The food is amazing!!! The lobster and fish is so fresh. The chef even went around to every table to ask what we thought of the food as well as took the time to talk to us about it. Where the fish came from and how he cooked it. The service is great, and staff is very attentive. I highly recommend this place. Perfect for a date night or even a family night.

Great service! Delicious food and great portions. Drinks were also delicious and our server Karen was great! She was very attentive, very kind and professional and explained the menu options clearly. RECOMMENDED!!!

First they have parking. Second you'll probably get your food before you get your table. However, Simon behind the bar is phenomenal.

I’ve been coming here at least twice a week this past month since they dropped their game day happy hour. It’s absolutely fantastic having $1 oysters pretty much all day. With oyster season back make sure to get these deals while it last!

My wife and I dined here not knowing what to expect beforehand. The service was great and the food was delicious! We enjoyed the appetizers and lobster. John our server did a good job of making us feel welcomed and even brought us complimentary glasses of champagne as we were celebrating our wedding anniversary. 👍👍

This place is beyond amazing! My first date there was with the love of my life, whose now my beloved husband. The food is to die for. The atmosphere was ecstatic, the view outside was beautiful. I stopped counting how many time I go over there lol. They have decent prices and great servers. I’ll give them 5 more stars. You guys are the best! My second home for sure!

Food and service was good. It's a bit pricey but hey its seafood, Red Lobster has cheaper prices but it's a different environment. We had courtesy bread and butter that they supply plus we bought appetizers which came at a decent time it made it feel like we were not waiting for a long time for the main course. The patio area is nice.

We dined 18 deep. It was a great time and an amazing Sunday. Everything was delish except the lobster bisque soup. It was brown, not orangey and not tasty. Nick work on that please because I love, love lobster bisque soup and have had many from Maryland, Rhode Island to New York and never ever was served brown lobster bisque soup.

"Awesome" Great atmosphere.Sat outside on the deck for a sunset dinner. The Staff was amazing 👏 Food was even better.Can't wait to go back again. KOREAN BBQ Rib tips where out of this world, Hats off to the Chef.

We went there for my birthday, the view is alway amazing. Our waitress was lovely. I ordered the surf and turf; my steak came out more cooked than what I ordered, and she was so understanding when I asked if it could be changed. Everybody's food was good and the portions are big. My suprise lava cake dessert was delicious too. Overall, a wonderful experience.

What an amazing restaurant. I have lived in this neighborhood for over 15 years, and I just tried it for the first time in June 2024. It is now November 2024, and I have visited Nick’s lobsters over 20 times. Omg, I have to chill. I love this place. The calamari, codfish tacos, jerk salmon bites, and the lobster cream pizza are amazing. Entrees: lobster cream pasta, the California roll, the stuffed shrimp..etc are all to die for. Thank you for being a staple in this little neighborhood of ours.

I grew up in the area and haven't been here in decades and just assumed it was an old restaurant. Beautiful upgrades and great views of the water. The food was delicious, huge portions. I had the branzino and it was great. The salmon and seafood risotto was delicious too! I will definitely be back!

We had such a wonderful time for our friend’s birthday! The only thing that needs improvement is our server . She didn’t ask if we needed anything after our meals were brought to our table. however, she may be new to the restaurant industry

My wife and I had such a nice dinner here on 7/23/22. Our waiter was friendly and the service all around was great. The oysters were fresh and delicious. They were also shucked very well. The steamed lobster was delicious. It arrived with the shell already cracked, you do not even need the nutcracker. Nick's did a great job renovating, the patio is right on Mill Basin with views of the large houses and docks across the way. It feels more like New England than Brooklyn. They also have a large parking lot. I highly recommend Nick's Lobster House.

+2

I always go here on a warm sunny day. Today I went and as always I’m still in love with this place. The food was fresh, flavorful & finger-licking good. My window seat was like being in dream, I could imagine waking up to that view. Floor to Ceiling windows catch a panoramic view of the docks along side a marina. This is Brooklyn. GO HERE!

Great time! A little expensive for the main dishes but you can game a little if everything seafood by picking a few of the more reasonable items + a main and then sharing on a random day. Better yet, they have specials on certain days, mostly middle of the week! Great views of the water and the across the dock neighbors. I'd say it's a great place small groups and nice rate evenings! Everything was tasty when my wife & I went for a weekend date!

+3

Been coming here with my family for my mothers birthday for years. Love this place! The seafood is always fresh! The view is beautiful. The staff is great and nice! Always love coming and hope to come back soon! We had more, but this was some of the good food

Just left and couldn’t wait to give review.. omg meal was beyond delicious, customer service was excellent and drinks was off the hook… my new favorite restaurant

The lobsters had very sad eyes, but i can say, they tasted delicious. This was my first time having an entire lobster and OMG... I don't have the knowledge to describe fully all the sensations. Over all, A+ to food, service, atmosphere and overall experience. The place has a rich menu and the wait time is not bad. (The only downside is that without a car, i dont think one will be able to get here easily, no public transportation). Overall, this place is excellent for romantic date night or family gathering. Absolutely recommended.

