Menú
I Love NY Pizza
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Schenectady

I Love NY Pizza

★★★★ 4.1 · 101 reseñas

At I Love NY Pizza, we're passionate about serving up delicious, thin-crust slices that capture the heart of New York City's iconic pizza culture. Our specialty pies are made fresh daily, and our pasta and subs are crafted with love to satisfy every craving. We've built a cozy sp...

I Love NY Pizza

Pizza · Schenectady

4.1 · 436 ressenyes Google
www.theoriginalilovenypizza.com

Sobre I Love NY Pizza

At I Love NY Pizza, we're passionate about serving up delicious, thin-crust slices that capture the heart of New York City's iconic pizza culture. Our specialty pies are made fresh daily, and our pasta and subs are crafted with love to satisfy every craving. We've built a cozy space on Union Street...

At I Love NY Pizza, we're passionate about serving up delicious, thin-crust slices that capture the heart of New York City's iconic pizza culture. Our specialty pies are made fresh daily, and our pasta and subs are crafted with love to satisfy every craving. We've built a cozy space on Union Street in Schenectady where friends and family can gather over a cold beer or glass of wine. Our friendly service team is dedicated to making every guest feel like part of the neighborhood. With terrace tables perfect for enjoying a slice (or three) outdoors, we're the perfect spot to relax and savor the taste of authentic New York-style pizza.

Què diuen els clients de I Love NY Pizza

I Love NY Pizza in Schenectady is a local favorite known for its delicious NY-style pizza with thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce. Customers rave about the variety of slices, especially the Bacon Ranch Tomato. Service is friendly, and many appreciate the outdoor seating.

Plats populars

Bacon Ranch Tomato slices sweet honey bbq chicken buffalo chicken broccoli and chicken CBR vodka sauce buffalo wings garlic knots

Ideal per a

Locals Ràpid Informal

Tip: Try the many varieties of slices to experience the range of flavors. Outdoor seating is available for enjoying your meal.

Services

🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian
🎯 Casual 👥 Groups

Què veure a prop

Central Park
A 953m

Central Park

parque

Veure detalls

Dades de Wikidata

Preguntes freqüents sobre I Love NY Pizza

I Love NY Pizza es troba a 1705 Union St, Schenectady, NY 12309, Schenectady.
I Love NY Pizza ofereix cuina pizza.
I Love NY Pizza té horari d'atenció. Consulta el perfil per horaris actualitzats.
I Love NY Pizza ofereix els serveis següents: menjar al local, per emportar, lliurament.
Els plats més recomanats a I Love NY Pizza segons les opinions dels clients són: Bacon Ranch Tomato slices, sweet honey bbq chicken, buffalo chicken, broccoli and chicken, CBR.
I Love NY Pizza és ideal per a locals, menjar ràpid, informal.
I Love NY Pizza in Schenectady is a local favorite known for its delicious NY-style pizza with thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce. Customers rave about the variety of slices, especially the Bacon Ranch Tomato. Service is friendly, and many appreciate the outdoor seating.
Try the many varieties of slices to experience the range of flavors. Outdoor seating is available for enjoying your meal.
436
Ressenyes

Opinions de I Love NY Pizza Schenectady

4.1
436
5★
64%
4★
15%
3★
5%
2★
4%
1★
12%
Ressenyes (101)
J
John Walter

Good atmosphere, and amazing owner. Took time out of his day to talk to us and keep us company.

m
max cardenas

Awsome NY style pizza, owner is a great cat with good conversation!

S
Sandra Perkins

Just rcvd a delivery...meat lovers pizza garlic parm wings. Meat ravioli w vodka sause..dessert frys even the delivery from packaging to the driver...ALL DONE W PERFECTION... finally a place worth the $.. don't change..thanks

E
Elliot Nish

Awesome. Owner takes great care and is straight up and down to Earth. Love it.

R
Robin Phifer

Pizza is great always! Love the friendly atmosphere, and my host/ server is the coolest. Thank you for your humor and kindness.

T
Tabitha Buono

Stopped in to pick up a couple of slices at 8:40pm. Very nice, accommodating, and super fast!! The pizza was great, and HUGE!! Literally like getting 4 slices. Very, very good!

R
Renee Alane

Went in for a slice with my friends two little girls. We all got free cookies with our awesome pizza and service! Nice people. Good food. What’s not to love? Thanks!

G
Ginny Brim

I order from time to time and never had an issue. Tonight I did and they rectified it with no issues and sent a new order in a timely manner. Thanks for delivering!!! The delivery driver definitely went out of his way.

