Fatte's Pizza

Best pizza i have ever had . Definitely recommend the white sauce, however it did not looked the cleanliest inside if you can ignore that its pretty good

Ordering over the phone was very pleasant, whoever took my order was so cheerful it was a little contagious lol. Always satisfied with the Monster Combo!

I found their pies to be phenomenal (I got 2 veggie pizzas) fresh ingredients and a perfectly risen dough. Plus cant be beat for the price! I unfortunately had an issue with one of the two pies however they were kind enough to give me a full refund (after me denying twice that they make me another pizza.) Overall 9/10 would reccomend! The customer service could be a bit better but again they did the right thing which is why I'm giving this place 5 stars. Enjoy!

Always AMAZING. Wonderful pizza 11/10, amazing service every time 11/10. My favorite white sauce pizza EVER. Super happy to have this wonderful pizza place nearby :)

Fattes pizza in Slo is the best ! Always yummy , consistent all the way around. I even travel from Atascadero to go to this specific location because their food is always too notch and super fast ! Owner is such a a nice guy too ! Beats the Atascadero location from every standpoint !

Been coming here for almost two decades. All pizzas are two for one and super solid. They have a fairly chewy dough with a crisp outside that I love but it may not be everyone's cup of tea. Fast and cheap, highly recommend anything with white sauce and the monster sub, but nothing I can knock about a classic pepperoni with red sauce or their premade pies. Just call your order in, I've never had the SLO online ordering work if it even exists.

You get 2 pizzas for the price. They have a wide variety of choices or you can design your own. It's always hot, toppings are good looking & enuf, not too doughy but it's not a thin crust. Very good value & very close to my house!

We ordered the family meal and it was great. The pizza was delicious as was the buffalo wings . You can't beat the price of $42 and that was with delivery . The delivery guy was great and more importantly brought the complete order .

Their two large pizzas for 19.99 is literally the best deal in slo and the pizza is so good. You can get two larges and a salad that will easily feed 3 or 4 people for less than 30 bucks if you pick it up. Fattes is a gem.

Classic, simple, and delicious! Born and raised in SLO, and Fatte's has always been a staple. Their prices are reasonable, and their pizza is absolutely delicious. Whether you're hosting a party or just craving some pizza, you can't go wrong here.

AMAZING Pizza. Buy one get one free is an insane deal, and the pizza is actually really good. The wings are skippable, too fatty, and my wife went bananas for the garlic bread. Highly recommend this place

We made a door dash. And when we called they said they do a buy 1 get 1 free pizza, which was not listed on door dash site. The gentleman on the phone was so helpful and told us how to enter the info in door dash so that we didn't get over charge. We ended getting 4 pizzas for the price of 2. I got the small chicken combo without olives. It was soooo DELICIOUS!! I'm a travel nurse and upset I didn't find this place earlier. Other pizza joints crust are flat and bready like flat bread. But Fatte's pizza crust is soft and airy like pizza crust should be! The white sauce was flavorful and the toppings plentiful. I recommend this place 100%. They will be my go to pizza place. I'm definitely going to try their Hawaiian😁. Woot!!

Listen. Best Pie Ever. A must-stop any time we’re in the area. The ratio of cheese to toppings and the delicious white sauce makes for a heavenly combination. PLUS, it’s ALWAYS 2-for-1. Like. Always.

One of the best pizza spots in the 5 cities area. Hands down best garlic bread. Pineapple belongs on pizza. Change my mind

Riza Ali

AMAZING Pizza. Buy one get one free is an insane deal, and the pizza is actually really good. The wings are skippable, too fatty, and my wife went bananas for the garlic bread. Highly recommend this place

San Jean

We made a door dash. And when we called they said they do a buy 1 get 1 free pizza, which was not listed on door dash site. The gentleman on the phone was so helpful and told us how to enter the info in door dash so that we didn't get over charge. We ended getting 4 pizzas for the price of 2. I got the small chicken combo without olives. It was soooo DELICIOUS!! I'm a travel nurse and upset I didn't find this place earlier. Other pizza joints crust are flat and bready like flat bread. But Fatte's pizza crust is soft and airy like pizza crust should be! The white sauce was flavorful and the toppings plentiful. I recommend this place 100%. They will be my go to pizza place. I'm definitely going to try their Hawaiian😁. Woot!!

