Landon Mannor

Stopped in and ordered a Philly cheese with shaved ribeye. The sandwich was very good as was the service.

Rob Carlo

Ordered a pepperoni calzone to go today 5-21-25. Was sooooo good and the staff were awesome. Those who complained about the food here probably aren't happy anywhere. I'm only 12 miles away and don't go often enough 😁

Brett Chilcoat

Ordered pizza, and it was good. Service was good as well. Parking is the only thing I'm not crazy about, but there is a small lot out back with access to the restaurant from the rear.

Karen Stearns

My pecan salad was delicious,. And portion sizes were great. However, my mother was disappointed with her spaghetti and meatballs. The garlic in the sauce was too over powering for her taste. The wait could have been a little more attentive. We did enjoy sitting next to the fish tank. Very soothing after a stressful day.

Kevin Lucas Art

The food was okay. I had the Chicksn Riggies and my wife had the Kickin Chicken. My wife liked hers but mine was super bland. It wasn't very spicy and it needed some fresh herbs or chicken thighs instead of breast meat. Just not a lot of flavor. The pasta was cooked perfectly though. It looked clean in the dining room and the service was okay. When we got there, it was about 25% full and never got super busy but we were told they didnt a have a normal table so they sat us at the tiniest little pub table I've ever seen. It was a game of Tetris trying to get our meals and drinks puzzled togther on it which was annoying. They had a huge salt water aquarium. With some beautiful fish and corals which was nice. Might go again to try another dish.

+4

David Bryk

Pizza was average. I liked the beer list and great seating outside. Live music was wonderful.

Good portions in kind of a standard Italian type of menu. Wait staff was fine, however were while we waited at the bar even though our table was reserved. Large portions and a good value. Very nice outdoor dining.

The town of tullys only real sit down spot besides kurdish and its a tad bit of a let down, dont let the outside esthetic fool you this food will be insanely mediocre. The people are relatively normal, no complaints there could be nicer but whatever. The food is 100 percent hit or miss, the only spot on guaranteed to be good option is the calzone... and everything is overpriced for tully. Wish this place could shape up better, it would really be a nice spit if done correctly!

Angela Churchill

Edit again 2/26/22 I ordered a greek pizza online and as always, put instructions to replace the kalamata with black olives. It wasn't done this time and I hate kalamata olives.. there was MAYBE 6 cherry tomato halves on the entire pizza, and zero artichoke hearts. I even lifted up the cheese to see if it was underneath. It's like they don't even care, because they clearly don't read these reviews. The wings had zero sauce of any kind and were dry. And they really need to update the website. Incorrect prices, and items on there they no longer have. Pretty much done with this place. Too expensive to not get what I ordered. Edit: I have ordered a few more times. Still on the pricey side, but the pizzas are huge and the wings are good. Friendly staff from my experience. Food was ok, but we were way overcharged. Their menu prices were not the same as online. Spent about $15 more than we should've. Not returning

Patrick Barry

Been driving past this joint for years and a month ago we stopped in for dinner. NY Style pizza came out amazing. Similar in thickness to Twin Trees with loads of pepperoni but in a 20" pie! One of the best pizza experiences of my life. The next visit the dough was 3/4" thick and awful. Tonight we ordered a pickup pizza and even stressed we wanted their thin NY Style pizza. Nope, not tonight. I might as well have ordered DiGiorno. The great service and great atmosphere goes right out the window when the quality control doesnt exist. So sad. I want that first pizza again and again and again...

Alexis White

I usually like everything here till today. Got a ribeye that was the smalls thing I have seen for $42 . Then there was the steak salad that was a plate full of lettuce with a small piece of steak. And to top it off neither one was cooked right.

Jay Procita

As a resident of Tully, we order from here once a week at least. The pizza has gone back to being terrible It looks like they are back to using pizza crust shells instead of fresh dough. There is no love at all put into their pizzas. Do not order. The pizzas were terrible four years ago when we first moved in to town and started getting them and then something changed. They started being awesome and tasty. UNFORTUNATELY, THEY HAVE GONE BACKWARDS NO TASTE. THE DOUGH IS TERRIBLE. IT’S NOT EVEN DOUGH. IT’S A PIZZA SHELL AND THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO LOVE BEING PUT IN. TO THE MAKING OF THE PIZZAS. DO NOT BUY. 7/16/25