A
April Fair

Best Pizza in the capital region. We love going the there. Nice setup and great service.

Z
Zarif Hanif

The local pizza joint. Great pizza shop pizza reasonably priced menu and friendly staff. The one thing that keeps me going back is the cleanliness!

C
Chas Trigler

The Best New York city style pizza in this area. The pizza guys are real new Yorkers, one bite of their delicious pizza makes it obvious!!!! So,upon editing this review,let me say these guys make the best pizza in the area, but,the WORST italian sub I've ever had...I ordered an italian sub for dinner tonight,they told me all of the ingredients on the phone..including provolone cheese...they had the balls to charge me $11 for an italian sub,then when I get home there was no provolone cheese on it...I'm learning that around this area,you have to check your order before leaving the place..I'm really dissapointed in this place...😡

A
Alex Flowers

It's really awesome pizza. I've been going for more than a year now, and have yet to be disappointed. There used to be a soda machine that for whatever reason mixed particularly well, though now it's just cans. Still one of my favorite pizza places though.

J
Jenna Barno

Picked up a pizza and wings today. I'm picky with my pizza and wings but this was perfectly made! The staff were super friendly!! This is definitely a go to spot!

J
Jesse Bird

Phenomenal service, notch food and the guys in there are some of the chillest dudes you'll ever come across. I'd give 100 stats if I could.

J
Jackson szova

My boyfriend and I are pizza crazy. ILNY pizza was about the third pizza place weve tried in schenectady and it will definitely be our last. There's no need to go anywhere else. Their food is amazing! Everything from the pizza, to the rolls, salads and even appetizers. Plus they're super friendly, funny and the prices are cheap.

N
N. “Aniel” Galloway

Pizza was top notch, they didn't have alot of vegetarian selection but what they did have blew me away. The guy working there was pleasant, will definitely be back

n
nooch x

Always have a great experience here, food is consistent, My family is always happy to come here. This is the type of pizza we love, please don't change

D
David Kinlock

Best pizza around. Very fresh and authentic. The service is top notch and the prices are quite reasonable. Located in a friendly neighborhood setting.

C
Christopher Lentakis

Great pizza, better than dominos

P
Phil Ammirati

Always love this place. The closest you're gonna get to a correct and authentic NYC slice. Great wings here too!

M
Mimi Phillips

I am a fan for sure!!!! I just love the wings I get !!!!!

L
LoyalKale

My family really loves the margherita pizza here. Whenever I pick up my order, I'm happy to see that the staff are wearing masks and there is signage to remind patrons of mask wearing and social distancing.

J
Judy Tomisman

Staff are super friendly and take care of my special requests......lots of little pieces! Pizza is delish....love all of the varieties. Cheesecake is good too!

A
Austin Stein

Traveling for work and found this place, and was beyond impressed. Between the hospitality and the quality of pizza it was the best New York experience I've had 10/10

T
Trisha Little

Ordered through Grubhub, the grilled chicken wrap was awesome! The delivery was quick, the guy I talked to on the phone to modify the order was super nice. Will definitely be trying this place again

N
Neil Alers

Daily full range of all-yummy pies! My favorites are BBQ chicken, and plain. Great, flavorful crust. Friendliest pizza joint in the area. Six tables inside, more on the new deck. Parking is a challenge, but this is well worth the walk.

J
JP B

Yeah, this place is legit! Awesome pizza- thanks!

R
Rachael Andrews

I have never been disappointed ordering from I Love NY Pizza. They always provide the best customer service & the food is always delicious! Thank you for all your hard work & for providing top quality food & service! ❤️🍕

K
Kelsey Gaines

Went with a larger group after church and the owner was the sweetest guy! Food was fresh and delicious!

T
Trish G

We took the kids there tonight. We order one of the specials that came with soda & wings. Order garlic knots on the side. Everything was delicious. Cooked perfectly. It was real pizza, not that stuff they try to pass off as authentic pizza up here. We were born & raised on L.I & we are very picky about our pizza. This was by far the closest to L.I pizza that we have had since we moved up here 10 years ago. The staff was without a doubt the most polite & friendliest of any place we had ever gone to. We had to make a few changes to our order after we ordered (picky kids) & they were more than happy to help. We ate inside the place & the girl that works there even brought the kids over some cheesecake. They were so happy & said it was yummy. lol We all cant wait to go there again. I don't know how they got any bad reviews. This is my 2nd time going there & both times we were more than satisfied with our experience. I already told everyone on FB that they have to go try the food there. The only complaint I have is I wish they were closer to where I live in Amsterdam. Definitely worth the trip though. :)

A
Anna Manzari

Tried this last week, ordering again tonite. We love it. My 1 year old had 2 slices. Definitely the best place to get pizza and wings. I wanted to call and complain bc it was so good wish they would have put more food in my order. I don't mind ordering more though, no problem at all. Prolly will order once a week for a pizza and wing night!! I love NY PIZZA, I appreciate you guys.

