Jenna

A favorite of ours! The vibe is always chill, the beers on tap are great, and the sandwiches are tasty. Love to grab a bite then do a little shopping up front for tea & snacks!

Zach Greenfield-Feig

This place has absolutely fantastic coffee. They also serve pretty decent breakfast. I really like working here and I like the idea that I could work on the coffee shop side all morning, and then switch over to the pub in the afternoon / evening and have a beer!

Ali Vidler

Wow the smell in here is amazing! Made me hungry instantly. It’s a great shop with wonderful staff and has some areas featuring local art.

+6

Giveita Shank

The mochas are solid but just a warning a large with a flavor shot will cost you over $8

Jared Wood

The space is great. Very clean, and well curated with nice furniture, and a great gift shop selection. The coffee is also pretty good. Staff was really friendly and attentive. My only critique is the egg used on their breakfast sandwiches. Soggy, no flavor and very similar to a gas station sandwich. I was quite confused, as everything else seemed like they care about their quality. Baked goods next time🙂

Rachel McElroy

Friendly staff but underwhelmed by the coffee and avocado toast for the price. Mocha had very little chocolate flavor and hazelnut syrup was also bland. The iced coffee had an unpleasant aftertaste. Avocado toast: I was hoping for real avocado but it seemed like a prepackaged spread.

Jen Scordato

Time for a name change the Ithaca Coffee Company is so focused on the beer and back of the shop they don't sell coffee - so frustrating to go into a place called coffee company and be told that they are not making coffee. It's extremely hit or miss for getting a coffee in the afternoon and on your way home from work. Very disappointed in what used to be one my favorite shop local places.

Christina Luo

This review is strictly for the cafe part of the store. I got an iced oat matcha latte and rooster sandwich. Matcha is fine, not bad but nothing special. The sandwich was very salty and biscuit was a bit gluey. Would not recommend, maybe try a dif sandwich. Service is a bit slow but the staff are very friendly. My friends got hot lattes and the barista drew some simple latte art, so cute! Im not a coffee drinker, but i think the coffee is quite nice.

EllaRose Sherman

Food and coffee was good, but it took ridiculously long to get it. About 30 minutes in and we still haven’t gotten our croissant, and the latte took a good 15 minutes. Usually I don’t judge for wait times, but the place is not very busy and there’s little to no line. 8/17/25

The Slow Travelers

I would not suggest this if you’re ordering a slight customization on the menu. It took them 25 mins to make a bagel - in not a busy time, with 2 members behind the counter - and even then, they added meat on it when I asked them a few times not to. At the 20 min mark they were just getting the eggs done (when we were the first customers to come in). I appreciate them making things fresh - but honestly - it takes me much lesser time doing this by myself while multitasking. The staff just needs a lot of training.