Sara R

Listen. Best Pie Ever. A must-stop any time we’re in the area. The ratio of cheese to toppings and the delicious white sauce makes for a heavenly combination. PLUS, it’s ALWAYS 2-for-1. Like. Always.

Brittny Perez

One of the best pizza spots in the 5 cities area. Hands down best garlic bread. Pineapple belongs on pizza. Change my mind

Great deal on pizza my fav the chicken combo with the white sause. Staff is always friendly.

Take out and delivery only. I have been going here for a very very long time. They know the sound of my voice! I always pick it up and tip in Modelo Especial (for the guys that are over 21). Also, Fatte's is really good if you have to feed a crew that can eat 10-20 pizzas, just give them a little notice. Still a good price point during these "transitory inflation" times.

Best pizza place in the world and I've had pizza from coast to coast. The workers are awesome in the delivery drivers are very good people. They were so quiet and respectful my dog did not even bark so he got some pizza too.

These guys really know how to make a pizza. Aside from that they are a bunch of locals who are actually nice! Who’d of thought? Good food, good service and kindness. A great combo for any pizza night!

Went inside and got one pizza for the second one to be free. Now i know that this deal exists but for some reason it suprised me today. Anyways the pizza was so delicous 10/10 will come here as soon as im craving pizza.

Extremely helpful staff! Also they have a great deal where for the price of any one pizza you can get two pizzas (you will pay the price for just the more expensive pizza). Pizza was also super delicious, one small pizza had about 6 small slices which was enough for two small meals! Definitely recommend and will be back!

This place has been a go to spot for years and never once has it disappointed in their quality. Their monster combo is incredible and don’t even get me started about the cheese sticks. Definitely a must try.

So we found this place looking for pizza places it had pretty good reviews, so we went ahead and started looking for this place. It ended up being a little hole in the spot. Didn't look like much, but the traffic flow coming in and out said otherwise. We were able to by two pizzas one topping each for $26. But if I was you I'd call my order in instead of just coming down and ordering there for it'll be a little late. This being a small store is actually producing a lot of pizzas. When we got to order it smelled so delicious the nice smells coming from the pizza part of the aroma of their sandwiches chicken smelled good but when we finally took a bite of the pizza it wasn't bad. The flavors were good I'd prefer to thinner crust though but all in all I come back I'd visit this place again on another vacation. I gave it and eight or eight and a half. But don't take my word for it come down and check it out for yourself.

Sebliminal

Went inside and got one pizza for the second one to be free. Now i know that this deal exists but for some reason it suprised me today. Anyways the pizza was so delicous 10/10 will come here as soon as im craving pizza.

ryry love

Best pizza place in the world and I've had pizza from coast to coast. The workers are awesome in the delivery drivers are very good people. They were so quiet and respectful my dog did not even bark so he got some pizza too.

HL L

Great deal on pizza my fav the chicken combo with the white sause. Staff is always friendly.

Caley O'Horo

Extremely helpful staff! Also they have a great deal where for the price of any one pizza you can get two pizzas (you will pay the price for just the more expensive pizza). Pizza was also super delicious, one small pizza had about 6 small slices which was enough for two small meals! Definitely recommend and will be back!

Jessica

Ordering over the phone was very pleasant, whoever took my order was so cheerful it was a little contagious lol. Always satisfied with the Monster Combo!

Am Lg (Nyx)

This place has been a go to spot for years and never once has it disappointed in their quality. Their monster combo is incredible and don’t even get me started about the cheese sticks. Definitely a must try.

jessica beeching

The gentleman who took my order was respectful and attentive, he answered my questions and gave me even better suggestions! I travel a lot for work and seek out small businesses like this, when I'm in town next I'll for sure be visiting again. Also, the garlic bread and pizza were some of the best I've had in *forever*!!

Michael H Jaranilla Sr

So we found this place looking for pizza places it had pretty good reviews, so we went ahead and started looking for this place. It ended up being a little hole in the spot. Didn't look like much, but the traffic flow coming in and out said otherwise. We were able to by two pizzas one topping each for $26. But if I was you I'd call my order in instead of just coming down and ordering there for it'll be a little late. This being a small store is actually producing a lot of pizzas. When we got to order it smelled so delicious the nice smells coming from the pizza part of the aroma of their sandwiches chicken smelled good but when we finally took a bite of the pizza it wasn't bad. The flavors were good I'd prefer to thinner crust though but all in all I come back I'd visit this place again on another vacation. I gave it and eight or eight and a half. But don't take my word for it come down and check it out for yourself.

