SEAN GIBBS

Heard about this pizza shop serving up some delicious slices on the island so of course I had to go see if it was worth the hype and truthfully this place is a vibe. Let’s start with the staff, some of the most friendliest and most welcoming people I have met in a while. The atmosphere is amazing. Great environment for families. Now let’s talk about the pizza. I grab two slices because I couldn’t decide since everything look so amazing. The pizza was fantastic. The price is average for this day and age so I love that and overall speaking my experience was a definite 100. If you haven’t yet tried prime pizza kitchen I highly recommend adding it to your must try spot. 8.5/10

Blessed K. M.

That pizza was so good!! The dough was perfect and the sauce and cheese tasted great! I’ll definitely go back!

Sengul Mersi

Overall best pizza plus dining experience. Every staff member had a friendly welcoming smile on their face. Quick service for amazing quality food. Their regular pizza alone is the most mouthwatering pizza I’ve ever eaten. Nothing compares.

BellaDona29

Prime Pizza is by far the best pizza in Staten Island they are sooo reasonably priced, extremely delicious and so kind. I have ordered catering twice from them for a party and for my daughter’s teachers .. People talked about the long chicken heroes , pasta and pizzas for DAYSSSS. A real gem in Staten Island , for real.

+1

Brian Yi

Great pizzeria, lots of parking. Prices are fair. I like their specialty pizzas. My favorite is the garlic knots. Taste of garlic and bread is soft. There is a eat in area with a decent amount of tables and chairs. I also like the vanilla coke in a simple can. Hard to find that flavor. They also have their own soda brand, taste great. This is definitely a tasty pizzeria in staten island.

Gregory Myers

Great slices from the Alfredo to the vodka with ricotta(my fav)even the regular slice is super thin crispy!!! The franchese is soooo good I def recommend this if you want some pizza in staten island.

+1

brendan kane

Another pizza place I hadn't heard much about but I enjoyed. Had a plain cheese pie. Good tasting sauce. Crust at the end could be a little better. They have a large selection of specialty pies. All looked very good. Good service too. 7.5 on the pie.

Alex Sher

Food: The food was satisfying, earning a solid four stars. The pizza, in particular, was flavorful, with a delicious blend of fresh ingredients and a well-balanced crust. While enjoyable, it didn't quite reach the level of exceptional taste that would warrant a higher rating. Service: The service provided matched the quality of the food, deserving another four stars. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring our orders were taken promptly and checking in on us regularly. Their professionalism contributed positively to our overall experience. Atmosphere: The ambiance of Prime Pizza Kitchen also earned a solid four stars. The restaurant had a welcoming and cozy atmosphere, making it a pleasant place to dine. However, a bit more attention to lighting and decor details could further enhance the dining environment. While Prime Pizza Kitchen offered a consistently enjoyable experience, there's potential for refinement in each aspect to elevate it to a higher rating.

Rich Rivera

Hands down one of the worst pizza places , not only in Staten Island which is insane, but in NY. The quality of a single slice is horrific, the pies are AWEFUL, and the service is subpar. They never put enough cheese on your slice and dump pounds of sauce . It’s really sad tbh

Lucas Sotelo

I been ordering for a long time and never had problems. I live in a building apartment, today I ordered and the delivery guy called me saying he’s upstairs so I opened my door and he’s not there so I go downstairs to see if he’s there, to see my order on the floor in the lobby where everyone has access even people who not live here. Called the delivery guy and he’s excuse was that he’s not allowed to come inside so that’s why he left it outside. They been delivered plenty times and always ring and I buzz them in. Who wants dinner to be delivered on a dirty floor??

Christopher L

You guys consistently lower the quality of your pizza as if no one will notice, well I do this isn’t the first pizza I’ve gotten like this it’s the 6th you should be shut down there isn’t a reply you could give me that could get me to forgive this. If you like ultra thin pizza give em a try they love going as thin as possible except for the on the sauce where they use so much that the cheese falls right off the pizza as you pull a slice off the pie making the entire thing inedible. This isn’t hate this is a terrible store.