Pizza My Way

Simply good pizza with wholesome ingredients, delicious flavors, and wide selection of curated creations - of course, customizations are possible. It was a pleasure!

In town for my daughters bday... and we are always looking for new places to eat. Menu was incredible... so many choices. Delicious pizza and wonderful service. Mentioned that it was my daughters bday and she was sick in bed back at the hotel and when we got back to the room we found a handwritten Happy Birthday.... Feel Better ...written inside our take out box.... you really made her day. Thank you for your kindness. Your heart is amazing ♥️

Excellent pizza. We got the chicken Masterpiece and the Veggie Delite, both of which were extremely tasty. Delivered to our hotel within 30 minutes. Wish they had a thin crust option, since the bread makes you full too soon.

The place is in quiet plaza across from Traders Joe. We ordered cheese and California's veggie pizza and were served quickly. Veggie pizza ranks as one of the best we had. Pizza size seems to be larger than chain pizza sizes. Cannot recommend enough.

They’re my go to when I don’t feel like cooking. After two years I have yet to have anything wrong with my order. The Mediterranean Pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had. Perfect combination on a pizza. If you’re thinking about going here, order it. You won’t be disappointed.

I was quite surprised to see the FRESH ingredients! FRESH mushrooms, not canned, REAL garlic CLOVES, not powder, the Vegie Delight was AWESOME, in fact been there over 3 times now and it just gets better each time FRESH artichokes, RED onions OH MY! Sara is such a delight too Service is the best. Recommend this place to even my finicky pizza lovers My ONLY peeve is not having olive oil and vinegar Don't really want a processed salad dressing on my salad. OH, the portions are more than generous. They need MORE stars

Been going to this place since I was 17... and I'm 42... still the best pizza I've ever had! It's the pepperoni with white sauce that takes the cake!

The wind, howled and the rain fell all day long so we decided to pick up a pizza and take it back to our motel and dine in front of the fireplace. Pizza my way was nearby and had favorable local reviews so we placed the phone order and drove overto pick it up. The pizza was delicious and loaded with toppings. When my wife returned to the car with the pizza, she said it was not the type of place that had an eat inside appeal to her. My three star rating for atmosphere is just a guess.

This store is located nearby 17mile drive and had nice pizza with some locally brewed beer. I wouldnmt say excellent but its nice in it

We have been going here from 2015. The food is spectacular. One of the best pizza places in the Monterey area

First of all the place is clean. The service is excellent (friendly, helpful, and attentive). Lastly, the food was very good - we ordered vegetarian pizza with red sauce and the veggies tasted fresh.

Everyone was very friendly and the service was excellent. We've frequented Pizza My Way for many years and the quality has remained the same, extremely high. It was delicious as always.

It was nice and cute place, delicious pizza and welcoming family place. I got the BBQ pizza and it has pineapple which I love highly recommend

While thinking about where to eat jeognac after golf, we suddenly fell in love with pizza. This house we accidentally found while searching was more perfect than expected. The interior was so cuddly, so lovely, so kind and cute a server welcomed us. Pizza was the very taste we were looking for, which was not salty and light. If you want to eat the pizza you want, order custom pizza. I strongly recommend it.

Recommended by my boss, a coworker and I decided to try this pizza joint out. Indeed we were recommended well. A small quaint quiet building. A mural on the wall depicting a local favorite spot, Lovers point. The painting is epic. Accompanied by others flash card size drawings posted along side a designated art area. That's always fun, having paper and something to draw with whilst your waiting. The place was empty just my coworker and I with quite the amount of people coming in to pick up an order Well lit with an Italian vibe , that reminds me of Tuscany. Plenty of seating, including for children. Childrens chairs available. A wide variety of options to choose from all the way from of course pizza , salads, calzones and kid friendly choices as well. Different types of beverages from soda to orange juice and of course wine and beer. Nice small cut limes complemented a nice cold Modelo beer. The pizza was cooked well. No burned spots or saggy dough. The toppings did not oversaturate or over covered the surface. The pizza taste evenly and better than it looked. Highly impressed by the presentation of the food. Chicken wings available. Well cooked through and through . We tried the buffalo wings were tender, the meat was nice and white with a balance of flavor. The spicy level was mild. Nice orange coat on a white plate presented itself as delicious as it looked exquisite. Parking seems limited but it might depend on the days. We found parking easily and readily available. The hostess was welcoming and very helpful. Let us take our time and even asked us a few questions about ourselves. The area is safe and well lit right on one of the main streets of that area. The restroom was clean. The atmosphere was calm and the price was reasonable . I will definitely be going back to try other things in the menu

I got some pizza here while I was visiting relatives in Monterey, and I must say the California Veggie is DIVINE!