A solid & well earned 4 star. Honestly, a 4.5 star rating if it was possible. Warm and friendly staff. FAST made pies to perfection. Sauce is incredible. Quality cheese and toppings. Hits the spot, time and time again.

Fattys has pretty good pizza and good deals. I like it but find myself ordering from other locations instead. Nothing that notable I can remember.

What a deal! "At Fatte's, it's ALWAYS buy one, get one free." For value and where quality of ingredients combine to stretch your dollars (BOGO), this pizzeria makes good pizzas. Their ingredients on white sauce veggie had plenty of flavor. Great job! A pleasant surpirse to find the Veggie pie full of California's finest artichokes sprinkled all over. This ingredient is not typically default for a pizza, in the USA. (Thank you to California's farmers!)

Fattes has SUCH GOOD PIZZA!! You can't beat the buy one get one free deal they constantly have. I HIGHLY recommend the white chicken pizza. It is SO delicious. The workers are pretty friendly, they missed one of our pizzas, but gave us soda to make it right which was very nice of them. Grab some pizza before hitting the beach. It is a central coast/college staple.

We stopped by because we have visited other locations in California, and Coalinga CA still has the best. They don't have a lunchtime deal Coalinga offers either. We got their two small one-topping pizzas, one pepperoni, and one sausage. They were really good. We met a really nice young man .

Jed Justiniani

What a deal! "At Fatte's, it's ALWAYS buy one, get one free." For value and where quality of ingredients combine to stretch your dollars (BOGO), this pizzeria makes good pizzas. Their ingredients on white sauce veggie had plenty of flavor. Great job! A pleasant surpirse to find the Veggie pie full of California's finest artichokes sprinkled all over. This ingredient is not typically default for a pizza, in the USA. (Thank you to California's farmers!)

Ericka Gilliland

Fattes has SUCH GOOD PIZZA!! You can't beat the buy one get one free deal they constantly have. I HIGHLY recommend the white chicken pizza. It is SO delicious. The workers are pretty friendly, they missed one of our pizzas, but gave us soda to make it right which was very nice of them. Grab some pizza before hitting the beach. It is a central coast/college staple.

Boone Hutchins

We stopped by because we have visited other locations in California, and Coalinga CA still has the best. They don't have a lunchtime deal Coalinga offers either. We got their two small one-topping pizzas, one pepperoni, and one sausage. They were really good. We met a really nice young man .

I order chicken pizza yesterday night. There is no chicken.

I ordered a chicken garlic combo with white sauce and a vegetarian combo. Picked up the order and got home and my pizza was just chicken and garlic without any of the other ingredients. Called to get it corrected and was told it was my fault. I order this pizza all the time. Never had an issue before.

Fatte's Pizza is one of favorite though unfortunately last night is the first time we were not too pleased with our order. The hot wings tasted burnt and the pizza wasn't that good. We ordered 3 different types of pizza so not sure if we'll be going back anytime soon.

Pizza is super mediocre... 24.95$ for 2 medium pizzas?!?! I got veggie too! No expensive meat!! No extra anything. Pizza got here quick but I'm literally a 1/10 of a mile from the place. I'll go else where from no on.. Dude was super rude on the phone too honestly

I have ordered from here before and have never had a problem until tonight. I was on my second slice of pizza and I bit into this plastic that has some sort of numbers on it. I immediately stopped my kids from eating their food. This is so unacceptable as it could've been one of my kids eating this.

Angie Cano

I have ordered from here before and have never had a problem until tonight. I was on my second slice of pizza and I bit into this plastic that has some sort of numbers on it. I immediately stopped my kids from eating their food. This is so unacceptable as it could've been one of my kids eating this.

