Mels Pizza, Pasta, & More

The pizza and Greek salad delish!

This place is truly a hidden gem! I got lost one day when I stumbled across Sinapi’s. Wow am I glad I did! I ordered 40 wings and a small pie The verdict?….. ABSOLUTELY, UNBELIEVABLY, UNEQUIVOCALLY mouth watering delicious!!! Their pizza is the perfect pizza; just the right size crust, slightly crispy, real mozzarella, and a hearty sauce. Now the wings…let me tell you, I am a strict critic especially when it comes to wings, but SINAPI’s WINGS ARE POPPIN!!! I don’t know about you but I can’t stand wings that are rubbery because they’re not cooked all the way on the inside. These days it seems to be the typical standard for all places that serve wings, except Sinapi’s. In this picture I was served crispy wings cooked all the way to the center with I’m not kidding you, the most delicious sauces fully ingrained or infused into each wing’s crispy skin. Hands down- I vote best wings in Westchester, Putnam, Rockland, hell NY! As you can tell from everything I have written so far, I fell in love with Sinapi’s that day and even though I live about an hour away, I still drive there at least twice a month because in my eyes nobody really comes close to competing with them. I give them 5 Stars all around. Super friendly staff, the best food, and affordable too. I implore you to go see for yourself. You’ll be glad you did.

Awesome food, great personalities and the only place in town that have, beef patties with cheese and pepperoni....!

Been searching for a great pizza for so long and I finally found it in Sinapis. Only pizza I will eat around here at this point.

They just make great food. They make better BBQ than the BBQ place next door.

First time ordering here from Pennsylvania great food will definitely be back the next time I'm up here

It so good and not greasy pizza

Had another wonderful meal with the Sinapi family. Good atmosphere, great food, great people!

Stopped here with the family and friends after the water park, everything was delicious and great service. Will be coming back, thanks!

Great pizza and food! Staff is very friendly.

Love their meatball parm garlic bites. They are so good.

Very good pizza nice people the pepperoni garlic rolls are excellent

Love this place! The owners are super friendly and the food is excellent! Highly recommend!

Good food, good people, great place.

The mild Buffalo wings were the best I've ever had

Great food Amazing service Excellent prices Consistently every visit

Great food, good variety. Friendly service.

I was excited to see this place open up close to home. I was even more excited to see a really clean bathroom. Kitchen & bathrooms go hand in hand in the food industry!! I had the sausage & broccoli rabe pizza. If you like Italian, you know rabe. I’m really critical about pizza & rabe. I was really impressed. Rabe had substance & wasn’t mushy. Also dark green, & full of garlicky goodness w/ a little crushed red pepper. Luigi Sinapi asked if I would like crushed red pepper. The dough was slammin. Not floppy, no folds needed. #perfect!! Only thing, I should’ve ordered a large one. Also ordered fettuccine w/ sausage & rabe to take home. It was amazing take out too. #aldente Thanks for being close to home. Owner operated. That’s like a guarantee of happiness

We love the pizza. Right now it's tome to support lo al businesses and this is one you'll love toh support. It's a family business and they are wonderful people. The food is always fresh and really good.

Even after a year and with a new owner this pizzeria has been doing amazing, the food the service, everything! It’s impeccable. I’ll be looking forward to coming here more often.

This is some of the best pizza I have had in the area in awhile. You can taste the quality of products used. I look forward to trying more of the menu.

Placed catering order: easy to work with, accommodating & fair. 50+ guests all said the food was amazing. Thank you to the team at Sinapis Wappingers ! -

I thought I could find a good pizza place north of Leo’s. Well Mel’s is great. The sauce they make reminds me places I’ve been in Italy. Love this place!

Used to work for a place that had me driving around everywhere and I would always stop here before heading back home and pick up a few slices and let me tell you that this place has consistently great pizza that would even make Dave Portnoy smile at the sun on a breezy day

We accidentally called in a pizza for pickup, and it was supposed to be delivery. They went above and beyond to delivered us a hot fresh pizza. Thank you!

We have ordered 2x now and the food is delicious!!!! It’s delivered hot and on time. The staff is super friendly and appreciates you ordering from their establishment!!!! I would definitely recommend to anyone!!

