Tosco's Pizzeria

Eric Ma

Decided to try Tosco’s for the first time. There are honestly many pizza choices in the area so it’s hard to give everyone a shot. We wanted something different though, and saw that they sell a chicken francese pizza! We ordered that in a 16”, garlic knots, a kids spaghetti and meatballs, penne alla vodka, and fried dough (I assume they mean zeppole). Everything except the garlic knots I would say tasted good! The pizza crust is pretty thick. I’d be willing to give pizza another shot, thinking they made this one thick to support all the pizza, cheese, and chicken. Toppings are generous. The knots are light on the garlic and long, never had long ones before. Definitely prefer them garlicky. Kids portion was generous too. Four meatballs. The wife is picky with here penne alla vodka. She says this one doesn’t have shallots but otherwise was tasty. I thought it was good. The “fried dough” was good. A little too crunchy on the outside. All in all, would be willing to give Tosco another try! Oh, they didn’t give the doordash the kids soda, which is fine since I was just going to drink it lol. Didn’t bother complaining but that may not be the case for you.

Terri Tripi-Daniels

First time there. Pizza was good except they put half mushroom order on 3 slices. Called once home & woman at front desk shocked & said bring receipt & photo and they'll do good by us next time.

We wanted our pie fixings and we found this place. I wouldn’t say this was the best pie. Nothing to shout out about and the kids were also kinda meh. I thinking if we ate it right away it might have been better. We got the Philly cheese pie and like it said it was to crave our fixings. Thank you guys. I’d definitely give them another try.

Great pizza place in the neighborhood and I cant really compare it to the other in the vicinity... but there's a lot of em! Personal pies are nicely sized and they make pretty good wings! The store could use a renovation but that's another issue. I just joined planet fitness and I hope toscos is their partner for pizza night

Galen Kilroy

Solid place with a big menu. We've only had their pastas and rolls. Portions are generous and everything seems freshly prepared. Staff is generally friendly.

Rob Chu

We wanted our pie fixings and we found this place. I wouldn’t say this was the best pie. Nothing to shout out about and the kids were also kinda meh. I thinking if we ate it right away it might have been better. We got the Philly cheese pie and like it said it was to crave our fixings. Thank you guys. I’d definitely give them another try.

Update for a new visit. Since the last time I was here, they raised the prices on the online ordering to 20% over the menu prices. Given that they also charge extra for using credit cards in the store, I’ve now changed from a customer for life to someone who is only going if someone else is buying. Ordered the Calamari Fra Diablo, which was not ready on time but was tasty, but the large garlic twists coming with the dish became small, hard garlic knots instead. —— previous review: Excellent! Ordered the Chicken Scarpariello entree, very reasonably priced. Very generous serving size — I’ve just moved back to the area after time in northern New Jersey, this would be $20 there or more for the same dish, maybe with less food. Ordered online, order was ready when I arrived, 5 minutes before the promised time. Impressive packaging (yes, it was only a pizza box, but you’d be amazed how many places will just use a leftover, soiled box leftover from a soda delivery to hold the food ) Why only 4 stars? The garlic knots were undercooked, raw dough inside, and the two employees were both wearing their face masks on their chins when I entered.

Michael Zier

Update for a new visit. Since the last time I was here, they raised the prices on the online ordering to 20% over the menu prices. Given that they also charge extra for using credit cards in the store, I’ve now changed from a customer for life to someone who is only going if someone else is buying. Ordered the Calamari Fra Diablo, which was not ready on time but was tasty, but the large garlic twists coming with the dish became small, hard garlic knots instead. —— previous review: Excellent! Ordered the Chicken Scarpariello entree, very reasonably priced. Very generous serving size — I’ve just moved back to the area after time in northern New Jersey, this would be $20 there or more for the same dish, maybe with less food. Ordered online, order was ready when I arrived, 5 minutes before the promised time. Impressive packaging (yes, it was only a pizza box, but you’d be amazed how many places will just use a leftover, soiled box leftover from a soda delivery to hold the food ) Why only 4 stars? The garlic knots were undercooked, raw dough inside, and the two employees were both wearing their face masks on their chins when I entered.

