Ezra Rain

Stopped by before a concert for some food, excellent mini personal pizza, and garlic knots. Price was incredible for the amount of food received, and service was also really great. Very polite staff, we had such a great experience that after the show we decided to stop by again, now every time we go to St Vitus we've decided this will be our “go to” to eat.

Viktoriia Bochkova

The place is very welcoming. Pizza is tasty. My favourite one is with pasta! I was not expecting it to be so goood!

Jonathon Otero

Great food. Amazing service. Took my wife here 10 years ago for her first ever New York slice of pizza and brought her back recently 10 years later. We will always make our way back whenever in New York.

GREENPOINTMUSIC GREENPOINTMUSIC

🍝𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗡𝗘𝗪 𝗖𝗔𝗦𝗔𝗡𝗢𝗩𝗔'𝗦 ... definitely a deliciously, people filled good time tonight at the "new" Casanova's! The best part was the whole place talking across 5 different tables, laughing, reminiscing. All neighborhood people - from midi-gahn to gavone. It was Wonderful! I also got to have my tripe - and YES Thomas Panepinto they make it with patayta's & peas! It was like butter and the flavor was like my father's. The gol-uh-mod actually had tentacles instead of all pre frozen rings. I gotta tell-ya, I'd match it against any neighborhood gol-uh-mod! The gravy was wonderfully light and sweet marinara like. The Broccoli rabe tender as the gol-uh-mod with delicious neighborhood flavor. The owner Tony's wife prepared everything from the eggplant copanata and this very surprising sweet, cold pomodoro like mixture and olive oil they brought out for the "warm-up" - to the very homemade version of their Tiramisu... We went basic grilled chicken parm and regular chicken cutlet parm with macaroni's just to test it out. Nice portions. No surprises and very enjoyable. Tony sat and was broken-English BS'ing with us and everyone else in the joint all night. The service was good. The prices were right. We had a great night of food and people. I'm so happy they're back! More pics in comments...

Haley

In general, I really liked the atmosphere and decor of this place. It was a little noisy at times because of the nearby road, but its a great place for a romantic dinner. I'm giving 4 stars because the food was OK, but not great. It was a little bit pricey compared to other restaurants in the area and the pizza we had was dull and lacking in flavor. There is, however, a wide range of wine options available for a decent price. The tiramisu was divine.

Alex Hoshi

The menu is on the counter, and it's a bit inconvenient to read the list of ingredients without pictures. For some reason, the staff was not friendly to me, when my order was ready I could not understand where the payment terminal was and I was rudely told that I had to pay before leaving. It turned out that the terminal was far behind the counter and I had to give my phone to the staff so that they could bring it and scan it. The pizza is not bad, but for me, the price is too high for such a service

Sophia F.

I used to come here all the time and was excited they opened again. Unfortunately, the pizza was bad, couldnt even get myself to finish the slice. I gave them another chance again, but I can't say I'll ever go back. Bummer.

Kristin D

Loved this place but it appears to be out of business. The review here is not for the food, but for the fact that I placed an order and wasted a night, trying to get food for my family and ended up having to scramble to find a last-minute dinner before my toddlers bedtime. Wish I would’ve seen the latest reviews stating that whatjust happened to me, had happened to them; placed a pick up order online, walked over and saw a sign saying the restaurant was closed. Just “closed” — No information about whether this is temporary or permanent. Although they took themselves off of GrubHub, they’re still on other food service websites, including Chow now which is where I placed my order. If you’re out of business, that’s too bad because I really liked your food but please just tell people thank you.

Giana Ganesvoort

Showed up after placing a pickup order to a closed down restaurant. Work equipment and drills inside. Would be nice to know before wasting my time and money. Please take yourself off of online ordering sites like Grubhub and Too Good to Go

Steph Russ

Passed through this spot after a gallery showing. Thumbs and toes down! Pizza and customer service were in competition for most disgusting and they both won. I wouldn’t recommend to an animal. Run in the opposite direction! Just Yuck! 🤮

Lewis Gerendasy

I purchased a chicken parm hero. It was inedible. The chicken cutlet was an eighth of an inch thick and was rock hard. It was tougher to eat than a piece of leather. I had to throw the sandwich in the garbage. How can they sell this?