Mayflower

Olivia N

Overall rating: 4.6 Super cute and intimate spot. I went around dinner time so it wasn’t too crowded. The drinks were good but extremely expensive for the size of the place. It’s a great place for a night cap. I’d recommend if you’re in the area & looking for something quiet.

Benjamin Zelditch

Blink and you might miss this place. Awesome neighborhood spot for classic speakeasy cocktails. Love the understated vibe here.

Gustavo R

Speakeasy small unassuming bar with amazing drinks, very cool decor and excellent service. Perfect place for cocktails with a friend or two or with a date. Bartender is a master of his craft and can prepare you the most exquisite drinks based on your general taste preferences. A great time!

Kelly McComas

Cozy spot that fills up fast but if you find a seat it’s a lovely place for a drink. Service was great, space is small so it doesn’t get super loud.

What a great vibe! Kenny and Rose are excellent bartenders, highly recommend

5 stars, mostly because of Rose, the one woman show who filled my cup and my heart. #roseforpresident2024 Very cozy atmosphere, balanced cocktails, and fun music. Will be back! It is small and intimate though, so only go with small groups/people you really like because you won’t be able to shuffle around. More of a sit down vibe here. Perfect for date night

Such a cute spot! Went in on Tuesday and the bartender was friendly and helpful. It’s a sexy place to grab some mid-week drinks.

my favorite cozy spot! rose is honestly a genius of a bartender. i prefer mocktails, and she’s always whipping me up something incredible that’s unlike anything i’ve ever had before. vibes are super cute and everyone there is so friendly.

absolutely looooved this little bar, what a good little find. the bartender had the best vibes, she was so fun and really great to chat with. She was very helpful when we had questions about amaro and made us feel so welcome. we’ll absolutely be turning Mayflower into a regular spot for all future nyc trips

Cozy and welcoming spot; best for a date night or small group. Got there around 8:30 on a Friday and we were lucky to grab the remaining bar stools. The bartender was nice and friendly.

We only stopped there for a quick bite and a drink but I will definitely be going back. We both had Lobster salad and Marguerites. Everything was delicious. We ate outside. Inside seemed a bit noisy.

Very cozy, great seating, tight menu, & the drinks were excellent! My bartender was a delight - efficient, friendly, & helpful!

kenny was an truly amazing bartender, he + rose bring so much to the space. will definitely be back!

Kenny was the best. the place is so cute and drinks are soo good. such a cool vibe

This is such a cute, cozy spot! I came in on a Wednesday night and the atmosphere was great and the bartender was amazing—she was so attentive and fun. Will def be back!

Aja Brandman

Cozy and welcoming spot; best for a date night or small group. Got there around 8:30 on a Friday and we were lucky to grab the remaining bar stools. The bartender was nice and friendly.

Aaron Melocik

Very cozy, great seating, tight menu, & the drinks were excellent! My bartender was a delight - efficient, friendly, & helpful!

Olivia Mei

absolutely looooved this little bar, what a good little find. the bartender had the best vibes, she was so fun and really great to chat with. She was very helpful when we had questions about amaro and made us feel so welcome. we’ll absolutely be turning Mayflower into a regular spot for all future nyc trips

Monica Kim

my favorite cozy spot! rose is honestly a genius of a bartender. i prefer mocktails, and she’s always whipping me up something incredible that’s unlike anything i’ve ever had before. vibes are super cute and everyone there is so friendly.

Pamela Corzo

Kenny was the best. the place is so cute and drinks are soo good. such a cool vibe

Maximillian Lewis

What a great vibe! Kenny and Rose are excellent bartenders, highly recommend

Gretta Wilson

kenny was an truly amazing bartender, he + rose bring so much to the space. will definitely be back!

k B.A

We only stopped there for a quick bite and a drink but I will definitely be going back. We both had Lobster salad and Marguerites. Everything was delicious. We ate outside. Inside seemed a bit noisy.

Diana Bishop

This is such a cute, cozy spot! I came in on a Wednesday night and the atmosphere was great and the bartender was amazing—she was so attentive and fun. Will def be back!

Emily Kane

Such a cute spot! Went in on Tuesday and the bartender was friendly and helpful. It’s a sexy place to grab some mid-week drinks.

Julia

5 stars, mostly because of Rose, the one woman show who filled my cup and my heart. #roseforpresident2024 Very cozy atmosphere, balanced cocktails, and fun music. Will be back! It is small and intimate though, so only go with small groups/people you really like because you won’t be able to shuffle around. More of a sit down vibe here. Perfect for date night

Very cozy slightly hidden cocktail bar. Nice set of small tables for intimate drinks. Good date spot. I've been coming here for years. Always loved it. Unfortunately they recently sort of did away with menus (printed OR barcode scannable). I went in tonight, 11/23/24 and asked to see the menu. The young bartender, deep in convo w her friends, barely broke off her conversation to point to the handwritten menu over the side of the bar. No prices on the menu and writing very hard to see in the dim lighting. I stood there squinting at it for a bit, could not clearly read any of the selections and couldn't tell what anything cost and didn't want to interrupt her again to ask what the prices were (since she was deep back in her convo w friends) so I decided to take my money and order elsewhere. Too bad. It's a sweet place.

(Note: this review was posted late) This spot is as lovely and cozy as the reviews say but be aware of what seems to be a temperamental bartender. When I went late September she was too occupied with talking to her one friend at the bar than to answer our questions and tend to our group, and, when we were able to borrow her attention for a brief moment, she was short and dismissive. Almost as bitter as some of the amaro she serves

S

(Note: this review was posted late) This spot is as lovely and cozy as the reviews say but be aware of what seems to be a temperamental bartender. When I went late September she was too occupied with talking to her one friend at the bar than to answer our questions and tend to our group, and, when we were able to borrow her attention for a brief moment, she was short and dismissive. Almost as bitter as some of the amaro she serves

Joseph Roepcke

Very cozy slightly hidden cocktail bar. Nice set of small tables for intimate drinks. Good date spot. I've been coming here for years. Always loved it. Unfortunately they recently sort of did away with menus (printed OR barcode scannable). I went in tonight, 11/23/24 and asked to see the menu. The young bartender, deep in convo w her friends, barely broke off her conversation to point to the handwritten menu over the side of the bar. No prices on the menu and writing very hard to see in the dim lighting. I stood there squinting at it for a bit, could not clearly read any of the selections and couldn't tell what anything cost and didn't want to interrupt her again to ask what the prices were (since she was deep back in her convo w friends) so I decided to take my money and order elsewhere. Too bad. It's a sweet place.