I have no idea how this place has such high reviews?? Pizza is terrible. The crust literally tastes like cardboard. If you have leftovers forget about eating them. The crust gets so hard it cuts your mouth! If you want cheap pizza that is actually good, go to Pizza La Nova at Madonna & Los Osos Valley Road. 2 larges for $13.99! The only reason I rate Fatte's two stars is because when the pizza is fresh it is halfway edible, and they are relatively cheap.

i’ve gone in there several times for delivery orders, and they’ve never once asked to see my phone, …but this time they want to see my phone to show that I’m not lying to them (when I would not know about the order ahead of time if I was not assigned to it) and what really pisses me off about it is that I was on a phone call and he wanted to interrupt my phone call to prove to him that I’m not lying to him to get the food to be delivered that was already paid for

The worst pizza place in SLO. The owner/business owner increase prices by the day and week and do not honor any valid coupons with valid expiration dates that come in the mail or are posted on their website (which they conveniently claim is not theirs). I will be reporting this business to the better business bureau for price gouging and unfair business practices! There is a limit to what loyal customers will put up with before being taken advantage of. I hope other customers boycott this unethical business as I have sadly after 20 plus years of buying pizza from this place.

Pizza is almost below standard quality.. For the price anyone would expect more. Seem to be in over their heads, several orders (for 6 minutes away) took over an hour and a half! On an off day too. When told that our next order would be half off for the wait, the guy on phones (absolutely brain dead fellow) told me to EMAIL THE OWNER TO GET OUR DISCOUNT VERIFIED?! Everyone who has delivered has looked and been stoned and inattentive.. For the few times we get it for the kids, really falls short for pizza, simple enough yet missing mark by a mile. We WON'T BE ordering from them again, which is their loss as its easy money...If you don't care about quality, level of service, or price, then they will work just fine. I'm local and a native and they are a damn shame.

I see a bunch of good reviews and I must have caught them on a bad day . Garlic bread was cooked on one side and the butter side soggy. Had to recook it at home . And the man who answered the phone was rude and when I picked the food was very rude and was slamming my salad on my pizza boxes . I've been in the restaurant business for a long time . And that is no way to treat a customer I don't care how busy you are . And I hope the owner gets to see this review

Selling mediocre pizza is fine, but Domino's doesn't charge me to use my credit card without any disclosure of the fee, which is both illegal in California and in violation of this merchant's contract with Mastercard. If you can't afford business expenses as simple as a 3% credit card fee, you are an unsustainable business and need to close. Or take cash only, but I'm sure that would illicit similar eyerolls from the staff that I received when I asked for a copy of my receipt. POS systems aren't difficult to use, but neither is making pizza and they can barely do that, either.

Daniel cruz

I see a bunch of good reviews and I must have caught them on a bad day . Garlic bread was cooked on one side and the butter side soggy. Had to recook it at home . And the man who answered the phone was rude and when I picked the food was very rude and was slamming my salad on my pizza boxes . I've been in the restaurant business for a long time . And that is no way to treat a customer I don't care how busy you are . And I hope the owner gets to see this review

Amy Brooks

Selling mediocre pizza is fine, but Domino's doesn't charge me to use my credit card without any disclosure of the fee, which is both illegal in California and in violation of this merchant's contract with Mastercard. If you can't afford business expenses as simple as a 3% credit card fee, you are an unsustainable business and need to close. Or take cash only, but I'm sure that would illicit similar eyerolls from the staff that I received when I asked for a copy of my receipt. POS systems aren't difficult to use, but neither is making pizza and they can barely do that, either.

A few minutes I just got my pizza, chicken combo with garlic sauce and I was giving the first bite when I pulled out of my mouth a big ball of tangle hair, this was disgusting and disappointing because is the first time it happened this in this restaurant. And obviously this will be the last time I will buy a pizza from them.

Really bad customer service. Had questions on pricing and toppings due to the fact that I didn’t read their online menu. Might I add which is very vague in detail. The guy on the phone was rude and seemed frustrated. Nice start to my Labor Day. I’ll order form dominos instead it’s the same quality pizza anyways.

Ernesto C.

A few minutes I just got my pizza, chicken combo with garlic sauce and I was giving the first bite when I pulled out of my mouth a big ball of tangle hair, this was disgusting and disappointing because is the first time it happened this in this restaurant. And obviously this will be the last time I will buy a pizza from them.

Alejandro Guillermo

Really bad customer service. Had questions on pricing and toppings due to the fact that I didn’t read their online menu. Might I add which is very vague in detail. The guy on the phone was rude and seemed frustrated. Nice start to my Labor Day. I’ll order form dominos instead it’s the same quality pizza anyways.