+6

The food, service, and esthetic was amazing! I will definitely return.

Salt was our waitress 💗 she was so great! Highly recommend. The lobster and shrimp scampi was cool to perfection. Love this place. A gem

Nick's Lobster House is a great place to bring family and friends. The atmosphere is great and the view is wonderful. The services is amazing and not to mention you food comes out relatively quick after your order is made. The selections on the menu are great and I believe you and yours will have a great dining experience here. When you get a chance ask for "Alejandro" he is very detailed orientated and will be very helpful when it comes to ordering. Please visit very soon and enjoy...........SWillliams

+6

Everything was good. Rachel, our server, was the best. The chicken noodles soup, BBQ wings, and Korean BBQ salmon sandwich, chicken alfredo, and lobster roll were delicious.

+2

What can I say from a kid to being totally in love with Nicks has been many years of true NY seafood deliciousness and love! By far “Nicks Lobster House” is the best seafood spot in Brooklyn and its service and menu is just awesome! You can come and buy fresh seafood here too! whats mores special, is “Nicks Lobster House” honored veterans veteran’s day 2024 and always make me feel at home (USAF) and my beau (USMC) as we are both veterans!

+1

This is my place to go..Period. The food is fresh and tasty. The drinks are great and the atmosphere makes it feel at home. The service is immaculate and everyone is so friendly.

I love the restaurant, good food and great view seeing the water, the owner is a nice kind person.

The service was excellent and the food was very good. They had nice live music; not sure if it’s daily or a special event.

+3

Came here to celebrate my son birthday! Our server Ricardo was excellent. He was super attentive. Food is always nice and fresh and delicious here. Portions size are huge.

+1

Beautiful view outside of the marina, tasty food and great vibe. Little pricey but everything is fresh and delicious. Non alcoholic mojito was priced as alcoholic one 16 $, but it was delicious and made just right as I ordered without sugar and syrups. I also ordered sushi "Brooklyn roll" without rice and it was no problem to make it and was absolutely delicious.

+6

august 29 2024 - very nice place, beautiful view of outside and the food is great. for the seafood risotto, it was a very salty, otherwise good along with the COD tacos! I tried the strawberry and mango flavored piña colada’s and they were awesome! also, Sylvia and the others are nice! 🫶🏼

Hands down some of thee BEST food I’ve had in a long time! I had to switch my reservation in the last minute and they accommodated this request, swiftly. I wanted to change my seat and they cleared a table by the water for me. The customer service was top tier and I will be coming back soon! Thank you for the New York hospitality, all the way from Philly.

+3

Excellent food, as usual. We started with soup (Manhattan clam chowder and lobster bisque, then 2 kinds of salad, with added toppings (salmon and grilled shrimp were our selections.) For dessert we chose lava cake with vanilla ice cream. Service was great, the staff was courteous, and overall a pleasurable experience!

Nicks lobster has beautiful views that one can enjoy while feasting on delicious seafood. I started at the bar / lounge area & enjoyed their $5 Margaritas, Red Wine & White Wine Sangrias. I also had yummy Salmon Cakes at the bar/lounge area for $10 (great proce). The cocktails were well-prepared & refreshing. I then ventured out to the dining area to enjoy the view while eating Scallops & a Baked Potato. While it was $50, which is a bit overpriced, it tasted good. The complimentary brad w/ butter is good as well. Rachel is attentive, friendly and nice. She took her time to explain the menu options as well as various bar specials. I had a fabulous experience and I will be back for more $5 cocktails! Thanks Nick's Lobster!

This spot is perfect for unwinding after work. They have a solid drinks menu—the cocktails are well-balanced and not too sweet, and they have a decent selection by the glass. But the real star is the snack/small plates menu. It’s ideal for sharing. We got a few things: the crispy potatoes with aioli were dangerously good, and the charcuterie board was high-quality and well-portioned. The atmosphere is buzzy but relaxed, making it easy to actually have a conversation. Highly recommend for a low-key evening with friends or colleagues.

vincent torrie

I came for lunch and it was very good.next week is restaurant week,i look forward to going there for dinner.ask for a seat overlooking the bay

Lyndon Johnson

This place was amazing. Family dinner with a party of 12 and the staff did not disappoint. We had our own area off to the side and the staff showed so much love. The food was amazing, the view is great because its right on the water. Bartender was amazing and so we're the drinks. I have nothing bad to say about this place and can't wait to return for another dinner. Soup: new England clam chowder App: dozen raw oysters Main: seafood kabobs/ veggies & rice rice Dessert: we bought with us a birthday cake - which the staff was more then helpful cutting and serving for us.

