Tatiana Klochkova

Short stop for the late lunch. My son had Maui special pizza. Fast and friendly service. The place gives you a unique feeling of immersion in history, takes you 50-100 years back. Bwt. Pizza was very good!

+3

Ezra S.

First of all, the service here is always amazing. We had a server today, don't catch her name but she was super nice and made dining in even better. Best pizza I've ever had! Other pizza places I've been to never fill me up but with just 2 slices here I'm satisfied! You never have to worry about not getting enough cheese on your pizza and the taste is super good! They also have delicious ranch! I'll be going here for pizza often! Tried their boneless wings too and were also great!

Ava Chiao

My friend Michelle and her partner Brenden said this was a traditional to go to Gay 90s Pizza after the Scottish Festival. So yesterday we were inaugurated to delicious food. This was their 4th year at the festival. Best service far according to them. Our waitress was kind and checked in with us. The pizza was absolutely delicious. For even better pizza It could have used 5 more mins in the oven to get crust baked all the way through and crunchy roasted cheese!! Bread was crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside. It was so flavorful by itself. The bottom of the crust is good. It’s kind like a marriage of deep dish with Sicilian thin crust. Besides the toppings tasted fresh and the sausage was especially good. The sauce is also what made it super flavorful on Franks Special. Read the captions for the review.

+1

Keshila Shannon

I’ve always seen this place on my visits to Pleasanton and decided today was the day. It was solid—great value for the money. The pizza dough was thick and had the right blend of salt. Lunch comes with a decent house salad. I had the pesto pizza with sausage, bell pepper, and onion, and I would easily have it again when in the area. The service was sweet. Talk about friendly people who sincerely want to help you. Love the energy. Note picture of pizza was of a friend and this is a small.

Bradley Nakaji

First time here. Looks to be an old time Italian/pizza parlor. Pizzas looked good and smelled better. We had pasta dishes and those also looked and smelled wonderful. Not too expensive and very family orientated. Addendum: Went back a few months later. Still haven't tried the pizza. Pasta is too good. The only bummer, the server assigned to us was not very attentive. Served salad and meal together. Never came back after throwing the food on the table. Just our server was not so hot. The other server in the area had twice as many tables and she was around 10 times more.

+3

Hugh McLaughlin

We’ve been coming to this restaurant many times over the years although it has probably been about 5 years since our last visit. We had a fantastic server today who really took good care of us. Her name was Julie. She was great. Our pizza was a medium 1/2 Veggie and 1/2 Hawaiian. The crust was cooked to perfection but we thought overall the pizza was lacking real flavor. Maybe our taste has changed over the years since we have are big fans of Tony’s in SF (or his newer Slice House Establishments) or Gold Dust Pizza in Ripon. I still think this place is a nice restaurant if you are looking for a well made pizza and you’re in the Downtown Pleasanton area. We will go back if we are in the area and want pizza.

+4

Paige

First time to eating here, was greeted by Connor . Had high hopes as I’ve heard really good things about this place . We ordered our pizza for pick up half Maui half tomato and basil. When we got home the pizza was watery, there was not enough cheese . I think it was the sauce that was the problem . It was all merged together so we had to recut it. And then when u picked up each piece it fell apart. It was tasty but super messy . The other review photos look good so maybe just a bad run but bad first impression sadly .

Allison Wright

Food was ok. Too much cheese on the pizza for me. Minestrone soup was under seasoned. The bread was fresh, hot, and delicious! Service was great!

+6

We got delivered the wrong pizza?!?! And The tomato sauce as a odd taste but the toppings and the pizza overall was yummy and freshm

I grew up eating gay 90s pizza. The last time I ordered pickup, they kept my credit card and I had to return to the restaurant for it. Today, I ordered a medium veggie pizza, the one with the artichokes, and added Canadian bacon. I asked for extra Weil cooked and 12 slices instead of eight. I went to pick it up and looked at it, and said what is this? This was not the regular vegetarian pizza. It was their fancy deluxe one with feta cheese and eggplant. There is no artichoke hearts on the fancy one. They did add the Canadian bacon. They said that I could wait another 30 minutes and they’d make me a new one, but I’m taking it to a skilled nursing home to have it with my mother who’s recovering from a stroke. She’s waiting for me and this pizza so we can have it watching the Super Bowl from her room. I ended up paying for the pizza. No discount, no apology, just a lame offer to make me a new one which I don’t have time for. I am so incredibly disappointed with their Customer service. This is the second time in a row I’ve had a problem with gay 90s. What is going on?

Wojtek Rocko

Ordered a pizza for pick up during lunch break, it was ready 30min late. Waitress couldn’t print the receipt and had to call some to get help, took 30min to get that. In the end pizza was just ok. For that price point i was expecting more

Veronika Švecová

The place was half full and staff was running around crazy. It took 45min to get two pizza’s to go. If you like Italian pizza, this place is not for you. It has heavy bread dough. Toppings are good and fresh. But pizza dough has no taste, you can’t even taste salt in it. Wanted to try something else but we are not coming back and sticking with Mike’s.

Froyd Newton

Food was okay. Service was awful. The appetizer I ordered never came. My child's meal was the last to be served to the point that I assumed they forgot it too. The waitress never came to refill our drinks. When everything was done, we waited 10+ minutes for her to bring out our check and she never came; we had to go in and find someone to pay. Food was not worth the awful service and wait.