Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Restaurant

Very delicious vegetable and pesto pizza. I was happy to be able to enjoy the crust, too! Sometimes I have to rid the crust if too hard and it was super delicious! The staff are also super friendly. Glad to find a great pizza joint honestly ❤️😊

We catered a party yesterday from this true gem of a pizzeria. The hero we ordered was phenomenal. Everyone raved about The Godfather hero. My guests loved of course their grandma pie and regular pie. First time we ordered the chicken Marsala and it was delicious!!!! And the only way to get Baked Ziti is with the dollops of Ricotta cheese in it. Keeps the Ziti from drying out and keeps fresh and saucy for next day leftovers!!! Add the delicious garlic knots and we had some spread !!! Thank you Mamma Grace for the delicious food and being so warm and grateful to your customers. We appreciate you and hope that you have a successful business for years to come!!!

I love their pizza and quite honestly anything on their menu! They are so friendly and accommodating, I have three boys and anytime we go in they talk to them. They have a great selection of things to order and a great selection of pizza! By far one of my favorite places!

This place has to be one of the coziest little pizzeria shops around. The owners are always bubbly & super friendly! The pizza is always fresh and hot & THEY HAVE THEE BEST CALZONES AND SAUCE!! Hands down will be coming back time and time again and dont forgot to support small business guys!

I ordered pizza to be delivered. The pizza is delicious, after one large slice I was already full, but it was just too good that I had to help myself to another slice. The dough is fresh and is the perfect amount of crispy and fluffy.

Their pizza and pasta’s are great especially the grandma pies! They are very family oriented and since day one, they have always welcomed my family and always have a smile for you when you enter the shop. You will not be disappointed.

This was truly one of the best pizza's I have had in a long while. I came up to Sparrow bush for a quick getaway from NYC. On our first day we came across Mamma Grace Pizzeria on our way to the rental property and noticed quite a crowd of people outside. We decided then and there to try the spot during our week long day. Boy! I am glad we made the right choice. We ordered the Charlie Special pie and some wings. The pie was made perfectly! The crust was crispy yet a little thick, which is a rarity. Usually one associates crispy crusts with thin pizza. Charlie Special contains Broccoli Rabe, garlic amongst other ingredients. The veggies were fresh and there was ample amount of garlic (my fav). The sauce (sweet) balance the entire Pizza. I am glad I got to try their pizza and very happy that it happened on the last few days of our trip! Otherwise, I would have gained quite a bit of weight eating there everyday. Thanks guys. Hope to be back soon and making your shop the first stop!

Wow, I am quite impressed. We called for a delivery. The woman on the phone was very pleasant. She was honest and let us know it would be an hour and an hour is what it was. Delivery person was also very pleasant. The food was still hot and delicious.

Great pizza and beef patties, wonderful wonderful people. They were kind enough to let me stay for 3 hours while I waited for my ride after my own vehicle broke down. Pizza reminded of home (brooklyn ny). Sandwiches looked delicious also. Great family vibe. May become a regular stop when I'm in the area

Finally had the opportunity to swing in here after seeing many good reviews. My fiance and I got the Italian hero and they were great! Prices are very fair. Been looking for a new sandwich place since my favorite place closed up. This is it!

The food is great, have tried many different dishes. Very positive atmosphere. Very family oriented. Everyone makes you feel like family. Definitely recommend Mama Grace ❤️

Can only speak for the pizza. No fancy bistro this, but if you want top shelf pizza this is the hidden gem in a little known town called Sparrowbush, NY...near the Hawk's Nest ( a popular biker's hangout.) I urge all you bikers to stop in and get ruined after trying their pies (pizza)...you will never be the same. If this place was located where the old Hawk's Nest eatery was, before it burned, it would do a killer business and we'd be standing in lines to eat there. I've lived in NYC for a number of years and have had some of the best pizzas in NYS. This little joint can easily compare to the finest pies I've eaten there. It's worth the search and the prices are great. Big slices, too. Bon appetito, and your welcome.

I have to say that the Sicilian pizza I picked up last night was probably the best I have ever had! The crust could not have been made any better. The cheese, sauce and toppings were on the money. On top of that, they gave me a veterans discount. A1

They provided tons of food for an event we hosted and it was delicious and gorgeous! They are clean and service is fantastic! Even delivery was timely and friendly ! I can’t say enough about them and will use them for any quick or large orders

Best food around, all home made from scratch, including dough, cheese and sauce, none of that store bought stuff. Customer service alone is 100 out of 10. They knock it out of the park every single time. Wait times are excellent. Will forever be a returning customer!

