Original Emilio's Brick Oven

I was in the area for business and went to a pizzeria across the street from Emilio’s and was greeted with “we only take cash” so me and my coworkers left and were trying to decide where to have lunch and saw Emilio’s on the other side of the street. What a wonderful mishap that the other place didn’t take card! The food at Emilio’s was amazing!!! So fresh and tasty! I debated taking another slice to go but the one slice was very filling! 100% recommended and would definitely go back if in the area.

Fresh ingredients and so amazingly good. They are always very friendly inside as well! Try the “grandma pie” - their version of a margherita, it’s insanely good!!

Really nice customer service, cheap food, and delicious 🤤.

It’s about the Grandma Pie for me! Delicious sauce - just the right amount of sweet and garlic. We order it every time my parents come to visit because my mom loves it too! (And - coincidentally, she’s an authentic Grandma.) Fast delivery and great prices/quality…

We have been here twice traveling through between Maine and Florida. It is the best pizza we have ever had. The staff were accommodating on both visits. We particularly liked the buffalo chicken sicilian, but everything we tried was delicious. Anytime we head north this place is a must do.

Been going here for years, best pizza pie in town! Great chicken Parm hero and chicken rolls too. Mamaroneck has quite a few pizza places to choose from, but if you want a great NYC pizza without going to the city, go to Emilio's!

Mary

Really nice customer service, cheap food, and delicious 🤤.

Jonathan Sacks

Personally, my favorite Pizza on the Avenue. Bugger slice than Sals.

Nick

Fresh ingredients and so amazingly good. They are always very friendly inside as well! Try the “grandma pie” - their version of a margherita, it’s insanely good!!

M UC

I was in the area for business and went to a pizzeria across the street from Emilio’s and was greeted with “we only take cash” so me and my coworkers left and were trying to decide where to have lunch and saw Emilio’s on the other side of the street. What a wonderful mishap that the other place didn’t take card! The food at Emilio’s was amazing!!! So fresh and tasty! I debated taking another slice to go but the one slice was very filling! 100% recommended and would definitely go back if in the area.

Marjorie Sanchez

Order from here about once a week. Excellent eggplant pizza, tortellini soup, chicken Parmesan here. Always good and delicious.

Olivia Morton

Absolutely amazing!! I’ve never had a pizza this good, how is this place also cheaper than commercial places like dominos is crazy.

Stacey Gee

It’s about the Grandma Pie for me! Delicious sauce - just the right amount of sweet and garlic. We order it every time my parents come to visit because my mom loves it too! (And - coincidentally, she’s an authentic Grandma.) Fast delivery and great prices/quality…

Joe Mercado

Emilio's pizza and food are great. The prices are the best in the neighborhood. While other places charge for a large for over $22. Emilio's prices are great.

Ryan U

Never disappointed here. Great pizza and always really fast. Much less hectic quicker and friendlier then some other pizza places in mamaroneck.

Bill G

Been going here for years, best pizza pie in town! Great chicken Parm hero and chicken rolls too. Mamaroneck has quite a few pizza places to choose from, but if you want a great NYC pizza without going to the city, go to Emilio's!

Joseph Downey

We have been here twice traveling through between Maine and Florida. It is the best pizza we have ever had. The staff were accommodating on both visits. We particularly liked the buffalo chicken sicilian, but everything we tried was delicious. Anytime we head north this place is a must do.

Ted M

I have lived in town since 1977. Emilio's is without question the best pizza place in town. Not sure who that reviewer was who gave it a ONE Star and said good reviews are probably friends of Emilio's. I do not know Emilio personally, and would say if you try them all (in town) you will see for yourself that he is a solid 5 (no less than 4.5) stars. GREAT Grandma slice too, decent variety of pizzas. Only issue is that his place seats 12 to 15 people at a time. Otherwise, great pizza and dishes.

Good pizza. Quick and efficient service. Two cheese slices and a 20 oz. soda was $9.50. A few tables and chairs in the space. Would like to return to try some other items. Metered/Mobile App parking in front along Mamaroneck Avenue.

I had a cheese calzone for $6.50 cash and it was great. There’s a clean customer restroom available which is a big plus. Plenty of seating as well.

Jemlnlx

Good pizza. Quick and efficient service. Two cheese slices and a 20 oz. soda was $9.50. A few tables and chairs in the space. Would like to return to try some other items. Metered/Mobile App parking in front along Mamaroneck Avenue.

Geovanny

I had a cheese calzone for $6.50 cash and it was great. There’s a clean customer restroom available which is a big plus. Plenty of seating as well.

Really nice guys and they take care of myself and my workers for our weekly trip in. Consistently the best pizza in Mamaroneck. I haven't tried the rest of the menu but when I see other people eating other dishes it always looks good. Don't get sucked into eating greasy pizza at Sal's!

Emilio's Grandma pizza is addictive. My stomach calls it to mind at least three times a week. Parmigiana heroes are filling and delicious. Everything's made to order but because everything is run by only ONE person you can expect to wait a bit if you walk in so order in advance.

I had the plain slice, and I was not disappointed. It was crispy and fresh. I might even prefer this pizza spot over the popular choice of Sal's Pizza.

K R

I had the plain slice, and I was not disappointed. It was crispy and fresh. I might even prefer this pizza spot over the popular choice of Sal's Pizza.

Iggi Choi

Emilio's Grandma pizza is addictive. My stomach calls it to mind at least three times a week. Parmigiana heroes are filling and delicious. Everything's made to order but because everything is run by only ONE person you can expect to wait a bit if you walk in so order in advance.

steven garner

Really nice guys and they take care of myself and my workers for our weekly trip in. Consistently the best pizza in Mamaroneck. I haven't tried the rest of the menu but when I see other people eating other dishes it always looks good. Don't get sucked into eating greasy pizza at Sal's!

I'm not sure what happened at this place, the food was awesome, I talked to a great customer service guy..... then the next time, I ordered I talked to the owner I think, told me I disrespected, he hung up, I called back I said I don't understand, you guys are the best I love you guys I'm sorry, and he continued to act like an alpha to a costumer. 5 out of 5 great food ... but very rude and egotistical owner..... he should probably stay off the phone.

samusexplorer

I'm not sure what happened at this place, the food was awesome, I talked to a great customer service guy..... then the next time, I ordered I talked to the owner I think, told me I disrespected, he hung up, I called back I said I don't understand, you guys are the best I love you guys I'm sorry, and he continued to act like an alpha to a costumer. 5 out of 5 great food ... but very rude and egotistical owner..... he should probably stay off the phone.