Gourmet O's Pizza

Nice guy, nice quick grab and go type location. Pizza is decent, not the greatest i ever had but I'm guessing it can hold it's own against other local pizza.

My Husband and I ordered a medium pizza to share between the two of us. We ordered our favorite pepperoni & pineapple. The pizza was hot, fresh and delicious. It was so yummy! We completely indulged and destroyed the whole pizza to ourselves. So glad we decided to order from here.

Love this new york style, the atmosphere the food and that lady Liz who served us made my day. Made us feel welcomed, delivered great customer service and lifted my mood immensely since I'm not with family. The pizza, garlic knots and canoli 🔥🔥🔥 Great job, will definitely be coming back Happy holidays to yall

+2

Best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life, I won’t eat any other any more. The guy there, Josh, even gave me a birthday gift.

The pizza was incredible! Want that nice Italian cheesy stringy bite that’s know for NY Pizza. Slices New York has it! Sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and crust was delicious! I’ll definitely be back again!

The staff at Slices New York were incredibly kind and welcoming. From the moment I walked in, they greeted me warmly and made sure I felt comfortable. Their friendliness and attentive service really stood out, adding to the overall experience and making the visit even more enjoyable.

As someone who knows and loves real New York pizza, I can confidently say this is the most authentic and delicious New York-style pizza I’ve ever had outside of the New York. From the perfectly thin, foldable crust with the rich tomato sauce, high-quality mozzarella and finally the balance of flavor every bite transported me straight back to a New York pizzeria. The balance of flavors, the crisp-yet-soft texture. If you’re a true pizza lover or a homesick New Yorker, this place is a must-visit. A rare gem—10/10!

After a week of absolutely bad Orlando pizza, these guys absolutely brought the heat with some of the best pizza/calzone I have ever head. Everything was amazing, cheese, sauce, crust - and they topped it with delicious parmesan and herbs. Seriously top 5 pizza I’ve ever had, don’t look anywhere else these are your pizza people. A delicious oasis in a desert of disappointing Florida pizza. Very quick service and owner staff delightful to interact with. Pictures are half pizza and roll because we absolutely inhaled it.

I’m from Tampa Came here to see a friend and stopped for some pizza and it was a great choice Dylan was very nice and very friendly I would definitely recommend and will come back sauce was delicious cheese was great and the crust reminded me of home originally from ct

+3

Best pizza and wings I have ever eaten! The owner and staff are great, kind and very attentive. The food was fresh and delicious. Service was fast and short wait time. I highly recommend this Pizza Place!

Service was good, 2 pizzas and soda was a great deal and my girl doesn’t usually like pizza but she loved this one, I prefer a little more crispy to hold well but I can’t complain because the taste of the dough and everything else is really good, new regular for sure

Sully service was incredible it’s the best I’ve had since living here in Orlando Kissimmee the pizza was original took me back to Brooklyn rs Thalia’s recommend

So I'm visiting Orlando and I drove past this restaurant and the first thing I said was "they have amazing pizza" for a specific reason, their store front has three words only on it "PIZZA PZZA OPEN" the sign of a truly amazing Brooklyn style joint. Holy moly it was amazing pizza the seasoned crust, fresh sauce, and if you look at my images you can see whole cut peppers not some canned garbage. Taste will tell you that as well. The service was also amazing from someone so friendly and willing to have a little banter at the front counter. Another important feature is this - a flat price for the topping types eg ham or mushrooms(size of pizza makes this different) but they allow SUBSTITUTIONS also. To give an idea of the price my 18" in the image was 26 bucks. Very rare to find a high quality, friendly, fairly priced pizza place anywhere now in days. If you like new york/Brooklyn style and have the opportunity try this place out!! You will not regret it.

Do yourself a favor and grab some pizza we ordered three large pies and weren’t disappointed. I’m from Connecticut and I really enjoyed my pizza. 😊

Garlic sticks 🔥 We inhaled these piping hot garlic goodies in the car before we even left the parking lot. Owner is so nice. Awesome dude. Amazing hours for the night owls like me. 10/10 - recommend!!

Got the pizza dough on the “2 good 2 go” app to make the pizza at home it was an amazing deal the dough was fresh made same day and the portion was enough for two adults. Service was excellent the guy working the kitchen and front counter was nice and friendly even told me about a good sub shop down the street. We also got the garlic knots to go with the pizza and it was such a good choice 10/10 recommend. Hope this place is long lasting and keeps up the good food and service.