I have ordered food from Mel's 4 or 5 times now and the tast and portions of the food has always been great

We have never had a bad meal here. The pizza is the best but their pasta dishes are outstanding!! Best alfredo sauce EVER!!!

My family and I love Sinapis! The pizza, the chicken parm sub, the meatballs...all amazing! Their salads are delicious too!

Went there for the 1st time tonight. Owner was very friendly. I order the couple things and he gave me suggestions. The food was great.. He even threw in a couple slices.. Will be returning.

Great food and service, highly recommend. They also have gluten free pizza (some other items also) As some in are party have celiac. I tried the gluten free pizza is was good

Absolutely favorite Pizzeria in the area if you haven't tried it yet you must it won't disappoint. From pizza to rolls and dinner dishes everything is top notch

This place is great! Their pizza is amazing 🍕. They also have much more on the menu to satisfy every member of the family.

Mel and the entire staff are great! Delicious food, friendly service, and fair prices. My family and friends are, and will be customers for a long time 🙏.

Awesomeness….. I only wish they were closer to my home in Hyde Park, but this is definitely worth the drive…

Stopped in on the way to overlook drive in. First Time Ordered a special Italian sub with roasted pepper, was amazing and they put it together quick. Will go back for sure!!!

I live down south now but I still fantasize about this Pizzeria. And I go when I visit Poughkeepsie. Definitely worth the visit from any place the pizza is very very good.

I ordered a sandwich and asked them to change and add some things (which they did without any issues) and it was FANTASTIC! Definitely will be ordering again

Sinapi's makes delicious pizza with high quality ingredients. I highly recommend this family friendly Italian restaurant.

Great pizza and food. Nice Staff and they deliver.

It's the pizza I grew up with and I still love it! Service is always prompt and friendly

Everything here is always delicious. From their pizza to their desserts. The cheesecake is otherworldly.

Best pizza in town, owner suggested us good yummy pizzas and was prepared and served hot. Was very tasty I enjoyed every bite. I loved the pasta which he suggested. A complete delicious package at one place 😋😋

Hands down the best in every aspect. All the food is exceptional and the service is great. There is something for everyone on their menu so you never have to worry even if you have a dietary restriction. We have ordered from them multiple times and we are never disappointed!

This is hands down the best pizza place in the area it’s definitely our number one go to. Everything is delicious - from their pizza to their sandwiches to their salads. Try their salad pizza - you won’t regret it!

Very nice service. We did a pick up order and were a little late after a wrong turn but they were still nice about it. We brought home a good pizza and now a specialty I saw in the window has been on my mind...

I am from the Bronx, and moved up here many years ago. I could never find a good pizza place till I ate at Sinapi’s. Their pizza is absolutely delicious, crispy and the sauce and toppings are incredibly amazing. I highly recommend them. You will not be disappointed. Oh,and I forgot to mention, it is family owned and they are so very nice and accommodating. I feel like they are family.

We get our holiday catering from them. The food is great. Always friendly to us. Ordering off the menu for dinner is always good as well. We love the pizza here. It's worth the stop to try it out..

Finally! Found good pizza in the area! Moved from Orange County and could not believe how different and bad the pizza was. This pizza is amazing and the dough is the way it should be, soft chewy and bubbly, unlike all the other places that have this strange flat bland dough. And the sauce is delicious! Can’t wait to try more from here :)

Whenever I'm in Poughkeepsie I make a point to eat here. The pizza is bar none the best I've had outside of the city. Their reheated pizza tastes fresh! And the staff is great

Fantastic pizza! The buffalo chicken is our favorite. Edit: I was initially hooked on this place because it was the only one around with a more traditional/thicker pizza crust. My last few pizzas here have been super thin, which is disappointing for me. However, I won't lower my rating since that is just my preference. Edit 2: I will try asking for thicker crust on my next order! 😁

Literally EVERYTHING we get from Sinapi's is 10 out of 10! Pizza, hero's, wraps, pasta and fries... everything is so good!!! It's hard to find a place that is constantly on point! Unfortunately we are moving down south in a few days. We are going to DEEPLY miss this place! We have ordered every dinner here for the past week because we are packing and I'm not getting bored!!! When we come back to NY to visit, Sinapi's is going to be the first thing I'm ordering!! Complements to the chef 😂👌🏼

Food is amazing, got a cheeseburger last night and it was 10/10 definitely recommend trying Mel’s pizza out. Pizza is also great aswell as the wings best wings in the duchess county.