Always a great place to come to if you want friendly & quick service. Best pizza in the area no doubt BLOWS PORT JERVIS PIZZA AWAY.. the quality you get is amazing here and consistent very happy

Don't travel far when the best pizza is so close! Over COVID we have tried everything within 30 miles, and nothing comes close! Great crust, fresh ingredients, and unique (and tasty!) specials. . .try it, you won't be disappointed!

im too busy enjoying the food but next time i go ill probably remember to update this, whoops! my absolute favorite place in the world. the owners, ambience, quality, freshness, prices are beyond words.

Tried the Grandma pie and it is awesome, garlic knots and cheese fries were great too!!!!

UPDATE: July 7th, 2022 This place can hold it's own against any pizza joint in Brooklyn...The Charlie's special with broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella and garlic is delicious, and the Grandma's Pie with that pesto drizzle and added pepperoni was just amazing. The Mamma Grace special, the garlic knots and the rice ball parm were just as finger licking good. This place is a gem in such a beautiful part of New York that delivers, thanx again Mamma Grace for taking care of us. Being new to Glen Spey, we were looking for a taste of home, Brooklyn pizza, and we just found it at Mamma Grace. From the Sicilian with chicken and broccoli, to the fried calamari, to the eggplant roll and the garlic knots, everything tasted fresh and delicious. Can't wait to taste the rest of their huge menu...Thanx Mamma

What can I say about this place excellent food great service and they treat you like family and if you are feeling like something and it’s not on their menu they will take a shot at making it for you from their pizza to their pasta it’s all delicious Thank you for catering our wedding.

Wonderful place! Excellent customer service. Definitely family run. The food was hot and delicious. We got a pepperoni pizza and a gyro on a pita. Pizza had a delicious dough and a great sauce. Gyro had a yummy sauce and a good amount of tomatoes, lettuce and meat. There are about 4-5 tables inside if you want to eat in. Everything seems clean too. Would totally recommend!

Momma Grace catered for us today and it was fabulous. Chicken park, chicken Frances’s, sausage and peppers. Cannolis, cheesecake and an absolutely fabulous rainbow cake!

I come a whole hour away to get the best pizza around. They have the best chicken parm pizza I’ve ever had!! Great family ran pizzeria and environment, definitely would recommend

The pizza is one of the best I've had. The crust is possibly the best thing ever. The staff is so friendly and seem to genuinely care about your business.

Alex Kadansky

UPDATE: July 7th, 2022 This place can hold it's own against any pizza joint in Brooklyn...The Charlie's special with broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella and garlic is delicious, and the Grandma's Pie with that pesto drizzle and added pepperoni was just amazing. The Mamma Grace special, the garlic knots and the rice ball parm were just as finger licking good. This place is a gem in such a beautiful part of New York that delivers, thanx again Mamma Grace for taking care of us. Being new to Glen Spey, we were looking for a taste of home, Brooklyn pizza, and we just found it at Mamma Grace. From the Sicilian with chicken and broccoli, to the fried calamari, to the eggplant roll and the garlic knots, everything tasted fresh and delicious. Can't wait to taste the rest of their huge menu...Thanx Mamma

kira Fisher

What can I say about this place excellent food great service and they treat you like family and if you are feeling like something and it’s not on their menu they will take a shot at making it for you from their pizza to their pasta it’s all delicious Thank you for catering our wedding.

Leeta Law

Wonderful place! Excellent customer service. Definitely family run. The food was hot and delicious. We got a pepperoni pizza and a gyro on a pita. Pizza had a delicious dough and a great sauce. Gyro had a yummy sauce and a good amount of tomatoes, lettuce and meat. There are about 4-5 tables inside if you want to eat in. Everything seems clean too. Would totally recommend!

Charlotte Van Horn

Momma Grace catered for us today and it was fabulous. Chicken park, chicken Frances’s, sausage and peppers. Cannolis, cheesecake and an absolutely fabulous rainbow cake!

Dylan Felter

I come a whole hour away to get the best pizza around. They have the best chicken parm pizza I’ve ever had!! Great family ran pizzeria and environment, definitely would recommend

Jessica M

The pizza is one of the best I've had. The crust is possibly the best thing ever. The staff is so friendly and seem to genuinely care about your business.

