Goodfellas Pizza

We've lived right around the corner from these guys for about 7 years, and they never disappoint! New Yorkers have super high expectations for good pizza, and Goodfellas delivers on all big, gooey, juicy, delicious fronts! They are also very fast, with a friendly staff.

Great place to get pizza across from Overlook Manor dorm of Manhattan College. Had a large pizza with sausage and mushrooms and was over the top! Was my main pizza place years ago when I was in school and I'm sure it is still for the current generation. Look forward to many return trips.

Got delivery. Most pizza deliveries in area come with an overcooked stiff bottom crust. Goodfellas will, upon request, bake your pizza "Light." Very much like "Old style New York pizza." My family and I will stick to Goodfellas.

Best Chicken Parmigiana Pizza I ever had. It was made fresh, the amount of extra cheese, sauce and the way the chicken is cut was perfect couldn't have asked for better. It was soooo good. Get it! A+

Great atmosphere and fresh pizza. It's not easily assessable, and it's located in a remote hilly obscure residential area in Riverdale, but it's worth the trek if you're walking or care to drive but parking in this area extremely difficult!

Casual , relaxed atmosphere , easy take out or dine in option , Italian American done well in Riverdale

RayRay

Best Chicken Parmigiana Pizza I ever had. It was made fresh, the amount of extra cheese, sauce and the way the chicken is cut was perfect couldn't have asked for better. It was soooo good. Get it! A+

LKA

Great atmosphere and fresh pizza. It's not easily assessable, and it's located in a remote hilly obscure residential area in Riverdale, but it's worth the trek if you're walking or care to drive but parking in this area extremely difficult!

Eric Izik

Casual , relaxed atmosphere , easy take out or dine in option , Italian American done well in Riverdale

I've been getting pizza here for years, it's been a staple of my college experience. Quality hasn't dropped off, I don't know what the other reviewers experience has been like but I haven't noticed. My go to slice is their chicken vodka, very delicious.

Great Pizza and Amazing Food. Service was fantastic. Placed a phone order for my office, delivery driver was really nice. Prices compared to other was actually surprisingly low for the large portions. The guys in here can't get enough of the Meatlovers Pizza and the girls love the Vodka Sause. 2 Large house salads was enough to share with 7 people and the garlic bread was perfect. Highly Recommend!!!

Myself and my coworkers are always ordering form here! They’ve got great food both the catering menu and regular menu

Bought a sausage & ziti parm dinner and it was very flavorful. Sauce was very tasty and almost like when I was a child about a hundred years ago. Ok.. I am really not that old.

Alexander Molina Nenger

I've been getting pizza here for years, it's been a staple of my college experience. Quality hasn't dropped off, I don't know what the other reviewers experience has been like but I haven't noticed. My go to slice is their chicken vodka, very delicious.

Kathleen

Myself and my coworkers are always ordering form here! They’ve got great food both the catering menu and regular menu

cesar rodriguez

Great Pizza and Amazing Food. Service was fantastic. Placed a phone order for my office, delivery driver was really nice. Prices compared to other was actually surprisingly low for the large portions. The guys in here can't get enough of the Meatlovers Pizza and the girls love the Vodka Sause. 2 Large house salads was enough to share with 7 people and the garlic bread was perfect. Highly Recommend!!!

John Ludewig

Bought a sausage & ziti parm dinner and it was very flavorful. Sauce was very tasty and almost like when I was a child about a hundred years ago. Ok.. I am really not that old.

Very cool little pizza shop that boasts having the Worlds Best Pizza. That's a lot to live up to and they don't disappoint. they large brick oven stands out in the open kitchen and can be seen from almost anywhere in the small dining space. The huge windows offer a great view of the street as you dine on delicious slices of fancy pizza. They even accomodate 1/2 and 1/2 pies so you can experience more than one pizza. The wine list is also a big bonus and pairs nicely with the many different pizza's they offer. It may not live up to the Worlds Best title it prominently displays but it's damn good.

Pizza was good, very little sauce on the pizza though. The crust was nice and thick...yum! Can't go wrong with a slice of margarita.

Decent spot to get the Pizza by slice. They do have a nice variety of slices and the whole pies are pretty good too. They have daily special entrees which are decent as well and they have a limited seating. I usually order for delivery or pick it up to-go.

Meatball hero was excellent. Server was polite. I would rate 5 . But it was chilly night. When door open my friends were cold. You felt cold blast until door closed. I was good 👍.

Fast delivery, reasonable prices, nice people answering the phone (we've never dined in). If you get a menu, there are some decent coupons (free soda with pizza or $1-2 off a large type dealies). The pizza is ok, not great. But it is one of the better places in the neighborhood because there are a bunch of really awful spots. It's top 2-3 on our pizza delivery rotation list.

The Brushchetta pizza was delicious! The extra $4 to add bacon on half a pie was worth it. Didn’t get pics but the garlic knots were a bit burnt. Also the slices weren’t cut all the way through. Other than that though this was great NY pizza.