M
Maya McClure

I just moved and needed to find a new local pizza place. This is definitely the one! The pizza was absolutely delicious!! My husband and I had a few friends over and it was a hit with everybody. Definitely will be ordering again soon! 😊

O
Oniesha Brunson

I absolutely love their pizza. I would have to say its the best in town. Always fresh, hot & never too doughy 😋. I wish they didnt close on Sundays 😢. Great staff

M
Michelle Kumar

It's a great little place to have pizza! The staff is friendly, and helpful. The place is nice, and clean. The bathroom is really nice, and clean smells good. The pizza is to die for better than all the other pizzas out there. The only thing is parking there's a small lot next to it, but limited space. There's also the road in front you can park, but watch out for the cars. If your looking for great tasting pizza this is the place for you!

J
Justin Wilburn

You're out of your mind if you think you've been anywhere better. These people literally made the best food I've had in my entire life. I'm telling you this food put entire Thanksgiving meals to shame. They're friendly as can be and have a nice joint to sit down and eat at the patio. I can't wait to go back, and I just left. Do yourself a favor and grace your tastbuds with pizza fit for gods

H
Hannah Bodenstab

This is my favorite pizza. I make my husband take me here every time we come back to visit from Arizona.

R
Ryan Morris

Ordered a pizza and garlic knots, it wasn’t what I expected but I can’t blame the restaurant,it seems to be the delivery driver, everything is outsourced nowadays and it seems like nobody wants to work, my knots and Pizza were a little cold when it came but I could tell they were still very good when I had it. Just talked to one of the workers here and he was very understanding. I am not sure where these people who don’t want to work or getting all their money from, all us blue-collar workers have a work ethic and it seems like a lot of other people do not. I’d highly recommend this pizzeria

A
Andrew Moore

One of my favorite pizza places. The pizza is delicious and you always get it very quickly. Even though most of the time they are reheating the pizza, it always tastes excellent. The price is also quite good, as you can get several very large slices for 5 - 6 dollars. I would highly recommend their barbecue chicken and buffalo chicken pizza.

T
Tammy Hoke

We order from the guys every week and we never get a bad pie. They get to know their customers and crack jokes. It’s a real neighborhood pizza joint and I love that. Keep making yummy pies, gentlemen!!

M
Margaret Wood

The food was delicious, carefully prepared with very fresh ingredients. We have been ordering from another local restaurant, but after our experience tonight, I Love NY Pizza will get our business from now on. Great job!!

M
Michael Burke

I've had pizza in Chicago, New York City, Texas, and everywhere else that people say it's better in. I'll tell them all today, ILNY Pizza on Union St. is hands-down my favorite pizza. I used to go to this place all the time in high-school and get slices for lunch. I recently returned the other day after a few years. I'm happy to say that their quality is still incredible. Great slices. The guy that is always at the place is a nice dude, but he'll throw any attitude you give him right back at you. He's always been very nice to me. Quality slices at a quality place!

Lauren Darlington
Lauren Darlington

I repeatedly ask myself why this place isn't rated higher. You get fantastic pizza with so many different and creative toppings, pies or slices. Favorites are the buffalo chicken, broccoli and chicken, CBR, vodka sauce and more.... Also the best buffalo wings you can find in Schenectady. Everyone who works there is always friendly. They work extremely hard and efficiently to get you hot pizza on time. Go-to spot for 10 years now! During the warmer weather it's a nice low-key place to sit down and eat with family. Call day ahead for holidays like Halloween, as they have been swamped and aren't able to pick up the phone.

Bruce Dimick
Bruce Dimick

Came to the area from Kansas to visit some family, wanted to experience local NY pizza. We wandered in and immediately started talking with customers and staff about the 2015 KC Royals (beat the Mets!!). They served us even though we're Royals fans! Gave us a sample and instructed us in the proper NY way to fold and enjoy. Pizza was delicious, quick, and economical. Staff was so friendly. Would definitely drive 1,500 miles to come here again, even without family to visit!

T. Hall
T. Hall

Friendly service and great pizza. Reasonably priced.