The Best pizza I've found thus far! The closest to New York style pizza!! It was so delicious I couldn't wait to get home, ate it in the car hot, fresh & delicious but after I took my very 1st bite, I turned around called in for another pie to take home. It's that good!! And not overpriced either. Me & my family absolutely love their pizza. Definitely give it a try, I promise you will not be disappointed 🤞🏼

This feels like and tastes just like I’d imagine if I were in New York City. The pizza is delicious fast and affordable. You can’t go wrong, eat here!!!! I want the owner of this place to know that Josh is an amazing person and he should be highly valued at your pizza shop. He is super friendly, enthusiastic about his pizza skills, and just made me feel welcome. He makes this pizza shop that much better!!!

My husband and I had a hectic day running all around Orlando, we wanted to get a quick bite before we got back on the road last evening and my husband did a quick google search of what was in the area and found this Pizzeria. Immediately upon arriving we knew this was going to be fantastic pizza, it’s a cute little hole in the wall place with a few seats, you know these places put out amazing food and that they did! THIS pizza is the best pizza we’ve had in many years, it reminds me of how pizza was made way back before people got lazy and cheap and started cutting corners. The staff there was very welcoming and kind! Shout out to Liz for being pleasant and kind and shout out to the cook! Don’t let me forget to mention the garlic knots, absolutely delicious! Can’t wait to come back and we will be! You all better get yourself one of these pizzas!!

Food was SOOO GOOD! Top tier. The pizza tastes the way I remember pizza tasting when I was a kid, if that makes sense. Great balance of salt, cheese, sauce & overall flavor was so far beyond anything I’ve had in the past 30+ years. On top of how good the food was, the guy working was cool. We ordered a xl Supreme pizza, garlic knots, and a garden salad - he said it’d be ready in 12 minutes.. and it was! Idk how he did it. This place is truly blessed. Thank you for amazing food & service!

Top 5 pizza I had in FL, top in Orlando so far, reminds me of New Haven, CT pizza, very delicious. Josh hook me up with the wings with teriyaki sauce since not many establishments carry teriyaki out here, and they were very delicious. The second time in here, it's hard to find good places like these traveling around.

Anthony DiSpirito

Do yourself a favor and grab some pizza we ordered three large pies and weren’t disappointed. I’m from Connecticut and I really enjoyed my pizza. 😊

Lunalynn

The Best pizza I've found thus far! The closest to New York style pizza!! It was so delicious I couldn't wait to get home, ate it in the car hot, fresh & delicious but after I took my very 1st bite, I turned around called in for another pie to take home. It's that good!! And not overpriced either. Me & my family absolutely love their pizza. Definitely give it a try, I promise you will not be disappointed 🤞🏼

Tracy Baldridge

Garlic sticks 🔥 We inhaled these piping hot garlic goodies in the car before we even left the parking lot. Owner is so nice. Awesome dude. Amazing hours for the night owls like me. 10/10 - recommend!!

Ringo Hulsey

Got the pizza dough on the “2 good 2 go” app to make the pizza at home it was an amazing deal the dough was fresh made same day and the portion was enough for two adults. Service was excellent the guy working the kitchen and front counter was nice and friendly even told me about a good sub shop down the street. We also got the garlic knots to go with the pizza and it was such a good choice 10/10 recommend. Hope this place is long lasting and keeps up the good food and service.

Nathan Schrock

This feels like and tastes just like I’d imagine if I were in New York City. The pizza is delicious fast and affordable. You can’t go wrong, eat here!!!! I want the owner of this place to know that Josh is an amazing person and he should be highly valued at your pizza shop. He is super friendly, enthusiastic about his pizza skills, and just made me feel welcome. He makes this pizza shop that much better!!!

Chasing Euphoria

My husband and I had a hectic day running all around Orlando, we wanted to get a quick bite before we got back on the road last evening and my husband did a quick google search of what was in the area and found this Pizzeria. Immediately upon arriving we knew this was going to be fantastic pizza, it’s a cute little hole in the wall place with a few seats, you know these places put out amazing food and that they did! THIS pizza is the best pizza we’ve had in many years, it reminds me of how pizza was made way back before people got lazy and cheap and started cutting corners. The staff there was very welcoming and kind! Shout out to Liz for being pleasant and kind and shout out to the cook! Don’t let me forget to mention the garlic knots, absolutely delicious! Can’t wait to come back and we will be! You all better get yourself one of these pizzas!!