Corner pizza spot in Riverdale. Ordered 2 mushroom slices and got a polar seltzer $14.00. Slices were great as to no flop with the crust a nice sauce cheese balance and a ton of shrooms. Decent hard working staff was helping out a the local fire station ordered for 40+ right in front of me but no complaints. Overall solid pizza spot for good football pizza just a little too pricey but it was worth it. Goodfellas does a good football pizza.

Great tasting cheese slice, not thick, just has the right crunch and cheese. Nice pizza discount, 2 slices and fountain soda $6. My first time stop, I will revisit. Decor needs remodeling, their sturdy solid tables and chairs just needs refinishing.

Came here on a Saturday afternoon they were busy with deliveries, I got a regular slice to go , a bit much got a slice and a snapple 6 and change ,the slice itself id give it a 5 out of 10

Danira Vasquez

The Brushchetta pizza was delicious! The extra $4 to add bacon on half a pie was worth it. Didn’t get pics but the garlic knots were a bit burnt. Also the slices weren’t cut all the way through. Other than that though this was great NY pizza.

Jeff S.

Corner pizza spot in Riverdale. Ordered 2 mushroom slices and got a polar seltzer $14.00. Slices were great as to no flop with the crust a nice sauce cheese balance and a ton of shrooms. Decent hard working staff was helping out a the local fire station ordered for 40+ right in front of me but no complaints. Overall solid pizza spot for good football pizza just a little too pricey but it was worth it. Goodfellas does a good football pizza.

Jasmine Rivera

Great tasting cheese slice, not thick, just has the right crunch and cheese. Nice pizza discount, 2 slices and fountain soda $6. My first time stop, I will revisit. Decor needs remodeling, their sturdy solid tables and chairs just needs refinishing.

leonard

Came here on a Saturday afternoon they were busy with deliveries, I got a regular slice to go , a bit much got a slice and a snapple 6 and change ,the slice itself id give it a 5 out of 10

Food use to be so good. Idk what happen with the chicken parm. Maybe cheaper cheese,diff sauce but definitely not the same smh

Good pizzaria. Has nice selection of pizzas, and Italian heroes. Open every day. Does home delivery. Average price on its menu. Has 4 indoor dining tables, but no outdoor tables.

Ordered a Sicilian margherita pizza and wouldn’t order from here again. The flavors were good, but the crust was very tough and hard to chew. The cheese also seemed like it wasn’t fully melted.

The food was good, that wasn’t the problem. The problem was their delivery rider(male), he was very rude and disrespectful. I paid for my food, however I wasn’t the one who called so I asked how much to know how much I was supposed to receive in tips and he came a snappy remark. Then when I sensed the attitude and he gave me my money, I was going to give him a tip but because it wasn’t the amount he wanted he said something rude. My partner went outside to address him and the driver was nice to him.

Red Maple

Ordered a Sicilian margherita pizza and wouldn’t order from here again. The flavors were good, but the crust was very tough and hard to chew. The cheese also seemed like it wasn’t fully melted.

Luke Allison

The food was good, that wasn’t the problem. The problem was their delivery rider(male), he was very rude and disrespectful. I paid for my food, however I wasn’t the one who called so I asked how much to know how much I was supposed to receive in tips and he came a snappy remark. Then when I sensed the attitude and he gave me my money, I was going to give him a tip but because it wasn’t the amount he wanted he said something rude. My partner went outside to address him and the driver was nice to him.

Two stars because ive ordered from this restaurant multiple times and they have good food but it is now 10:55PM i placed an order at 8:45PM and I still have not received my food. This is the second time this happens and at this point it is unacceptable. I will be taking my business elsewhere as there are several other pizza restaurants in the neighborhood.

Nothing to brag about, even their "fresh" out the oven" pizza is dry and borderline tasteless. I would say its a good spot for college students but the relativity high price for low quality food subverts that.

Food used to be so much better- nearly doesn't taste the same anymore. Quality definitely changed

Gave this place a bunch of chances and it just misses the mark every single time. Tried a lot from pastas, pizza slices, pizza pies, garlic knots, salads. I would call this College campus food. Wouldn’t recommend to anyone. Definitely not authentic Italian.

I don’t know what happened but this pizza is burnt to hell lol. Almost as if someone forgot and left it in the oven for too long

Christian O

I don’t know what happened but this pizza is burnt to hell lol. Almost as if someone forgot and left it in the oven for too long

Got 2 slices with sausage. Way too much cheese for our liking. Cheese dominated the slice to the point you couldn't see any sauce and wasn't flavorful at all. I like a nice 50-50 ratio of cheese to sauce. There was enough sausage on the slices but no flavor like it was old. Very disappointing for the price.