I bought the special Stromboli, the dough was super soft and crispy on the outside. An excellent combination of meat and vegetables. It’s big enough for two persons and the sauce was also good. I will say this is the best Stromboli place in Monroe, not even Rome have pasta so fresh. Bonus: it’s open on July 4th!

Absolutely terrible customer service when it comes to delivery. Was told twenty minutes for delivery. Called after fifty minutes of waiting and was told another 15 minutes because the oil needed changed. Waited another 25 minutes for the delivery to show up at our motel. Some of the items were missing so I called to see about what could be done about it. I was told that they can't run back out those items. No offer to refund or fix the problem. The Veal Parmigiana was the toughest piece of veal that I've ever had. The spaghetti noodles and sauce tasted okay.

C. O.

I bought the special Stromboli, the dough was super soft and crispy on the outside. An excellent combination of meat and vegetables. It’s big enough for two persons and the sauce was also good. I will say this is the best Stromboli place in Monroe, not even Rome have pasta so fresh. Bonus: it’s open on July 4th!

russell caseman

Absolutely terrible customer service when it comes to delivery. Was told twenty minutes for delivery. Called after fifty minutes of waiting and was told another 15 minutes because the oil needed changed. Waited another 25 minutes for the delivery to show up at our motel. Some of the items were missing so I called to see about what could be done about it. I was told that they can't run back out those items. No offer to refund or fix the problem. The Veal Parmigiana was the toughest piece of veal that I've ever had. The spaghetti noodles and sauce tasted okay.

Ordered one time before and thought it was pretty decent and worth a re order. Decided to order a chicken salad sub and added American cheese. Chicken salad is one of my favorites and I was very excited. You can imagine the shock and heartbreak I experienced when I looked in the delivery bag and didn’t see a sub. Instead I found a salad with chicken with a few slices of American cheese on top of it. I don’t know what kind of serial killer thinks it’s ok to just ignore the words SUB in an order and slap some Kraft singles on top of a chopped salad with some chicken cutlets on top. I’m working on a final for my science class that’s due tonight at midnight and I just wanted to fuel up on one of my favorite foods to power me through my work. I might actually fail my final now because Ted Bundy back in the kitchen didn’t think it was a little weird that someone would elect to spend an extra ¢95 cents to add American cheese to a salad. Grub hub promptly refunded my money back to me, but that’s not good enough. What am I supposed to do with this? I don’t want this disgusting pile of plastic cheese, lettuce, and cucumbers. I would have given them 1 star but I also ordered boneless garlic parm wings, and despite being very soggy, they are delicious. Would not recommend ordering from here unless you want the chef to bless you with his own modern art interpretation of what you actually ordered.

Tom Fischbach

Ordered one time before and thought it was pretty decent and worth a re order. Decided to order a chicken salad sub and added American cheese. Chicken salad is one of my favorites and I was very excited. You can imagine the shock and heartbreak I experienced when I looked in the delivery bag and didn’t see a sub. Instead I found a salad with chicken with a few slices of American cheese on top of it. I don’t know what kind of serial killer thinks it’s ok to just ignore the words SUB in an order and slap some Kraft singles on top of a chopped salad with some chicken cutlets on top. I’m working on a final for my science class that’s due tonight at midnight and I just wanted to fuel up on one of my favorite foods to power me through my work. I might actually fail my final now because Ted Bundy back in the kitchen didn’t think it was a little weird that someone would elect to spend an extra ¢95 cents to add American cheese to a salad. Grub hub promptly refunded my money back to me, but that’s not good enough. What am I supposed to do with this? I don’t want this disgusting pile of plastic cheese, lettuce, and cucumbers. I would have given them 1 star but I also ordered boneless garlic parm wings, and despite being very soggy, they are delicious. Would not recommend ordering from here unless you want the chef to bless you with his own modern art interpretation of what you actually ordered.