Kerstien Robinson

Food was SOOO GOOD! Top tier. The pizza tastes the way I remember pizza tasting when I was a kid, if that makes sense. Great balance of salt, cheese, sauce & overall flavor was so far beyond anything I’ve had in the past 30+ years. On top of how good the food was, the guy working was cool. We ordered a xl Supreme pizza, garlic knots, and a garden salad - he said it’d be ready in 12 minutes.. and it was! Idk how he did it. This place is truly blessed. Thank you for amazing food & service!

jdiazfl

Top 5 pizza I had in FL, top in Orlando so far, reminds me of New Haven, CT pizza, very delicious. Josh hook me up with the wings with teriyaki sauce since not many establishments carry teriyaki out here, and they were very delicious. The second time in here, it's hard to find good places like these traveling around.

Made an order on the way to Orlando from Winter Haven and it was ready when we arrived! So delicious and bigger than we expected!! If you like a thinner crust it’s perfect.

Sully is an awesome person. Makes the food really good make sure you give him his props because this place has really good food. Come check it out!

I love this small pizza shop, it truly reminds me of New York. The quality is top-notch, everything is super delicious, and the service is always quick. Ramon is so sweet and easy to get along with, and he made our birthday celebration feel so special. I highly recommend this place!

Absolutely loved this place! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with high-quality ingredients. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft inside, and the toppings were generous without being overwhelming. Service was friendly and quick, and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. You can really tell they care about what they’re serving. Easily one of the best pizza spots around — I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending it to friends!

Andrew Johnson

There was a slow window of time for the store being "dead". We walked in and had fresh made Pizza in less than 15mins! Always perfect!!! Sully was the hero tonight, thank you!

Enas Shenouda

I love this small pizza shop, it truly reminds me of New York. The quality is top-notch, everything is super delicious, and the service is always quick. Ramon is so sweet and easy to get along with, and he made our birthday celebration feel so special. I highly recommend this place!

Tara Nannini

Stopped here late after leaving Magic Kingdom one night. AWESOME pizza and great service!! Loved they were open passed midnight and the guy working was so friendly! Would definitely come back!

Withcraft

This is my third time visiting the shop and the workers are always super nice to me, today i had sulky take my order and he’s always super eager when I walk in and is super nice. Him and sebastian always make take my order and make my food. Super welcoming and always go above and beyond with customer service. The pizzas is DELICIOUS 🤪 and the wings couldn’t be any better. I personally recommend the all meats or a classic cheese pizza. Keep up the good work and to who ever trained them kiddos to you , you did a job!!

Pretty good slices. Not too doughy but not too thin. Prices are reasonable especially being close to Disney world. Recommend the meatball and pepperoni slices. Would order again if on Disney world property.

Joe Quatt

Pretty good slices. Not too doughy but not too thin. Prices are reasonable especially being close to Disney world. Recommend the meatball and pepperoni slices. Would order again if on Disney world property.

This pizza place had some mixed review but I decided to try it as it was the closest with "New York Style" pizza to where we were staying for our Disney Vacation. We ordered two extra large (18 inch) pizzas. Both with extra cheese and one with pepperoni (see pictures). I picked it up myself. When deciding which place to pick; I liked the Yelp review from Kristin S. who said "One of the best pizza places this Jersey girl had found thus far in Florida. Thin, crisp crust with just the right amount of sauce and lots of cheesy goodness." I would expect a "Jersey Girl" to have some more experience with NY Style Pizza. The shape and size were right. Taste? Not close. Crust? Not thin enough and the crust does not taste as good as a pizza from NY City. Also, the crust was way too soft (not crisp at all). I would have preferred "Brett R. (Yelp review)" "Lightly baked" pizza to what we got. It has way too much garlic (the prominent taste by far). The extra cheese is what I would have expected "regular" cheese to be. Was the pizza awful? No - it was good, average pizza; on par with Papa Johns. However, if you are looking for the taste and think crisp tasty crust of a true NY Pizza you ought to skip this place.

The food and the customer service is good and very humble people. The reason for the score is it says there open until 2am I went inside at 10pm and mentioned they are closed which is very misleading. They should really change the time and not get people excited before getting blindsided

This was the personal pizza that I ordered and it took 50 minutes to get the order. I was definitely not happy for having to wait that long. Staff member that helped me didn’t have the best tone of voice or polite response to anything. The pizza crust was good the cheese was good the pepperoni was good but the sauce does have a slight off taste to it and it was greasy not exactly what I’m used to being part of a multi pizza restaurant family. And the price for a personal was $18 way to much!! I personally will never go back.