Dee Wickert
Dee Wickert

It's a pizza counter with some seats inside and outside. I'll give it a 5 for atmosphere because it's very good at being a pizza counter, but don't think table service. It's really warm inside because of the ovens.

Grace Gervais
Grace Gervais

Always delicious! Have been getting pizza from here for years. Affordable too.

Joseph Stacey
Joseph Stacey

Best Pizza in Schenectady. Definitely try the Bacon Ranch Tomato slices! Oh yeah... they have slices... great slices and soooo many varieties... it would take a while to try them all. Thin and crispy crust with a flavorful sauce. Small eat in space with outdoor seating for good weather.

Timothy Herzog
Timothy Herzog

Best pizza up here yet really good not crazy Pizza like in New York City style style and the pizza stays firm when you hold it

Adaljisa Almonte
Adaljisa Almonte

First time there, I have visited other pizzerias in Schenectady and this one in my opinion is the best!! Just like the real NY PIZZA is suppose to taste!! Thin crust, the right amt of cheese, severed hot,good sauce, and good customer service!!!

Shawn Collins
Shawn Collins

Delicious pizza with plenty of selections. The sweet honey bbq chicken I highly recommend. The owner is a kind and funny guy. Place has seating indoors and an outdoor patio with tables, chairs and umbrellas. Definitely the spot to stop in 💯

shawn quackenbush
shawn quackenbush

I order the same every pizza place I try. Extra sauce extra pepperoni and well done. Excellent pizza

Danielle Burke
Danielle Burke

Great local pizza place. It's always the same people working and they are very good at their job. I think the kid's name is Shawn, he's the best. Our delivery driver didn't bring us an item we ordered, so he literally drove it to us himself. We're moving out of Schenectady but will always be back when we are in the area.

Kallen Heermance
Kallen Heermance

Best pizza place in town!! I ate my salad in less then 5 minutes it was so good lol & their pizza is top notch! … I highly recommend !!!!

Anil Singh
Anil Singh

A hometown establishment with delicious pizza and wings. Pizza is always spot on and wings never disappoint with regards to size and quality. Outdoor seating is great for quickly grabbing a slice and sitting down to enjoy it. Definitely check this place out and give it a try.

t
thomashk

Standard pizza place in with good pizza. What else? There are 5 pizza shop around the corner and It is my go-to

J
Judith H

I'm a pizza snob. There is no pizza like the pizza in the 50s and 60s in NJ, NYC and CT. So... I'd have to say that while this is a little walk-in place with no claim to atmosphere or over-the-top friendliness, their pizza is great, the price seems low for the value, and the selection is very good. I keep trying other places in the area, and keep coming back to the fact that I Love NY Pizza on Union has the best.

H
Hunter Balfour

Pizza was 4 bucks a slice (cash is cheaper) and pretty good for what it is. Took a few minutes to reheat and I was out the door. Good place for a quick bite.

R
Richard wilmoth

The honey Barbecue wings is really good, would buy from there again

Kevin Persaud
Kevin Persaud

I LOVE NEW YORK PIZZA! I love everything at this place and I love the people running it. I must say... the one thing I have an issue with is the garlic knots. I remember these lovely knots being plump, juicy and filled with the g-love. I feel now, that... they have been abandoned and orphaned from mama flavor. I honestly really like the food here, bit I'm not sure what happen to the knots. I will still be a loyal customer🫡

John Knapp
John Knapp

The calzones are enormous and delicious! I recommend the broccoli flavored one. Trust me when I say you'll be stuffed after eating one of these!

Joe Masucci
Joe Masucci

Fast and friendly service. Counter girl was polite and happy. Place was clean, always a plus. Ordered a pepperoni calzone and it was excellent. Hot and filled with lots of cheeses and more pepperoni than I wanted. Actually scooped some out. It was way larger than I thought it would be and so I couldn't finish it. Washed it down with an ice cold bottle of Pepsi. My only dig is that the side sauce was also ice cold, but when asked they gave me fresh hot sauce to dip in. Good place. Makes me want to try their pizza.