Hugo G

Great seafood gem in southern Brooklyn. Great food, excellent service. Beautiful company...what's more to ask for?

Tanya Seguinot

I have been coming to this place for years and I must say it is my favorite restaurant. Very friendly staff, great food and the atmosphere is very relaxing. I highly recommend this place.

+1

A Jackman

Wow 🤩 what an amazing experience for my birthday. I will definitely be back ! This was my first visit , but not my last. Waitress Irene was assertive, friendly, and professional. She made us feel like we were at home. The food was immaculate! The vibe and energy from the atmosphere made us not want to leave.

Karen Oliver

Celebrated wedding anniversary here. Best lobster I've had in a long time. The steak was also divine, can't wait to go back! The service was great, will visit during the day next time to take advantage of the outside sitting area by the water.

Eliana Hamilton

My friend & I had a taste for lobster rolls & oysters and a Google search led us to Nick’s where our craving was more than satisfied! The oysters hit the spot and we really enjoyed our drinks (a frozen guava piña colada and a giant margarita). But the star of the show was definitely the lobster rolls — delicious & flavorful, made with super fresh meat. We were pleasantly surprised that the portions are well worth the price. The pretzel bun and touch of Dijon made the rolls unique. It’s no wonder they’re a popular item on the menu! I loved everything (even the fries were perfect, crispy & well seasoned). My pre-birthday lunch felt like a getaway with the water-side dining and beautiful ambiance. The staff was so nice and attentive, making for a great experience. I’ll definitely have to visit Nick’s again next summer and try some other menu options.

Mercedes Landeta

My loving boyfriend suggested we should try the lobster 🦞 here and we received a huge dish full of seafood but just half a lobster, he was disappointed ☹️ for me it was delicious 😋

+6

C Griff

I got there right after work, 2pm. I enjoyed a cold Guinness as I waited for my food! 🍻 Everything was perfect! 👌🏽 I cannot complain!! ☝🏽😅😅😅

deanna chillemi

I’ve been here a bunch of times. Irene is an amazing server! We also loved Danielle. They were so sweet and attentive. The food and drinks are amazing and absolutely love the atmosphere!!

Mark Soto

Nick’s lobster house is a 4.3. It stays at the overall rating 4.3. Highlights for me where the Buffalo wings. Done well and organic. A surprise. The lava cake gets a new title. It’s called “the semi lava cake”. Or should we say the missing lava. The cake was absolutely tasty, so I’m definitely ordering it again but now I know it has subtle amounts of lava. My lobster pasta pasta dish was good, but it could’ve been a little more flavorful. Little salt maybe some additional spices. Spinach cilantro. My niece‘s dish was absolutely spectacular. Pasta with broccoli In garlic and oil. The Bronzino was also excellent. Now I had the Mojito, but I’m not sure if it was actually a Mojito or some other alcoholic beverage. But it was OK. If you like great atmosphere this is the place to go and the food won’t let you down.

+11

BLESSED

Nick's is an amazing indoor restaurant which also has a lovely side outdoor eating space... The ambiance is wonderful. It would make you feel like you're someplace else other than New York... Great seafood restaurant to have dinner or lunch at any time and also entertain guests.. the servers are very professional and knowledgeable about the menu choices. Also very attentive to customers needs.

Karena

This place is amazing!! Food was delicious, service was good, and atmosphere is perfect for date night! Lobster cream pasta was SO. GOOD. They give you so much lobster in there too. And the grilled octopus was hands down the best I’ve ever had. Couldn’t get enough of it!! It sucks there wasn’t that much :( I got the lobster tail pasta out of curiosity for their Valentine’s Day menu. It was ok. I do appreciate the whole lobster tail though. I honestly ended up just stealing from my boyfriend’s lobster cream instead 😅

Khumoyun Akhmadjonov

Recently, I had a wonderful lunch with friends at Nick's Lobster House, a place with a rich history and unique charm. We enjoyed the freshest seafood and a cozy atmosphere on the outdoor terrace, which made the meal even more enjoyable. The service was top-notch — the staff were very attentive and welcoming. Having a photographer with us helped capture all the great moments. Everyone was happy, and I’m glad I made this day special for all of us. Some may say the prices are slightly above average, but the experience is definitely worth it. Thank you, my friends Khumoyun Akhmadjonov

+18

Came here for Restaurant Week, I hadn't been in a while, and the interior has clearly been redone. The space feels refreshed, like it got a full facelift, while still keeping that classic Nick's Lobs…

Beautiful restaurant with friendly wait staff. Went for a family dinner and sat outside. Everyone enjoyed their dinner and left with tons of leftovers. Will definitely be back.