Pizza was almost mediocre. One of ours came out hot while the other was cooled. This is because only one of our pizzas was made, even though we ordered two. Subpar customer service, and we would have expected some of the price to be knocked off considering we already had to wait unexpectedly. Overall, this dive pizza bar will do in a pinch but there’s definitely better out there.

Andy E

Pizza was almost mediocre. One of ours came out hot while the other was cooled. This is because only one of our pizzas was made, even though we ordered two. Subpar customer service, and we would have expected some of the price to be knocked off considering we already had to wait unexpectedly. Overall, this dive pizza bar will do in a pinch but there’s definitely better out there.

I walked in personally to make my order. The person behind the counter wasn’t very welcoming and also didn’t seem like they cared too much to be there. I asked in person for a med (16 in) eggplant rollatini. Everything seemed to be fine and understood. He said 20 mins and when we arrived before that time, the pizza wasn’t even hot and unfortunately to me, I was semichecked out in realizing in that moment that something was wrong. The tag on the box was labeled the correct order and it wasn’t until we got home that we realized everything was wrong. Not only did we NOT get a complete pie, it was cold, it looked like it was slapped together two different pies, it was very doughy and not crispy like asked, we were charged the completely wrong price (charged for a large cheese only pizza per their menu prices and the pizza was not large at all despite asking for a speciality medium) and we weren’t informed that a fee percentage would be added for using a card to pay. I called 3 times the same night and all there was a busy tone so I didn’t bother any more and decided on this review. I feel bamboozled and also deeply frustrated that my order was completely messed up and I was charged a price that barely makes sense. The counter person clearly didn’t listen or better didn’t care and albeit I should have checked the pizza before leaving, there’s really NO excuse for this wrong order considering the kitchen tag literally has the right order. I stopped going there before due to similar situations in the past and now again this will be my final time ordering from there forreal. No more chances. Plenty of other pizza shops in town anyways who get the orders right.

Where is the previous owner? Haven't been there in a while so I stopped off on my way home. Took a bite and the crust tasted like oven cleaner. Put the slice on my car seat and it didn't look appetizing at all. You can't just rub dough, spread sauce and cheese and call yourself a pizza maker. Making pizza is an art. NEVER AGAIN

I wait 50 minutes for two pene vodka whit chicken that dissapoimen is horribly without flavor and a piece of pizza all burned

Memo

I wait 50 minutes for two pene vodka whit chicken that dissapoimen is horribly without flavor and a piece of pizza all burned

Bianca N Martinez

I walked in personally to make my order. The person behind the counter wasn’t very welcoming and also didn’t seem like they cared too much to be there. I asked in person for a med (16 in) eggplant rollatini. Everything seemed to be fine and understood. He said 20 mins and when we arrived before that time, the pizza wasn’t even hot and unfortunately to me, I was semichecked out in realizing in that moment that something was wrong. The tag on the box was labeled the correct order and it wasn’t until we got home that we realized everything was wrong. Not only did we NOT get a complete pie, it was cold, it looked like it was slapped together two different pies, it was very doughy and not crispy like asked, we were charged the completely wrong price (charged for a large cheese only pizza per their menu prices and the pizza was not large at all despite asking for a speciality medium) and we weren’t informed that a fee percentage would be added for using a card to pay. I called 3 times the same night and all there was a busy tone so I didn’t bother any more and decided on this review. I feel bamboozled and also deeply frustrated that my order was completely messed up and I was charged a price that barely makes sense. The counter person clearly didn’t listen or better didn’t care and albeit I should have checked the pizza before leaving, there’s really NO excuse for this wrong order considering the kitchen tag literally has the right order. I stopped going there before due to similar situations in the past and now again this will be my final time ordering from there forreal. No more chances. Plenty of other pizza shops in town anyways who get the orders right.