M
M Mc

New York style thin crispy crust pizza. The dough/crust was good, felt the sauce lacked a little bit. HUGE slices

C
Cindi Goodrich

FYI - the prices on the menu are incorrect. According to the person I spoke to at the pizza place claimed Google won't update prices or take the menu off the website. The wings were good but I should have ask for extra crispy and the sauce on the side. 😕

J
Jennifer Bux

I wanted to get a cheese pie, always passed by but never went in. Today I decided to try their pizza. As I walked in 2 guys infront preparing the pizza for pickup /orders etc. As I stood there for about 5 mins without any acknowledgment it made me think and felt less of. Then after I stood there for the most longest 5 mins the guy comes up and says how can I help you. I placed an order for a large 12 cut cheese pie, and order of garlic knots and chicken wings. He took my order as I sat in the restaurant waiting to get my food, about 15 ppl came in after me and was acknowledged/spoken to in less than 1 min or 2. I watched his interaction with each and every person who came there after me. But for me it wasn’t the the same. It made me think because I was a brown woman I stood out in a place like that. For them to not acknowledge me as I walked in there but did for everyone else’s after me. Meanwhile there is a minority working in the back making pizzas. It’s really a shame that human beings still treat other humans beings this way. Yes I’m of color, I’m a paying customer just like all the other ppl who go there. Plz do better next time. This is 2022 and people of color should not be treated this way. Thank you.

T
The Feminine Principle

They did not even try! The sauce was runny and there was a puddle of water on one side of the box; my pizza was soaked!! I asked for a veggie pizza with no cheese. I was expecting some vegetables; it was just tomato sauce, a few pieces of ill cut green peppers and a pile of tomatoes!!! Disgusting. I'm appalled. The only reason I give 2 stars is because the driver was courteous. Otherwise waste of money, low end of the spectrum on this one. Shame.

H
Hester Smith

Ordered pizza and wings on 2/17/20 and after waiting an hour and forty-five minutes they brought me the wrong order. I called and spoke with someone who promised to remake the pizza I wanted and have it delivered. Then about 15 minutes later the person who was my delivery driver called and said they will refund me the money for the pizza and if I wanted it delivered I have to go and reorder it online. I said just refund my money. I know after that incident I will never order from them again . UNSATISFIED CUSTOMER!

P
Pamela Shanks

Pizza was ok, the sauce lacked flavor. Crust was good. Wings and garlic knots were very good. Service could have been better if the employees girlfriend/wife wasn't hanging out there and monopolizing his time. She was giving dirty looks to everyone that came in like they were interrupting. Made eating there uncomfortable.

B
Brian Sewall

I Love NY Pizza should be embarrassed to have 'NY' in the name of their restaurant. It would benefit them greatly to actually take a trip to NYC to see what REAL pizza is supposed to taste like. I am yet to have good pizza in Schenectady and this place is no exception. The staff is rude, the food is incredibly overpriced, the pizza is mediocre at best and their wings are subpar. I had their delivery person insist that I meet them on the other side of the street because they couldn't find my building; after opening my pizza I found that all the cheese and toppings had slid to one side of the box. When I called to complain they hung up on me as soon as they realized I was not placing an order. I don't understand how this place has remained in business as long as they have been.

J
Josh

I used to love this place but a few months ago they stopped delivering so I stopped ordering. Then I get a mailer saying they deliver so OK I order. They charge 4 bucks for delivery fee and if you order online the lowest tip is 5 bucks. So 9 bucks added to every order. 8 cut pepperoni, 12 wings and 2 liter comes out to around 40.00. I answer the door, the person asks me what I ordered, then doesn't have it all. The food was good but cold. Is that worth a 5.00 tip? See ya!

w
whiteboiiwinning

I do not know what happened but the last 3 times I got pizza here it's been burned and hard now they always have good new York style pizza I'm from down state and I only found 1 place that came close to the pizza I love but now I will not be getting my pizza from here unless they fix this I paid good money for a few pizza ' s so don't order pizza from them

E
Ernst Johnson

I haven't felt more ripped off on a pizza, in many years. We used to like this place. It is not what it used to be. We paid $21 dollars plus tip, for a pizza I would not value at more than 8 bucks. Our pizza had almost no detectable cheese on it, even though we ordered extra. Toppings were pathetically light, and the dough was tasteless and comprised of 90% of the entire pie. I thought the box was empty when it was handed to me by the driver.. What a rip off!!

M
Maribel

Went to location ordered my pizza crispy this guy gives me a burnt pizza pie. I called him to let him know that pizza was burned. He didn’t care never once said I will replace or on your next order you’ll get a pie. Nothing disgusting and he definitely lost a customer.

s
steve parks

Ordered pizza Well done extra cheese and onion n bacon Not well done 1\2 raw , no extra cheese and minimal onion n bacon. 5 pc chicken dinner I got no mashed potatoes and gravy asked for dbl order got Zero. Chicken wings more like chicken nuggets They said door dash problem wth?? Lmk

G
George Younger

I went to this place and ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and it was terrible, when I got it home which is approximately 17 blocks away and I went to seperate each slice to serve it for the family and my dinner the cheese seperated from the whole crust of the pizza, also I know what a pizza with extra chees is supposed to look like and it looked nothing like extra cheese was on it, on top of this the cheese smelled terrible. I have seen so many people buying from this establishment and decided if the quality of the pizza I purchased is this bad, I will never again buy anything from this pizza place.

