Vinny's Pizzeria

Daniel Dambrosio

Hadn't had a calzone in years, so I decided to give them a try. To my amazement, that calzone was PEEFECT! Now, I have to resist the temptation to go back regularly and gain weight, lollll. Small family operated pizzeria with a few tables. The menu is extensive. it looks like everything is freshly made. The corner that Vinny's occupies seems to be occupied by some loud fellows, but in truth, they're probably harmless. This is a basic, no frills location that seems 100% legit. Give them a try. Addendum... I ordered a large two topping pizza, should have been $15.00 + $8.00 = $23.00, plus tax =$25.01. Order was entered as an EXTRA LARGE, should have been $17.00 + $8.00 = $25.00 + tax = $27.19. Why the hell did they round up to $30.00? Plus I kicked out a $5.00 tip!!! If you order delivery, INSIST on a receipt showing the math!!! How DARE you guys exploit a cancer afflicted wheelchair bound senior citizen!!! You should be ashamed of yourselves!!!!! Att. Fernando, your offer of a $2.00 refund was an INSULT. When I come back in person, I will make it understood that I do NOT tolerate shifty business practices!!!!

Vic da G

First time here. Got here with my work partner. We both got One regular slice, one buffalo chicken pinwheel, one pepperoni pinwheel. Everything was tasting great. Between that regular slice and the buffalo pinwheel idk which was better. Loved it. Plenty flavor and not too much grease! I don't like greasy pizza. Everything was just right. I'll be back

My local neighborhood walking distance pizza spot of choice if I don't feel like driving to Rosa's or From Rome to Brooklyn pizzeria. They make a mean plain slice and personally its the best one around. Vinny's has been around for a while and for good reason.

Okay I'm not going crazy. I've been eating Vinny's pizza since 1980, and it's not the same. I usually order the Sicilian, but I didn't like the taste. A few days ago, I said let me order their regular pie with extra cheese. I do not like the taste of the sauce. They added something to it I don't like. They need to go back to the old recipe. I threw out what I didn't eat, never did that before. I remember meeting the guy who used to work there all the time on the bus a few years back, but he retired. This is not Vinnie's pizza, they need to change the name.

I like the pizza but that's about it. When ordering spaghetti and meatballs, the meatballs are undercooked and full of bread crumbs. The sauce is very sweet and uneatable. I did mention this another time and I was told " well, most of our customers ask for a sweet sauce." Last night's dinner unfortunately went into the garage. I just couldn't eat the sweet sauce and undercooked breadcrumb ball's (meatballs.) Management is pretty good about it and offered something different but, I don't want to go back outside in the freezing weather 🌡️. I'll continue ordering pizza but that's it.

Abraham

I like the pizza but that's about it. When ordering spaghetti and meatballs, the meatballs are undercooked and full of bread crumbs. The sauce is very sweet and uneatable. I did mention this another time and I was told " well, most of our customers ask for a sweet sauce." Last night's dinner unfortunately went into the garage. I just couldn't eat the sweet sauce and undercooked breadcrumb ball's (meatballs.) Management is pretty good about it and offered something different but, I don't want to go back outside in the freezing weather 🌡️. I'll continue ordering pizza but that's it.

rioleo8

Okay I'm not going crazy. I've been eating Vinny's pizza since 1980, and it's not the same. I usually order the Sicilian, but I didn't like the taste. A few days ago, I said let me order their regular pie with extra cheese. I do not like the taste of the sauce. They added something to it I don't like. They need to go back to the old recipe. I threw out what I didn't eat, never did that before. I remember meeting the guy who used to work there all the time on the bus a few years back, but he retired. This is not Vinnie's pizza, they need to change the name.

The pizza tastes pretty good, but they didn't put a plastic table on it, and half the cheese was stuck onto the box.

Christian Arlet

The pizza tastes pretty good, but they didn't put a plastic table on it, and half the cheese was stuck onto the box.

I knew this pizza was going to be nasty! My family came to visit from out of town and they wanted to try NYC pizza. We ordered a half cheese and half pineapple. IT WAS HORRIBLE!!!! It was worse than thought! Who puts sugar in pizza dough and tomato sauce? Pizza sauce does not need that much sugar. Pizza should be savory and not sweet! At least the guy who took the order gave me a small $1.50 discount. But I’ll never order from this shop again. Please 2 Bros. Open a shop here in LeFrak City. You’ll put these two disgusting pizza shops on 57th Avenue out of business!

I’ve never had an antipasto salad with broccoli, carrots ,yellow American cheese, Green olives instead of black olives, and a teaspoon of dressing, I am very dissatisfied with this salad.

Of all the pizzerias I've ordered from in the 30 years of living in NYC, this is by far the worst. 1) delivery driver was 20 minutes late because he walked into the wrong building on a completely different street and blamed it on me saying "it's because it's your first time ordering" oh and I had to meet him street level... 2) ordered a pepperoni pie, received plain 3) ordered veggie slice and received a cheese slice with 4 bell peppers and 3 olives on it. Called and the guy apologized and said "we'll send you the correct order and you can keep the other pie". I thought he did the right thing and cooled myself off saying things happen and they fixed it. Delivery driver comes up and hand me the correct order and says now I need to return the other pie. I don't care for the other pie but don't say one thing and do another. Worst establishment ever dealt with.