Beautiful restaurant with friendly wait staff. Went for a family dinner and sat outside. Everyone enjoyed their dinner and left with tons of leftovers. Will definitely be back.

One of our go to seafood places. Good drinks and service. Multiple sitting rooms with cozy interior, outdoor patio in the summer, overlooking the water. Over the years we've tried pretty much mos…

One of our go to seafood places. Good drinks and service. Multiple sitting rooms with cozy interior, outdoor patio in the summer, overlooking the water. Over the years we've tried pretty much most …

One of our go to seafood places. Good drinks and service. Multiple sitting rooms with cozy interior, outdoor patio in the summer, overlooking the water. Over the years we've tried pretty much most …

Restaurant has been there as long as I can remember and this was my 1st time going. Food was good and good customer service was good. I will return. Relaxing and friendly vibe. Diverse environment.

Restaurant has been there as long as I can remember and this was my 1st time going. Food was good and good customer service was good. I will return. Relaxing and friendly vibe. Diverse environment.

Once again yesterday we enjoyed another wonderful afternoon lunch at Nick's. Always greeted by Chef's Dimitrios staff today our always great waitress Rachel. All seats are great with view of Mill Ba…

Once again yesterday we enjoyed another wonderful afternoon lunch at Nick's. Always greeted by Chef's Dimitrios staff today our always great waitress Rachel. All seats are great with view of Mil…

What a lovely lunch we had at Nick’s Lobster House. And our server, Delisha was absolutely awesome! I will definitely visit them again.

What a lovely lunch we had at Nick’s lobster House. And our server, Delisha was absolutely awesome! I will definitely visit them again.

Great food Great food. We have not been here in a while and it has greatly improved. food delicious, ambience great. Lots of nice changes. Definitely will come again. And our server Stephanie …

Great food Great food. We have not been here in a while and it has greatly improved. Food delicious, ambience great. Lots of nice changes. Definitely will come again. And our server Stephanie was …

Great food at Nicks lobster House on our way to the airport - the caeser salad and the salmon are a must try. Stephanie our sever was great!

Great food at Nicks Lobster House on our way to the airport - the caeser salad and the salmon are a must try. Stephanie our sever was great!

Excellent service, great food! Our waitress Jaime was such an amazing person! Probably the nicest I’ve met in decades! ambience is very cozy. Will definitely be back soon!!! Five stars!!!

I had an amazing experience. Ricardo was our server and he did an awesome job. Went over all the specials, ensured that we received our drinks and food timely. Ricardo really made my first time exc…

Bekka was soooo freaking friendly. She advised us of the specials for the day. My tempura shrimp was fried to perfection & let’s not forget the juicy lobster.. please get the lemon drop drink it’s …

Bekka was soooo freaking friendly. She advised us of the specials for the day. My tempura shrimp was fried to perfection & let’s not forget the juicy lobster.. please get the lemon drop drink i…

Again we had a great lunch at Chef Andre's Nick's Lobster House in Flatbush/Mill Basin. It our all the time guarantee seafood restaurant for the last 6 years. What a great find. It was a delightfu…

Food was delicious. Very authentic clam chowder and the drink 'The Remedy', exceptional! Salta was very patient and knowledgeable server. Keep up the good work guys

Food was great, cocktails also good. Staff seems overwhelmed. Spent alot of time waiting for our food to come out and even longer for the check. Dinner cost around $200 (1 app, 2 entrees, 4 cocktails), including tip.

Food was very good! The bread served before the meal was nice. It was soft and warm 😊. The lobster ravioli with pesto sauce was yummy. We went on a Thursday and the daily special was buy one pasta dish and get the other half off. There is a lobster special on Tuesdays. They have updated the interior of the restaurant with new flooring, tables and chairs. Looks nice. There is also an event space adjacent to the dining area.

+1

Table reservation was quick and easy. The atmosphere was pleasant, but it was a 30-minute wait to order drinks and appetizers after arrival. I was not disappointed with the overall experience. Give it a try for yourself

Delicious seafood. The room is open and pretty simple. You're not there for the decor. But for the food. I went around 5:30 and it was perfect. It was not busy.

The food was good and the service was great. I came to Nick’s Lobster House for lunch. I was served by a young lady named Rachel with a very good attitude and a pleasant personality. I will be back.

+1

Our experience was amazing. The view at sunset is one of a kind. Our waiter Steve was extremely courteous. Even give us info on a never by beach to enjoy the rest of our night.

This is a lovely place by river, If it’s possible, get a table by the window for pretty pictures. Food is rather tasty and definitely good service by Alejandra who waited and checked on us several times during the dinner!

+1

This restaurant is open all year round with beautiful water front views. The oysters were fresh, stuffed shrimp a winner buttt the chicken parmesan was not that great. It was too thin and overcooked. Will be back to try other seafood dishes. Crème Brûlée was ok.