Interesting location but have this place a try after a Slice recommendation. Easily my favorite new pizza place in the Hudson Valley. This is what NY Style pizza is about. Delicious, great staff, and was ready in a fair amount of time. Highly recommend

Just finished eating and need to write a review. Just ordered a Hawaiian pie (judge all you like), a chicken marsala pie, hot wings and a children's chicken tender platter. Delivery: order was received faster than what time frame I was given. The driver was very friendly and was very professional as she made sure that she was social distancing herself. The food was nice and hot upon delivery. Pizza: they have a nice crust and a tasty sauce. The crust is not super thin but not overly thick. Toppings we're generous and covered the entire pie. Hot wings: these are by far the best wings I've had in a long time. They weren't shriveled up wondering what I'm putting in my mouth chicken wings. These were fresh and meaty. They also didn't just throw on Frank's red hot like other establishments do. At first glance I didn't think they even put a sauce on but then I tasted it and it was delicious. Children's chicken tender platter: a generous portion for an adult, but a magnificent feast for a child. These chicken tenders are the real deal with a nice breading. This was my first experience and ordering online was very easy to do. I did call prior to make sure that they did deliver to my area. The young lady who answered the phone was very nice. We definitely will be ordering from them again.

The pizza was delicious, atmosphere was very pleasant, and you feel like family when dining-in. The steak sandwich was indescribably delicious, as was the chicken parmigiana. If I could eat there every day I would. Also, cleanest rest room I have ever seen in a public establishment. Will definitely eat there all the time!!

Love going to Mel's Pizza. The food is delicious. Whether I am grabbing a slice of pizza or getting a meatball parm sandwich. Make sure you try the garlic knots. Everything is always freshly made. Check out the daily specials.

A perfect lunch stop! We were greeted when we walked in and there were a variety of options ready to go. The pizza and garlic knots were delicious! The staff was professional, diligent, and friendly.

Fantastic customer service and food🍕. The owner and employees go out of their way to customize food orders, make recommendations and ensure you are satisfied. Every meal we've gotten from Sinapi's has been solid and I'm happy to report that when it comes to what matters, 'they've got the sauce'👌😁. Also cool that they're very progressive with tech. Open 5G wifi in the pizza shop, and at the time of this review, they accept apple pay, and are available on GrubHub, the Slice app and deliveries can accept credit cards using Square.

If you're not ordering from Sinapi's, you're doing it wrong. We have been ordering from them since they opened, as personal family meals, parties and large events, and lunch 2 or 3 times a week at my workplace. Most recently they catered a family member's bday for us. Not a single person at the party wasn't ranting and raving about how good the food was and asking where we got it from so they could get their food there in the future as well! The food was hot, well packaged, beautifully presented, and of course, delicious! The chicken parm was cheesy and tender, the penne vodka was full of flavor and just the right texture. Sausage and peppers just exploding with flavor, and one of my personal favorites, their home-made ranch dressing makes any salad taste amazing! We also ordered a few dozen zeppolis that the kids (and adults alike) devoured immediately after they were put out! Louie, Pete, and their team are super friendly and make sure that you have everything that you need as they help you carry your food to your car. They are clearly passionate about cooking and serving their community and it shows! You feel like family when you're in their restaurant! We can't recommend Sinapi's Pizza enough and if you haven't been yet, grab your keys and get moving! You'll thank me later!

I only stop here now and then but the pizza is very good. Whether a regular slice or Buffalo Chicken, it never disappoints.

A great pizza place located on route 376 in Wappingers falls right outside of the Red oaks Mill intersection. Has a great selection of pizza as well as a couple Buffalo slices I had in the Grandma's Pizza that my father had. I would eat there again if I was crossing passed during the day again.

