Buffalo Pizza

Sarah Goold

One of my new favorites! The crust is incredible and the quality is great. The sauce is on the sweeter side and the toppings weren’t skimped on. Customer service was great and picking up was quick and easy.

J M

A friend was telling me about breakfast pizza and I honestly didn't think it would taste good but I was wrong. My first time and it was actually really good, considering there's no sauce on the pizza. I got the chorizo and added jalapenos on it. The pizza dough wasn't over cooked or undercooked. I normally don't eat the crust but the crust was soft that I actually enjoyed it. Staff was super courteous and nice. I'd definitely go back for more breakfast pizza or try their regular pizzas.

Brendan Cohen

Quality pizza. Really tasty and textured dough with good flavored sauce. I also love that they have the mini pepps. Worth the price for a good pie.

We got pizza here before a movie at tower. The guy made a mistake and gave us a large for the price of a small!! Super nice guys, there were only 2 of them! The set up is a little weird ngl but the PIZZA THE PIZZA MY GOD it was so good! We burned ourselves eating it and it was sooo worth it. Totally recommend and will be going back!

Best vegan pizza in sactown! they have everything u need for good pizza. Vegan cheese is delicious not tapioca-y ifyk vegan meats are flavorful not overly salty. Crust is to die for sooo amazing 🤤. sometimes I got just to buy the vegan ranch or marinara sauce bc they are too good ☺️

Sophie Joseph

We got pizza here before a movie at tower. The guy made a mistake and gave us a large for the price of a small!! Super nice guys, there were only 2 of them! The set up is a little weird ngl but the PIZZA THE PIZZA MY GOD it was so good! We burned ourselves eating it and it was sooo worth it. Totally recommend and will be going back!

I ordered online for pickup on a Sunday evening. The ETA for a single Pesto Pistol was 30 minutes and they had it done on time. The pizza was good although it did taste like a little something was missing from the recipe. The ambience of Buffalo Pizza is ridiculously basic but that is of little import. Judging by the influx of customers as I sat and waited for 20 minutes it seems the locals are in agreement.

Finally had the opportunity to try this place! Ordered pick up. Their staff was friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend them to their vegan options! It's refreshing that they know vegan. We got the Buffalo pizza, vegan white, vegan garlic bread, and the vegan ranch. Yummy. Reason for the 4 stars is due to the first time i tried going there and they were closed. No sign on the business or anything. It was disappointing and left a little bad reputation for them in my mind. Otherwise, great food. Will be back.

Specifically reviewing my order - I’d probably give this place a second chance but with a different pizza. The vegan cheesy bread was amazing. Why oh why don’t they use the same cheese for the vegan pizzas? Got the pepperoni and it wasn’t stand out at all. Not bad but not anything I’ll write home about. Use the VCG bread cheese on your pizzas!!!

Vegan pizza ❤️ I gotta remember to ask for EXTRA sauce. Not enough sauce for my liking. Perfect pizza for a lazy day when you just wanna veg out on the couch all day and do nothing but eat pizza

So, this place is very inviting, a little slow but tastes great. Major downside (and the reason for the star loss) is no allergen listing on the website. I ordered a vegan pie here but they must have used some kind of almond in it and I had a pretty rough reaction. I'm obviously fine, but some info would help people with allergies avoid a similar mistake. I wolfed an entire piece I'm 3 bites before noticing the tingling burn of an allergic reaction, but man was it good. Highly recommend for flavor and vegan options, but the owners should make allergen info readily available. Also, parking is eh, we parked behind the building and walked a half a block maybe. Also, no real seating, so plan for takeaway only. Maybe go have a picnic in the very pretty (and quiet) cemetary across the street, I'm sure they'd like the company!

If I could rate the vegan/non-vegan pizzas separately, I would give the non-vegan pizza five stars and the vegan three. The vegan breakfast pizza here used to be my favorite pizza in the city when compared to other vegan and non-vegan pizzas alike. The last few times we’ve come here, though, the vegan pies have been covered in thick layers of vegan cheese to the point that it gets stuck in your teeth and is hard to swallow. It’s such a shame because the other vegan toppings and sauces are delightful and make remarkable pizzas when they’re not unnecessarily covered in goo. Would be nice if they included vegan cheese as a topping in the description of the pizza so you could choose whether or not to include it.

