Anthony Cioffi

Great service and the food was delicious. Interesting specials, including a crab meat stuffed pretzel. Never had that before. The Ribeye was quite tender and cooked to order. The lobster rolls were really jammed with lobster so a great review for that to. Pretty decent desert menu too. I would strongly suggest making reservations as walk-ins were getting turned down. All together a very nice experience with excellent ambiance if you are sitting outside. On a beautiful day, the Hudson River views are enjoyable watching the personal.water crafts and commercial marine vessels navigate the river.

Priestly Canty

I liked this place alot. It was a little chilly in there, but we were by the waterfont, the doors were open, and people were outside sitting underneath the tent. The staff is friendly, and attentive. The food is amazing. The Sole Francaise was something new for me. Never tried it before, but it was delicious. I recommend trying the Buffalo Shrimp, & Clams Oreganato. I really enjoyed those as appetizers. A nice experience overall!

+6

Executive East

We had a Beautiful view overlooking the Hudson Bay. The fried cod was delicious and The clam chowder is good. The horseradish sauce they make is excellent. I asked for blue cheese on my Salad and they pre-tossed it, which is sort of weird so when the salad came out, it Was soggy lettuce and didn’t taste much like dressing. They did not give you salad dressing on the side so you can put it on yourself. I didn’t eat the salad with wilted lettuce. Guitar player and singer were wonderful.

Frank DeSantis

We Love Captain Jake’s. Been coming for years and never had a bad meal. Very friendly, comfortable. On the Water Front in Newburgh. The afternoon lunch has a nice view of the Hudson. Evening lights are very nice. Come and enjoy.

+3

Vicki M

I ordered the calamari (I found it bland, so I added a salt ) it was nice and crispy served with a warm marinara. We also ordered the Kung pao shrimp.. it was served with a sweet sesame ginger soy glaze(sweet) and a side of greens.. for our main course we ordered sole franchises.. comes with a starch and veggies.. the options were roasted red potatoes, mash, French fries, white rice, or a butternut squash risotto.. and they only serve broccoli.. I ordered the risotto.. my hunny ordered clams sauce with linguini.. he enjoyed it. The drink was a muddled blueberry refresher.. it was strong.. not sweet.. but I’m not complaining.. it made me happy! The Spanish girl who cleans the tables is the hardest worker I’ve met! She’s amazing!

+3

Alex

I enjoyed everything and it was reasonably priced. Lobster was fresh and the Buffalo wings were cooked just right. Views by the water are available and definitely the best seat in the house

Lauren DiMicco

The hostess went out of her way to get us a table without reservations on a very busy first nice weather day of the year. The food was ok (calamari a little disappointing, only 4 shrimp in a fairly expensive app special), and I would have liked to try a few more things, but service was impeccable and drinks were great. Overall a good experience.

W J

We are from out of town and wanted a place in the water. The playlists is good. Nicole was our server and she was “dynamite!” Very attentive, bright, and fast. The food has a few complaints: the potato croquet was cold in the middle (they solved that problem) , chicken parmigiana the pasta was great the chicken tasted microwaved. The dessert the brownie wasn’t hot.

+1

Samuel Lee

Fully packed waterfront seafood restaurant! It was Saturday night dinner so we made a reservation. We got the best table with the view. It’s a nice place to just hang out so it wasn’t a big deal but the service was very slow. Took 15 minutes to order drinks, another 25 minutes to make order for food and almost an hour to get our food. There were very long periods of time between each visit from the server, so if you ever needed anything, it was a long wait to get it. Thank goodness we asked to serve appetizers and mains at the same time. The first sip of coconut margarita was strong and good but it was a bit too much from the second sip. Oysters were fresh and really good. Buffalo shrimp were overpowered by the sauce. Lobster bisque was okay. Red snapper was very dry and lack of flavor but the potato croquette and broccoli that came with it were good. Lobster roll was pretty blend. Overrated, overpriced and inefficient!!!

+2

Clinton Weaver

The location is nice and service is great but the food was awful. I ordered seared scallops and they came out mushy and water logged. They had an interesting flavor but rather than send them back (which I should have done) I ate them and regretted it. I got a bad stomach from them. Would not recommend this place

J

Ate there with my newborn and my wife, the food was horrible, definitely over priced 2 people came out to 205$. We ordered the the side squash risotto” which might I add tasted like my grandmas feet”. I didn’t send it back I just asked for mashed potatoes” so they send over boxed mashes potatoes with no flavor. All in all, I will never bring my family back there. I ordered other food but I’m not gonna get into that. People now a days don’t know good food most people just settle for whatever. NEVER AGAIN CAPTION! FYI I HAD TO SPIKE THE MASHED POTATOES SALT, PEPPER, and SOME BUTTER FROM MY WIFES LOBSTER. This place is a real joke and I hope the owner sees this review and changes something for his sake.