Mary's Pizza & Pasta

First time eating at Mary’s after hearing lots of good things about it. Plenty of parking, but I definitely should have made a reservation - busy place! We had some incredible food in generous portions and the service was amiable in a very comfortable atmosphere. My in-laws kept saying I chose a great place to celebrate their anniversary - said best calamari they ever had, too. Highly recommend!

Dining is open on their outside patio and food is delicious and the service is great. Had seafood fra Diablo with sauteed spinach and my husband had veal cutlet parmesan with sauteed vegetables. Everything was so delicious.

This place has some delicious pesto and according to the rest of the people I went with the pene was delicious as well. Great portions and a very attentive waitress and staff.

Great higher end pizza and Italian restaurant. Booth, table, bar and high top seating and outdoor seating as well!

We had the lasagna and a burger! Ton of fries came with the burger and the lasagna is more than enough for 2-3 people. We sat at the bar and had a few drinks as well.

Wasn’t busy. (Came on a Monday Evening) The waiters and staff were kind and fast. Everything was very well tasting and I would come back here again definitely.

I dined in tonight and I am so impressed with this restaurant! The service here is excellent. My family’s server was Lauren and she was so attentive. Definitely will be coming back here.

My son threw a dart on a map, and we ended up at this special place. What a pleasant surprise. Beautiful backyard patio, friendly service, and don't skip the Detroit pizza!

What a great restaurant; food is delicious, manager is great , staff is wonderful; especially Lauren and Eric . Highly recommend

consistent. Go to favor. Always consistant. Five star quality. Alys a great dining experience!!!

I went twice in one week. A late lunch and a late dinner. Their flatbread pizza was delicious with an eye-pleasing presentation. Great lighting in the front dining area and appropriate level of light in quiet rear dining. The bar area seems quite inviting. The staff members seemed very nice and very busy.

I like food but I could’ve sworn there were free refills on root beer? They should add footlong pretzels to menu a lot of people would like that. I personally don’t like footlong pretzels but a lot of people would like it.

Everyone local loves this place. I feel it’s the way they make you feel while you’re dining. They go out of their way to make sure your dining experience is the best. The food is amazing.

Best pizza around, bar none. Everything is made fresh with the highest quality ingredients. I'll drive 20 minutes to get my pizza here even though there are two other pizza places 5 minutes away from me. Chef's kiss to Mary's!

Mary's is one of those places that never disappoints. The food is always freshly made with wholesome ingredients bringing the flavor of every dish to life. I live nearby so it's my go-to for a simple soup and salad or lobster pasta, pizza and meat dishes. Their wine selection is also very good. 👌

We're visiting family and went to Mary's. What a pleasure. We sat outside with such great ambiance. The food was amazing and our server Doug was the bomb. So funny and so fast. We were just so impressed with the whole experience I can't say enough about it.

Nice restaurant with great food and friendly staff. Highly recommended.

Everyone super Fri❤ndly. The aroma when you first pull into the parking lot is amazing even better when you walk into the door. The drinks are well made. The appetizers are tasty and the main courses are incredible. So worth taking the trip and eating here. Prices are normal. Place was clean service fast and the restaurant is nicely decorated. You will enjoy the experience.

Excellent. Excellent food at a very fair price. Service was perfect

Mary’s is a great little gem in Speonk. Food is always good and pizza is amazing. The place gets crowded and parking can be a bit of a pain but that is really the only downside. The owners are great and always giving back to community. It is a welcome addition to the area.

Our waitress Ashley was fabulous and made our night! Food was delicious! The food was delicious and very generous portions. The drinks were terrific! Overall wonderful experience! We spend Yeah Per person

Everyone was very pleased with the food. They said the pizza was great. I had meatballs and broccoli rabe as two sides and it was plenty of food and delicious. The others says they would order that next time.

Found my new favorite Italian restaurant tonight. Had chicken parm. You can always tell a good Italian restaurant by how good the chicken parm is. Let's just say it was awesome! Will definitely be back!

A great spot. Something for everyone with a great Italian menu and some American flair thrown in. A family favorite for us. Shout out to the best employee who’s been there since the start bringing out the delicious bread. He is such good vibes.