The mushroom and spinach breakfast pizza was really good! The crust is the perfect combination of chewy and crunchy, which not many pizza places get right. I will be back to try different pizzas. It is kinda weird walking into the place because it is really a bare bones place, but the pizza is good, so who cares?

Josh

I ordered online for pickup on a Sunday evening. The ETA for a single Pesto Pistol was 30 minutes and they had it done on time. The pizza was good although it did taste like a little something was missing from the recipe. The ambience of Buffalo Pizza is ridiculously basic but that is of little import. Judging by the influx of customers as I sat and waited for 20 minutes it seems the locals are in agreement.

Chloe Martins

Finally had the opportunity to try this place! Ordered pick up. Their staff was friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend them to their vegan options! It's refreshing that they know vegan. We got the Buffalo pizza, vegan white, vegan garlic bread, and the vegan ranch. Yummy. Reason for the 4 stars is due to the first time i tried going there and they were closed. No sign on the business or anything. It was disappointing and left a little bad reputation for them in my mind. Otherwise, great food. Will be back.

Mike Hoffman

Specifically reviewing my order - I’d probably give this place a second chance but with a different pizza. The vegan cheesy bread was amazing. Why oh why don’t they use the same cheese for the vegan pizzas? Got the pepperoni and it wasn’t stand out at all. Not bad but not anything I’ll write home about. Use the VCG bread cheese on your pizzas!!!

Jill Nakatani

Vegan pizza ❤️ I gotta remember to ask for EXTRA sauce. Not enough sauce for my liking. Perfect pizza for a lazy day when you just wanna veg out on the couch all day and do nothing but eat pizza

Joe Ragsdale

So, this place is very inviting, a little slow but tastes great. Major downside (and the reason for the star loss) is no allergen listing on the website. I ordered a vegan pie here but they must have used some kind of almond in it and I had a pretty rough reaction. I'm obviously fine, but some info would help people with allergies avoid a similar mistake. I wolfed an entire piece I'm 3 bites before noticing the tingling burn of an allergic reaction, but man was it good. Highly recommend for flavor and vegan options, but the owners should make allergen info readily available. Also, parking is eh, we parked behind the building and walked a half a block maybe. Also, no real seating, so plan for takeaway only. Maybe go have a picnic in the very pretty (and quiet) cemetary across the street, I'm sure they'd like the company!

Hannah Page

If I could rate the vegan/non-vegan pizzas separately, I would give the non-vegan pizza five stars and the vegan three. The vegan breakfast pizza here used to be my favorite pizza in the city when compared to other vegan and non-vegan pizzas alike. The last few times we’ve come here, though, the vegan pies have been covered in thick layers of vegan cheese to the point that it gets stuck in your teeth and is hard to swallow. It’s such a shame because the other vegan toppings and sauces are delightful and make remarkable pizzas when they’re not unnecessarily covered in goo. Would be nice if they included vegan cheese as a topping in the description of the pizza so you could choose whether or not to include it.

Summer

The mushroom and spinach breakfast pizza was really good! The crust is the perfect combination of chewy and crunchy, which not many pizza places get right. I will be back to try different pizzas. It is kinda weird walking into the place because it is really a bare bones place, but the pizza is good, so who cares?

The pizza is very good and so. Is the ice cream except yesterday the crust was under cooked.

3 pizzas 92$, vegan pizza was so good! Backyard bbq chicken, spicy jalapeno pepperoni!!! Crust was soft inside but perfectly crunchy outside! Fed 7 of us!!!! Will be back!!!

Apple Campbell

3 pizzas 92$, vegan pizza was so good! Backyard bbq chicken, spicy jalapeno pepperoni!!! Crust was soft inside but perfectly crunchy outside! Fed 7 of us!!!! Will be back!!!