Michael Choi

im too busy enjoying the food but next time i go ill probably remember to update this, whoops! my absolute favorite place in the world. the owners, ambience, quality, freshness, prices are beyond words.

John Dorval

Tried the Grandma pie and it is awesome, garlic knots and cheese fries were great too!!!!

One of the best pizzerias in the area. Very friendly staff.

The food was amazing here! They use the freshest ingredients from the pizza to the garlic knots to our entrées were all hot and delicious. It’s a family owned business and they take great pride in what they do here. It’s really hard to find amazing Italian food in this area but here it is, mama Grace ! We will absolutely be returning and telling everybody about this place what a hidden gem! Also, the owners came to our table to see how we were enjoying our food and that was a nice special touch! We will be back ! Thank you for preparing such delicious food for my whole family!

The food here was more than amazing! You can really tell they use the best fresh ingredients with everything they make! From the pizza to the calzones to the garlic knots to every entrée was out of this world! It’s a family own business,You can really tell how much they care about their customers and they take great pride in preparing the delicious meals that are homemade ! They also kept coming to the table to see how we enjoyed our food, which was really a nice special touch! The owners are really special amazing people. I will definitely be coming back here. I wish there was one closer to where I live, but I will make the trip to come to such an amazing establishment.!

Love the grandma pie, garlic knots and buffalo chicken roll. They also deliver.

What an amazing place haven’t had real NY/ Brooklyn style pizza in a very long time , Their Calzones are to die for. First off very fresh ingredients used on every single item , calzone was crispy crunchy and cheesy all in one bite.we then also got a veal Marsala and asked if it can be made into a hero ,which was excellent!!! compliments to the chef. We also tried a variety of different gourmet slices they were all delicious. My favorite slice had to be the Hot Honey Chicken Bacon Ranch. Compliments to the staff and pizza man for carrying out an absolutely wonderful product and service. We felt like family nothing less. There is scarcity of authentic pizza Joints nationwide but MAMA GRACE sure didn’t disappoint 11/10 we are definitely coming back in the upcoming days,weeks,months,and years , you’ve gained a customer forever. What a deliciously lovely pizza Joint.

Mama Grace Pizzeria is HANDS DOWN the best ITALIAN Restaurant around in and around Sparrowbush N.Y. It's an OUTSTANDING family owned restaurant that Gives you the Authentic Italian cuisine!!! It's family owned and Ran and all their heart and soul is poured into the food. . They provide the freshest, most delicious dishes and pizza around. Why? Because they truly, whole heartedly care and are seriously dedicated to making their food with all freshest ingredients so we get the best dishes around. They truly pour their hearts and souls into it. How many places will take a last minute order and STAY UP ALL NIGHT just so you can have your dish!?!?! This place!!! They are absolutely incredible!!! We have ordered dinners and placed huge orders for very large parties!!! All the food was superb and Out of this park delicious and everyone at the party was beyond impressed with the food. They are very generous and are beyond grateful for all of their customers. Whatever you order, whether it be a Pizza, Ziti, Panini, Gyro, the list is endless your guaranteed to get the best tasting REAL ITALIAN Food you've ever had!! Oh and their pizzas are actually huge!! Your not going to get one of those tiny ones other restaurants are calling a large that are the size of a frozen pizza!! Overall experience going here for years has been a 100 out of 100!! Thankyou Mama Grace for being a beautiful part of our community.

They have the best pizza and their sauce is so amazing! You can tell its homemade sauce not just "marinara" its actually flavorful. Meatballs are awesome and you definitely don't have to go to Philly for a cheasesteak! They are so great family owner business #supportfamilylocalbusinesses!

