Regina Gonzales

I loved it. Definitely better fresh. We got the 18 inch pizza and ate all but 2 slices. I'd definitely come here again. I wish we had a Mario's in Arizona. You definitely have to eat these with this signature pizza fold. This particular location small and was packed everyone outside had pizza even with other food places around.

Payal Sanghavi

Had ordered cheese pizza slice. The crust was neither thick nor thin . It was perfect ! Classic new york style pizza 😍 Definitely must try when in niagara .

+3

Ray Salmeron

Awesome pizza! Cheesy with delicious pepperoni, amazing flavor and the crust is crispy! Restaurant was clean and served us fast even on a busy day! Just as a small experience, I was already out of the restaurant when my coke fell and busted open. When I walked in and explained what happened they gave me a free coke! I thought it was very nice of them to treat customers this way!

Cherilyn Jones

Ok pizza. We popped in for a slice and it wasn’t terrible but wasn’t great either.

+3

Lisa Powers

The phone number listed on google and also on their front door does not work. We tried to call and order for pick up but got a message saying the number was out of order. So be forewarned if you are staying in a nearby hotel. Thankfully we were staying nearby and didn’t mind the short walk. We wanted to call ahead to order so it was ready to pick up when we got there but again the number was out of service. There was a nice selection slices you can grab to go as well as coolers with sodas and ice tea and bottled water for purchase as well. The pizza was delicious. We had Hawaiian slices and a veggie slice and a cup n char pepperoni slice. Walk up service was fast and easy. We ate at the outdoor tables.

+2

Andrew M

For the price, this pizza is great! As we walked by and saw some people enjoying their slices, we couldn't resist the temptation, even though we had just finished lunch. We thought, 'One slice wouldn't hurt.' So, we popped in, ordered a pepperoni slice, and within 2 minutes, we were back out the door, sharing a hot, delicious slice of pizza.

Greg smitz (smitz327)

Great little pizza place to get a NY style pizza 🍕 Pizza is kind of pricey, but it is good fresh. It's expected being at Niagara falls. Very good place for a slice

Ali Sabouki

They had New York style pizza that was ready to go. They’d pop it in the oven to warm it up for you. No real frills. There are maybe three tables for dine in you could also sit outside inside. There were pallets full of drinks next to the table, so it was kind of tight and squished, but it was a nice food to get quick while seeing the falls.

+1

Kathy

I'm from nyc and I went to look at niagra falls as I was there i did get hungry and found this place, it sure did remind me of the pizza back in Manhattan so I was excited to come here and try it. It was a pretty long line which was okay but turns out they only give pizza slices if the pizza you want is by the window display if not you're out of luck, luckily cheese pizza was there. I have to say the slices were pretty big and I payed 9 dollars for 2 which was not bad I guess but the thing is that the pizza wasn't all that good nothing like nyc pizza and the crust was all burnt 🙃. Sad to say this isn't like pizza back in nyc which was disappointing but the pizza itself was delicious

Jacob Kizer

Pizza was alright, could have used a bit more sauce. My wife seemed to enjoy her house salad. Lots of outdoor seating, very cramped inside the restaurant.

Jemlnlx

It's tough living in NYC and having to review pizza outside of the area... Marios has an efficient staff, indoor seating, outdoor seating, but...not the best pizza. Sauce and crust weren't the best. Pizza itself may be 4-5/10 but the prices were also higher than expected. I understand this is a tourst area, so the prices will be higher...but $12 for two slices and a 20oz. soda....definitely not worth it in my opinion. I know buying by the slice may not be the best...maybe others may have better luck with buying a fresh pie.

Bobby Khan

Ordered on 8/21/25 salad and pizza. Gave me small dressing for my salad and ask what will i do with big salad. They will charge you extra for dressing for dressing and worst customer service from the teenagers. Very rude to customers. Pizza was under cooked and very little sauce and missing spot with cheese. Do yourself a favor and go to another spot.

B. Saszare

This pizza crust was thin and gummy- not cooked properly. The sauce was weak and has no flavor. I couldn’t order the toppings I wanted on their menu because they didn’t have them, and their house chicken salad was unavailable as well. They only seems to have a few things and I was very dissatisfied with w their pizza.

+10