Jin

My number one spot for a great authentic New York slice. No other pizzeria in the area I've tried comes close. I always get a plain, extra well done pie and it tastes HEAVENLY. They deserve all the love and support!

Thomas Liquori

The family and I were looking for a good pizza spot before our drive back to PA. Our usual place was closed for the holiday weekend, so we decided to try this pizza place because of all the good reviews and was close in proximity to where we were in Hillside. Louie behind the counter is a great guy. Very nice and very welcoming with a big smile. The pizza was what you expect from a New York pizzeria. Crust is crunchy yet soft, nice little char on the crust to give it that blackened flavor after-taste, which is amazing. Everything from the cheese to the sauce made the cooked slice look like it was golden brown. The crust was also not too thin and also not too thick. It was the perfect size to get that crunch from a slice. I also ordered a sausage roll and garlic knots, which were also equally yummy. Overall, I would not hesitate to come here again next time I am in town. Great pizza with a smile.

+7

Jacob Miranda

Best Pizza In Richmond Hill Queens Hands Down!! I’ve been coming to this pizza shop since the early 90s. It has been in the community since 1974. It is family owned and still family run every time I visit my old neighborhood in Richmond. I must stop in at Alfie‘s to get a slice, it is basically a traditionand I’d like to pass that down to my son when I bring him to visit.

Chandler Gaines

I grew up eating Alfie's pizza. I returned to NY for my 50th birthday, and one of the first things I did was to eat at Alfie's, and it's still the best. Their slices are perfect, and the zeppoles were mouth-watering. Almost all of the pizzerias that I grew up with are gone, but Alfie's is still standing, and I'm forever grateful.

Benjamin Qiu

Keepin it real out here in Richmond Hill I actually really like this spot, grew on me over the years. Nothing special in today's standards but you can tell it's a family own neighborhood spot. Been around for a long time and still deliver solid pizza all these years.

Breanna Kimes

Wow. Super impressed. The owner/manager was sooo friendly and just a joy. We are a family and he even had already picked a movie for the TVs that avoided bad influences. Who thinks of that anymore?! That's above and beyond, in a beautiful way. We had a delicious grandma pie with vodka sauce, garlic knots, vegetable calzone, and chicken and broccoli. The food was perfect. The prices are so reasonable, and it was very clean. Was just a fabulous stop for grub. Sorry we didn't get the garlic knots or calzone pics. We ate it too fast. So yum!

Chris Celone

Stopped by Alfie's Pizzeria and Restaurant today after seeing a video of a great looking square pie. I ordered an upside down pizza and while we were waiting, Louie gave us a free slice "just to get the palate going". Their square pie is second to none! Can't wait to go back! Thanks for everything Louie!

Trehan

Beautiful Food, Beautiful service, Great choice if your after authentic Pizza from a family run business for now 50 years. Definitely a great choice. The pizzas were amazing and a great size too. You can choose by pizza or by slice along with some additional sides. Thank you for the Alfie’s experience. 💫

+1

Nicodemus Supangkat

I had the regular slice, Grandma and Upside Pizza. WOW to all 3. The best one by far was the upside down pizza. The tomato sauce was so fresh. The cheese was amazing. The best part was the crust, it was so soft inside and crispy outside. Phenomenal! Dan L. recommended this spot. Now, I recommend it to all of you. Best pizza in Queens! This is my pizza spot forever!

CY

BEST PEPPERONI ROLL EVER 10/10! Also the best pizza you’ll find in all of NYC! Highly recommend, affordable prices and great customer service. Their eggplant & a la vodka sauce is my favorite 😍

Mayumi Verse

Alfie’s pepperoni and eggplant parmesan slices are amazing! So is their service! The only qualms I have are that they could work on the toppings of their vegetable slice, the zeppoles could use a bit more powdered sugar and softness, and the spinach roll is a bit dry and plain. My previous neighborhood’s pizzeria (San Remo on Cortelyou Rd) had fully loaded vegetable slices and a thicker base to support it. Also, their spinach rolls had cheese pulls and more spinach. I think the prices are comparable, so step up your pizza game, Alfie’s! Saying this out of tough love! 🩵 Also, Apple Pay and cards should be supported 😭

Enzo Tan

Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant, boasting 800+ glowing reviews, definitely lived up to the hype! We tried the All Meat Calzone and Tuna Wrap, and both were absolutely delicious—I couldn't stop until they were gone, hot and fresh. Be aware, it's a cash-only spot, but they do have an ATM inside. While the dine-in area could use a bit more attention to cleanliness, it's clear they handle a ton of takeout and delivery orders. The staff were a highlight—super friendly and full of jokes! Overall, a great first-time experience and highly recommended.