Been living in NY for years and always pass by this place on my drive. Always wanted to try them but never worked the nerve to attempt to go (the highway/road just gets to be a pain with oncoming traffic; especially when busy). But after going to movies, my brother and I wanted to try a new place. So we decided to try this place out. Definitely would call it an upscale Red Lobster. The view by the water is beautiful and the place is clean. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable. The food was good too (some was a bit oily honestly but the taste is there). Some of there drinks come in these mason jars too (and they are huge. About 2-3 drinks worth id say). Id definitely recommend the lobster and shrimp Alfredo pasta with broccoli, the bok chocochoy, creamy lobster pizza and their wings. I'm told their burgers are good too (Definitely want to try that one day). Food can be pricey and the bill can shoot up there if not careful. If like me and you pass by this place all the time but never tried them, give them a shot.

+6

The view is absolutely amazing and only outshined by the food. I had the oysters which were good! I also tried the lobster roll even as someone who’s not a big fan of lobster it was still good! My party also tried the salmon bites which weren’t as good as I thought it would be but still decent. My sister ordered the shrimp pasta which was a very large portion which could easily feed 2 people. My mom ordered the lobster tail and it was delicious as well. We came with an infant and they were very accommodating. So anyone coming with children know that there’ll be no hassle. Overall a good experience. I would return especially since they were not very packed and the food was good!

My visit was on last Thursday, directly from the golf course opposite.(Marine Park)..I live oos. The food was good the waiter was nice!warm! & friendly. Dinning outside is just breathtaking and refreshing. However upon arrival that lady honestly made me feel like making a U turn..She was very ...... and I observed her during my stay and what I noticed is not nice. Overall nice place. But needs an shift around with 'staff' PLEASE!

The wait staff were super polite and welcoming, one might even say charming. Was rather slow considering majority of the restaurant was empty. That being said the food was very satisfying and reasonably priced for the quantity, quality, and area!

We had a great corner seat and the service was excellent. If you’re not vaccinated, I don’t recommend seating indoors because almost all the tables are filled. The food was delicious, especially the shrimp alfredo- but my entire family and I were very nauseous a few hours later.

The venue is big with indoor and outdoor seating. The staff is friendly; they messed up on a couple of orders but gave us some free things because of it. I was pleasantly surprised by their buffalo wings, they were really good. I also recommend King crab, the chicken parmesan, and generally any of their seafood. The desserts were also great. Overall, it's a nice spot with good seafood.

The food needs a tune up. Manhattan chowder was a bit salty for my personal taste. New England was better. The seafood was great, snow crab was very yummy and lobster. A variety would be better , like half lb of each. The pasta wasn't too flavorful, but a good pair. The fries tasted like they used the oil from all day, probably what happens when you come for late dinner. But overall the atmosphere was nice. Family and date friendly. Servers were knowledgeable and helpful. I'd say a bit pricey for the quality of food. We can chalk it up as an off day. Worth a try!

+2

Let’s just start off by saying they were very professional at the front and got me seated in a timely manner especially as a walk-in, great seats with a view! Waiter well he was a little off beat never got me utensils napkins or even bread to go with my drink or nothing ! Even after my appetizer came to table. I had to ask a busboy cleaning tables around me for some napkins and utensils! I will say food was delicious but was a little upset about my “bowl” of lobster bisque. It literally only had two pieces of lobster in it and small pieces like the size of a quarter. Mind you I did upgrade from cup to bowl so I can have more meat! So let’s say I wasn’t to happy on that part but okay! Then the meal came out was awesome presentation and tasted great but guess what no waiter so again I had to ask another waiter to get me some butter! He did show up a lot near the end of meal! Overall great food!

+2

Chicken wings were a bit dry....stuffed shrimp good,chicken parm good but a bit chewy, the soups were hearty,good,flavorful, sparkling water a must, delicious....my granddaughter loved the lava cake....best of all was the waitress Rachael...professional, and sweet

A very large restaurant on the bay. Beautiful view of the water. Excellent parking. Tasty food. Large selection of the freshest seafood and more. Perfectly cooked lobster, squid, octopus and snow crab. Another pleasant thing is that there are fresh flowers on the table. The service is pleasant, but not fast. Having ordered a pitcher of Margarita, you can wait 20-30 minutes for it. Cocktails with the same name differ in taste. Cocktails have a very high percentage of ice. The prices are quite high. For a 5 person campaign I paid $600 for dinner.

+3

Alex Serebrov

This is old school Brooklyn's restaurant that specializes on seafood, lobsters in particular. They have big selection of live lobsters and fresh seafood. When the weather permits they have open deck seatings with a view on marina. The place got busy especially on the weekend, so reservation is recommended.

