Stacey Love

I got a to-go order so I cant comment on the atmosphere, but the staff is super friendly! was my first time ordering from Mister M's and will definitely return in the future. I got the chicken parm chips and breaded mozzarella. the chicken parm chips are 10 out of 10 for sure! was slightly disappointed with the breaded mozzarella, but im super picky. was still good, just not for me. plus the prices are great, especially nowadays. definitely nice size portions as well! thanks for a delicious dinner 💗

Danielle Difrancesco

The food and the service here was great! Caprese was fresh, chicken wings crispy and saucey and my sandwich was massive and delicious. Will definitely be eating here again.

Michael M

The "Mister M's experience" is a culinary delight. Exquisite Italian cuisine prepared and served personally by the owner and proprietor. John and his buddy, Quiggs, served up a seven course meal, by reservation only, for a seating of six, that can be best described as stupendous! Reservations require months in advance, that is how good it is. Book it!!!!

Joelle Gurnoe-Adams

We found a gem! Our food was delicious, service was great and the atmosphere very friendly. My husband had wings and I had a Buffalo chicken wrap. We will definitely be back next time we are in town.

Jennifer “Jaypez423” Perez

**Review: A Hidden Gem for Italian Food Lovers** Tucked away on a quiet street, this small, cozy Italian eatery is a delightful find for anyone craving authentic flavors in a warm and inviting atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the rich aroma of fresh garlic and herbs, instantly transporting you to the heart of Italy. The menu is thoughtfully curated, featuring classic dishes made with high-quality ingredients. The pasta is homemade, and you can taste the difference in every bite—al dente and perfectly seasoned. The sauces are rich and flavorful, with just the right balance of savory and tangy notes. Their pizza, with its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings, is a must-try. What truly sets this place apart is the ambiance. The intimate setting, with soft lighting and rustic decor, makes it perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet meal with friends. The staff are friendly and attentive, adding to the warm, family-like atmosphere. If you’re looking for a spot that serves delicious Italian food with a personal touch, this charming little restaurant is definitely worth a visit. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel at home while delivering a dining experience that’s nothing short of exceptional.

+1

Jerry T

Newly opened spot. The pizza, wings, rice balls and steak and cheese sub, were all very good. Note: let them know how to cook your wings (which are huge), mine could have used a few minutes more. But flavor was great

Mike D.

Sat at the bar to grab a quick bite. The bartender was great and made some helpful recommendations. Definitely order the fried pickles. They're sliced up and filled with italian meats and cheese. It was fantastic. I ordered the chicken wings and they were cooked perfectly. Crisp but not overcooked with the right amount of sauce.

Micheal

Fresh out the plane looking for a little bite to eat later in the evening so we ran across Mister M. The portions were good. The homemade chips were great to go with my sandwich. The garlic Parmesan wings were OK and the blue cheese had chunks just like I like. I typically just drink water but tried the grape soda which was perfect to top of the meal. Good deal for the money.

Cliff Kendzia

Hot pepper roll ups were great. Wings and Sauces were on point. We didn't have the chicken parmesan looked great. It's was a huge serving. Definitely recommend visiting

Chel O

I came in late on a week night after a long travel day. The bartender was extremely personable and the kitchen took me as the last order. I was able to order the cauliflower crust pizza with steak and it was amazing. The crust was light and crispy and tyne pizza had amazing flavor. Thank you for a wonderful first day experience.

Christopher Frankhauser

Have you ever wanted to go to a place so bad because of the hype ? well this was the place for us .We have heard so many good things about this place. first I would like to start off by saying the only reason this place is even getting 3☆ is because of the friendly staff the bartender was extremely nice and helpful and even the cook came out and was also very nice and did everything to make sure we where happy . The food came out very fast and I can see why. I have posted pictures of the items we ordered we have never been here before and we decided to order alot of food to sample and to take home to eat later . we order apps Pretzels that are definitely ( microwaved) and deep fried mozzarella .Right off the bat the so called Beer cheese was canned nacho cheese witch was served cold until we asked for another one . the mozzarella cheese was awesome besides the cold sauce it was served in . Next we ordered BBQ wings on the pitt . but I guess there broiler broke 🤔 hummmm on the pit means grilled but what do I know . so we ordered garlic parm we also order the half pizza half Calzone and the famous roast beef. boy I was surprised let's start with the wings if you like butter mixed with Parmesan this is the place to go . absolutely no flavor at all besides butter . We decided not to try the pizza until we went home later that night. it wasn't that bad but again lacking something ( herbs or something) . O.K now let's get to this beef on weck.Honestly in my 29 years of life that I have been able to eat on my own I have never had a sandwich so bad. This item should be removed from the menu and the kitchen staff should be Ashamed to even call it a beef on weck. (pictures tell the story ) the roast beef had to be cook for the last week it was so dry the extra auju couldn't even help it out and the over toasted roll just brought my mouth back to a childhood experience when I eat sand. I try to never give a bad review even when I am not happy and I never take it out on staff because I have worked in the industry for the last 25 years but the food here is one for the books. and hope that something is done because this place has a very beautiful bar and very friendly staff

+2

Lori Felvus

When we entered the restaurant my husband and I was greeted very warmly by the bartender which was very nice but leaving was a different story. The chix fingers with slider sauce were excellent but the fries and the cheese sauce for the warm pretzels were stone cold which should be at least heated up. As for my husband and I leaving the restaurant was very disappointing when the waitress insinuated that my husband left the restaurant without paying. I have worked at St. Mary’s Hospital for 32 years and my husband has been a truck driver for as long as he could drive a truck has never ever left a restaurant without paying for our meal and we have been married 44 years. We are very honest people and yes I took that personal. I just stood there in disbelief when she blurted out “Maybe he walked out” I get it our waitress was just making sure the bill got paid but the other waitress should have minded her business. Shame on you for making your customers feel that way.