So many different things here. The breakfast pizza was a huge let down, it is basically cheesey bread. It has no sauce and the day break is just cheese. This is a rip off and on that note we where overcharged, the pizza is listed as $26 and we where charged 30. The upside is that the ingredients and crust were delicious. We also got the vegan ube ice cream, which was a rich tasty ice cream. The down sides to the ice cream was that it has a lot of ice crystals in it and a lot of food dye (our mouths were purple for the rest of the day).

Alex DeMartino

So many different things here. The breakfast pizza was a huge let down, it is basically cheesey bread. It has no sauce and the day break is just cheese. This is a rip off and on that note we where overcharged, the pizza is listed as $26 and we where charged 30. The upside is that the ingredients and crust were delicious. We also got the vegan ube ice cream, which was a rich tasty ice cream. The down sides to the ice cream was that it has a lot of ice crystals in it and a lot of food dye (our mouths were purple for the rest of the day).

We read the reviews and we're so excited for breakfast pizza options. Unfortunately, the pizzas we received were greasy, chewy and the cheese on top was overdone. They don't use any sauce, just dough, meat and (overcooked) cheese. We will not order again.

Sunday , 2/20/2022 was the worse experience ever ! the chorizo looked like it was hand thrown on the pizza from 10 feet out ! some slices came with no flavor ! i called back 4 times no answer! originally the younger guy said 1 hour but i left early and got there in 45 minuets to find it done and just bartley warm ! If i waited the hour it was gonna be room temp. The cheese was formed hard already not soft! i would have appreciated a warning that the pizza was done early because, i drove patiently , stopped for gas and stopped a few times. Pizza was not good , miguel took the order !

As a returning customer of a few years, I'm a bit sad that my experiences at Buffalo have been getting worse and worse each time I return to the new location. I've visited the new location 3 times now over the span of a year and the service has been consistently bad. The bros running the shop could care less about being there and are incredibly nonchalant. I miss the service of the old location. The food was ok, not as good as the old location of course, but this last time, the pizzas I got were no better than what I could get for a fraction of the cost. The cheese on my vegan pepperoni and vegan garlic bread were burnt to the point that biting in, cheese would be literally flying across the table. The spicy pepperoni had no tomato sauce and the cheese was also burnt. My order was ready for pickup well before the estimated time, so wild guess that the bros just rushed the order so they could continue just chilling in the kitchen. There were also no vegan ice cream flavors when I went at 6pm. Honestly I don't see the point of Buffalo moving to an amazing new sit-down restaurant location if this is the type of experience that I can expect. I don't see myself returning anytime soon. $60 down the drain :(

The Bully Art Kennels

Sunday , 2/20/2022 was the worse experience ever ! the chorizo looked like it was hand thrown on the pizza from 10 feet out ! some slices came with no flavor ! i called back 4 times no answer! originally the younger guy said 1 hour but i left early and got there in 45 minuets to find it done and just bartley warm ! If i waited the hour it was gonna be room temp. The cheese was formed hard already not soft! i would have appreciated a warning that the pizza was done early because, i drove patiently , stopped for gas and stopped a few times. Pizza was not good , miguel took the order !

Nikki

As a returning customer of a few years, I'm a bit sad that my experiences at Buffalo have been getting worse and worse each time I return to the new location. I've visited the new location 3 times now over the span of a year and the service has been consistently bad. The bros running the shop could care less about being there and are incredibly nonchalant. I miss the service of the old location. The food was ok, not as good as the old location of course, but this last time, the pizzas I got were no better than what I could get for a fraction of the cost. The cheese on my vegan pepperoni and vegan garlic bread were burnt to the point that biting in, cheese would be literally flying across the table. The spicy pepperoni had no tomato sauce and the cheese was also burnt. My order was ready for pickup well before the estimated time, so wild guess that the bros just rushed the order so they could continue just chilling in the kitchen. There were also no vegan ice cream flavors when I went at 6pm. Honestly I don't see the point of Buffalo moving to an amazing new sit-down restaurant location if this is the type of experience that I can expect. I don't see myself returning anytime soon. $60 down the drain :(