+18

Jing Chen

This is my third time visit Nick’s lobster house, we love the oyster. But this time my husband and I both felt the oyster too light, maybe over wash away the salty water. The chowder soup we had not very hot. The salad is normal, the grilled octopus is crispy and delicious.

+1

Calou Beckford

Nicks lobster was quality dining experience. They offer a parking lot, and waterfront views (the highlight of the experience). They have a full seafood menu with many of the classics such as salmon, lobster, crab, branzino, and more!! Service was slow, but our waiter mentioned that they were short staffed. They were friendly overall. I would definitely dine there again.

Cat Lau Hunt (clh1804)

This is a legit fresh seafood restaurant with a nice marina view, spacious interior, and good atmosphere. I have been here several times, and it's always a positive experience. The food is consistently on point, and the cocktails are quite good too. The portions are well-sized for an eater like me, you leave feeling full and happy. Being a seafood lover, this place is a go-to whenever I want fresh quality offerings from the ocean.

+1

How much is a potato worth??? Two local customers, apparently. We have been Nick's customers for years, having dined in for special occasions and hosting out of town guests. We went in tonight for a …

This is old school Brooklyn's restaurant that specializes on seafood, lobsters in particular. They have big selection of live lobsters and fresh seafood. When the weather permits they have op…

This is old school Brooklyn's restaurant that specializes on seafood, lobsters in particular. They have big selection of live lobsters and fresh seafood. When the weather permits they have open d…

This is old school Brooklyn's restaurant that specializes on seafood, lobsters in particular. They have big selection of live lobsters and fresh seafood. When the weather permits they have open d…

I visited on SAT evening. Here is the break-down of my points: \nFood: 2 stars - appetizer mussels were too salty. lobster roll was burnt and hard. \nDrink: 2 stars - wine was stale\nWaiting: 1 sta…

Unfortunately, I had high hopes for this spot as for it was highly recommended, but was let down. High prices for mediocre/bad food. For example: baked clams alone were $30, lobster roll $40 (whi…

Unfortunately, I had high hopes for this spot as for it was highly recommended, but was let down. High prices for mediocre/bad food. For example: Baked clams alone were $30, lobster roll $40 (which…

THE OG BROOKLYN SEAFOOD RESTAURANT\n\nNick's lobster House is a family-owned company that is comprised of a restaurant including an outdoor deck, seafood market and waterfront event venue on the Mi…

Greek salad was good but a small order. Fish taco was awesome and the east cost oysters were huge except 2 of them. The snow crabs were disappointing for $50. The atmosphere was awesome facing the …

Lobster boil was overcooked service was good but they are really overpriced. \nWon't be going back they charged for butter! Desert sizes are ridiculously small for the price and aren't all that g…

Alejandro was an excellent server. Top notch service and super friendly and accommodating. Service was also speedy. The chocolate brownie dessert was surprisingly delicious!

The service was excellent but the food just wasn't that great. I started off with the octopus appetizer and it was very good so I had high hopes for this place, I got the hurricane drink and it was good but they give you a glass of crushed ice so after two sips it's gone and in this economy I really dislike cheap tricks like that. After the appetizers they brought out the most delicious warm bread which is the bulk of the reason for the 3 stars. The seafood boil was decent but so salty and not really that flavorful. What I can say is that it's more then enough for two people.

Went for my birthday; I've had a bad luck streak of something always happening so we went to dinner here hoping for just a chill night Everything would've been fine but the waitress pretty much ruined the dinner She was judgey and rude and got one of our orders wrong then wanted to at first refuse to go fix it until we pressured her to fix it to which she did 😭😭 Our friend has low functioning autism which makes her prone to not being able to stand certain food textures when asked if she can get at least the chicken fingers on the kids menu the waitress gave us all looks and kept saying the kitchen won't allow it which I've never been to a restaurant that would deny that so we had to figure out alternatives We kept waiting for her to come to split our check/let us pay for our meal and she just never came when we went to another server to do it she came and then let out a "this is why we say to split the check before hand" when I asked about factoring in a tip The food was really good but my friends pretty much all agreed they wouldn't want to come back because of service alone especially when we are with someone with special needs who can't pick up on social ques So much for a good birthday lol

This is a nice spot. Has a great view of the water and you have the option to sit outside. You have to show vaccination proof so get it ready. The atmosphere is nice and the staff is good. The food is tasty. The steak was ok but didn't feel like it was worth $50. And a few mussels in my seafood plate had an off taste (yuck). So I guess I'll stick with good ole Clemente's Maryland Crabhouse which is in Sheepshead Bay area. They never dissapoint.

