Vanessa S.

Super cozy spot with authentic Italian food! Nothing fancy, just fantastic quality that you don’t get at a lot of other places. As a heads up: They don’t take reservations and only accept cash. Staff was very friendly and attentive. Food and drinks were top notch. Couldn’t ask for anything more! Thanks for the great dinner, will definitely come back.

+6

Ida Benedetto

This place is very old school and stubbornly stays that way. It's a great spot for neighborhood regulars. The food it supremely Italian-American, hearty and grounding. Not fussy with presentation but deeply satisfying.

Susie Su

Some of the best desserts I’ve ever had, loved their tiramisu and chocolate espresso cake. The entrees and appetizers were a bit lacking on their New Year’s Eve menu, I think they are known for their pastas so will come back to try their pastas in the future. Cash only.

+2

Tigershout

Definitely worth the trip, although not a 5 star. As everyone noted, this is CASH ONLY. Before 10pm, nearest ATM is 5-10 mins, after 10pm it's 10 mins so do bring enough cash for a good tip. We went without a booking at 9pm for 5 people. Indoors did have an excellent vibe but we were starving so were happy to sit in the outside covered section without waiting 40 mins. Even in December at 9 degrees (European) with the heater at the back it was definitely not even needed for jackets. Front of house is amazing, so friendly and chatty. As we were outside, getting attention or staff became tricky but everyone was very nice when we did. Despite it's reputation, we went for the garlic bread with homemade chilli oil, which is 100% a winner & still sad we didn't buy any. Do save some if you get pasta to mop up the juices as it went so well with the lasagne. The cacio e Pepe with asparagus & egg yolk went down very well, and the wine selection isn't outstanding but decent enough. We skipped dessert but everything looked great. I'd 100% recommend this as a safe, delicious, and fun bet for a group dinner. Would definitely go back.

Nicole Sparacio

Beautiful cozy, authentic Italian. Loved the buzz of the restaurant, good for a family dinner. Bruschetta was really good as well as the rice balls. Pasta was tasty and a big portion. Cash only & no reservations

Rebekah S

A really cute and cozy place for home styled Italian food. The staff are lovely and really kind. Its one of those places you sit at for a long time and just enjoy everyone’s company. TThe food is pretty good too and priced fairly. They have tortellini in bone broth which I haven’t been able to find anywhere else. It’s a classic Bologna dish. Lots of other options with traditional Italian dishes. Options for vegetarians too. I’d come back again!

Julia Asprey

This is a really cozy and cute neighborhood spot which I want to love, however both times we’ve been the food has really disappointed. Come for the atmosphere, but go somewhere else for tasty Italian food.

Matt Schenker

I want to like Noodle Pudding so badly. It has a lot going for it - cozy, family friendly, and the wait staff seems truly nice. The place was packed on what i thought would be a slow holiday weekend, so people clearly like it. The food however, was truly awful. I ordered a “seafood ragu” which was nothing close to a ragu. Instead, i was served pasta with watery tomato sauce no better than what comes from a can , surrounded by some mediocre seafood. Nothing like the slow cooked meat and vegetables a ‘ragu’ should be. My wife’s cacio e Pepe was slightly better, but still odd that the additional zucchini came as raw strips added in. Our side of broccoli was bland and tasteless (even our 4 year old refused to eat it, he eats broccoli all the time at home). Two stars as our toddler loved the lasagne.

dawn travers

Decent restaurant, food was ok. My order was not as described on the menu but it was pretty good so didn't make a fuss. I get up to use the restroom and can chased by a bartender asking if I need help. I explain I need to use the restroom and get asked if I am dining there, the restroom is customers only. I just spent $300 at this restaurant to get publicly embarrassed by someone who thinks I don’t belong there. Was just thinking I should come back with my coworkers as I work in the area but after this experience, I left feeling embarrassed and unwelcome.

Mohammed Latif

Actually this is my first time maybe i rank restaurant 1 star, for many reasons. The experience was disappointed, the food look like already made before order just but it in microwave, many items in the menu not available, I can’t finish my plate actually. They only accept cash!!. This is the worst Italian food i ever had.

+1