Google Brought me here as I wanted a quick slice. They had to make a pizza to pull the slices from. Not a big deal. At least my pizza would be fresh. Was charged 17.99 for the slice special, but it was a mistake and corrected. They didn't have change in the cash register to take a cash payment from my 20 dollar bill so I had to pay with a credit card .. so a 3.5% fee was added. Staff was not very friendly, but I realize anyone can have a bad day. I wasn't treated badly. Just talked to in a short way, no greeting, just someone coming to the register and waiting for me to order in silence while seemingly annoyed. When asked what I wanted to drink, I said 'Anything Diet'. The girl looked in her coolers and simply said "I have Water'. I took a Pepsi as a result Atmosphere is not meant to be welcoming or accommodating, but their business model is primarily takeout. A grand total of 4 seating spots were there. Finally the Pizza.. The pizza was just OK. Don't expect huge authentic New York slices for lunch. Very thin even by NY standards. Would not have been a problem if the pie had an extra minute in the oven. The whole place is not my vibe. The service and disinterest I experienced is enough to keep me from trying here again. There are enough great pizza places around where I can pop in, relax, and enjoy myself for a few minutes as I break from work or life. Never say never though.. it's still pizza.. and even mediocre or decent pizza is still PIZZA!

Darrin Vindiola

Google Brought me here as I wanted a quick slice. They had to make a pizza to pull the slices from. Not a big deal. At least my pizza would be fresh. Was charged 17.99 for the slice special, but it was a mistake and corrected. They didn't have change in the cash register to take a cash payment from my 20 dollar bill so I had to pay with a credit card .. so a 3.5% fee was added. Staff was not very friendly, but I realize anyone can have a bad day. I wasn't treated badly. Just talked to in a short way, no greeting, just someone coming to the register and waiting for me to order in silence while seemingly annoyed. When asked what I wanted to drink, I said 'Anything Diet'. The girl looked in her coolers and simply said "I have Water'. I took a Pepsi as a result Atmosphere is not meant to be welcoming or accommodating, but their business model is primarily takeout. A grand total of 4 seating spots were there. Finally the Pizza.. The pizza was just OK. Don't expect huge authentic New York slices for lunch. Very thin even by NY standards. Would not have been a problem if the pie had an extra minute in the oven. The whole place is not my vibe. The service and disinterest I experienced is enough to keep me from trying here again. There are enough great pizza places around where I can pop in, relax, and enjoy myself for a few minutes as I break from work or life. Never say never though.. it's still pizza.. and even mediocre or decent pizza is still PIZZA!

I placed an order for 6 breadsticks. They were made fresh and only took a few minutes. They packed them nicely so the oil doesn't leak out of the box and the napkins were great, but the size of the sticks themselves, especially for $8.89, we're very small. Literally only a few inches long. They were tasty but the portion size was too small.

Frankiel Blanco

The food and the customer service is good and very humble people. The reason for the score is it says there open until 2am I went inside at 10pm and mentioned they are closed which is very misleading. They should really change the time and not get people excited before getting blindsided

Placing the order was difficult. No one spoke any semblance of English. Called the place to ask questions.... and no one understood. After getting their and speaking to 2 different people... barely was able to communicate. The pizza itself.... greasy and in my opinion too much parmesean cheese. Too thin. Sauce and cheese was good. $28 for 20 wings. I didn't realize that and shame on me... but that's expensive for wings. 2 liter of soda was really cold. Pepsi products.

I came there the other day, and received the nastiest meatball parm I’ve ever had in my entire life. The meatballs were gray, small, and tasted absolutely GROSS. Also when I went back to the girl at the counter to let her know there was no marinara (only 2 drops of marinara) on my sandwich, she said she put it on there, so I proceeded to tell her she can check for herself. Anyways, she got me extra marinara. The tub was hot, but the sauce was still cold. The inside of my sandwich was cold before adding the marinara too. On another ocasión a few months back I went for a few slices of pizza. It was thin, SUPER SALTY , and made with cheap ingredients. The place itself look really dirty on the inside, and the kitchen (from the view of the front) looked gross. Never will I ever eat here again, or even waste a dollar there.