W
Will Cruz

I ordered a pizza with 20 piece chicken wings and a baked ziti with chicken. the wings was alright but the pizza was cold and it looked like it was preheated. I called to complain and the gentleman was rude and did not want to hear my complain after i spend 42.95 . I will never order from this pizza place again they do not care about their customers.

S
Shari Flack-Council

horrible was served burnt pizza and the manager was rude and will not deleiver a new pizza or give me my refund back. I complained through slice and they lied and said i wasnt avaiable after the manager told me i was gonna cancel your order because we dont deliver there, umm ive been getting pizzas here for a whole year. then told me its not burnt we dont give soggy pizza, but i dont want pizza to chip my tooth either. dont go here i complained to bbb.

D
Deborah Van brocklen

I was very disappointed in my order. I got 24 wings that were so small that I was not even sure they were wings. Usually a dozen of wings fill me. these just were tiny as hell. They were also over cooked. I threw half awa.they were hard Will not order from here again.

J
Jess

Don’t order from here my friends got subs and there were FINGERNAILS in their subs! I’ve ordered from here in the past and I have never had a good experience. The staff were very rude to me over the phone. This isn’t the first time I’ve complained about this place. It’s absolutely disgusting!

S
Superwatch

Copied the name of I love pizza. I got food poising, my brother threw up, my son got sick, and my husband luckily did not eat the pizza. I recommend that you do not to this restraunt.

E
Emmanuel Gonzalez

I only gave it a 1 star because there's no option for a zero. By far the worst pizzeria I've ever had. I ordered some pizza and wings, and thought I was gonna die literally. Me and my girlfriend ended up vomiting all night because of the food. Never going there again...smh

M
Matthew Daley

Worst delivery I’ve possibly ever experienced. Pizza was ice cold, chicken tenders were burnt to a crisp and inedible. That isn’t even the worst part. The salad. Seems to be an easy item right? Wrong! Unless you enjoy raw bacon on the ol’ Cobb salad, I would probably stay away from that also. Congratulations on losing our business but from the looks of it, probably didn’t want it anyway

D
Dayvonta Fareed

Just got worst pizza ever from this place and garlic knots were ice cold

J
J A

So I ordered a chicken parm sub and an order of mild wings. And I can’t say there was anything I enjoyed of either. The chicken parm had the worst quality chicken on it. And the wings had no sauce on it and was frost bitten looking. I called the store to tell them about the wings. And they gave me another order which was pretty much exactly like the first one. There was little to no sauce which looked like oil basically. Probably won’t be ordering from here anymore. It sucks because I used to love there wings. Just to clarify I ordered this on Friday 3/6/20.

M
Maria Wishart

Ordered a pizza for delivery at 11:20am. By 12:45pm no pizza. Called and the guy who answered was extremely rude and claimed the driver called me. He didn't. He told me I had to wait that it was on its way. 1:05pm called back and asked when I could expect delivery. He said it was on its way. Around 1:30pm I called back and said there was no pizza still. He told me (or rather yelled at me) that if I didn't like it I could cancel my order. I said "no, i prefer to just have my pizza." He said again it's on its way. I told him "No offense, but I've been being told that for a while." He started yelling at me telling me "No food for you. You call all day, i give you no food." I was shocked. I said "That's really rude! You shouldn't be so rude to your customers" He yelled at me again and said "I cancel your order, no food for you." and hung up. My husband called back and said "Look, if it's not on its way yet, we don't want it." (This was around 1:45pm) The guy on the phone said "Well, it's on its way so you'll have to take it." We waited another 5 minutes and left to go to a different pizza place. At 2:10pm the driver called "I have your pizza." C'mon 3 hours! And honestly... I've had this pizza before and it isn't good at all. We only ordered there because my husband was craving pizza and we thought our regular place was closed. NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE.