Delicious food. Very friendly staff and service. I recommend getting a reservation as you will be waiting on a Friday or Saturday night. I always get the chicken Marsala with risotto

Everything that I’ve eaten or my family has eaten in this restaurant has been phenomenal and that’s what keeps us coming back. It’s a beautiful restaurant the staff is absolutely terrific very attentive and accommodating. You definitely won’t be disappointed. They also have filet mignon, which is delicious also. This is definitely a hidden Jim that I only discovered two years ago. And certainly has become a hotspot for great food and dining experience.

If you're searching for authentic Italian cuisine with a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Mary's Pizza & Pasta in Speonk is an absolute must-visit! Ambiance & Service From the moment we stepped into the restaurant, we were greeted with a cozy and inviting ambiance. The staff was exceptionally friendly and attentive, making us feel like part of the family. The service was prompt without feeling rushed, allowing us to savor our meal at a leisurely pace. Menu Highlights The menu at Mary's offers a delightful array of Italian classics, each prepared with fresh ingredients and a touch of love. Some standout dishes include: Veal Chop: A generous portion cooked to perfection, tender and flavorful. Focaccia Bread: Served warm and soft, it was the perfect start to our meal. Pasta Dishes: From creamy Alfredo to hearty Bolognese, each pasta was cooked al dente and paired with rich, flavorful sauces. Pizza: The thin-crust pizza was crispy and topped with a generous amount of fresh ingredients. Each dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor, showcasing the culinary expertise of the kitchen. Overall Experience Dining at Mary's Pizza & Pasta was an unforgettable experience. The combination of delectable food, exceptional service, and charming ambiance made for a perfect evening. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant is worth a visit. 10/10 — Highly recommend!

First Rate! Highly recommend! We reserved for 6, but our party grew and we ultimately needed a table for 12. They accomodated--no problem! Bartender, Molly; server Katie. Super friendly and helpful. Thanks to all for a fantastic experience!

I have only been there three times and each time the service has been great . The staff are nice and friendly and helpful. The food is very good. . If your in the neighborhood definately stop in and grab a bite. You won't be disappointed.

Great staff, always go out of their way to make sure you have a pleasant dining experience. Food consistently good, and prices reasonable. It’s one of my local favorites for after work dinner and drinks with coworkers.

It was pleasant, just would be nicer if the outside sitting wasn't to bright, not a place to go on a date. But the was on point, thank you!!!

Large restaurant with huge indoor and outdoor seating. The food portions were large and many dishes came with sides. Overall, food was decent. And service was quick and excellent

Food was very good! Only down side is that it is very loud. We couldn't hear our waitress tell us what the specials were. Should definitely make a reservation.

Great place. Good food and drinks. Redone. It was loud in the dining room, just be aware. Not a problem for me but in case you want to know. Very busy and energetic. Waitress was great. I will be back for a slice and a drink at the bar.

Clean comfortable atmosphere, with good food. The staff was very courteous and pleasant to deal with.

Food was amazing ,. Comfort Italian food that’s is made with love like grandmas cooking

The servers were very friendly and helpful, and it was a lovely place. We got the hot honey pepperoni pizza and the bolognese, and they were very hardy and flavorful (the cheese on the pizza, OMG!). My only complaint is that the "personal pizza" is enough to feed two or three people, so my husband and I ordered way too much food. Had we known, we could have saved 30 bucks on a very expensive vacation.

We came to Mary’s to dine in for the first time. We had done take out on a number of occasions. Service unbelievably slow. Took 15 minutes for drinks to come out, food felt like eternity. Waiter apologized but you could see him hanging out at the bar. Thank god for the bus boys. They were responsive and attentive. They asked if we wanted coffee or dessert! 😂 They were the best part of the night!

I had got a panini and a slice. The slice was very good. (chicken bacon bomber) The panini was on a roll (weird, why not ciabatta? ) and so dry. There was no sauce at all. It was a chore to eat and not at all worth the price. I may go back for another slice of I'm in the area but it definitely disappointed me.

Was just charged $16 for 2 slices of pizza. 1 buffalo chicken and 1 white slice. Certainly my last visit.