Mama Grace, There was a quick delivery hiccup, but it was resolved right away—and the food was amazing! We’ll absolutely be repeat customers

Grandma 0f -5

Mama Grace, There was a quick delivery hiccup, but it was resolved right away—and the food was amazing! We’ll absolutely be repeat customers

Jessica J

Mama Grace Pizzeria is HANDS DOWN the best ITALIAN Restaurant around in and around Sparrowbush N.Y. It's an OUTSTANDING family owned restaurant that Gives you the Authentic Italian cuisine!!! It's family owned and Ran and all their heart and soul is poured into the food. . They provide the freshest, most delicious dishes and pizza around. Why? Because they truly, whole heartedly care and are seriously dedicated to making their food with all freshest ingredients so we get the best dishes around. They truly pour their hearts and souls into it. How many places will take a last minute order and STAY UP ALL NIGHT just so you can have your dish!?!?! This place!!! They are absolutely incredible!!! We have ordered dinners and placed huge orders for very large parties!!! All the food was superb and Out of this park delicious and everyone at the party was beyond impressed with the food. They are very generous and are beyond grateful for all of their customers. Whatever you order, whether it be a Pizza, Ziti, Panini, Gyro, the list is endless your guaranteed to get the best tasting REAL ITALIAN Food you've ever had!! Oh and their pizzas are actually huge!! Your not going to get one of those tiny ones other restaurants are calling a large that are the size of a frozen pizza!! Overall experience going here for years has been a 100 out of 100!! Thankyou Mama Grace for being a beautiful part of our community.

S Potter

Love the grandma pie, garlic knots and buffalo chicken roll. They also deliver.

janel miller

They have the best pizza and their sauce is so amazing! You can tell its homemade sauce not just "marinara" its actually flavorful. Meatballs are awesome and you definitely don't have to go to Philly for a cheasesteak! They are so great family owner business #supportfamilylocalbusinesses!

Beth Gibbs

The food was amazing here! They use the freshest ingredients from the pizza to the garlic knots to our entrées were all hot and delicious. It’s a family owned business and they take great pride in what they do here. It’s really hard to find amazing Italian food in this area but here it is, mama Grace ! We will absolutely be returning and telling everybody about this place what a hidden gem! Also, the owners came to our table to see how we were enjoying our food and that was a nice special touch! We will be back ! Thank you for preparing such delicious food for my whole family!

Beth Gibbs

The food here was more than amazing! You can really tell they use the best fresh ingredients with everything they make! From the pizza to the calzones to the garlic knots to every entrée was out of this world! It’s a family own business,You can really tell how much they care about their customers and they take great pride in preparing the delicious meals that are homemade ! They also kept coming to the table to see how we enjoyed our food, which was really a nice special touch! The owners are really special amazing people. I will definitely be coming back here. I wish there was one closer to where I live, but I will make the trip to come to such an amazing establishment.!

Anthony Scaturro

What an amazing place haven’t had real NY/ Brooklyn style pizza in a very long time , Their Calzones are to die for. First off very fresh ingredients used on every single item , calzone was crispy crunchy and cheesy all in one bite.we then also got a veal Marsala and asked if it can be made into a hero ,which was excellent!!! compliments to the chef. We also tried a variety of different gourmet slices they were all delicious. My favorite slice had to be the Hot Honey Chicken Bacon Ranch. Compliments to the staff and pizza man for carrying out an absolutely wonderful product and service. We felt like family nothing less. There is scarcity of authentic pizza Joints nationwide but MAMA GRACE sure didn’t disappoint 11/10 we are definitely coming back in the upcoming days,weeks,months,and years , you’ve gained a customer forever. What a deliciously lovely pizza Joint.

I picked up a large pie for my friend, she was having her Grandkiddies over. I just dropped it off. She called me & said the pie was dry & tasteless & the slices cut so uneven. Looking at the pic I would say she was definitely correct. Isn't there a guide that can be used to slice up a pie? I asked her to save a slice so I can taste it, it really does look dry. Anyway, 1st impression, not a good one. Maybe next time?

Rea

I picked up a large pie for my friend, she was having her Grandkiddies over. I just dropped it off. She called me & said the pie was dry & tasteless & the slices cut so uneven. Looking at the pic I would say she was definitely correct. Isn't there a guide that can be used to slice up a pie? I asked her to save a slice so I can taste it, it really does look dry. Anyway, 1st impression, not a good one. Maybe next time?

I waited a while to give an honest review, The owner and husband are nice, the stars they lose for atmosphere will Likely go up once they finish their renovations and fix parking, as it is now there are only 2 tables and 2 parking spots. This leaves a mad dash when they are busy. I tried the plain slice and if you like a more sweet and sugary sauce this is the place. I was told that their plain isn’t their best and that they specialize in Sicilian grandma pies. I’ll be sure to check that out next time, as of now, as a dine in restaurant for a family of 5, It’s best to order delivery from here. And avoid the plain if you like savory thin and crispy slices. The grandmas pie is the 3 stars this review is getting, it was worth the return for the single slice. They should call it Mama Graces Grandma Pies and Pizza. Would sell their strengths more!