+4

I came here for a friends birthday yesterday and tried out a bunch of items on the menu. It was a Tuesday and the waiter did not tell us abut the special until I saw the sign when I left. My fault for not researching which is fine. Imo the cold bar is the only reason to come here. I ordered a cold platter which pretty much has everything is the way to go. My table got baked clams (sorry no picture) alright ..grilled octopus it was very good but portions are pretty small and a surf and turf as a entree. I’m not sure why I thought getting a steak was a good idea at a lobster house 😂 Still it's not bad like I said cold bar you can go wrong they do specials daily so it's pretty good. I can't give it any higher than 3* only cause I just wasnt a fan of the cooked portion of my food

Brought my husband here for a birthday dinner. I called ahead and thr person on the line was super helpful. Once we arrived the place is really nice..great location. We were shown to our seat and shortly after our waitress came. She was attentive. We ordered the Nick's sushi roll which was disappointing Not sure how ones messes up sushi. The hurricane drink was not good and soo much ice. As if it was a sushi. The fried seafood mix was not good. We did not eat it. It was bland, very bland. The sweet potato fries were crisp but also not good. I am going to chalk it up to the oil. The lobster bisque looked like gravy and I was not a fan. The fries tasted as if they are cooked in the same oil as the seafood. Which I hope not. All in all, I may try here again and ordered something different.

Went here with my companions out of curiosity. I mean when you drive by a place called "Nick's Lobster House" your mouth has got to water just a little. The decor there is really nice. And there are certain seats where you can see a lovely view of the water and all the homes near by. The staff was lovely and all worked together with catering each table. The wait for the food takes a while. I guess if your distracted by conversation you won't notice so much. Our appetizers taste good. Everyone at my table didn't enjoy their dinner though. I got the stuffed shrimp and I so would get it again, it's absolutely delicious. But my companions got (what I believe is called) the Colobiam lobster. They didn't like it. They said the sandwich was dry, they could tell it wasn't cooked before serving and that it must have been frozen over night. Only the fries were good.

2014 club music was blasting the whole time and really ruined the experience for us. The food overall was subpar - lobster bisque was a light brown color and not super flavorful and the lobster roll was not worth $40 to say the least.

I came back and this time was not satisfied. First let me say that staff was very kind while I was waiting for my pickup order sense I ordered togo. What got me disgruntled is the fact I ordered a $22 burger that tasted like something I can get at a family BBQ at a park without the lobster included. It wasn’t better than Five Guys, Smash-burger, Shake Shake which those are half the price I paid. Burger was well done when I asked for Medium. The Fried Calamari was actually good. My Fiancee said the Salmon was okay but not as good as other locations we goto. Out of everything my grandma enjoyed the raw oysters which is the saving grace. I paid $170 for everything but didn’t feel like $170 quality. I’ll most likely attempt to come back but for something else sometime soon.

+3

Leon

Service was good, food was decent. Grilled octopus has a good balanced taste. I'm not sure where they get their prices though, but if you have cash to burn, this is a decent option.

Went to Nick's Lobster for a date night with my hubby during Restaurant Week. The location is definitely a highlight, right by the water, and I can already picture how lovely this spot must be in the…

Went to Nick's Lobster for a date night with my hubby during Restaurant Week. The location is definitely a highlight, right by the water, and I can already picture how lovely this spot must be in t…

Went to Nick's lobster for a date night with my hubby during Restaurant Week. The location is definitely a highlight, right by the water, and I can already picture how lovely this spot must be in t…

Went to Nick's Lobster for a date night with my hubby during Restaurant Week. The location is definitely a highlight, right by the water, and I can already picture how lovely this spot must be in t…

We went with family to celebrate three birthdays occuring within one week. There were several pros and at least an equal number of concerns.. Pros Parking was easy We were seated immeadiately in a ro…

The waterfront view was absolutely stunning, and the service was attentive and friendly. However, the portion sizes were quite small, and the lobster bisque was a major disappointment - served without any lobster meat

After seeing this place over and over again on the Instagram feed it looked so great we just had to drive to Brooklyn from Long Island.. WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT 😞!!! Where do I begin??? We weren't thrilled with the drive in to Bk to begin with as we hit horrible traffic so our morale was a bit low.. We finally arrived and as we pulled in to park we noticed the sun was setting on the completely opposite side of the highway. So no sunset dining here ever... Ok... no problem... We're starving so lets get inside! We were guided into a small (the far left side) dining area... Not attractive but a decent window on the water atleast. We sat down and literally waited 15 Minutes and NO ONE came to the table. No hello, no water, not acknowledged at all.. NOTHING. Finally grabbed someone practically begging for attention... and got menus and some water!! We ordered a pitcher of Sangria which is literally $59. and was not really good at all. The Lobster bisque was SO SO and BARELY any pieces of Lobster 🦞 in it! Booooo. The bread was stale.. by the way... so dipping it in the soup made it edible. I had the surf and turf... for $75.. Probably the WORST, driest, most tasteless Lobster I've ever eaten. The turf part was a thin piece of meat with tons of fat and gristle. The small piece of corn on the cob was stringy and plain. Yuk. The potatoes were average and boring. The carrot cake for dessert was ok and the rice Pudding was decent. Needless to say we will NEVER be back here EVER AGAIN. When someone came in and requested to sit outside they were told there is a MAJOR mosquito issue.. like really bad... EW! I hate to give a bad review BUT.. SAVE YOUR TIME AND MONEY!!! This place BOMBED HORRIBLY!!! BOOOOO

