romana is a hidden gem and offers the best square slices. Marketing themselves as Roman-style pizza, I would say the squares are more like Sicilian slices. We have been here several…

Fabulous pizza, excellent choices, great service. Very small inside so we felt lucky to get a seat to eat there. We loved the crust- a crispy finish but still foldable. Everything looked and taste…

Fabulous pizza, excellent choices, great service. Very small inside so we felt lucky to get a seat to eat there. We loved the crust- a crispy finish but still foldable. Everything looked and tas…

Fabulous pizza, excellent choices, great service. Very small inside so we felt lucky to get a seat to eat there. We loved the crust- a crispy finish but still foldable. Everything looked and tas…

This pizza place was conveniently round the corner from our hotel and had two vegan choices, and used separate utensils for their vegan pizza, so it was immediately a big hit with my daughter. The st…

This pizza place was conveniently round the corner from our hotel and had two vegan choices, and used separate utensils for their vegan pizza, so it was immediately a big hit with my daughter. Th…

These have a delicious crispy crust and a tasty sauce. Unlike most cheesless pizzas these do not skimp on sauce and veggies.

Gorgeous pizza perfect base and tomatoe sauce very tasty. Also desserts delicious try the chocolate mouse and tiramisu.. staff very friendly and helpful

Gorgeous pizza perfect base and tomatoe sauce very tasty. Also desserts delicious try the chocolate mouse and tiramisu.. staff very friendly and helpful

Great pizza and good size portion. service was great and enjoyed eating on site although the seating area is small. Each pizza is two slices so be aware of how much you are ordering!

We walked from Central Park in 15 mins. The place super clean, tidy, and had really cool little stools. The guy at the counter was super pleasant, and he took time to explain what was on offer. …

My pie has excellent pizzas!! we ordered three different kinds but my favorite was the Carmelized Onion pie with added gorgonzola. The pies have excellent crust (which as we all know counts for…

Excellent place, a cozy and relax vibe even though being near the busy areas of the city. menu and food was awesome, wings and sliders are great, however it will be good if they add more options. The service was great with a lot of attention and support from Dario. Definitely deserve another visit next we travel NY City.

I visited for dinner and drinks and really enjoyed the atmosphere. The space feels stylish and cozy, with a modern, Instagram-friendly vibe. It’s connected to a hotel, which gives it a slightly hidden feel but also makes it calm compared to louder Midtown spots. Cocktails were creative and well-made, and the tapas are meant for sharing; portions are small but flavorful. Prices are a bit on the higher side for tapas, but the quality and presentation make it a nice spot for a date night or catching up with friends.

Harold PK

Our visit was influenced by a good review and a drive to sample some of NYC’s finest we decided to check it out. Stylized and similar to Detroit square deep dish…this one varied in a thinner crust. Fresh ingredients fused with a very rich crust that’s reminiscent of quality EU breads. We loved it. Price points seem quite reasonable. I recommend check it out.

Linda M

Good value. Interesting flavors. The Buffalo chicken ($7) had a spicy but salty sauce - there was a substantial amount of chicken. The dough is a little chewy. The crust was a crispy. The truffle mushroom pizza had a fair amount of mushroom ($6) but could have used more truffle oil. The warmed up pizza was not hot enough. Annoying. The rectangular pizza was filling enough and a good size for a snack. 2 slices would make it a meal. $14 total with tax. A reasonable price for a meal in midtown Manhattan. April 2025.

+6

I stopped in My pie to grab some lunch. The store is tiny and has limited seating. I ordered two Grandma slices and got them fresh out of the oven. The slices were good, but had too much char and t…

Ani Avetisyan

Cute little spot with budget-friendly prices, but the pizza didn’t quite hit the mark.

Shreya R

I’m not the biggest fan of a thick crust, but these pizza crusts were thankfully the exact consistency of focaccia and had a beautifully webbed crusting (as if excess cheese had cooked on the edges). Otherwise, these were okay pizza slices. I loved the rectangular shape of the slices, though.

Stopped here for a quick bite while in the city. There is limited seating and it got quite busy at around 5pm in a weekday. The pizza itself was quite bland. I had a slice of pepperoni and a slic…

A good selection of pizzas sold by the slice or as a whole pie. It is not a pie but squares. We had the mozzarella which was quite good but rather smaller

Bonsaii is an overt attempt at capturing a specific demographic, seeking the instagram photo-op and little else. With a back wall stereotypically covered in fabricated ivy and pink neon sign that reads as some AI generated inspirational quote, Bonsaii is as non-discreet in its attempts as the IG counter prominently displayed on its bar shelf. For a wine bar the selections were modest and average, as too were the tapas. While extensive, they were mediocre at best. Instead of trying to attract crowds, they should focus on an identity. This place is lacking character and trying to make up for it with appearances.

Big slices, zero quality. This pizza was disgusting, Don't waste your time or your money. There are way better spots literally anywhere else. 0.9/10.

Big slices, zero quality. This pizza was disgusting, Don't waste your time or your money. There are way better spots literally anywhere else. 0.9/10.