DO NOT BUY THIS PIZZA , they should be ashamed of themselves for the garbage they call pizza. Even if they hadn't brought my pie all messed up the flavor and textures are all bad this should be a dollar slice joint at most.

This pizza shop is really unhygienic. There are cockroaches on the pizza. Too disgusting. I want to vomit. Never order their pizza in the future

$3 for a regular slice. this thing is dry as a cardboard box. WHERE’S THE SAUCE?

Michael D Sells

I knew this pizza was going to be nasty! My family came to visit from out of town and they wanted to try NYC pizza. We ordered a half cheese and half pineapple. IT WAS HORRIBLE!!!! It was worse than thought! Who puts sugar in pizza dough and tomato sauce? Pizza sauce does not need that much sugar. Pizza should be savory and not sweet! At least the guy who took the order gave me a small $1.50 discount. But I’ll never order from this shop again. Please 2 Bros. Open a shop here in LeFrak City. You’ll put these two disgusting pizza shops on 57th Avenue out of business!

christina brantley

I’ve never had an antipasto salad with broccoli, carrots ,yellow American cheese, Green olives instead of black olives, and a teaspoon of dressing, I am very dissatisfied with this salad.

Alex Shaulov

Of all the pizzerias I've ordered from in the 30 years of living in NYC, this is by far the worst. 1) delivery driver was 20 minutes late because he walked into the wrong building on a completely different street and blamed it on me saying "it's because it's your first time ordering" oh and I had to meet him street level... 2) ordered a pepperoni pie, received plain 3) ordered veggie slice and received a cheese slice with 4 bell peppers and 3 olives on it. Called and the guy apologized and said "we'll send you the correct order and you can keep the other pie". I thought he did the right thing and cooled myself off saying things happen and they fixed it. Delivery driver comes up and hand me the correct order and says now I need to return the other pie. I don't care for the other pie but don't say one thing and do another. Worst establishment ever dealt with.

juan henriquez

DO NOT BUY THIS PIZZA , they should be ashamed of themselves for the garbage they call pizza. Even if they hadn't brought my pie all messed up the flavor and textures are all bad this should be a dollar slice joint at most.

Edison chen

This pizza shop is really unhygienic. There are cockroaches on the pizza. Too disgusting. I want to vomit. Never order their pizza in the future

Simon Li

$3 for a regular slice. this thing is dry as a cardboard box. WHERE’S THE SAUCE?

Ordered through seamless. Only ordered 2 slices and seamless added the 15% to tip. I live a half mile away and the delivery guy arrived yelling and screaming that his tip was only $2. The food wasn't secure in any form and in fear I didn't bother eating it cause he may have tainted it from his distress. Will never order again from this establishment.

I asked the person in charge.How much for 2 slice, he said seven dollar, one dollar for the soda. 8 total ok. After I came out from the restroom, he told me 9 dollar I asked him, why ? Can you tells me 1 dollar to use the restroom. I told him, are you kidding me? You never told me that. He's worse than a thief. I will never go back to buy anything in here.

The delivery was demanding more of tip even though I tipped him 6 bucks and was complaining, thought that would work since I didn’t have lot of cash on me at the moment. Just very rude and unprofessional

For anyone going here looking for vegan pizza, don't even park. Another comment led us to believe they have vegan pizza, but when we asked they pointed at the veggie pizza, and when we asked if the cheese was vegan... They don't know what the word means.

Victor Zamora

The delivery was demanding more of tip even though I tipped him 6 bucks and was complaining, thought that would work since I didn’t have lot of cash on me at the moment. Just very rude and unprofessional

Elijah Bohorquez (comfortablegrey)

For anyone going here looking for vegan pizza, don't even park. Another comment led us to believe they have vegan pizza, but when we asked they pointed at the veggie pizza, and when we asked if the cheese was vegan... They don't know what the word means.

Brian Ramirez

Food is horrible. I got food poisoned 2x's.

Ali Abdo

Ordered through seamless. Only ordered 2 slices and seamless added the 15% to tip. I live a half mile away and the delivery guy arrived yelling and screaming that his tip was only $2. The food wasn't secure in any form and in fear I didn't bother eating it cause he may have tainted it from his distress. Will never order again from this establishment.

Daniel Ramos

I ordered my food at 6:10pm- I didn't receive it until 7:50pm! I know sometimes it gets busy but to wait that long when the restaurant in only 2 blocks away is beyond me. I called the restaurant at 6:58pm and was told it was ALREADY out for delivery and should be here soon. When it was 7:25pm I spoke to a Slice representative that was told that it was just sent out for delivery and should be there in a few minutes. I called the store again and first they asked me to repeat my order three times for some reason, and then said the delivery person left the store with 5 orders to deliver. I also work as a pizza chef so I understand if they have alot of tickets and are busy, but to take nearly two hours for a local delivery is unacceptable. To add insult to injury THEY FORGOT THE GARLIC KNOTS I ORDERED!!!