Bry T

Whenever I think of New York, pizza is always at the top of my list, and Mimi’s Pizza is one of those spots that absolutely stands out. I stumbled upon it not expecting much, but after trying it once, I can confidently say this is a place I’ll always make a stop at whenever I’m back in the city. The pizza here is just that good memorable in every sense of the word. The crust strikes the perfect balance: crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and sturdy enough to hold the toppings without feeling too heavy. You can tell the dough is made with care because it has that subtle flavor that only comes from a well fermented base. The sauce is another highlight tangy, flavorful, and seasoned just right without being overly salty. Paired with the fresh cheese that melts beautifully over the top, every bite feels like the kind of New York pizza experience people rave about. What I really love is that Mimi’s doesn’t try to do too much or reinvent the wheel. It’s classic pizza done right, with the kind of execution that leaves a lasting impression. I’ve had countless slices around the city, and while New York is packed with good options, Mimi’s has this way of sticking with you. It’s the kind of slice that you think about later and crave again. The place itself is unpretentious and welcoming, making it easy to grab a quick slice or sit down for a whole pie. Service is straightforward and friendly, which matches the casual, no-frills vibe. All in all, Mimi’s Pizza is a gem that deserves the praise it gets. Delicious, memorable, and the kind of pizza that makes you want to come back to NYC just to have it again.

+1

alex beebout

Delicious, straightforward slice joint. The plain cheese was to die for and I loved the packet of hot honey for my pepperoni slice. The service was friendly and fast. We also adored the Margherita, simply perfect with fresh basil and generous dollops of mozzarella. The veg pizza could use some love but overall will return!

Cathy A

A hidden little gem and best quality pizza!!! There are hundreds of pizzerias in NYC, so when you find a good one, it’s always great to spread the word! This pizzeria makes delicious pizza! The crust is perfectly crusted and the pizza sauce is unique in flavor! :)

Reena Haq

Second Best Pizza in the City lives up to its name with delicious, surprisingly light pizza that leaves you satisfied without feeling bloated. The crust is perfectly crisp and airy, the ingredients are fresh, and the overall experience is elevated by the genuinely kind and welcoming owners who make every visit feel personal.

Hannah Klein

Mimi’s Pizza in the Upper East Side is a great and affordable place to grab a slice. Great options, quick service, and insanely cheap prices for New York. Crisp bottom, fluffy dough, delicious toppings. 3 slices, garlic knots, and 2 drinks for $18.62. Highly recommended!

+2

Bradley C

I got a Truffle Mushrooms Pizza with spinach, jalapeno, and Gorgonzola Cheese. It smelled amazing when I walked into this pizzeria. Everything on the cabinet looked so delicious. The servers were very warm and friendly. I got my orders online, and it was ready within 15 minutes. When I received my pizza, it was still scalding hot, and the fragrant was just unbeatable. I love the ration of the crust, cheese, and all the other toppings I choose. Everything was so well put together. It was a very good pizza. I’d definitely come back and try other things on the menu. I heard the garlic knots are delicious, but I forgot to order them this time. Will come back soon!

BUGATTI SS

After a long day at the MET, I was absolutely starving, and Mimi’s offered just the right remedy. It was a beautiful warm fall day, so I grabbed a seat at one of their tables outside. I ordered the Grandma’s Margarita Pizza, which looked so good I burned my mouth on the first bite because I couldn’t wait for it to cool. The crust was crisp yet melted softly with a hint of sweetness, the cheese was fresh and delicate, and the sauce carried that tangy-savory punch I love. The wait for the pizza was a bit longer than I’d hoped, but once it arrived, my brother and I were racing each other for the next slice with pure enthusiasm — a true testament to how satisfying it was. If you’re near Mimi’s, do yourself a favor and stop in

Carla Orsello

Very good! Easy to order. I thought it may be a sit-down restaurant given the menu, but it is the typical order at the counter. I had the cauliflower crust which they can make with any type-personal size. It was delicious though the edges of the crust were too tough. All the options looked great. There’s a few tables outside but they were missing chairs for the high tops. Nice area and more relaxed than some of the touristy places. I would definitely go back!

Carly Pisarri

I popped in after work before I hopped on the train. I was hungry and needed something to hold me till dinner and let me tell you…this pizza HIT. I had low expectations, they don’t even really have a noticeable sign. Sicilian usually isn’t my thing but the pesto vodka slice was calling my name. The crust was perfectly crispy. Slightly doughy on the inside. Every bite I wanted more. I’ll def be back!

Amber Edey

Subpar pizza. Looked like school lunch pizza. I was highly disappointed. A colleague of mine was going out for pizza, so I put an order in for a rainbow slice.. look what was brought back to me. This is atrocious and embarrassing to be New York City pizza.

Tuzy Fatoozy

Loud stoner kid comes in practically every day for a hit of his bong with his buddies, ruins the vibe. Used to be my favorite spot for some pizza till this kid started a ruckus in the establishment. The bong smoke wafts into my nose, and this point, it’s just less enjoyable. Not on the restaurant, but entirely on this kid. Won’t be coming till I know he’s gone. Thanks.