The owners are a very nice peoples and I will eat there as much as I can. The food is phenomenal from the steak sandwich, to the pizza, to the bacon bruschetta ranch pizza, to the garlic knots. Lets just say all of it is good, and I am hungry for it writing this review. Great work Sinapi family

Great place, the staff is very friendly, and the food is always on point! I recommend the lasagna slice and the bites!

Mel can cook! Great quality of food, you can tell the difference between boring pizza joints. They make a ton of recipes from scratch, and sauces etc… Also, the Wings and Gyros are amazing 5/5

I ordered the grilled chicken caprese focaccia. I loved this sandwich... and I ordered the zeppolis.. also very good. I will definitely be ordering from here again. It was also delivered on time.

We trust sinapis for every one of our family parties, most recently for my dad's 70th birthday. Every time we hear "wow, where did you get the food "? I would claim it as my own if I thought anyone would believe I could make food that amazing. Seriously. Even the salad is great. You won't be disappointed, out of the park every time and they are a pleasure to work with all around. 5+ star's all the way!

I have always ordered from them.before the name change but today made me realize why I come back... I had to order a 2 ft sub last min for my daughter's bday normally they require more notice. But with phone calls back and forth they r filling my order .. if you only knew how much these means after the last few months ... hands down Mel's ty for the young man I spoke to today ..Clone him

BEST PIZZA IN DUTCHESS COUNTY! The pies are fresh, good quality. My sister has a gluten allergy and it’s the only place she’ll order GF pizza from. YOU GUYS ROCK

Great pizza in Poughkeepsie. I had the cheese pizza small personal size. Menu says it serves two people but it couldn’t. But too big for one. Very cheesy and saucy and crispy crust. Also had mozzarella sticks which were good but inexplicably served over lettuce. You can dine in or take out. There were a few tables and a tv showing weather forecast for Arizona. We got our food quickly and staff were friendly. This is a great pizza place. And they have other stuff on the menu too but that’s less fun.

They make a great pizza. My favorite thing about them is they have a dairy free (vegan) cheese which is great for the lactose intolerant. I think the prices are a little high but that's probably everywhere these days. Plus they're near an apartment complex without much nearby competition. I haven't gone to many different places for pizza so it's hard to compare.

Mel was absolutely amazing. I needed a caterer for a small, casual affair, the food was excellent, super nicely laid out, and my family couldn't get enough! MEL projected the perfect quantity, and quality of the food. All the food was consumed and everybody left satisfied. We had a variety of Italian food. All the food was a huge hit!

I've been going to Mel's Pizza for almost 2 years now and I think the owner and all his employees are fabulous! They're always very welcoming, professional, and polite. Let's not forget how delicious their food is :) I highly recommend to anyone wondering. Now, it's time for me to order some delicious pizza 🍕😁 Thanks Mel's Pizza!

The best wings and their homemade blue cheese is amazing!!!

It's the best pizza around. Go on Monday night when they have specials.

passed by on my way back from Arlington. They sell slices and the pizza was really good. I will be back.

Amazing food, great people! We have ordered catering from Mel’s many times for family parties. Everyone always raves about how good the food is and they end up asking where we got it from. They also have some of the best pizza in the area. But most importantly, the food is always consistent and we have never been disappointed at all. Mel and his staff are always friendly and you can tell they truly appreciate your business. Highly recommended!

My go to for when I'm off of work. Been dining there for years and never had bad food. Both the pizza and regular food are delicious. Pricing is reasonable as well.

We ordered here via door dash, the food was amazing. Homemade ranch, killer wings, garlic knots and pizza were out of this world. We will definitely be back!

Wow, definitely the best garlic knots I’ve ever had! The pasta was delicious as well. It took a long time for DoorDash to deliver, but the food still arrived hot and delicious!

My husband and decided to give Sinapi’s a chance. This was a few weeks ago and we have ordered from them several times. The food is fantastic. The salads are fresh, big and delicious. The pizza and the wings are amazing, and we ordered from them for a party and the catering was wonderful. I have a Sicilian grandmother so I know good Italian food and they have great Italian food. After we had received our catering order, the next day, the owner called to make sure everything was to our satisfaction. They have excellent customer service. Sinapi’s in now our forever pizza place and I will continue to order from them. Give them a chance and you will love them!