C K

Got 2 slices with sausage. Way too much cheese for our liking. Cheese dominated the slice to the point you couldn't see any sauce and wasn't flavorful at all. I like a nice 50-50 ratio of cheese to sauce. There was enough sausage on the slices but no flavor like it was old. Very disappointing for the price.

Ordered a large plain pie and it was cold, and not tasty at all. It was as if though they had just reheated a pizza from 3 days ago. This has happened before, but I was thinking it's a one time thing. It doesn't seem so as it's the 3rd time they do this- I learned my lesson- don't be ordering from here again.

bed fella from goodfellas. The grumpy old delivery man was rude and ridiculous. I never saw a delivery person complain about tip. 2 dollars only? really? That's what I heard. He didn't even put out pizza box from his bag.

April 13th, 2020 The Bronx Delivery person with a pizza had no mask and no gloves. As we rode the elevator, it was unsettling. I had a mask and gloves on. When I asked why the restaurant didn’t provide him with a mask, he answered “cause I don’t need one.” Well, guess what, NOW YOU DO‼️ #goodfellaspizzashameonyou

They got my order wrong .. and got a cheese slice it was so nasty . Undercooked . By far Worst pizza in the Bronx. Lived in the Bronx my whole life never had such nasty pizza .

I don’t know who was cooking tonight but I ordered a chicken Marsala with linguine by far the WORST chicken Marsala I’ve ever tasted in my life they literally poured half the bottle of Marsala wine in it I didn’t touch my food the linguine was dry sauce def taste unseasoned don’t waste your money there I ended making a grilled cheese for dinner 💯🤷🏻‍♀️

the PIZZAS, one day good, one day bad, but the worst thing is the bad treatment from the two white people who work there, nothing professional, very arrogant, and the hygiene is disgusting. I only order when I'm starving and there's nothing more bad treatment they give, right? Do you know what it means to be professional?🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤧🤧🤧🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤧🤧😷😷🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

The customer service in this business is HORRIBLE!!! I placed a delivery order today at 6:36p and was told that the delivery would arrive between 40mins - 1hr. An hour passed by and no order. I decide to call to verify the status on my order. The individual on the other end of the phone said it would take another 20mins for me to receive my order given how busy they were. 20 mins passed by and still no order. I of course cancelled my order given that my kids were hungry. The person I spoke with did not even apologize & had an attitude. This is not the 1st time I encounter an unpleasant experience with this business. After today I will not be spending my hard earned money at this business, I rather save myself the headache and go to a different establishment.

Come on... This is horrible. You can see it is pitch black burned. That isn't right. You can't serve food like this. You clearly see it is burned. I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate receiving burned food like this. This is just wrong.

Ada Sanchez

The customer service in this business is HORRIBLE!!! I placed a delivery order today at 6:36p and was told that the delivery would arrive between 40mins - 1hr. An hour passed by and no order. I decide to call to verify the status on my order. The individual on the other end of the phone said it would take another 20mins for me to receive my order given how busy they were. 20 mins passed by and still no order. I of course cancelled my order given that my kids were hungry. The person I spoke with did not even apologize & had an attitude. This is not the 1st time I encounter an unpleasant experience with this business. After today I will not be spending my hard earned money at this business, I rather save myself the headache and go to a different establishment.

Catastr0fc M

Come on... This is horrible. You can see it is pitch black burned. That isn't right. You can't serve food like this. You clearly see it is burned. I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate receiving burned food like this. This is just wrong.

First time that i stop and i order a pizza slice and a beef patty and the young lady open the beef patty in front of me without wearing globes sticking her fingers into the patty without following any quality standard. I didnt say anything and took my order just to throw it away ones i got out. Train your employees propertly or hire better.

The food is horrible, inedible. A few years ago I ordered a lasagna that was tasteless and watery. Threw it out. Tonight I gave this place another chance. Chicken parm hero was awful, both taste and consistency. Will never try this place again. How do they stay in business serving such bad food?

Food is okay, pretty overpriced, but customer service needs a big improvement. It’s free to be friendly. They cater to Manhattan College so maybe it doesn’t matter, kids will still come back. But locals won’t. Being unfriendly while overcharging prevents locals from returning.

Pablo Guerrero

First time that i stop and i order a pizza slice and a beef patty and the young lady open the beef patty in front of me without wearing globes sticking her fingers into the patty without following any quality standard. I didnt say anything and took my order just to throw it away ones i got out. Train your employees propertly or hire better.

Sunny Paracha

Food is okay, pretty overpriced, but customer service needs a big improvement. It’s free to be friendly. They cater to Manhattan College so maybe it doesn’t matter, kids will still come back. But locals won’t. Being unfriendly while overcharging prevents locals from returning.

Judy wayne

The food is horrible, inedible. A few years ago I ordered a lasagna that was tasteless and watery. Threw it out. Tonight I gave this place another chance. Chicken parm hero was awful, both taste and consistency. Will never try this place again. How do they stay in business serving such bad food?