+6

This is my family and I second time coming here. I don't recall the food being this terrible the last time we came which was before them renovating the restaurant. The food was bland, and was just terrible. I can only say the service was good and they were friendly and patient. Only my daughter enjoyed her chicken tenders and French fries. My lobster sandwich was so bad that I kept picking at my daughters food. My husbands food wasn't as bad as mine but almost. The pasta.... seemed as if they just boiled the pasta and threw the sauce on. No salt, pepper, oregano, ms. Dash..... nothing. We won't be coming back.... now I see why we haven't been back in the last 3 years.

Went yesterday for a prefixed menu and comedy show with a group of 15 They Advertised “colossal jumbo, shrimp, stuffed with seafood”. Received medium shrimp with breadcrumbs, no seafood stuffing, etc. Took very long to get very small appetizers, the main meal, and even longer for dessert which came after the show is over, lights were on and people are leaving. We were not asked about coffee or tea. More than half of us were unsatisfied with the meal and the service, although the server himself was very Personable. Would not recommend this restaurant.

Amy H

I use to really enjoy Nick's. I haven't been here in a few months and decided to visit . I loved their lobster cream pizza until today there was a huge Crack in my mouth due to a piece of lobster shell in the pizza and then I also got to Alfredo with chicken which was 32 dollars . I never recalled that being the price. No refills on soda and I have to pay a merchant fee if I want to use my card . For the prices you guys are calling you need to be that more upscale reasturant . I could go to Maggianos which is cheaper and much better for this . Not to mention biting into a peice of lobster shell. Absolutely horrid!

Be warned that this place charges a 20% service charge on top of the overpriced menu prices for the total amount of the food. I spent over $400 for a small dinner for a family of 4. Don't go to t…

Ironically after our bad experience here I heard on the news they were honoring vets for veterans day MAYBE THEY SHOULD RESPECT THEM AS WELL. MOST OFFENSIVE TO THEIR BAD service IS THEY ADD A TIP W…

This review is solely for the lack of good management and service.I cant rate the food because it never came...we waited 20 minutes for the waiter to come.when he finally came i ordered drinks and …

First time visitor and to be honest I was very disappointed in the food . I got a lobster roll and it wasn’t that great , had very little chopped lobster , tons of paprika and was just not good . My guest had the fried mixed platter and the batter was not good . The calamari was so hard we couldn’t eat it . The whole dish lacked flavor and salt. Shrimp was over cooked. The tarter sauce was nasty and tasted like mustard and cumin . Very disappointed. Not worth the price . I won’t be returning and I wouldn’t recommend this place .

Been going to nicks for years, usually my family and I eat at the restaurant and have a wonderful experience delicious food with great size portions, this time we decided to order take out(big mistake) when we got home with our food, my Cesar salad was not in the bag and the food was horrible. Two orders of the seafood mix ,the calamari was extremely hard ,the fish was falling apart like it was old. Lobster roll was very dry , the fries was such a small portion and were hard as well. I paid over $100 dollars for my order and we couldn’t even finish it. Nicks restaurant I’m very disappointed in the take out food. Over $100 dollars in the garbage

Place looks pleasant both inside and out. Amazing waitress WARNING: DO NOT ORDER SPECIALS 😑 ESPECIALLY "SEAFOOD FEAST" The whole plate "EVERYTHING" was rubbery either over cooked/over heated or over microwaved. Props to my server Valeriya S. She made it clear to the manager that the food was cold 🥶 and rubbery and I was gifted 2 appetizer. 😆 lucky me. But one the the food looks amazing 👏 but tastes like rubber 😜. I've been here before never had such an experience.

+2

Went for an early dinner with family and we were all very disappointed. The food was dry and flavorless. The service, although the waiter was a nice guy, he had a large party that came in after us that consumed all his time. We had to wait for even a fork and dinner was slow to come out. I wasn’t going to leave a bad review until we all got up this morning feeling sick. Never again!!!! Spend your money elsewhere cause I the prices are high and the place isn’t worth it!

Worst service ever. They informed us that there was an half hour wait. We got here then it was said an hour wait. It's been 3 hours waiting with the additional 10 minutes and you are next. It just not worth it. This place needs a better management so as to respected their customers time. Finally seated and we come to see that there are many tables available. Awful if you want to come to this place u will need s reservation and even so you will have to wait. Do not come here on special occasion. The waitress was outstanding.