Its a very small spot. Only one person taking and making orders. I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, lemon pepper wings and garlic bread. The pizza was delicious. The wings were horrible. They were under cooked and under seasoned. The garlic was bad as well. It still tasted like dough. Let's just say I will never go here again and I do not recommend.

This place is an absolute hole in the wall! We ordered the two slices and a can of soda meal. What we received was something I would serve a five year old child. The slice was cut into two to make it appear that it’s actually two slices. We paid $22.00 for that pizza and three cans of soda. DO NOT COME HERE!!!! This place is an absolute joke!

When I arrived at the restaurant there was no one at the counter. The guy making the pizzas asked if I was there to pick up or order. I told Him, pick up and gave him my name. My order wasn’t ready. I went back outside and when I came back in in 10 min. The day was again making pizza dough. He say me and grabbed my order and brought it from the back to hand to me. I grabbed it and left it when I was getting back to hotel I realized items were missing. The pizza was half burnt and I had ordered extra cheese and it looked like it barely had any cheese on it. I wanted a refund for item missing and they refused. They claimed I left it at the counter and I could go back for it. Stay away.

I ate here about 2 weeks ago and pizza was good. I decided to try it again last night Thursday night and I ordered a supreme and it had no taste at all. Not sure what happened in the course of 2 weeks . The veggies weren’t cooked with the pizza barely any sauce on it, I also ordered garlic Parmesan wings and all I could taste was salt did not taste any garlic whatsoever. I had to throw away the whole order. I didn’t bother calling to get it remade I just won’t be going back

I ordered a make your own pizza surprise bag from the app “Too Good to Go” and went to the store to pick it up. Despite all signs at the business and websites saying it should be open, nobody was there. The restaurant is completely closed but is allowing orders to be placed with nobody there to create them. Definitely a disappointing experience.

The guy working was great but on a Friday 10/31/25 night on Halloween he shouldn’t be working alone. He told me the owner was out and about with his family. No big deal just hire more ppl. I cook and eat a lot of wings. Wings tasted old and were black on the ends. One pizza was burnt the other was half cooked. I've eaten here 3 times in the last year and half and it was great. Not this time. I would give 0 out of ten. Absolutely horrible. If the owner reads this don’t blame the employee. Blame your self. My bill was around $80 for pizza that would $10 at Dominos. Won’t go back.

Poor advertisement. Before getting on the highway I wanted to stop in for a few slices. On the door it says open at 11:00 AM and on google it says open at 3:00 pm. I waited until after 3:00 as I got there a few minutes before. The pizzeria NEVER opened. Watched 3 customers walk away as well. Pizza is solid from previous experience but poor ownership.

Nicholas Alberta

Poor advertisement. Before getting on the highway I wanted to stop in for a few slices. On the door it says open at 11:00 AM and on google it says open at 3:00 pm. I waited until after 3:00 as I got there a few minutes before. The pizzeria NEVER opened. Watched 3 customers walk away as well. Pizza is solid from previous experience but poor ownership.

Rachel Omar

I ordered a make your own pizza surprise bag from the app “Too Good to Go” and went to the store to pick it up. Despite all signs at the business and websites saying it should be open, nobody was there. The restaurant is completely closed but is allowing orders to be placed with nobody there to create them. Definitely a disappointing experience.

William Abel

The guy working was great but on a Friday 10/31/25 night on Halloween he shouldn’t be working alone. He told me the owner was out and about with his family. No big deal just hire more ppl. I cook and eat a lot of wings. Wings tasted old and were black on the ends. One pizza was burnt the other was half cooked. I've eaten here 3 times in the last year and half and it was great. Not this time. I would give 0 out of ten. Absolutely horrible. If the owner reads this don’t blame the employee. Blame your self. My bill was around $80 for pizza that would $10 at Dominos. Won’t go back.

kristina beck

I ate here about 2 weeks ago and pizza was good. I decided to try it again last night Thursday night and I ordered a supreme and it had no taste at all. Not sure what happened in the course of 2 weeks . The veggies weren’t cooked with the pizza barely any sauce on it, I also ordered garlic Parmesan wings and all I could taste was salt did not taste any garlic whatsoever. I had to throw away the whole order. I didn’t bother calling to get it remade I just won’t be going back

Johnnelle Gamble

Its a very small spot. Only one person taking and making orders. I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, lemon pepper wings and garlic bread. The pizza was delicious. The wings were horrible. They were under cooked and under seasoned. The garlic was bad as well. It still tasted like dough. Let's just say I will never go here again and I do not recommend.