This is some of the better pizza I've had. (We got the My Sausage Garden gourmet.) The crust is nice and crispy on the bottom, so it holds up against the toppings. The toppings tasted fresh, the sauce was rich but not overpowering. Really, really good pizza. Paired perfectly with the Fat Lip Amber ale I ordered (good malty amber which matched well with the yeasty crust.) Will come here again if I'm in the area!

Happy 25th birthday thank you for having us and letting us be able to celebrate with you. The food was delicious. Thank you again.

Stopped here on a whim. So glad we did. I don't usually eat the outer crust on my pizza, but I didn't leave a crumb today! I had the thin crust, my guy had the regular. I had a veggie pizza, he had the meat lovers. We were both very happy!

The so called "giant" pizza it's not that giant,it's 20" ! It serves 2 to 4 grown up men, but overall it was a decent pizza. Although, I wish if the dough was not that thick, I'll give it a five for the halal options and for the lovely waitress there!

Hands down BEST PIZZA JOINT! Rather than trying to persuade you on why it's better than any other pizza parlor I've been to, I'll tell you "how" it's better. It was the experience of a moment by moment, slow motion play of not just having your taste buds excited, but the feeling of something so different and beyond expectation. The crew here, too, all work hard and keep things cool. It's not just the pizza, not just the joint... the whole extraordinarily exceeds the composite of all the parts... It's that good!

This is your perfect little community pizza joint... Super nice folks, serving up amazing pizzas made however you want. Delicious!

Lily Garcia

It was nice and cute place, delicious pizza and welcoming family place. I got the BBQ pizza and it has pineapple which I love highly recommend

M Pak

While thinking about where to eat jeognac after golf, we suddenly fell in love with pizza. This house we accidentally found while searching was more perfect than expected. The interior was so cuddly, so lovely, so kind and cute a server welcomed us. Pizza was the very taste we were looking for, which was not salty and light. If you want to eat the pizza you want, order custom pizza. I strongly recommend it.

Andres M

Recommended by my boss, a coworker and I decided to try this pizza joint out. Indeed we were recommended well. A small quaint quiet building. A mural on the wall depicting a local favorite spot, Lovers point. The painting is epic. Accompanied by others flash card size drawings posted along side a designated art area. That's always fun, having paper and something to draw with whilst your waiting. The place was empty just my coworker and I with quite the amount of people coming in to pick up an order Well lit with an Italian vibe , that reminds me of Tuscany. Plenty of seating, including for children. Childrens chairs available. A wide variety of options to choose from all the way from of course pizza , salads, calzones and kid friendly choices as well. Different types of beverages from soda to orange juice and of course wine and beer. Nice small cut limes complemented a nice cold Modelo beer. The pizza was cooked well. No burned spots or saggy dough. The toppings did not oversaturate or over covered the surface. The pizza taste evenly and better than it looked. Highly impressed by the presentation of the food. Chicken wings available. Well cooked through and through . We tried the buffalo wings were tender, the meat was nice and white with a balance of flavor. The spicy level was mild. Nice orange coat on a white plate presented itself as delicious as it looked exquisite. Parking seems limited but it might depend on the days. We found parking easily and readily available. The hostess was welcoming and very helpful. Let us take our time and even asked us a few questions about ourselves. The area is safe and well lit right on one of the main streets of that area. The restroom was clean. The atmosphere was calm and the price was reasonable . I will definitely be going back to try other things in the menu

Victoria & Jose Production's

Happy 25th birthday thank you for having us and letting us be able to celebrate with you. The food was delicious. Thank you again.

Chris Dow

This is some of the better pizza I've had. (We got the My Sausage Garden gourmet.) The crust is nice and crispy on the bottom, so it holds up against the toppings. The toppings tasted fresh, the sauce was rich but not overpowering. Really, really good pizza. Paired perfectly with the Fat Lip Amber ale I ordered (good malty amber which matched well with the yeasty crust.) Will come here again if I'm in the area!

Susan Cooper

Stopped here on a whim. So glad we did. I don't usually eat the outer crust on my pizza, but I didn't leave a crumb today! I had the thin crust, my guy had the regular. I had a veggie pizza, he had the meat lovers. We were both very happy!

Ali 47

The so called "giant" pizza it's not that giant,it's 20" ! It serves 2 to 4 grown up men, but overall it was a decent pizza. Although, I wish if the dough was not that thick, I'll give it a five for the halal options and for the lovely waitress there!

Howard Crampton Jr

Hands down BEST PIZZA JOINT! Rather than trying to persuade you on why it's better than any other pizza parlor I've been to, I'll tell you "how" it's better. It was the experience of a moment by moment, slow motion play of not just having your taste buds excited, but the feeling of something so different and beyond expectation. The crew here, too, all work hard and keep things cool. It's not just the pizza, not just the joint... the whole extraordinarily exceeds the composite of all the parts... It's that good!