Gregory Koch

Great pizza in Poughkeepsie. I had the cheese pizza small personal size. Menu says it serves two people but it couldn’t. But too big for one. Very cheesy and saucy and crispy crust. Also had mozzarella sticks which were good but inexplicably served over lettuce. You can dine in or take out. There were a few tables and a tv showing weather forecast for Arizona. We got our food quickly and staff were friendly. This is a great pizza place. And they have other stuff on the menu too but that’s less fun.

Larry Keshinover

Mel was absolutely amazing. I needed a caterer for a small, casual affair, the food was excellent, super nicely laid out, and my family couldn't get enough! MEL projected the perfect quantity, and quality of the food. All the food was consumed and everybody left satisfied. We had a variety of Italian food. All the food was a huge hit!

NATHAN FREDERICK

It's the best pizza around. Go on Monday night when they have specials.

Jenn Lee G

I've been going to Mel's Pizza for almost 2 years now and I think the owner and all his employees are fabulous! They're always very welcoming, professional, and polite. Let's not forget how delicious their food is :) I highly recommend to anyone wondering. Now, it's time for me to order some delicious pizza 🍕😁 Thanks Mel's Pizza!

Mavis Gewant

passed by on my way back from Arlington. They sell slices and the pizza was really good. I will be back.

Tom Tolli

Mels has been our go to pizza place for a while now so this review is overdue....Our takeout orders are always correct and everything we have tried over the time has been delicious, with so many pizza places in a 5 mile radius there's a reason we keep choosing mels...you have to try mikes hot honey and gyro pizza!

The Cakery

We ordered here via door dash, the food was amazing. Homemade ranch, killer wings, garlic knots and pizza were out of this world. We will definitely be back!

Rust Hunter

My go to for when I'm off of work. Been dining there for years and never had bad food. Both the pizza and regular food are delicious. Pricing is reasonable as well.

Amanda Fleming

Wow, definitely the best garlic knots I’ve ever had! The pasta was delicious as well. It took a long time for DoorDash to deliver, but the food still arrived hot and delicious!

Matt Woods

Amazing food, great people! We have ordered catering from Mel’s many times for family parties. Everyone always raves about how good the food is and they end up asking where we got it from. They also have some of the best pizza in the area. But most importantly, the food is always consistent and we have never been disappointed at all. Mel and his staff are always friendly and you can tell they truly appreciate your business. Highly recommended!

Frances Elia

I am from the Bronx, and moved up here many years ago. I could never find a good pizza place till I ate at Sinapi’s. Their pizza is absolutely delicious, crispy and the sauce and toppings are incredibly amazing. I highly recommend them. You will not be disappointed. Oh,and I forgot to mention, it is family owned and they are so very nice and accommodating. I feel like they are family.

Theresa Prezioso

My husband and decided to give Sinapi’s a chance. This was a few weeks ago and we have ordered from them several times. The food is fantastic. The salads are fresh, big and delicious. The pizza and the wings are amazing, and we ordered from them for a party and the catering was wonderful. I have a Sicilian grandmother so I know good Italian food and they have great Italian food. After we had received our catering order, the next day, the owner called to make sure everything was to our satisfaction. They have excellent customer service. Sinapi’s in now our forever pizza place and I will continue to order from them. Give them a chance and you will love them!

We are traveling and wanted a good sub. Based on the reviews we ordered two subs. The subs were good. The service was not great. We felt like we were bothering the guy taking orders. The guy in the back was working hard. I want to give them the benefit of the doubt because I think the guy at the cash register was new or covering for someone. He did not know the menu and there wasn’t a printed menu. He told us to look it up online. So maybe he was new. As I said the subs were good and we had the leftovers for dinner.

James Marland

We are traveling and wanted a good sub. Based on the reviews we ordered two subs. The subs were good. The service was not great. We felt like we were bothering the guy taking orders. The guy in the back was working hard. I want to give them the benefit of the doubt because I think the guy at the cash register was new or covering for someone. He did not know the menu and there wasn’t a printed menu. He told us to look it up online. So maybe he was new. As I said the subs were good and we had the leftovers for dinner.

