Amalfi Coast Pizzeria & Restaurant

Delicious food Great customer service The spinach and artichoke pizza is bomb as is the baked ziti and meatball. My fiancee and I usually order at least 2x a month.

Value for money... Authentic Italian Pizza My favorite was chicken toll

I ordered takeout for a small party at home and the food was delicious! Starting with the antipasto salad which was so fresh and bursting with flavor! We dug into cheesy, warm garlic bread, then had pepperoni, cheese and vodka pizza…yum! Rigatoni with large and scrumptious meatballs, penne vodka..so good! Pasta fagioli soup had a nice amount of garlic to give it a kick. The seafood pasta was full of mini clams, mussels, shrimp & calamari! Next, eggplant rollatini…hit the spot! Dessert was rich- deep fried oreos & zeppoles…super tasty!!! All the portions of food were very generous, food was fresh and really good!!!

Ive been eating pizza 🍕 since John Gotti was a free man. The sauce on the pizza is definitely old school taste, its amazing to say the least. Really brought back memories of the way pizza should taste. I love this place. #Thepicassoofthieves

The people over there are amazing and kind! The food tasted like heaven! And I suggest to go there for AMAZING FOOD!!

Felt like a neighbor hood gem. Was coming back from practice and had a triple sauce slice(name probably not accurate) was pretty damn good. The chef even made it fresh for us. The dough was soft chewy and crispy all at the same time. Very nice !

The owners are very friendly and respectful, even the employees, are never to be busy and welcome customers. This is always clean, pizza varieties right front, special dishes take time to prepare, well worth the wait. I leave very satisfied always. I go to this place always, especially Fridays I try to get there early to place an order by phone, in person, caus I work at night. Overall, Excellent place. Thank You your service to Midland Beach and beyond. Angel P.

Great pizza we feel the love was made in making our pizza. We ha e tried other and nothing comes close to this shop

Maximilian

Had no pizza for some reason.

Picasso

Ive been eating pizza 🍕 since John Gotti was a free man. The sauce on the pizza is definitely old school taste, its amazing to say the least. Really brought back memories of the way pizza should taste. I love this place. #Thepicassoofthieves

Jessica Sosa

Great pizza we feel the love was made in making our pizza. We ha e tried other and nothing comes close to this shop

Manjula Wim

Value for money... Authentic Italian Pizza My favorite was chicken toll

Angela Simonetti

Delicious food Great customer service The spinach and artichoke pizza is bomb as is the baked ziti and meatball. My fiancee and I usually order at least 2x a month.

Ethan Chen

Felt like a neighbor hood gem. Was coming back from practice and had a triple sauce slice(name probably not accurate) was pretty damn good. The chef even made it fresh for us. The dough was soft chewy and crispy all at the same time. Very nice !

Tyler Sam

Best pizza I've ever had. They got the best pizza sauce for sure! I drive from NJ just to get pizza from this place.

Angel Padilla

The owners are very friendly and respectful, even the employees, are never to be busy and welcome customers. This is always clean, pizza varieties right front, special dishes take time to prepare, well worth the wait. I leave very satisfied always. I go to this place always, especially Fridays I try to get there early to place an order by phone, in person, caus I work at night. Overall, Excellent place. Thank You your service to Midland Beach and beyond. Angel P.

Maria Markakis

I ordered takeout for a small party at home and the food was delicious! Starting with the antipasto salad which was so fresh and bursting with flavor! We dug into cheesy, warm garlic bread, then had pepperoni, cheese and vodka pizza…yum! Rigatoni with large and scrumptious meatballs, penne vodka..so good! Pasta fagioli soup had a nice amount of garlic to give it a kick. The seafood pasta was full of mini clams, mussels, shrimp & calamari! Next, eggplant rollatini…hit the spot! Dessert was rich- deep fried oreos & zeppoles…super tasty!!! All the portions of food were very generous, food was fresh and really good!!!

Randall Q

The best Stromboli in Staten Island, literally could not find anyone that can make a good “Stromboli” the way I always wanted it. Not just the food is great but the service. The owner and staff know how to treat customers. Ecstatic that they came to Midland Ave where we so needed a great neighborhood pizzeria spot. Will be trying other dishes but if you ever want to order my Stromboli I would recommend ask for the works. Green pepper, onions, cheese, pepperoni, sausage and a warm tomato sauce and that completes the meal. Amazing 🤩!!!

Small slice for $3. Crispy, medium thin crust. Cheese is well cooked, but couldn't taste the sauce. Plus, it pretty much taste like a grilled cheese slice. It was okay, but nothing to write home about. Rate this at 82.

Gary Wilson

Small slice for $3. Crispy, medium thin crust. Cheese is well cooked, but couldn't taste the sauce. Plus, it pretty much taste like a grilled cheese slice. It was okay, but nothing to write home about. Rate this at 82.

The positive reviews from before October 2019 are for the former pizzeria at this address Big Boys the. It became Cuzzin Joe’s & now it is Amalfi Coast. The place was empty and the tables needed to be cleaned. A man who wasn’t working but just watching TV and manning the register seemed to be an owner of some sort. The cook was working harder than the other 2 men in there. The pizza was just okay the sauce needed something to bring a tang out from the tomatoes but at least the pizza was cooked properly. (Big Boys Review: Sauce tastes great! Fried calamari was delicious and crispy and tender LOVED it! Service was fast and staff was friendly and made me feel like family! A great little pizzeria.)

Sherrelyn N

The positive reviews from before October 2019 are for the former pizzeria at this address Big Boys the. It became Cuzzin Joe’s & now it is Amalfi Coast. The place was empty and the tables needed to be cleaned. A man who wasn’t working but just watching TV and manning the register seemed to be an owner of some sort. The cook was working harder than the other 2 men in there. The pizza was just okay the sauce needed something to bring a tang out from the tomatoes but at least the pizza was cooked properly. (Big Boys Review: Sauce tastes great! Fried calamari was delicious and crispy and tender LOVED it! Service was fast and staff was friendly and made me feel like family! A great little pizzeria.)

I preferred the vodka square over the plain slice. The sesame seeds by the crust on the vodka square was a unique touch. 6.5

brendan kane

I preferred the vodka square over the plain slice. The sesame seeds by the crust on the vodka square was a unique touch. 6.5

Had a pepperoni slice, pizza crust was soggy and 10-15 minutes after eating I had to run to the bathroom. Will never go there again.

undersan32

Had a pepperoni slice, pizza crust was soggy and 10-15 minutes after eating I had to run to the bathroom. Will never go there again.

It’s a shame I used to like their pizza but recently they have a new cook and he is terrible. The pizza was undercooked. The meatballs had no seasoning tasted like straight ground beef. The old man that used to cook was fantastic but the new people that are in there now cooking Need to go to Burger King

Food use to be good went down down hill pizza is extremely thin and floppy the burgers taste like freezer they use fake ingredients. Sad had to turn this way.

Jimbo69

Food use to be good went down down hill pizza is extremely thin and floppy the burgers taste like freezer they use fake ingredients. Sad had to turn this way.

Rich Crowson

It’s a shame I used to like their pizza but recently they have a new cook and he is terrible. The pizza was undercooked. The meatballs had no seasoning tasted like straight ground beef. The old man that used to cook was fantastic but the new people that are in there now cooking Need to go to Burger King