Joshua Covington

This is your perfect little community pizza joint... Super nice folks, serving up amazing pizzas made however you want. Delicious!

I love and cherish and utterly miss this place. Unfortunately we no longer live in CA, but much of our money was spent on Friday night Pizza My Way. We went in so often, the staff began to recognize us. We've dined in once and it was really pleasant, but we mainly ordered takeout. Our go-to is the chicken masterpiece, it just has a wonderful flavor profile and never felt heavy/greasy to eat. We've tried other flavors, but nothing beats the masterpiece. I've attempted to make my own version at home; and I'd like to think I've gotten pretty good at it, but it's just not the same. I miss u pizza my way :(

Awesome.. love the pizza.. garlic bread and the salad was the highlight of the day.. will definitely come again🤩🤩🥹🥹😍😍

Sooooo goood. This is the second one I have been too and I must say that this one gives you your money's worth. My son and I split a cheese and combo pizza and my wife had the lasagna.

Some of the best pizza I've ever had, including home made and pizza I've had when living abroad! I have some dietary sensitivities and restrictions so ordering food can be challenging, but Pizza My Way has been consistently amazing every time. Ordering for pick up is also very quick and convenient. If you're craving some delicious local pizza, this is the place to go!

I normally don't order pizza but thought I'd try this place for a quick meal. Oh my gosh, I came here the next 2 days to order pizza again and again today on my last day in town! It's that good! The extra 5 lbs I gained were worth it! Lol! Loved ordering the small cheese pizza and then adding the additional toppings "my way" with thin crust. The dough is delicious combined with the sauce. I add garlic which makes it pop. Love this place.

Don’t let the outside fool you… it’s a charming little Italian feel inside with the sweetest hospitality (young woman with butterfly tattoo/hat was extremely caring about her job and the customers).we were going to order “to go” but it was so quaint inside we decided to stay. The best part was the food! The calzone was the perfect texture of cooked dough, thick cheese, perfect sauce and overall just melted in my mouth with goodness! Also got a fresh salad and a barbecue chicken flatbread which were just as rave worthy! It was nice to step away from the busy Cannery Row vibe to enjoy a great meal experience. Wishing I was a local to enjoy never ending chances at good Italian food!

Flawless, amazing pizza. Tomato sauce on point. Though the cashier was talking about some mad takes like Jordan would beat France over 2 legs.

riya punjabi

Awesome.. love the pizza.. garlic bread and the salad was the highlight of the day.. will definitely come again🤩🤩🥹🥹😍😍

Chris Schmidt

Sooooo goood. This is the second one I have been too and I must say that this one gives you your money's worth. My son and I split a cheese and combo pizza and my wife had the lasagna.

Maria S

I normally don't order pizza but thought I'd try this place for a quick meal. Oh my gosh, I came here the next 2 days to order pizza again and again today on my last day in town! It's that good! The extra 5 lbs I gained were worth it! Lol! Loved ordering the small cheese pizza and then adding the additional toppings "my way" with thin crust. The dough is delicious combined with the sauce. I add garlic which makes it pop. Love this place.

Amanda Stoufer

Don’t let the outside fool you… it’s a charming little Italian feel inside with the sweetest hospitality (young woman with butterfly tattoo/hat was extremely caring about her job and the customers).we were going to order “to go” but it was so quaint inside we decided to stay. The best part was the food! The calzone was the perfect texture of cooked dough, thick cheese, perfect sauce and overall just melted in my mouth with goodness! Also got a fresh salad and a barbecue chicken flatbread which were just as rave worthy! It was nice to step away from the busy Cannery Row vibe to enjoy a great meal experience. Wishing I was a local to enjoy never ending chances at good Italian food!

Mehul Sampat

We have been going here from 2015. The food is spectacular. One of the best pizza places in the Monterey area

Deace ESSC

Been going to this place since I was 17... and I'm 42... still the best pizza I've ever had! It's the pepperoni with white sauce that takes the cake!

Vinay A

This store is located nearby 17mile drive and had nice pizza with some locally brewed beer. I wouldnmt say excellent but its nice in it

Hannah A.

I love and cherish and utterly miss this place. Unfortunately we no longer live in CA, but much of our money was spent on Friday night Pizza My Way. We went in so often, the staff began to recognize us. We've dined in once and it was really pleasant, but we mainly ordered takeout. Our go-to is the chicken masterpiece, it just has a wonderful flavor profile and never felt heavy/greasy to eat. We've tried other flavors, but nothing beats the masterpiece. I've attempted to make my own version at home; and I'd like to think I've gotten pretty good at it, but it's just not the same. I miss u pizza my way :(

Excellent pizza in a small setting. We had the bbq Hawaiian chicken. It was crisp on the bottom & delicious. Decor is simple, yet interesting. They have a limited beer & wine menu, however the beers were small craft brews. Mine was smooth & enjoyable. We had pizza to bring home from a medium, in part because of the amount of ingredients on the pizza.