Alda Grant

Where is the previous owner? Haven't been there in a while so I stopped off on my way home. Took a bite and the crust tasted like oven cleaner. Put the slice on my car seat and it didn't look appetizing at all. You can't just rub dough, spread sauce and cheese and call yourself a pizza maker. Making pizza is an art. NEVER AGAIN

I spent 15.00 on a turkey hero with the up charge of extra turkey they provided the last amount of meat possible for a Nero covering it with old ketches and nasty tomato we had to Clem back and ask more meat for the value instead it appears he removed more layers completely unacceptable stay away from Their sandwiches

The place is meh. The pizza used to be really good but not so much anymore. The service as well is mediocre. I placed an order and the gentleman seemed very short with me like he didn't want to take my order and then I asked for a price and how long it would be and he just hung up on me

The food was HORRIBLE. The chicken francese I ordered was gross 🤢🤮. The sauce was this thick thick jelly creamy slop. Taste like I was chewing on lemon peel covered in butter. Chicken so thick and full of water. Wasted twenty dollars. The pizza was nasty too. The guy who worked counter and answered phones was cool tho. Polite . Respectful. The staff is cool . The restaurant itself was very clean and modern. Nice place inside. Wouldn't mind eating inside if food was ok. But I will not come back. You need to go to real Italian restaurant for entrees such as chicken francese. Turiello in nyack has the BEST. Also the Italian restaurant restaurant in shopping center where stop and shop and McDonald's is has very tod chicken francese also. Pizza good too. Updated December 10 2023. No I def won't give you another chance especially since your reply is a generic bot reply. You say the same thing to every bad review. I doubt you'll make any changes. I'm just one customer. But the food was that bad. 🤢. I now go to the pizza place next to AutoZone in that plaza. Everything was amazing. I have not had one bad thing. Don't waste your time or money at todcos they don't even have the decency to reply with an individual response to a negative review. What a joke.

Pizza was undercooked and over priced. Picked up an order and they forgot to put the salad with it so had to go back. Went back to pick up the salad and they gave me a bag with a panini?? Had to go back AGAIN and pick up yet another item. Girl at the counter was unapologetic and so nasty. Such a disappointment and waste of time. Go to marinas instead!

David Coleho

I spent 15.00 on a turkey hero with the up charge of extra turkey they provided the last amount of meat possible for a Nero covering it with old ketches and nasty tomato we had to Clem back and ask more meat for the value instead it appears he removed more layers completely unacceptable stay away from Their sandwiches

Georgia Brink

Pizza was undercooked and over priced. Picked up an order and they forgot to put the salad with it so had to go back. Went back to pick up the salad and they gave me a bag with a panini?? Had to go back AGAIN and pick up yet another item. Girl at the counter was unapologetic and so nasty. Such a disappointment and waste of time. Go to marinas instead!

NM Wilson

The place is meh. The pizza used to be really good but not so much anymore. The service as well is mediocre. I placed an order and the gentleman seemed very short with me like he didn't want to take my order and then I asked for a price and how long it would be and he just hung up on me

Michael Tee

The food was HORRIBLE. The chicken francese I ordered was gross 🤢🤮. The sauce was this thick thick jelly creamy slop. Taste like I was chewing on lemon peel covered in butter. Chicken so thick and full of water. Wasted twenty dollars. The pizza was nasty too. The guy who worked counter and answered phones was cool tho. Polite . Respectful. The staff is cool . The restaurant itself was very clean and modern. Nice place inside. Wouldn't mind eating inside if food was ok. But I will not come back. You need to go to real Italian restaurant for entrees such as chicken francese. Turiello in nyack has the BEST. Also the Italian restaurant restaurant in shopping center where stop and shop and McDonald's is has very tod chicken francese also. Pizza good too. Updated December 10 2023. No I def won't give you another chance especially since your reply is a generic bot reply. You say the same thing to every bad review. I doubt you'll make any changes. I'm just one customer. But the food was that bad. 🤢. I now go to the pizza place next to AutoZone in that plaza. Everything was amazing. I have not had one bad thing. Don't waste your time or money at todcos they don't even have the decency to reply with an individual response to a negative review. What a joke.