Analia Gerard

Feb 21-2025. Breakfast special. No rush. Tough to park. Packed as always. No wait. Nov 1st. It’s a Staten Island staple and never misses on a meal. The selections are broad and fresh and fabulous every time. Went most recently for breakfast - high marks for perfectly cooked over easy eggs, huge pancakes and crispy delicious bacon. Dec 28. Breakfast again - big portions on the breakfast specials but today I found the eggs Benedict disappointing. Over easy eggs and bacon for my husband were spot on, as was the coffee - yum. I’ve had the pastrami here for lunch, which was amazing - really, really great.

Frank Castellano

When I first walked into Andrew's Diner, it was like most of the diners in NY or NJ. We were quickly seated and iur server came to us for our drink order. Menu is extensive with nice variety of specials. I ordered a Greek salad with grilled chicken and was very impressed with the portion size but, the taste of the grilled chicken put the usual salad over the top for me. Very friendly and attentive service made for a very pleasant experience.

Sana Masoud

It was my first time coming here, and I was pleasantly surprised. The pancakes were delicious. The chicken parmesan was so good. I had ordered a salad and it was ok.

I love everything about Andrew's diner.\nThe food, waitresses, bus boys and the warm welcome always. My favorite is the pastrami. Wish it was closer to home. Maybe once or twice a month I go. There p…

I love everything about Andrew's diner.\nThe food, waitresses, bus boys and the warm welcome always. My favorite is the pastrami. Wish it was closer to home. Maybe once or twice a month I go. There…

Nice diner . Enjoyed my meatloaf platter that was a luncheon special with soup and potato and vegetable. Great service. Friendly staff and owner kept checking ig all was good. Limited parking in fron…

Nice diner . Enjoyed my meatloaf platter that was a luncheon special with soup and potato and vegetable. Great service. Friendly staff and owner kept checking ig all was good. Limited parking in …

Nice diner . Enjoyed my meatloaf platter that was a luncheon special with soup and potato and vegetable. Great service. Friendly staff and owner kept checking ig all was good. Limited parking in …

great service -and pleasant hosts & servers, delicious food too.\nGeorge always greets his customers like family which makes people want to go back " home" fir a meal.

great service -and pleasant hosts & servers, delicious food too.\nGeorge always greets his customers like family which makes people want to go back " home" fir a meal.

My daughter and Son in law took me here on a. Sunday Morning. We were greeted nicely and didn't even have to wait even though it was almost packed. I ordere silver dollar pancakes with a side of ba…

This is a neighborhood diner that is a great place for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The service was very good.

I love Andrew's diner. All of the waitor and waitresses are phenomenal and very attentive to customers. The food here is amazing. Just had a breakfast date yesterday I highly recommend the pancakes…

Ordered the Pastrami on Rye and it was lean, a decent sized portion and reasonably priced compared to NYC and NJ. Waitress was pleasant, owner stoped at the table and asked how was our order. Place…

Super sweet and cute place. Amazing service! Food is incredible! drinks are awesome! \nI haven't had diner food this great in many years... \nHands down the best diner on the island, and better tha…

Andrew's is our Diner of choice. Great food, great service, friendly atmosphere. Huge portions, not even my husband was able to finish his meal. Tonight the service and food was outstanding!\nThank…

I HAVE BEEN DINING HERE SINCE 1999 AND HAVE NEVER BEEN DISAPPOINTED AT ALL WHEN DINING. ALSO LUNCH AND DINNER MEALS ARE EXCELLENT AND GREAT. THE STAFF IS EXCELLENT THEY TREAT YOU SPECIAL LIKE NO OT…

I HAVE BEEN DINING HERE SINCE 1999 AND HAVE NEVER BEEN DISAPPOINTED AT ALL WHEN DINING. ALSO LUNCH AND DINNER MEALS ARE EXCELLENT AND GREAT. THE staff IS EXCELLENT THEY TREAT YOU SPECIAL LIKE NO …

The food was so good! We chose for the American breakfast. The staf is also very friendly. The prices very between 10-20$

The food was so good! We chose for the American breakfast. The staf is also very friendly. The prices very between 10-20$

Great classic diner! Food is solid and portions are huge—loved the breakfast platter. Service was friendly and fast, atmosphere has that cozy retro vibe.

Joseph Buro

You will never find this diner empty. It is a favorite by many. The service and atmosphere are what you would expect, and if you were a regular they would treat you well. I order a wrap or sandeich when I go and it is always good. I do feel that they do not impress as much as some other diners. Its a great spot to meet people, just not one you walk out of feeling like it was your best meal for the week or something. Parking also is terrible.

Melissa F

A large selection on the menu is always great. Fair prices and a small parking lot is available. Very family friendly

Far K

I've only been to Staten Island a couple of times, but Andrew's Diner always delivers that classic diner vibe. Both visits were super busy, yet we walked right in—no wait! The portions are huge, seriously, I can never finish everything. One time, I had waffles with turkey sausage and scrambled eggs. Those waffles were perfect: crispy outside, fluffy inside. They even had sugar-free syrup when I asked, which was great. Another time, I tried the pastrami omelette, and wow, it was massive! Easily enough for more than 1 person, especially with the side of home fries. Next time I'm in Staten Island, I'm definitely hitting up Andrew's Diner for breakfast.

