Ethan Cook

Friendly staff, 8pm Monday, not very busy, clean place to sit down. Pizza was interesting, The crust was thin in some areas and thicken others The bottom was not cooked all the way yet the top had some burn marks on it.

Ashley Blankenship

We ordered the gluten free pizza based on a flyer we received in the mail. The pizza looked lackluster when I picked it up, but hey - pizza, am I right? Flavor was reminiscent of Pudgie’s sheet pizza, but the crust center was doughy and over soaked with sauce. I asked a friend who ordered from the Horseheads location and she said hers did not look like this and was delicious. Total cost for this pizza was $16.47. Pass on the gluten free pizza at this location - Anellio’s is doing it better.

Ryleigh

My boyfriend and I decided to order subs since there was a coupon. It was buy one get one free. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak while my boyfriend got the burger sub. The cheesesteak was super greasy and lacked flavor. It was very bland and soggy. My boyfriend asked for no mayo on his sub and it came with mayo anyways. Besides that my boyfriend liked his sub, I on the other hand didn’t really like mine too much. (Corning pudgies)

Marie Hall

Probly won’t ever order from here again atleast not the Stromboli I got raw dough wasn’t impressed😡 especially sense I spent $60+ on the order.

Paula Mae

The pizza i ordered was awful 😖 I got the buffalo chicken wing pizza and the pizza itself was undercooked and the chicken was over cooked.. the other pizza i got was the meat sauce pizza and was just ok. I've gotten these both from the horseheads location and they are 10x better. Definitely won't be going to this location again. Also the customer service was awful no greeting when we walked in.

Elliott

Worst pizza I've had in a long time. Some frozen pizzas are better. What a waste of time and money.

Jennifer Evans

THIS IS AT THE Corning location.. The Cold Sub $7.50 on Wednesday ya supposed to have a coupon yet the coupon says NCP needed. I ordered my 2 subs on line so I didn't have to wait for them to make them. I was going to pay in-store option. Get ready to pay and I'm charged full price!! I explained it is the cold sub offer day and I seen it on FB the add on FB says nothing about a Coupon.. 2 workers said I needed one. That I needed to print it out .. ( when I left paying full price because I was not going to make a big show of how upset I was ) I get home look up coupons on the Pudgies website. It clearly states no coupon needed.. I will not go back !! I purchased subs because I was getting a deal ..False advertisement is what they are doing. I should of known better Dandy subs are cheaper and better trying to save a few bucks . Live and learn ( I would of given zero stars 🌟 if it was an option)

Robin Colegrove

Matt says they don’t guarantee your food to be delivered hot. WOW!!!! Got our food over an hour after delivering online and over 45 minutes after our message says it was out for delivery. It was received an hour and five minutes after ordering cold, wet and soggy.

Madasyn Ramsey

Ordered 2 slices of Buffalo chicken. It was probably the greasiest pizza I have ever had, I could not even eat it. I do not recommend. I would go to Rico’s or Aniello’s they have way better pizza.

Maria Cuda

I ordered online a large ham and cheese sub and a soda. My order was a couple dollars short for delivery so I had to order another item so I got Mozzarella sticks. My total was over $21 for one person then The order arrives in the ham and cheese sub had four slices of burnt ham on it couldn’t find cheese lettuce and one tomato small pc onion mushy and I live two minutes away I won’t order it from there again good luck I ordered online you should have the records