Wife and I ordered chicken parm sandwiches and pepperoni pinwheels. The chicken was dry and pinwheels were overcooked. Sauce seems to be missing something also. Though their pasta dinners are good. Especially seafood diavolo

Checkered Demon

Wife and I ordered chicken parm sandwiches and pepperoni pinwheels. The chicken was dry and pinwheels were overcooked. Sauce seems to be missing something also. Though their pasta dinners are good. Especially seafood diavolo

jeremiahryan

I waited a while to give an honest review, The owner and husband are nice, the stars they lose for atmosphere will Likely go up once they finish their renovations and fix parking, as it is now there are only 2 tables and 2 parking spots. This leaves a mad dash when they are busy. I tried the plain slice and if you like a more sweet and sugary sauce this is the place. I was told that their plain isn’t their best and that they specialize in Sicilian grandma pies. I’ll be sure to check that out next time, as of now, as a dine in restaurant for a family of 5, It’s best to order delivery from here. And avoid the plain if you like savory thin and crispy slices. The grandmas pie is the 3 stars this review is getting, it was worth the return for the single slice. They should call it Mama Graces Grandma Pies and Pizza. Would sell their strengths more!

I feel like I was bamboozled...I'm not sure where all these 5 star reviews came from, must be from people that haven't had Italian food before. The food is horrible, Frozen pizza is better. The pizza was soggy and the sauce is way way too sweet with no seasoning! The Garlic knots are horrendous, stiff, cold and not fresh by any means, it was like biting into a stale loaf of bread. This place is very very expensive, $20 for 12 wings, like come on. All the food went to the chickens 😂

I have been waiting over a year to try this place. I figured a Tuesday night would be a good time to try the food. The positive is that the place appears to be very clean and the staff are very pleasant. There were a decent amount of people picking up food and eating pizza there. I have not had a calzone since 2019 and we decided to order one and also have a plain slice also. The slice was fine, nothing that would make me want to gobble down several but it was okay. Now to the calzone. The size for the price was fine. Number one, it was not heated long enough but there were no cold spots. The bottom of it was very dark and almost burned. There were spots where the dough was not fully cooked. The calzone was a disappointment. The sauce that came with it was not very good and I just did not find it well seasoned. After this, we both agreed that we need not ever return based on this visit. I saw many positive reviews and was hoping for much better. You live, you learn.

Michael Waitforit

I feel like I was bamboozled...I'm not sure where all these 5 star reviews came from, must be from people that haven't had Italian food before. The food is horrible, Frozen pizza is better. The pizza was soggy and the sauce is way way too sweet with no seasoning! The Garlic knots are horrendous, stiff, cold and not fresh by any means, it was like biting into a stale loaf of bread. This place is very very expensive, $20 for 12 wings, like come on. All the food went to the chickens 😂

Ordered a pizza by phone and was told it would take 45 minutes, which was fine as I only live a short distance. When I arrived about 50 minutes later, they had no record of me ordering. I waited another 30 minutes while they made another. Was expecting them to at least offer me a complimentary side order for their screw up, but received nothing and paid full price. Not good customer service for a new business. Also while I was waiting a large spider that another customer pointed out was running across the floor which an employee promptly stomped. Better check your toppings they might not be what they appear to be.

Ordered a pizza at 4:00 pm on a Thursday. Waited 90 Mins. Called a second time and was told the driver showed up and no one was in our office. I've been in our office since 9am doing end of the year paperwork and planned on being here the rest of the night. The driver never even called. First time ordering from here and more then likely the only time. It's a shame really. Called Luna Rosa, who we usually order from, had the wife pick up a Grandma pie on the way back from our apartment after walking the our dogs. Maybe next time......

Jake Lazier

Ordered a pizza at 4:00 pm on a Thursday. Waited 90 Mins. Called a second time and was told the driver showed up and no one was in our office. I've been in our office since 9am doing end of the year paperwork and planned on being here the rest of the night. The driver never even called. First time ordering from here and more then likely the only time. It's a shame really. Called Luna Rosa, who we usually order from, had the wife pick up a Grandma pie on the way back from our apartment after walking the our dogs. Maybe next time......