T
Tony Ellis

This is usually the best pizza in town. But today’s pizza was terrible!!! I ordered my usual Meat Lovers pizza and it only had pepperonis and 1 sausage crumble. It was dry and just the worse. I may have to go to Sicilians from now on

B
Brittany Vachon

Worst service I've ever had. Ordered a pizza at 6:55pm, the delivery time said 7:53pm. We called at 8:20pm because our pizza was still not delivered to us, they said it's on it's way already. Another 20 minutes went by so we called back and said our pizza still isn't here and we ordered it almost 2 hours ago, they didn't apologize or anything, they scrambled to make up an excuse and said oh it's right here it'll be there in 10-15 mins, we only live 5 minutes from I love New York pizza. So at that point we were furious and said how is that even possible and then they hung up on us! So rude.

J
Jordan Briggs

This establishment has changed owners in the past two weeks. Always had a great experience previously...last night ordered pizza and wings...asked for extra cheese on both and pepperoni on one. The wings were extremely salty. I looked at my receipt after my boyfriend got home with the food and it was way more then expected. Now I dont have a problem paying for toppings at all but neither one of the pizzas had extra cheese on it. The pizza we ordered a couple weeks ago had the amount of cheese you would expect to get when you are paying for extra toppings. When I called to discuss my concerns they were extremely unprofessional and could care less. So sad to cross off what used to be a great place to get food.

M
Maria F

I will never order from this place again! Other reviewers have said as well, quality has gone in the toilet lately. The employees are rude when you place an order, that can be overlooked I guess if the quality and price is good, however, not the case here. Prices have gone way up. Pizza arrived nearly folded in half when I called to complain, the "manager" yelled at me, as if I had made this lousy Pizza. Don't waste your time and money, there are plenty of places all over town that know how to treat their customers with respect.

E
Elizabeth Gifford

Been going here since it opened. Used to love it in high school pizza and wings were good enough to oversee the horrible customer service. But the quality has steadily declined over the years, I only called tonight because they're cheap and would deliver and it's snowing. This is only the second time since moving into my new house and obviously will be the last. After taking my address, order and payment over the phone, they called back half an hour later to say they wouldn't deliver to my house, even though they did the last time I ordered there, when I told the owner that he started a yelling match saying I obviously had the wrong place (once again, been ordering there for 15 years) and when I told him I only cared about getting my money back he hung up the phone. So now I have to monitor my account everyday to make sure the money gets put back... it used to be worth it, it isn't at all anymore. Piss poor customer service served with soaked through pizza and burnt wings. Take my advice and go to Nikki P's not much different in price and so much better on all counts.

P
Pedro Hernandez

Pizza come whiteout cheese. Spend 56 pluss tax for 12 cut 12 wings and the 2 little soda didn't come in the delivery

T
Tiffany Pellegrino

I have ordered from here a couple of times, mostly because I like to give places a chance. Each time, the pizza came with a paper thin crust, and was watery to the point that it was falling apart- both the Sicilian and regular pizzas. Very disappointed, and will definitely not be ordering again.

P
Peter Dudley

Tried to call to order a pizza. Have the guy on the phone and he refused my order. Says “you need to place the order online.” Why!? I got you on the phone now!? Anyways I’ll be calling somewhere else from now on. Good business strategy guys. Maybe provide both options? I don’t know just a thought.

M
Melanie

Terrible. Can't call in with an order then when we went online to place it we got a call 20 min later saying they no longer make a marsala calzone but then still charged me for it even though we had to change it to just mushrooms and then it comes and it's just plain cheese the dough was more like a cracker in taste and texture. Terrible. This was our favorite pizza place and within a week or 2 they've gone completely into the toilet.

L
Lashawna Garvin

Dry looking pizza that looks like it's been out all day! Customer service sucks! I asked for extra cheese and after 10 minutes of waiting they tried to sell me a regular cheese slice as extra cheese! I'm from NYC so if I ask for extra cheese that's what I want! Don't argue with the customer please it's annoying and unprofessional! So back to Marino's I went! 🤷🏾‍♀️

K
Kaitlin Rock

Ok, so we get food here every once in awhile. We usually pick it up but lastnight I couldn’t. I ordered a meatball sub and mozzarella sticks. They told me it would be delivered by 6:50.. (I checked at 6:50 & 7) Well, I never got a notification or a phone call when they delivered my food, nor did anyone knock or ring the doorbell. My food ended up sitting outside for however long bc I didn’t see it on the porch.. I ended up going out and seeing it about 7:25pm... I opened mozzarella sticks, they were cooked to the point where there was no cheese, the marinara sauce was water. And the meatball sub had no cheese, the meatballs tasted old. & the sub was burnt.. & my food was cold.. so I had one mozzarella stick and a bite of my sub, 35$ later I wasn’t pleased at all.

z
zola romani

fish sandwich tastes like the dumpster of a seafood restaurant

D
Daniel Honore

O my god the worst pizza I've ever had. I basically took a few bites and had to throw the whole thing out even my dog wouldn't eat that garbage.

