Dutchy's Pizza

The Hot Goat is delicious (I add olives, mushrooms & peppers because I like lots of veggies on my pie) & they have awesome beer selection.

Mark Bradt

The crust is crispy, thin, and holds up well. The topping are balanced and not overwhelming. Lots of unique offerings and some traditional. Good beers on tap.

J D

Best customer service followed up but amazing pizza. Something as simple as a cheese pizza and it still turns out amazing. The sauce in particular was perfect. Wishing we went with the bigger pie! Came back a couple of days later for another pizza! It was even better! Literal only request… make some ranch from scratch for that extra touch!

Ruby Christine

Pleasantly surprised at how delicious this pizza was! Not much to look at from the outside, but the service was great and fast. The cheese had such a nice flavor and the perfect amount of chewiness. We got a large pepperoni, olive and sausage pizza… great crust. Not too thick not too thin, right amount of crisp and chew. Got it to go drove 15 minutes home and it was perfect. There’s nothing I would’ve changed about this pizza! Kame as a recommendation from the checker at Murphy’s market lol… Stoked to find a new-to-us great pizza place!

Carrina Hanson

I went in to try a Chicago Italian beef for the first time because of a good friend of mine in Chicago told me they're super good. I don't know if this is what they're like in Chi, but holy smokes was that a good sandwich! I will definitely be back for it.

Saalav C

OFF THE HOOK PIZZA! The dough is cooked perfectly OMG I could keep on eating! Addictive yumminess!! A hidden treasure in Arcata. A MUST GO TO!! Delicious food, fast, great service 😋

Cyril Oberlander

Great pizza and barbecue chicken, place has character and worth the visit. Has two monitors showing sports, and has outdoor seating.

Will Dower

A hidden gem. I passed by this spot for years and finally tried it. I've eaten there several times now and highly recommend it. If you want something a little different try the "Hot Goat" or for a more traditional flavor the "Veggie" is awesome. In addition, I think they have the best beer prices in town and they carry Redwood Curtain Sticky Fingers so that's a big plus too.

P. S.

We love Dutchy’s! Yummy pizza and fresh local ingredients for their caprice salad! I don’t even watch sportsball, but it’s always fun to post up at the bar and hang with those that do! Plus, two-player Mrs. Pac-Man!

I P

One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The crust was crispy and thin. Good amount of tomato sauce. The cheese melted perfectly. Nice edge crust with some garlic butter I think. A great pizza. I got a little flustered over the difference between a medium pizza and a 12-inch pizza. I learned there is no universal "small," "medium," "large" with pizza. A medium could be whatever-inch the restaurant makes it. My social skills have declined in the last decade and more rapidly in the last few years. Dutchy's has a 12-inch and then a larger size (18-inch?). It's great pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful. I got a half cheese and half pepperoni.

I went into Dutchy's today on my lunch break. And I have to be honest, it's the best pizza ive had in Humbold, so far. I am a fan of Paul's live from New York, and I wasn't expecting Dutchy's to quite stand up to my favorite pizza. But I was wrong..it's now my favorite. Service was prompt, direct, and reasonably priced. Next time I go in, it won't be on my lunch break, and ill be switching up from a Coca-Cola to a beer 🫡

Yummy pizza. Great cheese and sauce. Wonderful service. Happy little college eats!

Awesome Indian-style pizza. Not only do they have great topping options, but their crust is phenomenal - warm and chewy on the inside while slightly crispy on the bottom. Also, the crust doesn't go limp in the middle like other pizzas and this is true from the first slice to the last (some pizzas get limp after sitting for a while but not here). Overall this place is an excellent food-find in Astoria.

First time trying yesterday. I don’t know what took me so long. The Goat is fabulous. I’ve been thinking about it all day and I need to get it ASAP after work. Beautiful crust and flavor. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

A Johnson

Awesome Indian-style pizza. Not only do they have great topping options, but their crust is phenomenal - warm and chewy on the inside while slightly crispy on the bottom. Also, the crust doesn't go limp in the middle like other pizzas and this is true from the first slice to the last (some pizzas get limp after sitting for a while but not here). Overall this place is an excellent food-find in Astoria.

Clarissa Peyton

First time trying yesterday. I don’t know what took me so long. The Goat is fabulous. I’ve been thinking about it all day and I need to get it ASAP after work. Beautiful crust and flavor. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

Tracey Santos

Yummy pizza. Great cheese and sauce. Wonderful service. Happy little college eats!

S Jhggcc

I went into Dutchy's today on my lunch break. And I have to be honest, it's the best pizza ive had in Humbold, so far. I am a fan of Paul's live from New York, and I wasn't expecting Dutchy's to quite stand up to my favorite pizza. But I was wrong..it's now my favorite. Service was prompt, direct, and reasonably priced. Next time I go in, it won't be on my lunch break, and ill be switching up from a Coca-Cola to a beer 🫡

A Malin

Really unique pizzas, but the classics were great as well. We got the chicken tikka pizza, loved all the greens on top, and the pepperoni pizza was the perfect amount of super cheesy.

Teresa Wilson

Pizza was delicious! We way over ordered because everything looked so good & it was well worth taking home the leftovers. Would definitely make this a regular stop when in the area.

We liked the Indian style pizza's. Also nice staff!

Jordi Heilbron

We liked the Indian style pizza's. Also nice staff!

Found this spot while traveling, thanks to the reviews. We tried the Spicy Hawaiian pizza, and it was delicious—great flavor and a super crispy crust. I was mainly on the hunt for good wings, and while the flavor was there, they just weren’t crispy. More like grilled chicken than traditional wings. Still, a solid stop if you're craving good pizza!

Karla Evans

Found this spot while traveling, thanks to the reviews. We tried the Spicy Hawaiian pizza, and it was delicious—great flavor and a super crispy crust. I was mainly on the hunt for good wings, and while the flavor was there, they just weren’t crispy. More like grilled chicken than traditional wings. Still, a solid stop if you're craving good pizza!

The center of the pizza crust was pretty undercooked, a little soggy. The crust itself had a good crisp texture but was pretty bland, and I was hoping for better based on all the previous reviews. They are very generous with the toppings, as you can see from the picture, this was their Bigfoot 18". The staff was great! Overall, an okay pizza and I live to find great 🍕!

Shawn Curtis

The center of the pizza crust was pretty undercooked, a little soggy. The crust itself had a good crisp texture but was pretty bland, and I was hoping for better based on all the previous reviews. They are very generous with the toppings, as you can see from the picture, this was their Bigfoot 18". The staff was great! Overall, an okay pizza and I live to find great 🍕!

Sign outside says "Happy Hour All The Time. $3 and $4 pint beer" Not so. A Modelo on tap was $6. Pizza was tasty, but not nearly $30 for a 12". Place was empty. Rather chilly inside. Service was fine. No complaints on that one. I just don't like seeing a price and the register rings something different

Good pizza but they forgot to place my wife's togo order so when I arrived, as instructed, twenty five minutes later there was 🙂‍↔️ thing that pick up. I had to reorder and wait in that boring dining room for a half hour more. Good pizza crust though

Rene Buchanan

Sign outside says "Happy Hour All The Time. $3 and $4 pint beer" Not so. A Modelo on tap was $6. Pizza was tasty, but not nearly $30 for a 12". Place was empty. Rather chilly inside. Service was fine. No complaints on that one. I just don't like seeing a price and the register rings something different

Reviewer dogz

Good pizza but they forgot to place my wife's togo order so when I arrived, as instructed, twenty five minutes later there was 🙂‍↔️ thing that pick up. I had to reorder and wait in that boring dining room for a half hour more. Good pizza crust though