Food and service were excellent. Reasonable prices and good portion size.

good marsala pizza

Pizza was great. I love the sauce. The penne vodka seemed bland. I would definitely go back for the pizza though

Ordered a large plain pie. Pizza was good, particularly the sauce. Delivery was fast!

Fresh pizza that was cooked to perfection. Looking forward to trying the other food. No beer or wine yet?

Pizza is decent. Guess the new owners are following the old recipes

Pizza was so awful we threw it away

While food and service was alright, the cost was ridiculous. Got two slices paid 2/3rds the cost of a full pie.

Vincent Vanleuven

While food and service was alright, the cost was ridiculous. Got two slices paid 2/3rds the cost of a full pie.

We were excited to order from the new pizza place super close to home, but the pizza was rushed. My husband was told 20 min and when he got there, it wasn't ready and it took at least another 10. And because it was rushed the cheese then totally sloshed all over the pizza before he got it home. When we ate it, it was very gummy and undercooked. The owners were super friendly though! **update - we did try it again and it was a way better experience.

I waited over an hour inside for my food tonight after I was told that it would only be a 30 minute wait over the phone, I showed up 30 mins after which made the wait for my food a total of 1 hour and a half. My time was wasted for food that was mediocre, never going here again.

Too expensive for such a nasty pizza. How do you mess up pizza horrible after taste didn’t even taste like a pizza. You know pizza is trash when the kids don’t eat it smh.

I really tried to like this place. I ordered 3 times. The food is it bad but the kitchen staff doesnt pay attention to the orders. I ordered wings well done, they literally came pink and raw. The mgr did send me new ones. This happened 2 times 2 different times. Today I ordered chicken marsala with no mushrooms and it came with sauce that was so bad four people tried it and spit it out. It was pure sherry wine and pure liquid. Wasnt even reduced and seasoned. For our side we asked for spag with oil and garlic and they put red pepper flakes allover it. Why??? We had the southwest wrap, dry is an understatement. No flavor at all. Sad, I give up! No more for me. Hopefully the owner wakes up before it is to late.

I used to like this restaurant. The quality and service have gone completely down hill. I ordered delivery which was 15 minutes late. The delivery driver could not even follow directions. He rang the doorbell when I said to leave on table on front porch and to NOT ring the doorbell (I have 2 dogs that go nuts when the doorbell is rung so...yeah...I was annoyed). When I do answer the door, he puts the order on the ground in FRONT of the door as I was opening the door. REALLY???!! I had to push the boxes away with the door and my foot. Absolutely ridiculous. Pizza was supposed to be cooked well done but it was way undercooked, soggy, and falling apart. Garlic knots were burned with the top of them literally black and hard and tasted burnt. Stuffed mushrooms were burned on top and were so disgusting I threw the rest out. The chicken in the chicken marsala was like rubber. The side of pasta had runny sauce. Nasty food. 🤮🤢🤢🤮 I spent $67.74 for this disaster. Im never ordering from this place again. Do yourself a favor and order from another restaurant. This place is horrible.

A B

I used to like this restaurant. The quality and service have gone completely down hill. I ordered delivery which was 15 minutes late. The delivery driver could not even follow directions. He rang the doorbell when I said to leave on table on front porch and to NOT ring the doorbell (I have 2 dogs that go nuts when the doorbell is rung so...yeah...I was annoyed). When I do answer the door, he puts the order on the ground in FRONT of the door as I was opening the door. REALLY???!! I had to push the boxes away with the door and my foot. Absolutely ridiculous. Pizza was supposed to be cooked well done but it was way undercooked, soggy, and falling apart. Garlic knots were burned with the top of them literally black and hard and tasted burnt. Stuffed mushrooms were burned on top and were so disgusting I threw the rest out. The chicken in the chicken marsala was like rubber. The side of pasta had runny sauce. Nasty food. 🤮🤢🤢🤮 I spent $67.74 for this disaster. Im never ordering from this place again. Do yourself a favor and order from another restaurant. This place is horrible.