Kyle Delhagen
Kyle Delhagen

Have ordered from here in the past and loved it. Never again. Online ordering with the Slice app had never been a problem. Ordered at 3 for a 5:15 delivery so I could get my son out trick or treating. At 6:00, the app still said the driver was picking up the order. By my second call at 6:30, I was told the second driver had canceled the order. Not only could I not reach anyone AT the store, I was given an excuse that the driver had had an accident (they don’t have contingency plans for this, I guess). I will be taking my business elsewhere in the future. At least I got a full refund, which is the only reason I am giving one star.

Troy Calvin
Troy Calvin

Usually great pizza but tonight they dropped the ball. Absolutely no cheese, all dough. Big dough bubbles and dry.

Edward Weldon
Edward Weldon

I ordered food on 2/28/25 was for delivery said it was set for 6:30 pm at 6: 45 the slice delivery person was still not here I called and found out they. Claimed it had been delivered I explained I was outside and nothing. Got a refund,but I live the food but never ordering from them as long as they are use this delivery service food was stolen. Hope the person enjoyed it!!

Cassidy Lyne
Cassidy Lyne

This used to be our favorite pizza place. Drove out there to surprise my husband with it and made the mistake of not checking it until I got home. There’s a pound of sauce on it and the cheese wasn’t even melted. When we called them back they told us it “wasn’t their fault we didn’t like it.” Yeah well, wasn’t my fault it wasn’t cooked. I understand mistakes happen, but that customer service was horrendous.

Inicia sessió per deixar una ressenya

Inicia sessió
👑 És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Explora la teva zona

Més restaurants a Schenectady →
📸

23 Fotos

Explora les fotos de I Love NY Pizza

I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza
I Love NY Pizza
+18 Més
📍

Informació sobre I Love NY Pizza

Com arribar

1705 Union St, Schenectady, NY 12309

Carregant mapa...
I Love NY Pizza
Toca per direccions

Destacats

Bona Valoració
4.1/5 estrelles
💬
Moltes Ressenyes
436 ressenyes
💰
Econòmic
Nivell de preus
👨‍🍳
pizza
Tipus de cuina

Serveis

🍽️ Dinar
🍾 Sopar
🍰 Postres
🥗 Opcions Vegetarianes
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili
🍴 Menjar al Local

Opcions de Menjador

🍽️ Menjar al Local
🥡 Per Emportar
🚚 Lliurament a Domicili

Informació del Restaurant

Estat
Verificat pel propietari
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-9PM
Valoració
4.1/5
💬 Ressenyes
436
💰 Nivell de Preus
$
📞 Telèfon
+1 518-346-7272
🌐 Lloc Web
www.theoriginalilovenypizza.com

Comoditats

🅿️ Aparcament
🌿 Terrassa
🚻 Lavabo
💳 Targetes de Crèdit
📱 Pagaments Mòbils
🏘️

El Barri

Central Park

park in Schenectady County, New York, United States of America

A 953m
🎮

Jocs

🎮 Guanya Punts Mentre Explores!

Juga a Find Me i canvia punts per descomptes a I Love NY Pizza i altres restaurants

🎮

Guanya Punts a I Love NY Pizza!

Juga a Find Me i canvia recompenses aquí

Guanya punts extra i canvia'ls per recompenses de I Love NY Pizza

🏆 Recompenses de I Love NY Pizza

💰

Descompte 10%

A I Love NY Pizza

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Aperitiu Gratis

A la teva propera visita

2500 pts
Limitat
👑

Taula VIP

Experiència premium

5000 pts
Exclusiu

per canviar recompenses i guanyar punts

📋 Com funcionen les recompenses?

1

Juga a Find Me

Cada 100 punts de score = 1 punt de recompensa

2

Acumula Punts

Els workers obtenen 2x punts per partida

3

Canvia Recompenses

Descomptes, menjar gratis i experiències VIP

Trucar
Deixar ressenya a Google
👑

És teu? Reclama'l GRATIS!

Elimina anuncis i gestiona el menú

Inicia sessió i juga

Revisa el teu correu!

Sense contrasenya — t'enviem un enllaç per email

T'hem enviat un enllaç d'accés

Revisa la carpeta de spam si no el veus