Chad Jacobson

In my opinion, this is one of the best diners you'll come across on the island. Food is served quickly and prepared well. I have never had an issue with any of the 35 dishes I tried thus far. My kids love it here and always , ask to eat at Andrews Diner. The menu is highly accommodating, no matter what you are looking for. The atmosphere is comfortable and enjoyable. The diner is divided into two sections. The left side seems to be the more fancy side, as the right side is all booths. Most of the staff have been there for a while. They seem to be very proficient in taking orders accurately and staying on top of things. As for the prices they are a bit on the expensive side but you do get what you pay for. Overall I would recommend this eatery to all.

Michael Ponzini

Normal diner and experience. The service was excellent, the food tasty. My pastrami was piled high, the way pastrami was meant to be! My friend's meal was so totally covered with you couldn't tell what he was having. And that is not a complaint, it's a compliment.

There's a lot of social media hype about Andrew's having one of the best pastrami sandwiches in Staten so of course I had to try it. \nAll pastrami I eat is judged by Katz ' which sets the bar. \nThi…

On my few trips to Staten Island I've enjoyed getting the good old fashioned diner experience at Andrew's diner. Even though both times were very packed and busy we had 0 wait on walking in. Food i…

We sat down at 1. It's 1:14 and the server came. Not terrible. She knew the menu when we asked her questions. I ordered the onion soup and the gyro platter and my guest had the tuna. The soup was v…

Used to go alot and get the pastrami and it was good but a bit expensive. Last time I went for lunch with a friend of mine and we both had the pastrami and 1 onion rings and 2 sodas and an order of…

$26 for a pastrami sandwich and fries? Sure as hell wasn't Katz's pastrami or anything close \nVery disappointed \nAt one time I would have given 4 stars but as the prices have risen the quality of…

This is a diner that has been in Staten Island for quite some time. We decided to try it for breakfast. My daughter had the chocolate chip pancake, hubby had the shrimp parm hero ( he was in love a…

The queue that led from the diner out into the street spoke volumes as to how good this diner is. We went on two consecutive mornings. I had the 'meat lovers omelette' both times! The waitresses are …

The queue that led from the diner out into the street spoke volumes as to how good this diner is. We went on two consecutive mornings. I had the 'meat lovers omelette' both times! The waitresses ar…

The food was really tasty, the diner has a cozy ambience and the staff was super friendly and kind! Our waiter spoke in Spanish, (our first language), so we felt really comfortable.

The food was really tasty, the diner has a cozy ambience and the staff was super friendly and kind! Our waiter spoke in Spanish, (our first language), so we felt really comfortable.

The food was really tasty, the diner has a cozy ambience and the staff was super friendly and kind! Our waiter spoke in Spanish, (our first language), so we felt really comfortable.

LDA Rodriguez

Went here on Good Friday 2025 for breakfast. Chose this since it had high ratings and we were visiting Staten Island. It’s a regular diner. Nothing fancy but it works. Good menu selection. I liked the vegetable omelette. My husband was not thrilled about the eggs benedict with salmon and expected better taste. I expected better waffles somehow. Not great but decent food. Seems like many locals come here. Decent service. Their restaurant signage could use some repair. Since parking was limited, you can opt for street parking.

This is a quiet and sleepy diner. That isn't an insult... love places like this but they need a little background music or something. Food was your typical diner fare. Loved the muffin and omelette…

Egg shells in my omelette and place to small for comfort. Service is slow. No ambiance.

We have been going to Andrews for years and I would always bragg and recommend it to anyone . Not anymore . Recently we have been ordering take out/delivery and the service has been piss poor …

We have been going to Andrews for years and I would always bragg and recommend it to anyone . Not anymore . Recently we have been ordering take out/delivery and the service has been piss poor …

We will be ending our 19 year love of this diner. For 19 years we have called Andrews our favorite diner. The owners are family friendly and the staff has always been great….but something has chang…

Was here yesterday , food was okay . Our waitress the older woman with the blonde hair was extremely disrespectful, she didn’t ask how we were doing, and threw things and when we asked a question she ignored us. Terrible horrible service . Next time I come in I will never want her as our server again . Lady in the front was nice .

Brenda Alvarado

If I can leave no star I would… I’ve been here many times and not once I have ever deal with the owner. This owner was completely disrespectful. Went to eat breakfast at his diner and I was curious to know if they can use butter instead of oil on my pancakes and he went off on me. He began yelling saying that I can go home and make my own breakfast because no diner or restaurant will ever use butter and said that he will not do it for me or anyone. I explained to him that I was still willing to eat my breakfast there, it was simply a question. He proceeded to continue to speak loud telling me that he is not making changes to his diner and if I don’t like it that’s too bad, not once did I ask him to make changes to any policy. This explains why the waitress hesitated to ask him, she was more respectful than he was but her hesitation spoke a lot of volume for the way they are probably treated. I told him he was right, I can actually save my money by going home to eat and enjoy my breakfast with no oil, I told him if everyone here did the same you wouldn’t have a business. He was so disrespectful and embarrassing. I have never experienced this before!!

Roseann Deamara

We were so disappointed in their pastrami. It was thick, fatty and bland tasting. The fries were soggy and undercooked. The broccoli was hard and not cooked fully too. What happened? We usually love everything there. The cook must have had a bad night!