The pizza was great! Best I had in PG or Monterey. My fiance got a late night hunger so we went looking for somewhere to eat at 900 p.m. We found this shop on Yelp so we showed up before closing and who I'm assuming is the owner still told us no worries take a seat. We ordered simple pepperoni just because we felt bad we were there late. I didn't expect much just because I've passed by the place 100 times and never noticed it. Well let me tell you I was very impressed, the cheese was quality mozzarella and the sauce had to be home made and it was just the right amount not to much or too little. Now for me the crust is what brought it home for me. Im a thick crust and my lady is a New York style pizza and she it was crusty no bready.... her words..lol It was thick but cooked so the bottom was crisp but not burnt and had good flavor. I have to say I definitely will be going back for sure.

Don’t let the building fool you, this is a great pizza place! Had the BBQ chicken flat bread pizza, the garlic cheese bread, and a pepperoni pizza. It was all cooked perfectly. Came out quick and hot! I would definitely recommend coming here! The staff was very nice as well! 9/10

Very good pizza. The place is small and the atmosphere is not quite up to the quality of the food. Friendly staff. We ordered the sausage and roasted garlic special, which seemed like their headline pizza. It comes with sausage and roasted garlic, artichoke hearts, onion, spinach and white sauce- we ordered it with half red. The crust is not thin (I wouldn't say thick either) but still very flaky. The tomato sauce is mild (not spicy [I personally like spicy but it was still good]). Plenty of cheese. Fresh produce.

We ordered takeout. Very easy to order using the Slice app. They were missing one item and they called to apologize and wanted a substitution. The pizza is surprisingly good. We ordered the carne margarita pizza 4.5/5 and regular margarita with added ham 4/5. Easy order pick up. Not cheap, but good.

Ron Rogers

We ordered takeout. Very easy to order using the Slice app. They were missing one item and they called to apologize and wanted a substitution. The pizza is surprisingly good. We ordered the carne margarita pizza 4.5/5 and regular margarita with added ham 4/5. Easy order pick up. Not cheap, but good.

The pizza itself was fine but I am not sure why they cook the pizza with pesto already on it. It is well known that you are not supposed to cook with pesto, as it can turn bitter, which was the case with the pizza I ordered. Most pizza places apply the pesto once the pizza is finished baking.

It's a good, solid pizza joint. We ordered two small pizzas so we could sample more flavors. The shrimp with white sauce was a pleasant pizza with a peppery-garlicky white sauce and ample baby little shrimps. The meat lovers was definitely loaded with meat, but none of that meat was remarkable. I'm not a huge fan of doughy pizza, but that's just a style choice. Also ordered their Greek feta salad and that was a big disappointment: loads of lettuce with no dressing and a pile of stuff dumped on top. Never ordering that again.

We used to live right around the corner from this place so we would do pick up from here from time to time. The staff are friendly and they are usually able to turn around an order pretty reasonably. The pizza is fine, not really good nor is is great. I would consider this a step above your standard delivery chains for sure, but it isn't a true pizzeria quality place in my opinion either.

Pizza was ok, I just picked it up to take home. The Garden salad was not very good - the lettuce looked old, the tomatoes & mushrooms were limp...not what we've seen in other places...

David Rosner

Pizza was ok, I just picked it up to take home. The Garden salad was not very good - the lettuce looked old, the tomatoes & mushrooms were limp...not what we've seen in other places...

Never again! Really bad experience ordering for delivery. After hanging up from initial order, called back immediately to add more toppings and to downsize. Was told it was already in the oven but that additional toppings could be added. This was less than 30 seconds later! So much for "handmade". The pizza was less than mediocre and the additional toppings, which we were charged for needed a microscope to be found. Insult to injury, my credit card was charged 3 times!

We wanted to stop and eat here based on the reviews, but upon arrival we walked into a very dark restaurant with no one else there. We even checked out phones to ensure it was open since no one greeted us initially. Someone emerged in the ordering window and looked entirely annoyed that we walked in. Not seeing any menu, I further annoyed him by asking for a menu. But based on the atmosphere and welcome we received we looked for a second and decided we didn't want to stay in that dark grumpy place.

Jodi Mack

We wanted to stop and eat here based on the reviews, but upon arrival we walked into a very dark restaurant with no one else there. We even checked out phones to ensure it was open since no one greeted us initially. Someone emerged in the ordering window and looked entirely annoyed that we walked in. Not seeing any menu, I further annoyed him by asking for a menu. But based on the atmosphere and welcome we received we looked for a second and decided we didn't want to stay in that dark grumpy place.