Dominique Petersen

Just want to say thank you for your willingness to help. I ordered a cheese pizza , chicken Parm pizza and fried ravioli with melba. Food got here but cheese pizza was a mess. Half was smashed and cheese falling off. I called just to mention it as a suggestion to be aware and the owner explained it probably didn't rest before getting boxed. (My kids will still eat it but the next person may not be so kind) The individual asked to make me a new cheese pizza and have it brought over. I was so appreciative that I never even mentioned not getting my melba sauce haha. I was beyond surprised when 20 minutes later the man who took my call remade my ENTIRE order and made sure the remake had double melba. Needless to say my kiddos are full, I'm a happy mama, and want to thank one of my favorite local places for being so willing to fix an issue.

Tracy Oakland

Paulie's saved the day! Paulie's is our go-to for every pizza gathering but we, unfortunately, ordered from a different pizzeria for our daughters birthday party because of proximity. The delivery driver failed miserably and the pizza never showed up to the party which left me with a very hungry group of 7 year olds. I called Paulie's with a plea to make a few quick pizzas that I could get before the party ended and they absolutely came through! They got the pizza to us in 30 minutes (on a football Sunday no less.) And with incredible kindness and understanding. We certainly won't make this mistake again and are team Paulie's all the way.

Brandon Carbonare (blcman)

I’ve had Paulie’s a hand full of times now and they have delivered excellent quality each and every one. Great fresh pizza, comes how you order it, great wings and sauces and some dang good subs. A great hidden gem in Schenectady.

Randy K

My name is Randy I stopped by from Roland J Down to do some plumbing work and had to try the pizza here, it’s Amazing, love the cheese pizza and Paulie and the staff are great! Wish I could give more stars!!

Mark Putney

Chicken Alfredo was great. Enough for two people. Beacon cheeseburger was also great. The French fries are the best. My only complaint is I ordered wings and 4 were broken, so now I'm trying not to get pieces of bone in my mouth. I wish I lived closer because I would be a regular 🥰

Mckenzie Coles

Review from a foodie everything here is delicious I am really not a fan of toasted subs but now I totally understand why the bread is toasted lightly. The submarine bread is fresh . The wings are amazing and the pizza is delicious as well it isn’t too thick or too thin and it has the perfect balance of cheese and sauce . You won’t be disappointed with this business. I plan on visiting again and trying something else of these menu .

Cassandra Domingos

The pizza at Paulie’s is always perfect and one of the best in the area. I prefer the thin crust but their square pizza is excellent as well. Boneless wings are always great and their sauces are high quality and tasty. Eggplant parm was incredible. I’ve never had anything bad from their menu and their customer service is also top notch and friendly every time.

+2

John Dooley

The cheeseburger pizza and chicken parmesan pizza is absolutely amazing. I’ve probably ordered 8 or 9 pizzas from these young college kids and they’ve all been a party in my mouth. I live down the street from Paulie’s and it’s the reason I’ve had to diet.

Agustin Sandoval

Driver got the pie here quick, make sure to tip. Legit ingredients, recommend the Italian mix sub w/ olive & vinegar, and Italian dressing!

Lauren Glenn

The sauce on the pizza is excellent. I probably should've gotten extra sauce. The crust on the edge is a bit larger than I'm used to but it was still very good. If I had any complaint, it would be that there wasn't enough cheese and sauce... but next time I'll know to put in for extra sauce and cheese. Still, great sauce regardless. Not the very sweet marinara or runny sauce I've had elsewhere... just a nice thick dark sauce... just the way I like.

Joe Masucci

Three and a half stars truly. A solid local pizza joint. Tried a slice fresh from the oven and an Italian mix sub. The bread was warm and tasty, the meats and cheese were good quality. The slice was pretty good, nothing to write home about but solid. The cheese and sauce eclipsed the dough. Weak crust. Fast and friendly service. Place was pretty clean looking. Give it a try!

+1

Cass L

They aren't the worst pizza I've had, but their pizza is definitely inconsistent. I only come here because its around the corner from my house. I've had it too soggy or the sauce being too sweet, or just lack luster in general. Also it is quite irritating that when you order online it says a time it will be ready by, then I head to the shop and they tell me its going to be an additional 15 minutes because their times on the website are wrong, (just for a small cheese pizza btw). Can you fix that please?

I am done with this place. The stench alone when you go in there is just about enough to make you never want to go back. I literally pull clothes from my dirty laundry to wear when I go in to pick something up. Have they ever considered changing their fry oil or turning on a vent fan? But the final straw was today. I ordered a buffalo chicken sub. It came with 1 squirt of sauce on it. It was comical, like it was a prank or something. I ordered through the Slice app, so I snapped a picture and sent it to them. Asking for a refund because it was a joke. They refunded me a DOLLAR... I'll see if I can add the pic to my review. Hilarious. Edit: What a great response from Paulie's below. Instead of addressing the actual issue you try to make a joke out of it. Smart. I even provided a picture of the horribly made sub I bought, but that wasn't enough for you I guess. The point I'm making about wearing something from my dirty laundry when I enter your restaurant is that it smells so bad in there that I don't want to ruin any clean clothes. You trying to make a joke about that is hilarious, anyone who's ever been in there can attest to the smell. Laugh all you want, make jokes, but I won't be back. I've been a customer since you opened and given you enough chances. There are plenty of other places to order from that will make a decent sub and not cause my coat to smell for 3 days after being in there for 5 minutes. Second Edit: I ordered through the Slice app, which your website directed me to. When I had an issue I went through the app's customer service, sent them a picture, and they called you. Your solution to refund me a single dollar (which I still haven't received 4 days later) came through proper channels. If you don't want complaints to come through the app, don't direct people to use it? I haven't said anything nasty. Every single thing I've said is factual.

Kirsten Harris

Ordered a 6 cut cheese pizza it was absolutely disgusting. The worst pizza I’ve even had in my life. So disappointing